Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adam Kay and his husband’s babies

434 replies

MatildaTheCat · 18/06/2023 17:38

Apologies if this has already been covered.

I read in the paper this morning that AK and his DH have welcomed TWO babies into their lives, born to two different surrogates. One child is six months old and their sibling is two months old.

I genuinely cannot wrap my head around this. It seems so very odd to me. Is it a case of ‘one each’ or ‘get the baby stages over asap’?

Obviously nobody but the two parents can answer this but AIBU to find this really quite disturbing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
nothingcomestonothing · 10/10/2023 08:13

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 07:52

You know that buying your 11 yo is totally different though. You are able to give her away though if you wanted. What I am saying is that you disagree with surrogacy even if it was free (like adoption, or giving a kidney) so those arguments you are giving are pointless when comparing it to organs IMO and you haven't actually given any evidence to back yourself up in your replies to me about the effects on the mother or baby (nor have I).

If you disagree with surrogacy full stop that's fine of course. I would be a surrogate for a close friend or family member in a heartbeat, in the same way as I would give a kidney, i am closer to this subject than i am happy to discuss as its way too outing. Not everyone feels the way I do which is fine, I am not the only one on here to feel how I do though. I think it's best I don't engage with you further on this matter.

No I don't think buying an 11 year old is any different, because I dont think it's ok to do things to humans on the grounds that they won't remember it, which is the only difference between giving away a baby or an 11 year old. Do you?

I can't give my 11 year old away freely though can I? Social services would get involved and rightly so. There is plenty of evidence about the effects of removing children from their birth families, that's why (in the UK) it is only done as a last resort. I'm an adopter.

Giving away a human is not equivalent to giving away a kidney. Your kidney is part of your body, and is not sentient. Not the same

Sayitaintso33 · 10/10/2023 08:07

These anti-surogacy arguments will come back to haunt us. They always do when we try and prevent men from having something that is ours.

If we argue that the bond from pregnancy is so strong it must never be broken, it will lead to prohibitions on women giving up their children for adoption or otherwise abandoning them during their childhood. How dare you, who carried your child for 9 months put him in nursery to frivolously go and earn money to buy trinkets. Your husband can do that, you can go and nurse your child.

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 07:52

nothingcomestonothing · 10/10/2023 07:44

It doesn't matter if it's this purchaser, or a different one. It doesn't matter of they're straight gay old young wealthy nice desperate or anything else. Buying a human is wrong for any reason.

Unless you think someone should be able to pay me for my 11 year old, if they really really want one and have 'limited options'?

You know that buying your 11 yo is totally different though. You are able to give her away though if you wanted. What I am saying is that you disagree with surrogacy even if it was free (like adoption, or giving a kidney) so those arguments you are giving are pointless when comparing it to organs IMO and you haven't actually given any evidence to back yourself up in your replies to me about the effects on the mother or baby (nor have I).

If you disagree with surrogacy full stop that's fine of course. I would be a surrogate for a close friend or family member in a heartbeat, in the same way as I would give a kidney, i am closer to this subject than i am happy to discuss as its way too outing. Not everyone feels the way I do which is fine, I am not the only one on here to feel how I do though. I think it's best I don't engage with you further on this matter.

nothingcomestonothing · 10/10/2023 07:44

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 23:36

That's not really what I was saying but I'm guessing you know that really but can't accept others have different opinions. I was just pointing out another example that doesn't involve Adam Kay who everyone hates.

I just don't believe that it is morally wrong. There are many who believe that IVF shouldn't be available on the NHS but until you have experienced infertility I don't think you have a say in it. Its easy to say for people in a male/female couple who can get pregnant naturally, when a gay couple want to they have limited options.

It doesn't matter if it's this purchaser, or a different one. It doesn't matter of they're straight gay old young wealthy nice desperate or anything else. Buying a human is wrong for any reason.

Unless you think someone should be able to pay me for my 11 year old, if they really really want one and have 'limited options'?

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 07:32

Embarra55ed · 10/10/2023 06:16

I have experienced infertility. I’ve had 4 miscarriages.

But no, you don’t need to know what infertility is like to have an opinion on this.

The wants and needs of the person who wants to buy a baby (for whatever reason) do not matter more than the mother and child.

Your argument boils
down to saying that it’s ok for a woman to put her life on the line and a baby to be taken from it’s mother at birth because grown adults are “desperate” for a baby.

It is illegal to buy organs. And we don’t need to have experienced what it’s like to have lost an eye or a kidney to know that buying them from poor people is completely unacceptable. And arguably eyes and kidneys are more necessary to the person who wants to buy one than a baby would be.

