Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to want our children to eat red meat?

652 replies

Flymeaway4 · 18/06/2023 11:30

I'm vegetarian, have been for 20 years, partner is not. Since before they were born, I've said I'll let them have chicken, fish etc, but not red meat including pork. Once they're old enough to properly understand that meat was once an animal, then they can decide for themselves whether they want to eat red meat too, or be vege if they like, their choice. Partner thinks I'm ridiculous and said "why can't she have a ham sandwich" at a party yesterday, "what harm will it do". There were plenty of other options there anyway: chicken, cheese and egg sandwiches, quiche, fruit etc.

In case you think it's relevant, my reasoning behind no red meat is that I think cows and pigs are too intelligent, they know exactly what is happening when they arrive at the abattoir and I think that's just too cruel (and lambs are babies). Allowing chicken and fish, until they can make their own informed decision, was my compromise. If it were purely up to me, I'd be happy raising them vege!

So, am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
redboxer321 · 18/06/2023 18:56

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 18:30

You can choose veganism or vegetarianism for ethical reasons...I mean factory farming is abhorrent. However, human beings are meat eaters. Meat is part of our natural diet. Bizarre lab grown proteins mascarading as meat are not. You can be vegetarian or vegan whilst also admitting meat is nutritionally superior than most plant foods. You don't have to pretend otherwise.

You really can't use the it's natural argument sorry. Human beings are about as far away from our natural state as it's possible to be.

If you want to eat animal products naturally, help yourself to any insects you can catch. A small mammal or bird now and again. The odd bird egg. The rest of your diet should be plant based if you want to go the natural way.

Tantaijin · 18/06/2023 18:42

BurningBothEnds · 18/06/2023 15:51

I have just reintroduced fish, dairy and meat back into my diet around four months ago after being ‘whole foods plant based’ for 7 years.

I felt amazing when I first went vegan, then in the last two years my health started to decline. Extreme tiredness, stomach pains, regular mouth ulcers etc. When my blood test results came back my GP was shocked as how low my iron and B12 was.

I’d eaten very healthily, plenty of legumes, nuts, fruits and veggies. I also took all the supplements I was supposed to.

It was so hard to change my way of eating again (I was nearly in tears attempting to eat an omelette) but my god, I felt so ALIVE!

I now eat a healthy balanced diet and feel worlds better.

This is the most obvious fake post I’ve ever read. 😂 And yes it’s a first post or a name change, what a surprise.

Sorry…why do you think my post is fake?

a) report it to MN if you believe I am a troll.

b) Yes, I regularly name change and am a longtime user. This name change was inspired by a Chinese drama I’ve just watched (`Till the end of the moon’).

c) My MCH was 25.8, RDW at 15.4% and my transferrin saturation was 10.2%.

To be honest it was posts like yours that nearly led me to becoming severely ill. When I found out about my results and started to post asking for advice I’d get shut down and guilt tripped by evangelical preaches who said I couldn’t possibly have been eating right (despite following Michael Gregers book to the letter) or that I was lying about the fact I was taking the right supplements.

My body just wasn’t processing the B12 or iron form my fortified food/supplements. But now I am eating meat/fish/eggs/dairy my levels are approaching normal and therefore I feel a lot healthier.

What is so hard to believe about that?

Sirzy · 18/06/2023 18:37

I view this one and the same way as I do religion. It is fine for a parent to say “this is my belief” and even “this is what i practise at home” but it is wrong to suggest that the belief of the parent is the only way and to not let them explore and experiment with other areas.

i think in many areas of life it can become all to easy to try to force our children down the same path as us rather than giving them to space and skills to draw their own conclusions (even if that differs from ours)

BansheeofInisherin · 18/06/2023 18:35

Summary of the above research "In recent years, the pendulum has swung the other way, and studies are confirming the health benefits of meat-free eating. Nowadays, plant-based eating is recognized as not only nutritionally sufficient but also as a way to reduce the risk for many chronic illnesses. According to the American Dietetic Association, "appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases."

The key is appropriately planned, so not eating Fridge Raiders and Pringles.

BansheeofInisherin · 18/06/2023 18:33

Here's some research on veggie diets being fine, and often healthier. Western scientists are rethinking their views on veg diets being nutritionally lacking. Becoming a vegetarian - Harvard Health.

I think Michael Pollan has a lot more, but right now I cba to go through it. He annoys me a bit with his harping on what my granny has been doing all her life. "Eat real food, mostly plants."

I don;t know why people are going on about lab grown proteins being worse than meat. Most of the world does not eat them. They eat vegetables!

becoming a vegetarian

Becoming a vegetarian - Harvard Health

You can get many of the health benefits from becoming a vegetarian without going all the way. You can steer your diet in that direction with a few simple substitutions....

https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/becoming-a-vegetarian

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 18:30

Wenfy · 18/06/2023 18:26

Ancient Hindu and Jain cultures were athiest who believed in balancing the ecosystem & new no food could be produced without eating or killing animals of some sort. Ground flour contains a lot of insect eggs (which is why it gets beevils). Roots, nuts and legumes have insects inside them that you either must kill or consume to get the goodness. It’s why these cultures didn’t consider roots, figs, dates, dairy and other sticky foods vegetarian.

Also, most vegans in the UK live on a lot of processed junk - once research is done on Quorn etc I have no doubt it will be placed even higher than red meat as carcinogens. B

Why are you desperately trying to compare the odd insect on a lettuce leaf to the mass in
slaughter of animals on an industrial scale?

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 18:30

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 18:23

I think your post says it all actually. Enough said.

Not once have you acknowledged the pain, suffering and torture of animals, not once.

The world and its wildlife does NOT exist purely for your benefit. The irony of you calling others superior. Seriously take a good, hard long look at yourself.

You can choose veganism or vegetarianism for ethical reasons...I mean factory farming is abhorrent. However, human beings are meat eaters. Meat is part of our natural diet. Bizarre lab grown proteins mascarading as meat are not. You can be vegetarian or vegan whilst also admitting meat is nutritionally superior than most plant foods. You don't have to pretend otherwise.

YouMustBeJoeKing · 18/06/2023 18:27

think cows and pigs are too intelligent, they know exactly what is happening when they arrive at the abattoir and I think that's just too cruel (and lambs are babies)

if you eat dairy products then the above statement is meaningless to you. If you think it’s cruel to kill cows because they know what is going on, but think it’s ok to separate calves from their mothers and force cows to reproduce over and over again just for milk production, then you’re a hypocrite to not eat read meat but consume dairy.

Wenfy · 18/06/2023 18:26

Ancient Hindu and Jain cultures were athiest who believed in balancing the ecosystem & new no food could be produced without eating or killing animals of some sort. Ground flour contains a lot of insect eggs (which is why it gets beevils). Roots, nuts and legumes have insects inside them that you either must kill or consume to get the goodness. It’s why these cultures didn’t consider roots, figs, dates, dairy and other sticky foods vegetarian.

Also, most vegans in the UK live on a lot of processed junk - once research is done on Quorn etc I have no doubt it will be placed even higher than red meat as carcinogens. B

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 18:23

Watchkeys · 18/06/2023 18:19

Meat is more nutritious, yes, and it's not embarrassing to say so, even if you think that it is. You are not the judge, nor do you know everything. Why are you wanting to make people seem stupid? 'The mind boggles at the ignorance' is such a superior attitude to take. I'd find it embarrassing to say something like that, to be honest.

Meat has a more complete selection of essential nutrients for the human body, in more accessible forms, than vegetables. Obviously you haven't read the research yourself. Find the research that shows that a vegetarian/vegan diet contains all the nutrients we need, in the best forms for us to consume. That'll get you further in getting your point across than '??' and the 'Why are people such idiots?' attitude.

I think your post says it all actually. Enough said.

Not once have you acknowledged the pain, suffering and torture of animals, not once.

The world and its wildlife does NOT exist purely for your benefit. The irony of you calling others superior. Seriously take a good, hard long look at yourself.

Watchkeys · 18/06/2023 18:19

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:58

Societies in the third world have a genuine reason to eat whatever is available, I am afraid you don’t have the same free pass.

I can’t believe people still wheel out the old trope of meat being more nutritious even now with all of the education and accessible research we have now in 2023! Aren’t you embarrassed to post such misinformation? Or do you still actually believe eating meat is better for you?? The mind boggles at the ignorance.

Meat is more nutritious, yes, and it's not embarrassing to say so, even if you think that it is. You are not the judge, nor do you know everything. Why are you wanting to make people seem stupid? 'The mind boggles at the ignorance' is such a superior attitude to take. I'd find it embarrassing to say something like that, to be honest.

Meat has a more complete selection of essential nutrients for the human body, in more accessible forms, than vegetables. Obviously you haven't read the research yourself. Find the research that shows that a vegetarian/vegan diet contains all the nutrients we need, in the best forms for us to consume. That'll get you further in getting your point across than '??' and the 'Why are people such idiots?' attitude.

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 18:15

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 18:12

I can’t believe people still wheel out the old trope of meat being more nutritious even now with all of the education and accessible research we have now in 2023! Aren’t you embarrassed to post such misinformation? Or do you still actually believe eating meat is better for you? The mind boggles at the ignorance

I can't believe people still wheel out the old phrase "third world" even now with all the education we now have in 2023. Aren't you embarrassed to use such outdated phrases?

Your comedy cooking probably cant stretch to a nutritionally balanced vegetarian dinner.

BansheeofInisherin · 18/06/2023 18:13

Why don't you just give them veggie food at home and let them eat what they want outside? That seems a better compromise.

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 18:12

I can’t believe people still wheel out the old trope of meat being more nutritious even now with all of the education and accessible research we have now in 2023! Aren’t you embarrassed to post such misinformation? Or do you still actually believe eating meat is better for you? The mind boggles at the ignorance

I can't believe people still wheel out the old phrase "third world" even now with all the education we now have in 2023. Aren't you embarrassed to use such outdated phrases?

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 18:10

Flymeaway4 · 18/06/2023 18:04

To all those saying I shouldn't 'project my viewpoint' on my children, is your choice to eat meant not also your viewpoint that you are 'projecting' on your children?! Maybe you should also be offering them insects and dogmeat in case they may like it.

The very point of raising children is to instil morals, ethics and values - it’s up to them as they get older to challenge and decide for themselves. My kids love being vegetarian and always have done. We have been to thousands of parties and dinners, it’s never ever a problem.

Flymeaway4 · 18/06/2023 18:04

To all those saying I shouldn't 'project my viewpoint' on my children, is your choice to eat meant not also your viewpoint that you are 'projecting' on your children?! Maybe you should also be offering them insects and dogmeat in case they may like it.

OP posts:
GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:58

Societies in the third world have a genuine reason to eat whatever is available, I am afraid you don’t have the same free pass.

I can’t believe people still wheel out the old trope of meat being more nutritious even now with all of the education and accessible research we have now in 2023! Aren’t you embarrassed to post such misinformation? Or do you still actually believe eating meat is better for you?? The mind boggles at the ignorance.

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 17:42

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:37

I can’t speak for you but my reasoning goes beyond that of a lizard.

Humans did not have the option or ability to access limitless food along the lines of what we have today, there is simply no excuse for using prehistoric reasoning to justify your support of cruelty now.
Now you can eat your own body weight in food 247 if you so choose without any harm coming to animals, insects or birds.

Unless you are posting from a third world country you just sound ridiculous.

Third world? Maybe your reasoning skills don't go as far as you would like to think.

Watchkeys · 18/06/2023 17:41

Unless you are posting from a third world country you just sound ridiculous

Or unless you are using nutrition as an argument.

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:37

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 17:24

Of course meat was. Its far more calorie and nutrient dense. If you don't know when you will next eat, of course you eat the most nutritious, calorific thing

My friend has a lizard. Put a piece of kale in front of it and an insect. Guess which the lizard ate first?

I can’t speak for you but my reasoning goes beyond that of a lizard.

Humans did not have the option or ability to access limitless food along the lines of what we have today, there is simply no excuse for using prehistoric reasoning to justify your support of cruelty now.
Now you can eat your own body weight in food 247 if you so choose without any harm coming to animals, insects or birds.

Unless you are posting from a third world country you just sound ridiculous.

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 17:24

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:19

How the hell do you know animals were first choice? 😂😂 Were you there? Nope! So please stop projecting your own values as fact.

Of course meat was. Its far more calorie and nutrient dense. If you don't know when you will next eat, of course you eat the most nutritious, calorific thing

My friend has a lizard. Put a piece of kale in front of it and an insect. Guess which the lizard ate first?

Watchkeys · 18/06/2023 17:23

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:19

How the hell do you know animals were first choice? 😂😂 Were you there? Nope! So please stop projecting your own values as fact.

Because there's a much higher risk in hunting than in gathering, so if plants were the preferred option, we would have just eaten those and not taken that elevated risk.

'Nope!' doesn't really take the evidence into consideration.

BansheeofInisherin · 18/06/2023 17:20

Everyone can eat what they want, depending on what suits their bodies, but I personally think the nation has been enfeebled by ultraprocessed food.

GCalltheway · 18/06/2023 17:19

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 17:15

Yes exactly. Hunter gatherers did eat plants but if they had meat available that was always the preferred option. Plants would have been eaten because it's better than nothing but animals were always the first choice.

How the hell do you know animals were first choice? 😂😂 Were you there? Nope! So please stop projecting your own values as fact.

Comedycook · 18/06/2023 17:15

Watchkeys · 18/06/2023 17:09

@GCalltheway

Fortunately some of us have developed since then

Not much in terms of evolutionary biology, and especially not since we were hunter gatherers very very recently, in evolutionary terms.

Yes exactly. Hunter gatherers did eat plants but if they had meat available that was always the preferred option. Plants would have been eaten because it's better than nothing but animals were always the first choice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread