Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?

211 replies

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 10:54

1 in 3 women in this country obtain abortions at some point in their lives.

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK and to obtain one without being open to prosecution, a woman needs two doctors to permit it. because of this many many many women emphasise and maybe even embellish, or lie, to obtain that. Will it really mean you cannot afford your rent / mortgage and you'll be homeless? Probably not, but you just DO NOT want a(nother) baby. And actually a woman should be able to just NOT WANT a(nother) pregnancy or a(nother) child. Yet the woman is forced to say what needs to be said procure an abortion.

Therefore thousands of women every year would be jailed just like this woman has been.

The jailing was NOT because of the late term of the pregnancy, it was because she lied to obtain it and therefore she's in jail.

Lots and lots women have done that. Lots.

OP posts:
AllOfThemWitches · 18/06/2023 12:59

ThatFraggle · 18/06/2023 12:43

Having an unwanted child CAN lead to 'grave harm' psychologically.

OP thinks most women are lying when they say not having an abortion would result in grave harm.

Yep. I had an abortion in May and when I said I would struggle mentally if I continued with the pregnancy I absolutely wasn't lying. Just because I wouldn't necessarily have killed myself, doesn't mean I would have coped.

DameEdna1 · 18/06/2023 12:58

ThatFraggle · 18/06/2023 12:43

Having an unwanted child CAN lead to 'grave harm' psychologically.

OP thinks most women are lying when they say not having an abortion would result in grave harm.

I agree. And from reading the law OP quoted, it seems like saying 'I'm more likely to experience mental health problems if I continue the pregnancy than if I have a termination' should satisfy criteria a.

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:53

JinglingSpringbells · 18/06/2023 12:41

Because medicine and drs are supposed to preserve life.
And a foetus up to so many weeks is not classed as 'human life' (ie viable) in the same way as someone who has been born.

Also, the concerns around euthanasia are that it would be a way of hastening death for financial reasons (for beneficiaries) and the person who was unwell may not be of sound mind to agree to euthanasia.

I think euthanasia is the more humane option in many cases. I had an absolutely horrendous life. I cry and suffer every single day. I've attempted suicide before and I didn't succeed. The physical pain of that suicide attempt was horrendous. Knowing how much a suicide attempt can physically hurt, stops me from doing it again. I remember the pain, it was awful.

If there was a choice of euthanasia where I could have a safe, painless, medically assisted death, I would definitely choose it.

As we say we should be able to choose abortion by just saying "I don't want to have a baby".

We should also be able to choose euthanasia by just saying " I don't want to live"

Heyheyitsanotherday · 18/06/2023 12:53

I don’t understand your point. What ever reason is given for requesting an abortion would fall into part ‘A’ of a the law “effecting the mental health of the mother”. So no laws are broken. The issue with this lady was she lied about her gestation.

Lifeomars · 18/06/2023 12:51

Voted incorrectly as I read the post too quickly, I agree that abortion should be wholly a woman's choice that she does not have to explain to others nor to justify so that she can obtain the treatment. Carrying a pregancy, giving birth and then being responsible for another human being for the next 18 years are huge life changing undertakings and it should be up to the individual woman to decide whether or not she wants to go ahead. I think in the past women seeking a termination may have had to emphasise the negative consequences of continuing with a pregnancy but really it should just be accepted that she knows what is best for her and her life situation.

AllOfThemWitches · 18/06/2023 12:48

EasterBreak · 18/06/2023 11:25

She deserves prison. Awful what she did. So cruel. It was to late. Get the baby adopted if she didn't want it.

Oh yeah coz that's really easy for everyone

TheGreatATuin · 18/06/2023 12:44

There is an enormous difference between someone lying before 24 weeks to get an abortion because of restrictive laws and someone lying when they are almost to term. The difference is that between a fetus and a baby, and between abortion and infanticide.
I believe abortion should be available on demand in the early months and agree that it is an awful and difficult case, but I do agree with the prison sentence in this one.
The court found that she'd done a pregnancy test in December. She aborted in May. She had time to make a choice, even if it was a hard one.
If she is let off, it also sets a dangerous precedent.

ThatFraggle · 18/06/2023 12:43

Having an unwanted child CAN lead to 'grave harm' psychologically.

OP thinks most women are lying when they say not having an abortion would result in grave harm.

DameEdna1 · 18/06/2023 12:43

I don't think it's reading between the lines to see that criteria A clearly covers 'I don't want a baby.' If you don't want a baby and you're pregnant, continuing the pregnancy to term quite clearly poses a greater risk to your physical and mental health than having a termination- so criteria A would always be satisfied.