So you're OK if they do it for free then? Like giving a kidney? Surely if you disagree with it so much your arguments should stand for surrogacy regardless, so your organ example just doesn't stand up at all IMO.

We are allowed to disagree about this, you won't br changing my mind and I have no desire to try and change yours. Neither of us knows each others personal reasons for feeling like we do.

Embarra55ed · 10/10/2023 06:16

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 23:36

That's not really what I was saying but I'm guessing you know that really but can't accept others have different opinions. I was just pointing out another example that doesn't involve Adam Kay who everyone hates.

I just don't believe that it is morally wrong. There are many who believe that IVF shouldn't be available on the NHS but until you have experienced infertility I don't think you have a say in it. Its easy to say for people in a male/female couple who can get pregnant naturally, when a gay couple want to they have limited options.

I have experienced infertility. I’ve had 4 miscarriages.

But no, you don’t need to know what infertility is like to have an opinion on this.

The wants and needs of the person who wants to buy a baby (for whatever reason) do not matter more than the mother and child.

Your argument boils
down to saying that it’s ok for a woman to put her life on the line and a baby to be taken from it’s mother at birth because grown adults are “desperate” for a baby.

It is illegal to buy organs. And we don’t need to have experienced what it’s like to have lost an eye or a kidney to know that buying them from poor people is completely unacceptable. And arguably eyes and kidneys are more necessary to the person who wants to buy one than a baby would be.

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 23:36

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 23:29

Of course. But condoning the exploitation of women and abuse of children on the basis that Neil Patrick Harris makes it look nice on Instagram isn’t really the best argument, and doesn’t suggest you’ve engaged with any of the counter arguments on this thread.

That's not really what I was saying but I'm guessing you know that really but can't accept others have different opinions. I was just pointing out another example that doesn't involve Adam Kay who everyone hates.

I just don't believe that it is morally wrong. There are many who believe that IVF shouldn't be available on the NHS but until you have experienced infertility I don't think you have a say in it. Its easy to say for people in a male/female couple who can get pregnant naturally, when a gay couple want to they have limited options.

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 23:29

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 23:16

And I'm allowed to disagree with them 🤷‍♀️

Of course. But condoning the exploitation of women and abuse of children on the basis that Neil Patrick Harris makes it look nice on Instagram isn’t really the best argument, and doesn’t suggest you’ve engaged with any of the counter arguments on this thread.

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 23:16

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 23:15

The arguments against them doing this are all over this thread.

And I'm allowed to disagree with them 🤷‍♀️

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 23:15

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 22:39

I totally disagree that it is baby trafficking, its a valid option IMO for childless couples, I also agree he doesn't really seem a decent sort so perhaps they does skew the answers.

There are lots of gay couples who use surrogates and they seem like amazing parents, look at Neil Patrick Harris and David Burtka for example, they used a surrogate and implanted an embryo each, they have 10 yo twins now. I can't see an arguement against them doing this.

The arguments against them doing this are all over this thread.

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 22:41

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:08

It is I agree possible that some surrogacy arrangements may be exploitative. As can some marriages as potentially could donations of sperm. This does not as far as I can see mean that in principle surrogacy is wrong.

100% this. I would hope that in the majority of cases it is highly regulated but obviously there will be cases where it is not. I agree that this shouldn't mean it can never be acceptable.

MyNumber1Rule · 09/10/2023 22:39

I totally disagree that it is baby trafficking, its a valid option IMO for childless couples, I also agree he doesn't really seem a decent sort so perhaps they does skew the answers.

There are lots of gay couples who use surrogates and they seem like amazing parents, look at Neil Patrick Harris and David Burtka for example, they used a surrogate and implanted an embryo each, they have 10 yo twins now. I can't see an arguement against them doing this.

nothingcomestonothing · 09/10/2023 22:06

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:05

For some people this can be their only option of being a parent. There are a wide range of scenarios available so lets take one. A couple for medical reasons cannot carry to full term. They are desparate for a child of their own. A close friend agrees to carry their baby for them. The baby is born and cared for and nurtured by the couple. Perhaps you might explain how this would be baby trafficking?

How does the idea that 'this can be their only option of being a parent' make it not baby trafficking? Would you be okay with that as a reason if they'd bought a toddler? Or an eight year old? Would you be fine with someone stealing a new born from a maternity unit, if that was 'their only option of being a parent'?

Renting a woman's body and removing a baby from its birth mother is about the purchasing adults wants. It's wrong no matter how sad the purchasers will be if they can't have what they want, how wealthy they are, how much they want a baby, how loving they will be or anything else. Buying and selling humans is wrong.

oksothisisusnow · 09/10/2023 21:08

DinaofCloud9 · 18/06/2023 17:50

He doesn't seem a decent sort at all. He's a vile misogynist.

