Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?

211 replies

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 10:54

1 in 3 women in this country obtain abortions at some point in their lives.

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK and to obtain one without being open to prosecution, a woman needs two doctors to permit it. because of this many many many women emphasise and maybe even embellish, or lie, to obtain that. Will it really mean you cannot afford your rent / mortgage and you'll be homeless? Probably not, but you just DO NOT want a(nother) baby. And actually a woman should be able to just NOT WANT a(nother) pregnancy or a(nother) child. Yet the woman is forced to say what needs to be said procure an abortion.

Therefore thousands of women every year would be jailed just like this woman has been.

The jailing was NOT because of the late term of the pregnancy, it was because she lied to obtain it and therefore she's in jail.

Lots and lots women have done that. Lots.

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 18/06/2023 12:20

You cannot get an abortion 'for any reason'. It needs to be one of four reasons

In theory, yes. In reality, no. I was silly snd got myself pregnant at 18. Simply didn't want to be a mum, none of the aforementioned criteria applied to me. I went to the GP and said I wanted an abortion, they didn't pry into my circumstances, they simply referred me and an abortion was carried out.

GuinnessBird · 18/06/2023 12:20

OP you're acting like a bit of a clown here.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 18/06/2023 12:19

This is the bit of the legislation that allows any woman to have an abortion for any reason up to 24 weeks gestation:

  • (a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week and that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman or any existing children of her family;

The continuation of a pregnancy is always a greater risk than termination even for completely healthy women carrying much wanted babies.

There is no need to lie.

HyperionWarbonnet · 18/06/2023 12:19

I understood she had met a new man and didn't want him to know she was pregnant. If she was going to lie, it would have made sense to tell him she is carrying the child as part of a surrogacy agreement and have it adopted. That would have made him like her a whole lot more than this shitshow I'm sure.

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:18

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:13

It's a reason, but it isn't sufficient in our law.

I won't be gaslighted here. I've posted the law a few times now.

No you don’t get to that. You don’t get use a term used to describe abuse towards people who disagree with you, without being challenged.

Your therapy speak makes you look like you have no valid argument. And is ridiculous.

carrying and birthing a child you don’t want carry’s huge risk of causing grave injury to the woman’s mental health. That’s a fact. Stating that fact, is not gaslighting.

and using that term belittles victims of actual abuse. Which is usually women. The people who are pretending you are so passionate about protecting. That isn’t protecting women.

Harkhark · 18/06/2023 12:18

EasterBreak · 18/06/2023 11:25

She deserves prison. Awful what she did. So cruel. It was to late. Get the baby adopted if she didn't want it.

Local community would think it was very weird if pregnant lady with husband and other children announced they were having the youngest adopted

HyperionWarbonnet · 18/06/2023 12:17

She's in jail because she took the drug outside of the indications for the drug and knowingly did so. This resulted in the destruction of a foetus that could have just been born and adopted away

sleepyscientist · 18/06/2023 12:17

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 12:00

It is generally considered in the UK that forced birthing is not good for a woman's mental health. So we allow terminations of pregnancy fairly freely in early pregnancy.

In late term pregnancies, the baby has to be birthed. The options then are do you birth the baby and see if it survives. Or do you kill it first.

Can we please get past abortion killing the baby! She in effect commit significant self harm breaking down the tissue of her placenta and inducing labour. She obtained the drugs by deception yes, but would she be in the same situation if she convinced a doctor to give her other drugs which taken as an overdose actually killed the baby? What if she had threatened to commit suicide if she wasn't induced so she was and the baby died. In the same vein should woman who continue to drink, smoke, so drugs etc whilst pregnant also do 28 months inside as all these can cause premature labour and foetal demise.

She is a lady who needs significant support if she thought the only option to her was self harm.

fancreek · 18/06/2023 12:16

I really cannot cope with the OPs inability to grasp what people are saying, and just keep incorrectly stating that things are facts.