I don't think that criteria is saying that continuing the pregnancy has to be proven to pose a grave risk to mental/physical health or even that the woman has to be experiencing physical/mental health symptoms at the time of seeking a termination- just that continuing the pregnancy increases her risk compared with having a termination.

Goldbar · 18/06/2023 12:42

Despite being very pro choice, I do think there needs to be a cut-off point as aborting a viable baby is very different to aborting an early term pregnancy. Subject to certain exceptions, therefore, I do think it is acceptable for access to abortion to be restricted beyond a certain time limit.

That said, I agree with you OP in that I can't see that criminalising and jailing women in these very rare cases is the right way of dealing with them. I'm surprised first of all that it was thought to be in the public interest to proceed with the prosecution and secondly that a prison term was considered the appropriate punishment. These cases occur so rarely and in such difficult circumstances that I don't see the need to deter by prosecuting or harsh punishment. I also think jailing women with caring responsibilities is in general a terrible idea where they don't pose a risk to society and aren't likely to reoffend... who gains from it compared to the harm and trauma caused to vulnerable children through the loss of a parent?

LemonTT · 18/06/2023 12:41

Rosecoffeecup · 18/06/2023 11:43

I'm not sure you could have made your point less clear if you'd tried

How common is it for a doctor to not agree to a termination?

This really. The OP is not making a good argument and using a bad example to support it.

The reality of the situation is that current laws are a fudge and should be updated. I would personally prefer it if the law accepted that ending a pregnancy should be a choice up to a certain point. As in NI it would unconditionally legal. Thereafter it should be seen as a medical decision.

But I don’t think society as a whole has a clear grip on this issue. Therefore any political debate could end in something worse than the current fudge. The legislation in NI is better for the simple reason it was brought about by executive action.

JinglingSpringbells · 18/06/2023 12:41

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:32

What I don't understand is why is abortion legal but euthanasia isn't. We should be able to choose to not be alive as adults

Believe me if euthanasia was legal, I would have chosen it years ago in my early thirties. However I have to suffer on in a life I do not want to be in.

Because medicine and drs are supposed to preserve life.
And a foetus up to so many weeks is not classed as 'human life' (ie viable) in the same way as someone who has been born.

Also, the concerns around euthanasia are that it would be a way of hastening death for financial reasons (for beneficiaries) and the person who was unwell may not be of sound mind to agree to euthanasia.

SunnySun1 · 18/06/2023 12:35

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:00

No.

Sh could have been jailed for doing what she did at 12 weeks. She lied to obtain the abortion and that is why she was jailed, not because of the gestational stage. That is fact.

The pregnancy was not full term. This is also fact.

This fear mongering needs to stop. British women are not going to be imprisoned for having an abortion prior to the legal gestation. This woman you're referring to was 32-34 weeks pregnant and her Internet search history shows that she knew that she knew roughly how far she was along. She was also pregnant for several months prior to lock down so thats not an excuse for not having an early abortion. She had to give birth anyway so there was no need to commit the evil act of poisoning a baby that would've highly likely survived outside the womb.

I know someone who was born at 28 weeks and she isn't disabled. I'd class 30+ weeks to be pretty much full term. These prem babies need steroids to help with their lungs, but they are fully formed babies.

tigger1001 · 18/06/2023 12:34

"I've read the law.

THIS JUDGMENT was not about the stage of pregnancy, it was the way in which the abortion was obtained. Sure, she had to lie because it was 24 weeks +, but it is that she lied, not why she lied.

Beyond this woman, let me spell out my concerns.

As a woman, I cannot legally have a termination unless one of those four conditions are met. I have been pregnant, and had several children. However if during any of those pregnancies, at any time if I wanted to end the pregnancy I COULD NOT unless one of those four conditions were met. In my case they would not have been. If I said 'oh yes, I think my mental health would suffer' I could get one. But I would have lied, and therefore I could be prosecuted.

I'm saying AIBU to think that actually many women don't satisfy those four criteria, but they have terminations anyway even BEFORE 24 weeks. the law provides for those prosecution.

If you read something else into the law, then please elucidate as I'd be very glad to hear it."

Having a child you do not want puts mental health of the woman at risk though. It's an unknown - some women's mental health would be ok but others would really not be.