I have no idea what the poster has read about him, absolutely not what I'd consider a decent sort. At all.

TheKeatingFive · 09/10/2023 21:06

It is a legitimate choice for any couple- gay or straight who have no other option.

No one has a right to a child. Have a think about the impact on the other people involved. The birth mother and the child themselves.

ArabeIIaScott · 09/10/2023 20:15

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:09

I don not agree that surrogacy is buying a baby. It is a legitimate choice for any couple- gay or straight who have no other option.

And it is likely to have life long adverse impacts on the baby.

As well as the impacts on the mother.

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 20:13

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:09

I don not agree that surrogacy is buying a baby. It is a legitimate choice for any couple- gay or straight who have no other option.

What do you mean you don’t agree it is buying a baby?

Adam Kay and his husband literally paid someone for their babies. I’d love to know how the fact they are gay or really wanted kids somehow means this financial arrangement didn’t happen.

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 20:11

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:05

For some people this can be their only option of being a parent. There are a wide range of scenarios available so lets take one. A couple for medical reasons cannot carry to full term. They are desparate for a child of their own. A close friend agrees to carry their baby for them. The baby is born and cared for and nurtured by the couple. Perhaps you might explain how this would be baby trafficking?

No one is entitled to a baby or to take advantage of a woman just because they want one, no matter how desperately.

Outcomes for pregnant women can range from pain and discomfort to serious health issues/permanent disability to death.

The altruistic surrogacy arrangements you describe account for a tiny fraction of surrogacies, the vast majority of which are financially driven and essentially involve exploiting poor women. And even the altruistic examples are deeply problematic.

And that’s before you even begin to think of the impact on the baby.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 09/10/2023 20:10

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:05

For some people this can be their only option of being a parent. There are a wide range of scenarios available so lets take one. A couple for medical reasons cannot carry to full term. They are desparate for a child of their own. A close friend agrees to carry their baby for them. The baby is born and cared for and nurtured by the couple. Perhaps you might explain how this would be baby trafficking?

That's how surrogacy started isn't it - with friend / family links?
Now we get wealthy people renting the bodies of poorer women (often in other countries to avoid the legal protections for children that exist in this country) and then purchasing the baby.

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:09

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 18:34

Are you saying that surrogacy is acceptable for women who can’t carry children? What about women who just don’t want to? What about men?

The circumstances of the person buying the baby are irrelevant to the question of whether surrogacy is ok. What matters are the rights of the mother (ie the woman carrying the child) and the baby. And by definition surrogacy arrangements do not prioritise or value these rights.

I don not agree that surrogacy is buying a baby. It is a legitimate choice for any couple- gay or straight who have no other option.

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:08

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 18:34

Are you saying that surrogacy is acceptable for women who can’t carry children? What about women who just don’t want to? What about men?

The circumstances of the person buying the baby are irrelevant to the question of whether surrogacy is ok. What matters are the rights of the mother (ie the woman carrying the child) and the baby. And by definition surrogacy arrangements do not prioritise or value these rights.

It is I agree possible that some surrogacy arrangements may be exploitative. As can some marriages as potentially could donations of sperm. This does not as far as I can see mean that in principle surrogacy is wrong.

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:05

nothingcomestonothing · 09/10/2023 16:50

Could you explain how it's not baby trafficking?

For some people this can be their only option of being a parent. There are a wide range of scenarios available so lets take one. A couple for medical reasons cannot carry to full term. They are desparate for a child of their own. A close friend agrees to carry their baby for them. The baby is born and cared for and nurtured by the couple. Perhaps you might explain how this would be baby trafficking?

Embarra55ed · 09/10/2023 18:34

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 15:54

Surrogacy is a quite legitimate option for many women who are not able to carry their own eggs. Surrogacy is not baby trafficking at all. I have never understood the extreme response to it on mumsnet.

Are you saying that surrogacy is acceptable for women who can’t carry children? What about women who just don’t want to? What about men?

The circumstances of the person buying the baby are irrelevant to the question of whether surrogacy is ok. What matters are the rights of the mother (ie the woman carrying the child) and the baby. And by definition surrogacy arrangements do not prioritise or value these rights.

TheKeatingFive · 09/10/2023 16:55

Surrogacy is a quite legitimate option for many women who are not able to carry their own eggs.

Not much thought here for the woman who's body is being used as an incubator for rent, now is there?

nothingcomestonothing · 09/10/2023 16:50

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 15:54

Surrogacy is a quite legitimate option for many women who are not able to carry their own eggs. Surrogacy is not baby trafficking at all. I have never understood the extreme response to it on mumsnet.

Could you explain how it's not baby trafficking?