Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?

211 replies

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 10:54

1 in 3 women in this country obtain abortions at some point in their lives.

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK and to obtain one without being open to prosecution, a woman needs two doctors to permit it. because of this many many many women emphasise and maybe even embellish, or lie, to obtain that. Will it really mean you cannot afford your rent / mortgage and you'll be homeless? Probably not, but you just DO NOT want a(nother) baby. And actually a woman should be able to just NOT WANT a(nother) pregnancy or a(nother) child. Yet the woman is forced to say what needs to be said procure an abortion.

Therefore thousands of women every year would be jailed just like this woman has been.

The jailing was NOT because of the late term of the pregnancy, it was because she lied to obtain it and therefore she's in jail.

Lots and lots women have done that. Lots.

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:09

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:06

Do you find your mind turning to men when speaking about topics that relate to women?

I don't, so I won't comment.

Odd way of saying ‘I don’t have a response to that’

but let’s play! It’s like Shannon Matthews mum was jailed for telling a lie.

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:08

Abortion is hard because it's not a light topic.

Do I think women should have to carry forced pregnancies , no I don't.

So I think the killing of fetuses is also awful and sad. Yes I do.

It's not straightforward. It's a very sad topic

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:07

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:04

'Kill'.

Okaaaaay.

You do kill the fetus though in abortion. That is a fact. There is no point dancing around it is there.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:07

@BigPeople They need reasons for a termination at any stage. If they do not have them, it's a crime.

I'm not making this up!

OP posts:
TwilightBee · 18/06/2023 12:06

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:39

This is great. I'm glad that was your experience as you found yourself in that position.

However it means the clinician was acting outside the law. Unfortunately, this is not every woman's experience as many clinicians act within the law (which they can do to protect themselves).

The law is the law. I have stated it above.

You clearly don’t understand legalese. Not wanting a baby is enough reason and is covered by the law you are quoting.

When I was asked why I want an abortion I simply said I don’t want a baby.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:06

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 11:54

Using OP's logic Boris Becker was jailed for lying.

Do you find your mind turning to men when speaking about topics that relate to women?

I don't, so I won't comment.

OP posts:
sparkleice · 18/06/2023 12:05

@Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime

what are you trying to say with this post?

Are you saying (as per your user name) that abortion should not be a crime? as you are not clear, I'm confused about what you want?

BigPeople · 18/06/2023 12:05

Abortion before 12 weeks should be on demand. In practice, it is for most women. I’ve had two abortions 20 years apart at 8/9 weeks and I didn’t have to give any reason other than ‘I don’t want a child’.

Late stage termination is a different matter. There need to be concrete reasons to terminate a 34 week pregnancy rather than go to full term and adoption.

Having said that, I feel for this woman and I don’t think she should’ve been imprisoned. What good does that do? What she did was desperate and misguided, but for fuck sake she was obviously in a bad place, it was a pandemic and the health service wasn’t working properly and the world was upside down. She should’ve been shown mercy.

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:04

Sometimes you don't find out your pregnant until very late though.

I remember one time , I began to exhibit all the symptoms of pregnancy. Missed a period. Sore boobs. Very Swollen tummy.

I had last had sex 5 and a half months ago. So I knew if I was pregnant I would be five and a half months pregnant. I was terrified. I couldn't have the baby. I knew I was also very close to the date to have an abortion.

I rang an abortion clinic in a panic and asked if I would still be able to get an abortion at 5 and a half months.

I'll never forget what the man on the phone said . He said "we do abortions up to six months, however that is not a target for you to reach".
He was taking to me Like i would choose to be pregnant for up to as long as possible and then saunter in to get an abortion when I had reached the absolute limit.

He was very condescending.

I went to the doctor and it turned out i wasn't pregnant. I actually had a large cyst.

But I'll never forget the terror of thinking I wa pregnant at a late stage, and how condescending the abortion clinic was.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:04

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 12:00

It is generally considered in the UK that forced birthing is not good for a woman's mental health. So we allow terminations of pregnancy fairly freely in early pregnancy.

In late term pregnancies, the baby has to be birthed. The options then are do you birth the baby and see if it survives. Or do you kill it first.

'Kill'.

Okaaaaay.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 18/06/2023 12:04

I don't actually agree with this take, but I still think abortion should be decriminalised.
Women need help and support, and they aren't getting it. Punishing them for not having choices isn't how a civilised society works. Put the support structure in place, and then you can think about punishments.

Its not carrot and stick if there's no carrot.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:03

Daydreamer123456 · 18/06/2023 11:56

@Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime

Why do you keep posting the law if you’re not going to read it?

a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week

I've read the law.

THIS JUDGMENT was not about the stage of pregnancy, it was the way in which the abortion was obtained. Sure, she had to lie because it was 24 weeks +, but it is that she lied, not why she lied.

Beyond this woman, let me spell out my concerns.

As a woman, I cannot legally have a termination unless one of those four conditions are met. I have been pregnant, and had several children. However if during any of those pregnancies, at any time if I wanted to end the pregnancy I COULD NOT unless one of those four conditions were met. In my case they would not have been. If I said 'oh yes, I think my mental health would suffer' I could get one. But I would have lied, and therefore I could be prosecuted.

I'm saying AIBU to think that actually many women don't satisfy those four criteria, but they have terminations anyway even BEFORE 24 weeks. the law provides for those prosecution.

If you read something else into the law, then please elucidate as I'd be very glad to hear it.

OP posts:
Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 12:00

It is generally considered in the UK that forced birthing is not good for a woman's mental health. So we allow terminations of pregnancy fairly freely in early pregnancy.

In late term pregnancies, the baby has to be birthed. The options then are do you birth the baby and see if it survives. Or do you kill it first.

troubg · 18/06/2023 12:00

If the point you're making here is that abortion should be entirely legalised and treated as a healthcare matter then I agree with you.

I also do not think that jailing this woman was in the public interest. Suspended sentence plus mandatory counselling would have been far more appropriate.

agree

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:00

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:57

No it doesn't. B) is B) - grave injury. Not 'I just don't want this pregnancy'. If it was 'I just don't want this baby' it would say something to that effect.

Of course B is one that many women will indicate. My proposition here is that that might not be strictly true for many women who just don't want one.

Yes it is.

Careying and giving birth to a child risks grave injury to someone’s mental health. Can you read where it says ‘physical or mental health’?

ladyvimes · 18/06/2023 11:59

NeverendingCircus · 18/06/2023 11:34

I think what op is saying is that we should decriminalise abortion, which I understand is a fair position to hold. But what this woman did was poison a viable baby. That cannot be acceptable in any humane society. A cluster of cells is one thing. A viable baby is something else entirely.

I think it's an extremely tricky case. It's awful that her children have been left without a mother, and for the sake of those children, I would have preferred a judge to give a long but suspended sentence with full MH support (as if that exists in UK Hmm.) But there has to be a massive deterrent to any other woman thinking it's OK to lie about something like this. Especially given how many GP surgeries are keen to stay online and on the phone rather than returning to in-person appointments.

The thing is that many people abort what would further down the line become a viable baby for no other reason than they don’t want another child.

The law needs to be clear on when a foetus becomes a person, which, in my understanding, is at the point of birth.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 18/06/2023 11:59

NewShoes · 18/06/2023 11:58

I think the woman in question obtained the abortion pills on 11 May, and aborted the baby around 34 weeks. That would have meant she was 24 weeks on 2nd March, which would have been the legal limit to abort the baby - at that point the country was not in lockdown.

She lied and knew she was killing a viable baby. I’ve always been a supporter of the right to abortion, but not at 34 weeks. The thought is horrific.

Exactly - and she knew she was pregnant in January and didn't do anything about it. She had weeks to see a doctor or clinic and get a safe and legal abortion.

hattyhathat · 18/06/2023 11:58

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:08

Also she didn't need to be in prison. The judge had no sentencing guidelines and could have given a sentence of 24 months, which would then has been suspended. Instead He handed down a custodial sentence of 4 months longer that could not be suspended, so now her three children, including one with additional needs, will be without their mother for up to 28 months.

Yes if she'd pled guilty earlier. She didnt

NewShoes · 18/06/2023 11:58

I think the woman in question obtained the abortion pills on 11 May, and aborted the baby around 34 weeks. That would have meant she was 24 weeks on 2nd March, which would have been the legal limit to abort the baby - at that point the country was not in lockdown.

She lied and knew she was killing a viable baby. I’ve always been a supporter of the right to abortion, but not at 34 weeks. The thought is horrific.

3BSHKATS · 18/06/2023 11:58

gogohmm · 18/06/2023 11:22

Ps they do not scan prior to abortion unless the woman or medical professional is concerned about date's especially with relevance to the 24 week limit (I know my friend needed to certify gestation if likely to be over 16 weeks)

I thought scans were standard procedure. No matter what stage the pregnancy is at. A friend of mine had a horrendous experience because they forgot to turn the sound down or off and she heard the heartbeat at 8 weeks.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:57

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 11:55

And b covers anyone who doesn’t want their baby, as long as they meet the other legal limits.

Sometimes after

No it doesn't. B) is B) - grave injury. Not 'I just don't want this pregnancy'. If it was 'I just don't want this baby' it would say something to that effect.

Of course B is one that many women will indicate. My proposition here is that that might not be strictly true for many women who just don't want one.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 18/06/2023 11:57

Yes i understand what you mean op.

Most 'social' abortions are made legal by doctors signing off that continuing with the pregnancy would case harm to the mother's mental health. Its a bit of a stretch in many cases I'm sure. More like a tick box exercise.

We don't actually have abortion available on demand when you look more deeply at the legal side of it

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 18/06/2023 11:57

Daydreamer123456 · 18/06/2023 11:56

@Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime

Why do you keep posting the law if you’re not going to read it?

a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week

Because it doesn't fit with her "facts" Wink

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 11:56

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 18/06/2023 11:54

I feel like I'm in the minority but aborting a baby so late is disgusting. That baby is likely to have survived being born at that late stage. I am not anti abortion in any way if its before the viable stage but I'm sick of women being put on a pedestal on this site, it's like they can do no wrong. Yes her body her choice but she had months to make that choice.

Genuinely don’t think you are in the minority. I think the majority of people who are ‘pro choice’ and want abortion available also think there should be limits.

Daydreamer123456 · 18/06/2023 11:56

@Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime

Why do you keep posting the law if you’re not going to read it?

a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week