Doctors seem to agree with that, otherwise we would be reading about the number of women turned away from abortions under healthcare and a rise of back street abortions. And the fact that back street abortions is a genuine concern against lowering abortion limits shows that some women would risk being seriously hurt, or worse in order to terminate a pregnancy shows that the refusal of a safe abortion is actually detrimental to both their physical and mental health.

The case in question though - obtained an abortion after the 24 week deadline. It's not the same thing at all.

Mooshamoo · 18/06/2023 12:32

What I don't understand is why is abortion legal but euthanasia isn't. We should be able to choose to not be alive as adults

Believe me if euthanasia was legal, I would have chosen it years ago in my early thirties. However I have to suffer on in a life I do not want to be in.

ExtraOnions · 18/06/2023 12:31

There is “the law” and then there is the Interpretation and Application of the law … that’s why we have “case law” in this country.

That said .. Abortion should be freely available on demand.

JinglingSpringbells · 18/06/2023 12:30

Do you meant that 'you believe' as in people 'believe' in a religion or pink unicorns?

In other words, it's your opinion?

JinglingSpringbells · 18/06/2023 12:29

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK and to obtain one without being open to prosecution

Abortion is not a criminal act.

Do you live in the UK?

2bazookas · 18/06/2023 12:26

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK

That is a lie. Therefore the rest of your crazed rant is pointless

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:26

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:20

It doesn't follow that doing something you don't want to do creates a risk to your mental health.

I agree about pregnancy and childbirth carrying at least a minimal, tiny risk of grave outcome so I'm glad here, too. When thinking very flexibly, I'm not sure everyone would consider that a harm. I'm also pretty certain most women don't say 'I want a termination because I might die or come close'.

Depends on what that thing is? We are talking in general.

Going for a short walk you don’t want to may not negatively impact your mental healthZ

But we are talking about pregnancy. Pregnancy take a a huge toll on the body and always carries physical risk. Child birth, even a straight forward one, is physically and mentally demanding.

A pregnancy that is unwanted 100% risks grave injury to mental health. And no one asks anyone to prove it. You simply need to know it’s a risk. Grave physical and mental injury is a risk from any presence. The risk increases if you don’t want the child. It’s obvious dedicating your body 24/7 to 9 months of a physically and mentally demanding task that you don’t want to do is a risk to anyone’s mental health.

Namechangedagain20 · 18/06/2023 12:22

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:15

Ok, so maybe you're right. If so, I'm glad you think that might be the experience of many women.

If that is the case, your termination was illegal, though.

I wonder how that feels for many women.

It wasn’t illegal, it was an unwanted pregnancy. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that forcing a woman to continue a pregnancy that she doesn’t want will have a negative impact on her mental health, therefore fulfilling the the first criteria. Can you really not understand that? Being forced to go through an unwanted (and, in my case, accidental pregnancy - mini pill failure) would have impacted my mental health. Which would have negatively impacted my three existing children (mentally and financially).

They could see all of this on the paperwork they had from asking me about previous pregnancies , existing children etc and are clearly able to deduce the negative impact the pregnancy would have. They don’t ask you to spell it out and beg them for an abortion, which for some women could be traumatic, they ask background information which basically fills in the blanks for them.

HaPPy8 · 18/06/2023 12:22

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:04

'Kill'.

Okaaaaay.

Yes kill. They perform fetocide - that is the actual term used - by injecting potassium chloride into the baby’s heart . Glossing over this is not helpful to women.

and as seems to be ignored, women don’t need to lie pre viability as the risk of continuing the pregnancy is greater to their physical health due to common pregnancy complications, as people above have stated. I’m late pregnancy this is no longer true.

JagerPlease · 18/06/2023 12:21

According to BPAS, 98% of abortions are carried out under a.

It is completely legal.

https://www.bpas.org/get-involved/campaigns/briefings/abortion-law/

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 18/06/2023 12:21

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:07

No. She is not in prison because the pregnancy was late term. It was because he lied. This is fact.

Technically, yes but you’re being deliberately pedantic. You know full well why she in particular has a prison sentence.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 12:20

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 12:15

Yabu because they do fall into those categories

If you don’t want to carry and give birth to a child there’s serious risk of grave injury to you mental health.

Plus any pregnancy has a risk of grave injury to physical health.

It doesn't follow that doing something you don't want to do creates a risk to your mental health.

I agree about pregnancy and childbirth carrying at least a minimal, tiny risk of grave outcome so I'm glad here, too. When thinking very flexibly, I'm not sure everyone would consider that a harm. I'm also pretty certain most women don't say 'I want a termination because I might die or come close'.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread