Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?

211 replies

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 10:54

1 in 3 women in this country obtain abortions at some point in their lives.

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK and to obtain one without being open to prosecution, a woman needs two doctors to permit it. because of this many many many women emphasise and maybe even embellish, or lie, to obtain that. Will it really mean you cannot afford your rent / mortgage and you'll be homeless? Probably not, but you just DO NOT want a(nother) baby. And actually a woman should be able to just NOT WANT a(nother) pregnancy or a(nother) child. Yet the woman is forced to say what needs to be said procure an abortion.

Therefore thousands of women every year would be jailed just like this woman has been.

The jailing was NOT because of the late term of the pregnancy, it was because she lied to obtain it and therefore she's in jail.

Lots and lots women have done that. Lots.

OP posts:
SnackSizeRaisin · 18/06/2023 15:18

Also I don't think anyone should be in prison unless they are a danger to other people. I don't think this woman should be in prison either. Apparently if only the women who are a danger to others were kept in, and all.others released, there would only be about 4 women in prison in the UK.

SnackSizeRaisin · 18/06/2023 15:13

The jail term was because the woman pled not guilty initially. If she'd pled guilty at the first opportunity she would not have got a jail term for this offence. Our sentencing system is based on admission of guilt more than the actual crime. It seems she was badly advised to do that as there was plenty of evidence that she knew she was over 24 weeks.

It may well be that she could have got a legal abortion under B on mental health grounds but obviously she did not seek that (possibly due to COVID).

Personally I think abortion at any stage should be decriminalised. It should always be a woman's choice. No one is going to choose abortion at 32 weeks lightly. But even then it still needs to be a requirement for medical professionals to be involved to avoid suffering to the foetus. I wouldn't support late term home abortions such as this woman did being legal.

eggsbenedict23 · 18/06/2023 14:45

has sex

gets pregnant

“HOW DARE THIS CHILD BE IN MY BODY”

Vast majority of abortions are not due to SA as per the data.

CecilyP · 18/06/2023 14:43

No it doesn't. B) is B) - grave injury. Not 'I just don't want this pregnancy'. If it was 'I just don't want this baby' it would say something to that effect.

Of course B is one that many women will indicate. My proposition here is that that might not be strictly true for many women who just don't want one.

No it’s not B, it’s A. The overwhelming majority of terminations are carried out on ground A. Read Ground A again carefully this time- after all you’ve posted it enough times! The effect on mental health only has to be worse if the pregnancy were to continue , no mention of grave at all!

Very, very rarely, ground B is used for a termination after 24 weeks on mental health grounds. Probably when the patient already suffers a serious mental health or is already an in patient in a mental hospital.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 14:42

@OneFrenchEgg of course it isn't compulsory reading.

You and I are allowed to hold thousand of opinions. Some of those will be based on gut instinct and some on informing ourselves about morals, ethics, history, philosophy and opinions from those at all points of the argument.

Reading the law isn't compulsory either, this is what they woman involved in the recent case was originally charged with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_destruction

OneFrenchEgg · 18/06/2023 14:21

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 13:17

I presume everyone has explored the philosophical side to abortion and read Judith Thomson's A Defence of Abortion https://danielwharris.com/teaching/101/readings/Thomson.pdf

Why? Is it required reading before forming an opinion?

ProfessorXtra · 18/06/2023 14:16

purpleboy · 18/06/2023 13:47

I agree with you op, the links you posted up thread state the dr has to sign off on one of those conditions. What happens if they don't agree? Do we know how often women are denied access to early abortion because the dr didn't agree?
I worried this case could open the floodgates for this kind of thing to become routine, dr saying no based on whatever they decided, it then makes the abortion illegal.

I assume in practice that women are not refused based on the drs say so, but the law clearly states they could, which is why the law needs changing.

I believe fully in a woman's choice, as early as possible as late as necessary, and if you are one of those that claim to be pro choice but only up until a specific date that YOU deem acceptable, well then your not pro choice at all.

An abortion will always be a medical procedure. And as such will always need to be signed off.

as it needs to signed off there will always be guidelines. The guidelines allow for a woman to have an abortion for any reason up to a cut off.

The whole ‘you aren’t pro choice if you don’t agree to abortion for any reason at any time’ is counter productive.

Firstly I think it’s wrong. Most choices ar made with guidelines. Very few choices have nothing else to consider at all.

But also most of us that believe the rules, at this time are correct and don’t think abortion at any time for any reason, aren’t that fussed about having the label pro choice. If, whoever, decides these things decides I am not pro choice thats fair enough it’s not a big deal

For some reason the extremists of either end of the debate can’t accept that most people fall in the middle and aren’t desperate to label their opinion.

Kitchen12345 · 18/06/2023 14:15

Kitchen12345 · 18/06/2023 14:14

Exactly. Anyone saying an early abortion is less risky than birth for a woman has obviously never done it!

More risky, I think. You get what I am saying. Birth is the most dangerous thing a woman can do.

Kitchen12345 · 18/06/2023 14:14

RegimentalSturgeon · 18/06/2023 11:16

Since reason a) is always true, no lying is necessary

[If] continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman

The risk of childbirth at full term is demonstrably greater than that of earlier, professionally procured, termination.

It would still be better were abortion decriminalised but in practice early termination, which accounts for the vast majority of cases, is in practice available on demand.

Exactly. Anyone saying an early abortion is less risky than birth for a woman has obviously never done it!

Qazwsxefv · 18/06/2023 14:00

Thompson argues that to unplug the violinist and he survives then to slit his throat is immoral- is it not the same to slit his throat first to ensure he does not survive being unplugged?

I am pro choice as I am pro the mothers choice on being or not being pregnant at any stage of gestation, women are not incubators. Women have no obligation to keep babies growing inside them they do not want. Pre viability this means I support abortion (which the uk law allows for any reason as it is always more risky to continue the pregnancy) and post viability I would support induction on request. I cannot support the pre-induction foeticide of healthy viable foetuses as I cannot see that humanity of such a foetus is different from the humanity of a preterm infant of the same gestation.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 13:58

@Qazwsxefv I'm not trying to defend the woman in this case.

Qazwsxefv · 18/06/2023 13:47

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 13:17

I presume everyone has explored the philosophical side to abortion and read Judith Thomson's A Defence of Abortion https://danielwharris.com/teaching/101/readings/Thomson.pdf

This would not defend the women in this case. Her “unplug the violist” argument would support inducing pre term labour at the Mother’s request (not a thing legally in the uk as far as I know and seeing if the baby survives) not inducing foeticide and then pre term labour.

purpleboy · 18/06/2023 13:47

I agree with you op, the links you posted up thread state the dr has to sign off on one of those conditions. What happens if they don't agree? Do we know how often women are denied access to early abortion because the dr didn't agree?
I worried this case could open the floodgates for this kind of thing to become routine, dr saying no based on whatever they decided, it then makes the abortion illegal.

I assume in practice that women are not refused based on the drs say so, but the law clearly states they could, which is why the law needs changing.

I believe fully in a woman's choice, as early as possible as late as necessary, and if you are one of those that claim to be pro choice but only up until a specific date that YOU deem acceptable, well then your not pro choice at all.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/06/2023 13:17

I presume everyone has explored the philosophical side to abortion and read Judith Thomson's A Defence of Abortion https://danielwharris.com/teaching/101/readings/Thomson.pdf

https://danielwharris.com/teaching/101/readings/Thomson.pdf

Throwncrumbs · 18/06/2023 13:17

Mumsanetta · 18/06/2023 13:10

She did not “murder” a full term baby - full term is 37 weeks and this baby was 31-32 weeks. If you think a woman should be imprisoned for illegally obtaining a late term abortion then just say that, making up facts devalues your argument.

31 or 32 weeks is a viable baby, there’s no changing that fact!

Throwncrumbs · 18/06/2023 13:16

She aborted a near term baby, she got taken to hospital to have this child which is traumatising for staff, how the hell did she think she would get away with this , was she going to try and hide a dead baby if she had it at home? Women probably embellish why the want an abortion, but two doctors have to make the decision and it isn’t easy for them either. That’s why women are scanned

loveandpoprockz · 18/06/2023 13:15

sparkleice · 18/06/2023 11:24

Well said

as early as possible

as late as necessary

Lets not put blockers in the way

No

Mumsanetta · 18/06/2023 13:10

cuckyplunt · 18/06/2023 13:05

She murdered a full-time baby for her convenience, she deserves to have the book thrown at her!

She did not “murder” a full term baby - full term is 37 weeks and this baby was 31-32 weeks. If you think a woman should be imprisoned for illegally obtaining a late term abortion then just say that, making up facts devalues your argument.

MaPaSpa · 18/06/2023 13:10

You are right.

Qazwsxefv · 18/06/2023 13:06

SerenChocolateMuncher · 18/06/2023 12:19

This is the bit of the legislation that allows any woman to have an abortion for any reason up to 24 weeks gestation:

  • (a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week and that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman or any existing children of her family;

The continuation of a pregnancy is always a greater risk than termination even for completely healthy women carrying much wanted babies.

There is no need to lie.

This this this. The OP is for some reason ignoring this.

There is no need to lie or talk about stress or finances or mental health. Medically before 24 weeks continuing with being pregnant to term is more medically risky than having a termination so ALL terminations before this point are permitted legally. No other reason needed.

after about 24 weeks or so the foetus has to be birthed- surgically or vaginally. The only questions about this procedure being:

1.are steps being taken to end the pregnancy sooner than a spontaneous labour and

  1. Is aim for is the foetus to to be a live baby at the end

consider a women with pre eclampsia for whom ending the pregnancy needs to take place for her health early labour is induced with medications. It’s possible legally both to induce this labour with or without foeticide first (with being an abortion and without being a live birth). The labour and induction are the same. Should the baby once born show signs of life it must be resuscitated even if the aim was abortion (unless it is deemed that it would be more harmful to the baby’s health to try). Professionals performing late stage abortions are therefore very keen to ensure that a live birth does not occur. For me this womens real error was her risking this - if the pills she had taken had not successfully caused foeticide (in no way a certainty at 32 weeks) but had induced labour and a live birth had resulted, and then the baby died she would be I assume looking at charges of infanticide via neglect I assume

my final point is that medical professionals are also humans, I have strived to save 24 week babies and assisted with legal late term terminations (23weeks). The clear black and white distinctions some posters make between a baby and a foetus - one with rights and one without is not easy to maintain when faced with the reality that when delivered both look and feel very similar when you hold them. I do support the right to pre viability abortions essentially on demand and late term in specific circumstances but it’s not just “my body my choice” as your choice means that medical professionals are required to act out your choice - I do not think I could ever myself carry out the physical actions to terminate at 24+ week healthy live foetus if it’s or it’s mothers health was not significantly endangered.

RudsyFarmer · 18/06/2023 13:06

I’m sure at some point the puritans will regain control and all abortions will become illegal. Then you will be happy I assume.

Mumsanetta · 18/06/2023 13:06

Daydreamer123456 · 18/06/2023 11:56

@Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime

Why do you keep posting the law if you’re not going to read it?

a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week

The word “or” (instead of “and”) at the end of each ground means that you can have an abortion under the other 3 grounds after 24 weeks.

  • (a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week and that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman or any existing children of her family; or
  • (b) that the termination is necessary to prevent grave permanent injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman; or
  • (c) that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk to the life of the pregnant woman, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated; or
  • (d) that there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped.
cuckyplunt · 18/06/2023 13:05

She murdered a full-time baby for her convenience, she deserves to have the book thrown at her!

RecycleMePlease · 18/06/2023 13:03

I firmly believe in as early as possible, as late as necessary.

I don't think forcing a woman to continue a pregnancy at any stage is moral.

I also don't think I know enough about this particular woman's circumstances - she was pregnant, and didn't want to be, right at the start of lockdown, with 3 children, including one with special needs already.

Even with just one child and pre-covid, I ended up having to take him to dentist appointments and smears, because I had no-one to look after him.

During lockdown, I can easily see that this woman could have no options for childcare, for termination healthcare, and finally grasped the one option that finally became available - pills by mail.

I've read accounts by other women who were unable to procure a termination, of other women who had babies in lockdown and how their physical and mental health was damaged by it.

I can't condemn her. I cannot support jailing her for it. Punishing her, and her children. She's not a danger to society, she's not going to be rehabilitated in prison regarding this.

mycoffeecup · 18/06/2023 13:00

Going through pregnancy and labour is on average more damaging to your physical and mental health than having a TOP. So we effectively have TOP on demand up to the legal limits, which is of course a good thing, with no need to embellish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread