Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adam Kay and his husband’s babies

434 replies

MatildaTheCat · 18/06/2023 17:38

Apologies if this has already been covered.

I read in the paper this morning that AK and his DH have welcomed TWO babies into their lives, born to two different surrogates. One child is six months old and their sibling is two months old.

I genuinely cannot wrap my head around this. It seems so very odd to me. Is it a case of ‘one each’ or ‘get the baby stages over asap’?

Obviously nobody but the two parents can answer this but AIBU to find this really quite disturbing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
pinkginfizz9 · 18/06/2023 23:14

I found this thread so confusing until I realised it is not about Peter kay!

Tantaijin · 18/06/2023 23:11

autieawesome · 18/06/2023 22:28

@Tantaijin thanks for replying, you make some interesting points. Do you think it makes a difference if the egg/sperm belong to the prospective parents as opposed to the woman who is pregnant. So when the baby is born it's returned to the people it has the genetic link to? Is surrogacy worse than adoption

I do think that would make a difference yes.

The baby doesn’t care about its DNA. But their instinct screams at them to be near the woman whose heartbeat, voice and smell it has known for the months in utero.

The lifelong trauma that we know occurs in babies adopted at birth can’t be mitigated (no matter how loving or privileged the adoptive parents may be), but it’s accepted as that is what is deemed necessary and best for the baby at that time.

Deliberately creating a baby whilst knowing that you will remove them from their birth mother, not because it is best for the baby, but because of the selfish desire of adults can never be morally right.

GailBlancheViola · 18/06/2023 23:07

So many children come into the world in unfortunate circumstances - parents who are completely useless, unloving, abusive or whatever else, and probably didn’t want the babies in the first place.

As awful as that is that is no justification for selling babies and people, usually rich people, using the reproductive capability of women as a commodity.

But there are lots of loving families that have been created through successful, well prepared surrogacy arrangements where the surrogate also had a positive experience.

Is a positive experience for the child at the heart of this? This is a child being sold to gratify adult's wishes.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 18/06/2023 22:57

ManyMaybes · 18/06/2023 22:51

The story shared of the surrogate that had a negative experience is sad, but not exactly representative of all surrogacy arrangements. She went into the process with very little knowledge about it and then something dreadful and unrelated (and not common) also happened.

Surrogacy where women are being taken advantage of or where they don’t understand the process or are unprepared for it or doing it out of desperation are of course wrong. But there are lots of loving families that have been created through successful, well prepared surrogacy arrangements where the surrogate also had a positive experience.

So many children come into the world in unfortunate circumstances - parents who are completely useless, unloving, abusive or whatever else, and probably didn’t want the babies in the first place. Parents going through the surrogacy process seem much more likely to me to give their children a great upbringing where they are truly cared for.

Excellent, so, blah blah blah, surrogacy good etc etc. So we’ve established that you are totally fine with selling human babies - what’s the going rate? £10k, £20k? How much money would you personally be comfortable with selling a, say, Five year old human child for? £50k? £60k? What price would you think that was ok at???

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 22:56

ManyMaybes can you come up with a plan for how to allow altruistic surrogacy but properly ban commercial? As it stands in the uk commercial is technically illegal, but it happens (as do pretty much all illegal things). When the cases get found out by the authorities nobody actually gets into trouble because at that point the baby exists and sending the parents to prison is really not good for anyone.

ManyMaybes · 18/06/2023 22:51

The story shared of the surrogate that had a negative experience is sad, but not exactly representative of all surrogacy arrangements. She went into the process with very little knowledge about it and then something dreadful and unrelated (and not common) also happened.

Surrogacy where women are being taken advantage of or where they don’t understand the process or are unprepared for it or doing it out of desperation are of course wrong. But there are lots of loving families that have been created through successful, well prepared surrogacy arrangements where the surrogate also had a positive experience.

So many children come into the world in unfortunate circumstances - parents who are completely useless, unloving, abusive or whatever else, and probably didn’t want the babies in the first place. Parents going through the surrogacy process seem much more likely to me to give their children a great upbringing where they are truly cared for.

VestaTilley · 18/06/2023 22:50

YANBU. Commercial surrogacy is vile. Misogyny on steroids, and no thought for the babies taken away permanently from their mothers.

Dreadful man.

StarchySturgess1 · 18/06/2023 22:49

I wonder if he was as much of a cunt to the women carrying his children as is was to the ones he treated.

Odious little prick.

eewno · 18/06/2023 22:49

He's vile.

I also don't agree with surrogacy in general (few exceptions). A close family member did it in the US, as I believe AK did, and it's a business transaction at the end of the day. The woman is literally used a commodity and can be left with long term consequences e.g. never fully recovering from surgery.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 22:46

Re gametes: lots of it really does depend. I don’t agree with paying people for donation. The exploitative practice of offering thousands of pounds discount on fertility treatment for the woman donating eggs should also be illegal. And I agree with the UK law that children born from donor gametes have a right to know their heritage so are allowed to access the donating person’s details when they turn 18.

With those caveats in place I think it is okay to allow gamete donation. But I do wonder if we’ll look back on that and find that children who grew up without knowing their genetic parents have worse outcomes than those who did know them. I’ve no evidence to back up that gut instinct though, so don’t think it should be banned.

cocoloco117 · 18/06/2023 22:45

Lcb123 · 18/06/2023 17:58

how about it being none of your business?

He’s the one trying to leverage it for publicity. If he doesn’t want people making it their business maybe he shouldn’t do interviews with the national press?

BodegaSushi · 18/06/2023 22:43

They aren't the first with this strange arrangement.

Alec and Hilaria Baldwin have children born 6 months apart, one was via surrogate. Hilaria was perfectly capable of bearing children having had 5 before and once since.

Then Elon 'Worshipped on Mumsnet' Musk and Grimes welcomed a daughter via surrogate ONE MONTH after a woman gave birth to his twins 🥴

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 22:40

Is surrogacy worse than adoption

Adoption is better than the alternatives (leaving a baby with a mother who cannot or does not want to care for him/her; forcing termination on a woman who doesn’t want one).
Surrogacy is worse that the alternative (not creating the baby in the first place).

The more ethical choice for people who want to be parents and can’t have their own is definitely adoption.

autieawesome · 18/06/2023 22:28

@Tantaijin thanks for replying, you make some interesting points. Do you think it makes a difference if the egg/sperm belong to the prospective parents as opposed to the woman who is pregnant. So when the baby is born it's returned to the people it has the genetic link to? Is surrogacy worse than adoption

RedToothBrush · 18/06/2023 22:26

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 22:19

I was also a teen in 2004 and it is just not true to say that this was standard/ok at the time. Those songs were wildly offensive then - I guess that was the 'joke', but you can't then claim that condemning Adam Kay for writing them is somehow the same as banning Of Mice and Men... And in any case, he's continued to be pretty blatantly and publicly misogynistic ever since, which also suggests that he wasn't just pretending to be a sexist twat because that was cool in the early 2000s.

This.

I'd have thought prick then tbh.

I just perhaps wouldnt have said it as loudly.

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 22:19

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 18/06/2023 21:48

Sorry @GailBlancheViola I wasn't swerving, I was putting the kids to bed and replying on the hop.

Re: your other questions about free passes for outdated humour... well, not free passes exactly but I certainly don't think that we should be banning or cutting out things from TV shows/films/novels of the 50s/60s/70s etc, no. In my opinion cancel culture is mad and if we banned everything that has outdated ideas portrayed in it then we wouldn't have much art left. I'm an English teacher and we teach a-lot of literature that uses offensive language to us here in the 21st century (Of Mice and Men is a great example, and still widely taught). One of the main points of looking at old jokes/insults/language in general is to have a conversation about why society has moved on.

Not sure that I'd put the Amateur Transplants in that category though. It was student humour with a bit of gross/shocking stuff for their fellow medics. And a lot of it was genuinely very amusing. You've picked on the outliers in terms of their songs for shock value, but most of it was pretty benign and silly and in no way offensive.

I was also a teen in 2004 and it is just not true to say that this was standard/ok at the time. Those songs were wildly offensive then - I guess that was the 'joke', but you can't then claim that condemning Adam Kay for writing them is somehow the same as banning Of Mice and Men... And in any case, he's continued to be pretty blatantly and publicly misogynistic ever since, which also suggests that he wasn't just pretending to be a sexist twat because that was cool in the early 2000s.

Snugglemonkey · 18/06/2023 22:17

hattyhathat · 18/06/2023 17:53

I can only imagine they weren't expecting both to conceive at the same time

But they would know that the first had conceived before inseminating the second.

Mamanch · 18/06/2023 22:02

DinaofCloud9 · 18/06/2023 17:50

He doesn't seem a decent sort at all. He's a vile misogynist.

Exactly.

GailBlancheViola · 18/06/2023 22:00

Re: your other questions about free passes for outdated humour... well, not free passes exactly but I certainly don't think that we should be banning or cutting out things from TV shows/films/novels of the 50s/60s/70s etc, no. In my opinion cancel culture is mad and if we banned everything that has outdated ideas portrayed in it then we wouldn't have much art left. I'm an English teacher and we teach a-lot of literature that uses offensive language to us here in the 21st century (Of Mice and Men is a great example, and still widely taught). One of the main points of looking at old jokes/insults/language in general is to have a conversation about why society has moved on.

I agree with you on this.

nothingcomestonothing · 18/06/2023 21:59

Cyclebabble · 18/06/2023 21:37

@ArabeIIaScott You have no idea what the arrangement was with the surrogates was. Many dedicated women have a positive experience of being a surrogate.

Like these women?

https://www.legalizesurrogacywhynot.com/stories

Stories

Legalize Surrogacy: Why Not?

https://www.legalizesurrogacywhynot.com/stories

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 18/06/2023 21:48

GailBlancheViola · 18/06/2023 19:44

I mean, I'm a southerner. It did make me laugh at the time, yeah. It still raises a bit of a titter now. Doesn't mean it's right or true, just that it's objectively quite funny to hear those amusing lyrics over the tune to 'More than Words'. I also laughed at the lyric 'They're all lazy, fucking useless cunts' about London Underground train drivers, but I don't hate all TfL staff.

It takes all sorts I suppose. I note you swerved the other questions I asked.

Sorry @GailBlancheViola I wasn't swerving, I was putting the kids to bed and replying on the hop.

Re: your other questions about free passes for outdated humour... well, not free passes exactly but I certainly don't think that we should be banning or cutting out things from TV shows/films/novels of the 50s/60s/70s etc, no. In my opinion cancel culture is mad and if we banned everything that has outdated ideas portrayed in it then we wouldn't have much art left. I'm an English teacher and we teach a-lot of literature that uses offensive language to us here in the 21st century (Of Mice and Men is a great example, and still widely taught). One of the main points of looking at old jokes/insults/language in general is to have a conversation about why society has moved on.

Not sure that I'd put the Amateur Transplants in that category though. It was student humour with a bit of gross/shocking stuff for their fellow medics. And a lot of it was genuinely very amusing. You've picked on the outliers in terms of their songs for shock value, but most of it was pretty benign and silly and in no way offensive.

ArabeIIaScott · 18/06/2023 21:39

'dedicated' to what?

Cyclebabble · 18/06/2023 21:37

@ArabeIIaScott You have no idea what the arrangement was with the surrogates was. Many dedicated women have a positive experience of being a surrogate.

MagpiePi · 18/06/2023 21:31

lljkk · 18/06/2023 21:13

I wish them well and hope they all have a happy family life together. That is what is in best interests of the children.

The children are only in existence because AK and his husband paid for them to be created. AK and his husband haven’t saved these children from some kind of dreadful life.

Dubaibutwhy · 18/06/2023 21:30

The only situation where I can understand surrogacy is when a woman can't physically carry a child, due to uterine surgery or similar, but the child is conceived using her eggs.

Anything else makes me feel deeply uncomfortable

Swipe left for the next trending thread