Don't you think if you were right, that fewer doctors would sign off, and more people would be prosecuted?

Can you consider you might be wrong based on reading the thread?!

PumpkinSoup21 · 18/06/2023 12:16

Has anyone on this thread who is condemning this woman read the research about these very rare cases? It shows that women in these situations of unauthorised late term abortion are invariably facing immense psychological pressure and get into a state of mind where all they know is they ‘cannot’ be pregnant. This is very different to killing a child - they enter a state where they cannot think of the pregnancy as a baby, even at a late stage.

The judge’s summing up mentioned that the woman has spoken of being tormented night and day by flashback to the birth. She very likely has PTSD.

There is absolutely zero benefit to anyone from a custodial sentence. The woman won’t get the help she needs. Her existing children will go through further trauma. And as for being a deterrent - it’s laughable. That’s like saying we should criminalise suicide again to make people more worried about the consequences of trying to kill themselves.

HyperionWarbonnet · 18/06/2023 12:15

Can you not read the subtleties of the law surrounding this OP. The entire construct is deliberately created to cover all the grey areas. 'In good faith' etc is subject to scrutiny but only up to a point, as is 90% of the rest of it. Any individual would have a devil of a job proving a GP did not act in good faith and therein lies the basis for the whole thing and why it fundamentally works.

Hardly any woman that wants an abortion, provided her pregnancy is less than the cut off, is granted it.

There is no individual that can bring a case because they are not allowed access to medical records of another person without their consent etc. All these grey areas are covered and it works.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:15

Namechangedagain20 · 18/06/2023 12:13

At no point during my abortion (through bpas) was I asked my reasons for aborting, just that I was sure I wanted and wasn’t under any pressure from a partner etc. I saw midwives to scan and determine how far along I was doctors approved the abortion pills.

So YABU, I didn’t have to embellish, the fact that it was an unwanted pregnancy within the right time frames meant I didn’t have to have a ‘good enough’ reason.

Ok, so maybe you're right. If so, I'm glad you think that might be the experience of many women.

If that is the case, your termination was illegal, though.

I wonder how that feels for many women.

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:15

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:11

True.

I only understand The Law. Maybe you can read between lines, but I don't, I just follow The Law. I presume it has been written as it has been written for a reason.

But again, if you see criteria for 'I just don't want this pregnancy' please underline it in that law.

I'm not alone. If I were alone there wouldn't have been protests this week and Stella Creasy et al would be taking rubbish. Maybe we're all deluded and we just can't see words written in the law that are clearly there?

My AIBU was - AIBU to think most women don't fall within one of those 4 criterion.

Yabu because they do fall into those categories

If you don’t want to carry and give birth to a child there’s serious risk of grave injury to you mental health.

Plus any pregnancy has a risk of grave injury to physical health.

honeylulu · 18/06/2023 12:14

Sorry no idea why that huge space inserted itself!

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:13

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:09

Yes and I don’t want one is a reason

It's a reason, but it isn't sufficient in our law.

I won't be gaslighted here. I've posted the law a few times now.

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:13

roarfeckingroarr · 18/06/2023 12:12

@Mooshamoo I'm sorry you had a bad experience but I don't think a bit of negativity is the end of the world. Aborting a six month old foetus is pretty dismal.

Yes it is horrible. But what if the woman was raped. There are so many nuances to abortion.

Namechangedagain20 · 18/06/2023 12:13

At no point during my abortion (through bpas) was I asked my reasons for aborting, just that I was sure I wanted and wasn’t under any pressure from a partner etc. I saw midwives to scan and determine how far along I was doctors approved the abortion pills.

So YABU, I didn’t have to embellish, the fact that it was an unwanted pregnancy within the right time frames meant I didn’t have to have a ‘good enough’ reason.

honeylulu · 18/06/2023 12:13

The current legislation does not allow abortion on demand before 24 weeks. It should in my view and many if not most medical professionals feel similarly because (b) is the most often used reason, without its basis being anything other than superficially interrogated. So in reality (b) is used effectively to grant termination on demand. Termination after 24 weeks is a completely different issue legally and morally as the baby is potentially able to survive independently. It will only be legal if the baby is suffering a serious abnormality (this isn't defined anywhere and is controversial) or the mother's life is in danger. Neither of those appear to have applied in the case being discussed and in any event the doctors involved were not given the evidence to consider because the woman claimed to be much earlier in her pregnancy (rather than risking the high chance of a refusal). Late terminations involve euthanising the baby in utero so that it is not delivered alive and acquires no legal identity and experiences minimal suffering. The baby was actually born alive and lived for 45 minutes. This is exactly the sort of event the legislation is intended to protect against.

Yes

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:12

Abortion before 24 weeks is legal.

It said that the woman jailed was 7 months pregnant.

How does one month make that much difference?

roarfeckingroarr · 18/06/2023 12:12

@Mooshamoo I'm sorry you had a bad experience but I don't think a bit of negativity is the end of the world. Aborting a six month old foetus is pretty dismal.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:11

TwilightBee · 18/06/2023 12:06

You clearly don’t understand legalese. Not wanting a baby is enough reason and is covered by the law you are quoting.

When I was asked why I want an abortion I simply said I don’t want a baby.

True.

I only understand The Law. Maybe you can read between lines, but I don't, I just follow The Law. I presume it has been written as it has been written for a reason.

But again, if you see criteria for 'I just don't want this pregnancy' please underline it in that law.

I'm not alone. If I were alone there wouldn't have been protests this week and Stella Creasy et al would be taking rubbish. Maybe we're all deluded and we just can't see words written in the law that are clearly there?

My AIBU was - AIBU to think most women don't fall within one of those 4 criterion.

OP posts:
HyperionWarbonnet · 18/06/2023 12:10

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:39

This is great. I'm glad that was your experience as you found yourself in that position.

However it means the clinician was acting outside the law. Unfortunately, this is not every woman's experience as many clinicians act within the law (which they can do to protect themselves).

The law is the law. I have stated it above.

The clinician was not acting outside the law. Read the criteria you yourself have quoted.

JagerPlease · 18/06/2023 12:10

Abortion before 24 weeks will almost always be legal. And that is without the need for a woman to lie.

Firstly, carrying a baby to term is inherently more risky for the mother than an abortion at an early stage of pregnancy. Neither are "high risk" in most cases, but in relative terms, abortion is less risky.

Secondly, it is accepted that requiring a woman to carry a baby to full term that she does not want will be more damaging to her mental health than an abortion.

Up to 24 weeks you don't need to show that the outcome will be grave, it is just a direct comparison. So "I don't want to continue this pregnancy" is enough of a reason

After 24 weeks it is very different

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 18/06/2023 12:10

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:06

You cannot get an abortion 'for any reason'. It needs to be one of four reasons. And I do think that many many women, if not most, women who obtain abortions are not at risk o f'grave'outcomes, but they just do not want the pregnancy. And so they are in the position where they have to talk it up. This is demeaning, but I think is probably done day in and day out because women are not allowed to just not want a pregnancy, or just not want a(nother).

Abortion Law Criteria
The Abortion Act 1967 states that an abortion is legal if it is performed by a registered medical practitioner (a doctor), and that it is authorised by two doctors, acting in good faith, on one (or more) of the following grounds (with each needing to agree that at least one and the same ground is met):

  • (a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week and that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman or any existing children of her family; or
  • (b) that the termination is necessary to prevent grave permanent injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman; or
  • (c) that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk to the life of the pregnant woman, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated; or
  • (d) that there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped.

I had an abortion and none of this was discussed or mentioned.

All I said was "I do not want another baby"

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:09

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:07

@BigPeople They need reasons for a termination at any stage. If they do not have them, it's a crime.

I'm not making this up!

Yes and I don’t want one is a reason

Swipe left for the next trending thread