Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adam Kay and his husband’s babies

434 replies

MatildaTheCat · 18/06/2023 17:38

Apologies if this has already been covered.

I read in the paper this morning that AK and his DH have welcomed TWO babies into their lives, born to two different surrogates. One child is six months old and their sibling is two months old.

I genuinely cannot wrap my head around this. It seems so very odd to me. Is it a case of ‘one each’ or ‘get the baby stages over asap’?

Obviously nobody but the two parents can answer this but AIBU to find this really quite disturbing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ArabeIIaScott · 11/10/2023 10:44

The thing is that while people have a lot of compassion and feeling for the commissioning parents, and sometimes some for the woman carrying and bearing the child, my concern is for the baby.

Babies who are taken from their mother suffer. Why is there so little concern for the baby?

concernedmumhelp · 11/10/2023 10:41

It is possible to imagine a scenario where it seems absolutely the right thing for a woman to lovingly and voluntarily become a surrogate, with much love and satisfaction all around.

It is also possible to imagine a terrible situation where the surrogate, paid or unpaid, is not treated well.

So that is a real ethical dilemma I think, how to legislate for the best there.

Also, what happens if the surrogate parents, ultimately, struggle with coping? I think there are supports in place for fostering and adoptive parents, checks etc. I'm not sure what happens with surrogacy. Might the birth mother be offered the chance to have the child back?

Children in care can have a dreadful experience, it would be a great shame to think of someone acting as a surrogate and then to have that child end up in care.

ArabeIIaScott · 11/10/2023 10:38

https://surrogacyconcern.uk/2023/06/19/whats-happening/

https://stopsurrogacynowuk.org/

'Many people assume surrogacy in the UK takes place between friends and relatives. This is increasingly not the case: many parental orders are granted to parents who bring babies in from abroad, often conceived and carried through commercial surrogacy arrangements which are illegal here. And the ‘altruistic’ model sees strangers matched via surrogacy agencies, with many thousands of pounds changing hands: effectively buying babies off their mothers. Surrogacy, in all forms, is illegal throughout much of the world: in allowing surrogacy at all, the UK is an outlier. The proposals in this Bill would make this worse.'

What’s happening?

Commercial surrogacy (advertising for a surrogate mother, and paying her for her services) is illegal in the UK. The UK has what is commonly known as an ‘altruistic’ model of surrogacy,…

https://surrogacyconcern.uk/2023/06/19/whats-happening

ArabeIIaScott · 11/10/2023 10:36

https://twitter.com/CIAMS_Coalition/status/1709927554952638826

'Today, the European Parliament has overwhelmingly approved a bill to prohibit #surrogacy in all EU States, as it's TRAFFICKING of women and commercialization of newborns.'

https://twitter.com/CIAMS_Coalition/status/1709927554952638826

MyNumber1Rule · 11/10/2023 10:32

Embarra55ed · 11/10/2023 10:27

I’d love to discuss it if anyone could provide a reason for why it should be allowed that isn’t based on the person commissioning the whole thing just really wanting it.

If you’ve got a different reason or would like to explain the scenarios where it is ok and why those differ from the ones where it’s not ok then I’d be really interested to hear those.

I don't believe you are interested though really so I just can't be bothered to get into some huge row online with a stranger.

Just one example though, if I want to be a surrogate for my sister I should be able to if that is their only chance of having a baby. Why should you decide that it's morally wrong. You can disagree with people being paid for it if thats how you feel, but I don't understand how anyone can disagree with surrogacy in principle. Being paid or not, the risks and outcome are the same.

Embarra55ed · 11/10/2023 10:27

MyNumber1Rule · 11/10/2023 10:24

I never said that at all, everything I said was taken out of context. I am not willing to engage with you as you are clearly the sort of poster who thinks you are 100% right and has no interest in discussing things.

I’d love to discuss it if anyone could provide a reason for why it should be allowed that isn’t based on the person commissioning the whole thing just really wanting it.

If you’ve got a different reason or would like to explain the scenarios where it is ok and why those differ from the ones where it’s not ok then I’d be really interested to hear those.

MyNumber1Rule · 11/10/2023 10:24

Embarra55ed · 11/10/2023 10:22

What’s the right situation, out of interest? Because earlier in the thread you seemed to be in support of commercial surrogacy provided the parents seemed really great on social media.

I never said that at all, everything I said was taken out of context. I am not willing to engage with you as you are clearly the sort of poster who thinks you are 100% right and has no interest in discussing things.

Embarra55ed · 11/10/2023 10:22

MyNumber1Rule · 11/10/2023 10:12

I do agree with you there. I have been jumped on but I have never said surrogacy is appropriate in all scenarios and that it should be available at the drop of a hat, the regulation around it needs to be extremely tight but I do still feel that there is a place for it in the right situation.

What’s the right situation, out of interest? Because earlier in the thread you seemed to be in support of commercial surrogacy provided the parents seemed really great on social media.

ArabeIIaScott · 11/10/2023 10:21

cremona · 11/10/2023 09:57

I’m sceptical about surrogacy, but there’s somehow always something a bit repulsive on these threads about watching a lot of posters, most of whom have presumably been able to have the children they wanted, fall over themselves in their eagerness to deny that joy to another person.

I dgaf about someone's 'joy', if it means causing trauma to a baby.

Embarra55ed · 11/10/2023 10:21

cremona · 11/10/2023 09:57

I’m sceptical about surrogacy, but there’s somehow always something a bit repulsive on these threads about watching a lot of posters, most of whom have presumably been able to have the children they wanted, fall over themselves in their eagerness to deny that joy to another person.

Once again this response focuses solely on the desires of the person who uses a surrogate, and completely ignores the rights of the mother and child.

Nobody is entitled to the joy of a child. Being rich, or gay, or infertile shouldn’t mean that you get to exploit another woman’s body and pay to take her baby.

It’s a completely selfish desire.

concernedmumhelp · 11/10/2023 10:18

I also had infertility issues and multiple miscarriages before I eventually had children.

I can sympathise in many ways with couples wanting children, who can't have them the usual way.

However, it seems a bit odd to "order" 2 children at once, especially if you aren't sure about how you will cope, especially if you are a bit older and might find it demanding, especially if you are a busy couple, both with careers, who have other demands as well. It might be more sensible to go one at a time. There are various reasons, I think, why multiple births are relatively unusual for humans.

Even if you have lots of paid help, you can't outsource all the need for love, care and attention; and I imagine, managing and organising the paid help to cover the needs of 2 very small children would be quite an issue in itself.

MyNumber1Rule · 11/10/2023 10:12

cremona · 11/10/2023 09:57

I’m sceptical about surrogacy, but there’s somehow always something a bit repulsive on these threads about watching a lot of posters, most of whom have presumably been able to have the children they wanted, fall over themselves in their eagerness to deny that joy to another person.

I do agree with you there. I have been jumped on but I have never said surrogacy is appropriate in all scenarios and that it should be available at the drop of a hat, the regulation around it needs to be extremely tight but I do still feel that there is a place for it in the right situation.

cremona · 11/10/2023 09:57

I’m sceptical about surrogacy, but there’s somehow always something a bit repulsive on these threads about watching a lot of posters, most of whom have presumably been able to have the children they wanted, fall over themselves in their eagerness to deny that joy to another person.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 09:40

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 08:19

Do you actually know how surrogacy generally works?

I'm not engaging in this absolutely nonsense back and forth at all. Read the thread, many people disagree with you for many different reasons.

Yes by exploiting another human either through financial weakness or through emotional blackmail to carry and give birth to a baby which is seen as a commodity for the benefit of the couple who 'cant possibly survive' without a baby. The adult couple are centred first with the baby second and the woman right at the bottom.

This is an unhealthy dynamic. People who centre themselves first, don't make for great parents.

HTH.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 09:36

Cyclebabble · 09/10/2023 20:05

For some people this can be their only option of being a parent. There are a wide range of scenarios available so lets take one. A couple for medical reasons cannot carry to full term. They are desparate for a child of their own. A close friend agrees to carry their baby for them. The baby is born and cared for and nurtured by the couple. Perhaps you might explain how this would be baby trafficking?

Because they still have emotionally coerced the close friend into carrying the baby for them by using the line 'its our only option to be parents'.

That's abuse of power by using that close relationship to manipulate someones else.

I simply don't believe it's possible to have 'altruistic surrogacy'. It ALWAYS involves this emotional manipulation. And that relationship is altered by it. I do think there's a pretense that all parties are fine with it far too often. More relationships are hugely damaged by it than surrogacy advocates will admit to and many women who carry a baby and have regrets find it hard to vocalise that or feel they have no choice but to remain silent because speaking up when a child is involved is worse. Sunk costs and all that.

If the claim is actually true about it being the only way to have a baby it means they've been turned down for fostering and adoption. And you have to ask why. They aren't suitable to be parents. Red flags ahoy.

If that's not true the default alternative position is actually they are hamming up their point about it being their only option to be parents, and it's actually about them only wanting to be a parent in a particular way that suits them - and that makes it a demand coming from privilege. Poor people who are in similar circumstances can't just commission a surrogate. It's not a need it's a demand.

Fostering or adoption isn't suitable to these people because they deem these children as 'substandard' children who have been tainted in some way or it's all about the shiny new baby and not missing out on that stage (that's not about the kid that's all about the parents).

And that's forgetting that parenthood isn't for everyone - you can't have everything you want in life, but sheer entitlement is leading to the sanitising of baby trafficking for rich people at the expense of not so rich people. As I say, poor people don't commission surrogates.

Surrogacy centres the wants of adults not the needs children have. Depending on how it's done many children have their identity stolen from them as birth certificates are altered or donors concealed. This matters - the UN talks about how removing children from their cultural roots is a crime & we have massive scandals about adoption with children eventually seeking out where they came from years later often after adoptive parents have died because there is this natural desire to understand where someone has come from.

It's a monsterous practice whoever does it and however they do it. It's exploitative in what ever form it comes.

HTH

ArabeIIaScott · 10/10/2023 09:57

Literally the only reason that you or anyone else has been able to come with is that it’s fine because the person paying for it like reallllly wants it. Not good enough.

Yes. It's not okay to inflict suffering on a baby, or child, or another woman, not even if someone is themself suffering because they want a baby/child.

nothingcomestonothing · 10/10/2023 09:47

Embarra55ed · 10/10/2023 09:07

no, there aren’t “many different reasons” in support of surrogacy on this thread.

Literally the only reason that you or anyone else has been able to come with is that it’s fine because the person paying for it like reallllly wants it. Not good enough.

This.

There are plenty of things which we don't allow people to have or do, even if they really really want them. Even if the other human involved will not remember it, and they'll be really really well treated afterwards. Human trafficking is wrong, even if the people involved really really want another human and can't get one in a different way.

Embarra55ed · 10/10/2023 09:07

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 08:19

Do you actually know how surrogacy generally works?

I'm not engaging in this absolutely nonsense back and forth at all. Read the thread, many people disagree with you for many different reasons.

no, there aren’t “many different reasons” in support of surrogacy on this thread.

Literally the only reason that you or anyone else has been able to come with is that it’s fine because the person paying for it like reallllly wants it. Not good enough.

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 09:05

elliejjtiny · 18/06/2023 17:48

A few people who I follow on Instagram have adopted babies with very small age gaps. Some are a mixture of birth and adopted children and some are all adopted children.

In this case I'm assuming that they were both "ttc" with a surrogate each because they couldn't decide who got to produce the sperm (although you'd think they would do alternate months or mix their sperm together or something). Either that or they wanted to double their chances of conceiving each month.

I'm surprised that an obstetrician would have a child via surrogacy though. Surely he would know more than most people how this would negatively affect the baby.

He certainly knows better than most how badly pregnancy and childbirth can affect the woman.

According to his book he left medicine due to being traumatised after seeing a baby die and a mother almost die in childbirth and have to have an emergency hysterectomy rendering her permanently infertile due to undiagnosed placenta previa.

I guess he has recovered enough to let a woman potentially go through the same thing so he can have a baby.

Naunet · 10/10/2023 09:04

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 08:58

I don't believe it's human trafficking, that's my answer.

Based on? A baby is a human, they’re being sold/given to someone else without having any say themselves. How is that not trafficking?

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 08:58

Naunet · 10/10/2023 08:52

That’s ok, generally people with your views can’t answer at what age human trafficking becomes A Bad Thing. I wonder why…

I don't believe it's human trafficking, that's my answer.

Naunet · 10/10/2023 08:52

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 08:19

Do you actually know how surrogacy generally works?

I'm not engaging in this absolutely nonsense back and forth at all. Read the thread, many people disagree with you for many different reasons.

That’s ok, generally people with your views can’t answer at what age human trafficking becomes A Bad Thing. I wonder why…

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 08:19

Naunet · 10/10/2023 08:17

Why is buying an 11 year old totally different? What is the acceptable age limit on human trafficking?

Do you actually know how surrogacy generally works?

I'm not engaging in this absolutely nonsense back and forth at all. Read the thread, many people disagree with you for many different reasons.

Naunet · 10/10/2023 08:17

MyNumber1Rule · 10/10/2023 07:52

You know that buying your 11 yo is totally different though. You are able to give her away though if you wanted. What I am saying is that you disagree with surrogacy even if it was free (like adoption, or giving a kidney) so those arguments you are giving are pointless when comparing it to organs IMO and you haven't actually given any evidence to back yourself up in your replies to me about the effects on the mother or baby (nor have I).

If you disagree with surrogacy full stop that's fine of course. I would be a surrogate for a close friend or family member in a heartbeat, in the same way as I would give a kidney, i am closer to this subject than i am happy to discuss as its way too outing. Not everyone feels the way I do which is fine, I am not the only one on here to feel how I do though. I think it's best I don't engage with you further on this matter.

Why is buying an 11 year old totally different? What is the acceptable age limit on human trafficking?

nothingcomestonothing · 10/10/2023 08:15

Sayitaintso33 · 10/10/2023 08:07

These anti-surogacy arguments will come back to haunt us. They always do when we try and prevent men from having something that is ours.

If we argue that the bond from pregnancy is so strong it must never be broken, it will lead to prohibitions on women giving up their children for adoption or otherwise abandoning them during their childhood. How dare you, who carried your child for 9 months put him in nursery to frivolously go and earn money to buy trinkets. Your husband can do that, you can go and nurse your child.

No not 'can never be broken', but can only be broke if nothing else will do for the wellbeing of the child. Which is the standard for adoption in the UK. Surrogacy is about the wants of adults.