Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?

211 replies

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 10:54

1 in 3 women in this country obtain abortions at some point in their lives.

I sincerely believe that as abortion is a criminal act in the UK and to obtain one without being open to prosecution, a woman needs two doctors to permit it. because of this many many many women emphasise and maybe even embellish, or lie, to obtain that. Will it really mean you cannot afford your rent / mortgage and you'll be homeless? Probably not, but you just DO NOT want a(nother) baby. And actually a woman should be able to just NOT WANT a(nother) pregnancy or a(nother) child. Yet the woman is forced to say what needs to be said procure an abortion.

Therefore thousands of women every year would be jailed just like this woman has been.

The jailing was NOT because of the late term of the pregnancy, it was because she lied to obtain it and therefore she's in jail.

Lots and lots women have done that. Lots.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NatashaDancing · 23/06/2023 20:38

the Uk abortion act is therefore imo pretty clever as it couches in medical terms alone the justification for abortion - it removes all moral judgements from the law. It lets the pro lifers feel that abortion is still illegal but If you want an abortion you get one up to 24 weeks. After 24 weeks that’s when you get into the “grave injury” stuff
^^
I agree - whether it was deliberately written like that or a happy accident it works much better than say the Irish or other models where no medical justification is needed but the cut off is much shorter.

Qazwsxefv · 23/06/2023 20:34

your still missing the point OP - it’s got nothing to do with mental health at all.

ALL women who are pregnant under 24 weeks are physically more at risk by continuing to be pregnant than if they had a medically supervised termination and this is especially true before 12 weeks

simply by being pregnant a women meets criteria A - wanted or unwanted pregnancy , good mental health or poor mental health, healthy baby or unhealthy baby it is medically safer to have an early termination than continue to be pregnant and deliver over 24 weeks. Medically and technically speaking if you got pregnant and went to see a doctor before 12 weeks and said “physically what is the best thing I can do to safeguard my physical health regardless of the pregnancy ?” The answer would be to have a termination for your physical health. A women (or doctors) could never break the law before 24 weeks it’s always physically/medically safer to have an early termination than continue to be pregnant. The way it’s written also makes it pretty hard to overturn legally - how do you write a law that says women have to make a medically less safe decision that Dosent come afoul
of lots of other equality and human rights legislation and all of the assembled case law on medical best practices. To me it makes it a more secure bit of legistlation than one based simply on a rights justification.

the Uk abortion act is therefore imo pretty clever as it couches in medical terms alone the justification for abortion - it removes all moral judgements from the law. It lets the pro lifers feel that abortion is still illegal but If you want an abortion you get one up to 24 weeks. After 24 weeks that’s when you get into the “grave injury” stuff

evuscha · 21/06/2023 05:54

I am very much pro choice and disagree with all these ultra strict places that don’t allow abortion after 6 weeks etc.

UK has a limit of 24 weeks (very generous imho) and abortions for medical reasons are allowed after that limit too. (surgical, not via a pill) Noone ever goes to prison in these cases.

However to abort a full term baby is cruel and quite frankly murder. Pretty much the same as if she gave birth and killed the baby right after (which people absolutely go to jail for).

NatashaDancing · 21/06/2023 05:42

I just thought, when listening to all of the debate that I have listened to on this, that many women would have acted criminally

I don't know what point you're trying to make OP. You are however missing the point that if you think women have been illegally "talking up" why they want an abortion it would be the doctors who signed it off and/or the doctor or nurse who facilitated the abortion who have acted illegally.

Are you looking to provide ammunition to opponents of abortion in the UK? I'm sure you won't be the first (anti- abortion campaigner) to have hit on the argument that the 1967 Act is being unlawfully applied.

Personally I think the wording in the 1967 Act is quite clever. I don't know if that was by design or a happy accident. Several posters have explained why it's a low bar to get over. I think the fact that the requirement to have that bar allows UK law to keep the procedure as a medically justified procedure thus extending the right to have an abortion for far longer than jurisdictions which have "on demand" for no reason.

Ireland's 12 week "on demand" limit means women in Ireland are still traveling to the UK after 12 weeks

^^
^^

Lemonyfuckit · 21/06/2023 01:24

RegimentalSturgeon · 18/06/2023 11:16

Since reason a) is always true, no lying is necessary

[If] continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman

The risk of childbirth at full term is demonstrably greater than that of earlier, professionally procured, termination.

It would still be better were abortion decriminalised but in practice early termination, which accounts for the vast majority of cases, is in practice available on demand.

Actually scrap my earlier comment, I thought the risk to mental health was easy to satisfy but this is even more valid in terms satisfying that limb of the test.

Lemonyfuckit · 21/06/2023 01:21

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 18/06/2023 11:06

You cannot get an abortion 'for any reason'. It needs to be one of four reasons. And I do think that many many women, if not most, women who obtain abortions are not at risk o f'grave'outcomes, but they just do not want the pregnancy. And so they are in the position where they have to talk it up. This is demeaning, but I think is probably done day in and day out because women are not allowed to just not want a pregnancy, or just not want a(nother).

Abortion Law Criteria
The Abortion Act 1967 states that an abortion is legal if it is performed by a registered medical practitioner (a doctor), and that it is authorised by two doctors, acting in good faith, on one (or more) of the following grounds (with each needing to agree that at least one and the same ground is met):

  • (a) that the pregnancy has not exceeded its twenty-fourth week and that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman or any existing children of her family; or
  • (b) that the termination is necessary to prevent grave permanent injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman; or
  • (c) that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk to the life of the pregnant woman, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated; or
  • (d) that there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped.

To be honest, assuming the time limit is complied with, the first limb is actually a low bar to satisfy in terms of if the reason is just a woman doesn't want the pregnancy (which 100% agree with) - ie risk of harm to her mental health, greater than if the pregnancy is continued. If you don't want a baby to the extent you have an abortion, I suspect that de facto being otherwise forced to continue the pregnancy would harm your mental health more than having the abortion would if that makes sense. So I don't believe it theoretically is necessary to lie or embellish at all. I say theoretically though because I don't know whether in practice the doctors just sign that off therefore or whether they 'require' the woman to effectively embellish/elaborate the risk before they sign off. My reading of the legislation though I think it's actually an easy test to satisfy if that's your situation.

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 21/06/2023 00:53

Crunchymum · 19/06/2023 14:01

It doesn't follow that doing something you don't want to do creates a risk to your mental health

Well thank God the law understands that an unplanned / unwanted pregnancy is a little more than "doing something you don't want to" and that forcing a woman to continue with a pregnancy she does not want is going to be damaging and detrimental to her MH.

I am astonished that you consider yourself to be pro choice @Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime is your username ironic? Or are you conflating the recent case in the news and all abortions? I am very confused about your intentions with this thread to be honest.

I am pro-choice, and I actually believe a woman should have total control over her own body every single day of her life, and at any stage of pregnancy. In that sense I am probably more pro-choice than many people. But we are not discussing that right now. (I also think people should be able to take their own lives or choose when to die). But that is, again, another matter.

That sentence you quote sounds anti-choice if removed from my post entirely.

The law says a termination can be had if there is a grave risk to mental health. One poster said 'being made to do what you do not want to do poses a risk to your mental health' the suggestion is that therefore the law is sufficient.

Read my sentence again and you will see that it can be seen as pro-choice i.e. pregnancy should not have to pose a risk to me for me to be able to get one as some women will just not want one but think their mental health will not suffer if they do continue with the pregnancy.

I just thought, when listening to all of the debate that I have listened to on this, that many women would have acted criminally if indeed we were all kept to those four conditions. Most posters on here have said that I am being unreasonable to think that. I've taken that on board (it hasn't really changed my mind, but it has helped with more flexibility in thinking).

Thanks one and all.

OP posts:
Itisyourturntowashthebath · 19/06/2023 21:17

@LemonTT as a country we seriously under valued Theresa May.

LemonTT · 19/06/2023 17:11

pointythings · 19/06/2023 15:22

@LemonTT you're describing the New Zealand model, which I think is a good option.

It’s now the NI model brought in by the executive government. It’s ironic that the most regressive part of the nation moved to being the most progressive. The fact that our national government decided on a better model for one part of the nation suggests they know the current legislation should be revisited.

pointythings · 19/06/2023 15:22

@LemonTT you're describing the New Zealand model, which I think is a good option.

eggsbenedict23 · 19/06/2023 14:40

When the USA had abortions. How much did it cost there?

ContinuousProcrastination · 19/06/2023 14:32

This isn't about why anyone has an abortion.

Criteria a) of the law is that the continuance of the (sub 24 week) pregnancy poses greater risk to the health of the mother than termination.

All pregnancies pose greater risk to the mother than termination - pregnancy is not good for you, it carries many health risks. Therefore it is really about the mother's choice before 24 weeks.

Crunchymum · 19/06/2023 14:01

It doesn't follow that doing something you don't want to do creates a risk to your mental health

Well thank God the law understands that an unplanned / unwanted pregnancy is a little more than "doing something you don't want to" and that forcing a woman to continue with a pregnancy she does not want is going to be damaging and detrimental to her MH.

I am astonished that you consider yourself to be pro choice @Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime is your username ironic? Or are you conflating the recent case in the news and all abortions? I am very confused about your intentions with this thread to be honest.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/06/2023 13:30

You were, I accept,
in emotional turmoil as you sought to hide the pregnancy.
20.I have carefully considered psychiatric reports from Drs Gupta and Kennedy, the
Pre-Sentence Report; and letters from your former partner, the baby’s father and a
teacher at your son’s school. You were not suffering from any serious mental illness
at the time of this offence. I accept, however, that there is evidence of emotionally
unstable personality traits. More significantly, I accept that you feel very deep and
genuine remorse for your actions. You are wracked by guilt and have suffered
depression. I also accept that you had a very deep emotional attachment to your
unborn child and that you are plagued by nightmares and flashbacks to seeing your
dead child’s face.

I think maybe this sums up her state of mind more accurately than 'she was embarrassed.'

OrcasFree · 19/06/2023 13:29

NatashaDancing · 19/06/2023 13:20

Sentencing report.

Sentencing report

That's not a pre-sentencing report, which would have been completed by the probation service and the 2 different psychiatrists.

They're sentencing remarks by the Judge which did include the information I referred to.

NatashaDancing · 19/06/2023 13:20

OrcasFree · 19/06/2023 12:33

We do know she had moved back in with her estranged partner, had previously been having sex with 2 men and was not sure who Fatherered the baby, and was concealing the pregnancy from her estranged partner who she'd moved back in with.

Who was referred to as her ex-partner when he wrote a letter to the Judge at the point of sentencing so presumably became her ex at some point after the abortion.

All of these facts were in the sentencing remarks so although we don't know her exact motivations for the late-term abortion, we do know what psychosocial factors were present at the time. And she had 2 psychiatric reports completed pre-sentencing where no MH diagnosis could be made.

Sentencing report.

Sentencing report

https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/R-v.-Foster-sentencing-remarks-12.6.23.pdf

NatashaDancing · 19/06/2023 13:19

Qazwsxefv · 19/06/2023 10:09

i struggle with the term “forced birth” as when you have got past a certain stage of pregnancy like this women had birth is coming abortion or not. A late stage medical abortion is in the act of the pregnancy leaving the women’s body a “birth” in all practical aspects - contractions, pushing, pain, bleeding, afterbirth, midwife present etc - the same as an other vaginal delivery at that gestation - other than the fact a live baby is not the result. It’s a medically caused stillbirth.

I’m not trying to be insensitive in any way to those that have had late term abortions or are considering one, as I don’t think it’s at all useful to ignore biology/ a late term abortion does not remove the physical requirement to labour. The pregnancy tissue has to come out somehow - surgically or vaginally - the pregnancy can’t be made to disappear with a pill. The delivered pregnancy will (other than in some very upsetting conditions) look to the external eye like a (small) baby which is usually welcome to the mother who has had to make the very difficult decision to have a late abortion of a usually very wanted baby who has been found to have a condition not compatible with life.

I do wonder if the women in this case thought that the pill(s) she took would make the pregnancy disappear - she didn’t want anyone to find out - but at 30/32 weeks there is no way she could do that - abortion east access or not she was always going to have to “birth” the baby

I struggled with that post. It's gross hyperbole to suggest that society being concerned about the illegal abortion of a 32 week foetus is leading to Gilead. And as you say , by that stage it was always going to be a birth.

OrcasFree · 19/06/2023 12:33

AllOfThemWitches · 19/06/2023 11:53

Yes but you're really simplifying it by saying 'she was too embarrassed.' You can't possibly know what she was going through mentally.

We do know she had moved back in with her estranged partner, had previously been having sex with 2 men and was not sure who Fatherered the baby, and was concealing the pregnancy from her estranged partner who she'd moved back in with.

Who was referred to as her ex-partner when he wrote a letter to the Judge at the point of sentencing so presumably became her ex at some point after the abortion.

All of these facts were in the sentencing remarks so although we don't know her exact motivations for the late-term abortion, we do know what psychosocial factors were present at the time. And she had 2 psychiatric reports completed pre-sentencing where no MH diagnosis could be made.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/06/2023 11:53

TheGreatATuin · 18/06/2023 23:15

Because this was all part of the court case and reported on?

Yes but you're really simplifying it by saying 'she was too embarrassed.' You can't possibly know what she was going through mentally.

LemonTT · 19/06/2023 11:29

This is a classic example of “Hard cases making bad law” or in this case bad debate. We really shouldn’t use the example of one woman’s actions to reformulate laws or underpin debate. Especially given we don’t know why she did what she did and many people are filling in the gaps.

There is a fundamental inconsistency in UK law re abortion. Northern Ireland now has laws which provide women with the right to an unconditional abortion up to 12 weeks. In the rest of the UK that right is conditional. This perhaps is what the OP wanted to highlight but did so in a poor way.

The distinction may seem nuanced given that abortions are approved conditionally without any evidence required. However I would support the right to unconditional abortions up to a point and thereafter require them to be medically approved and supervised.

I do however believe there should be criminal recourse to deal with anyone causing the unlawful death of a viable baby. I’m not convinced the mother should be excluded from this.

Qazwsxefv · 19/06/2023 10:09

malificent7 · 19/06/2023 05:55

I don't agree with what she did ...it's awful, but nor do I agree with forced birthing of babies people don't want. So it's a moral nightmare.
Ultimately ...are we just vessels for children? If you think so then Gilead is that way➡

i struggle with the term “forced birth” as when you have got past a certain stage of pregnancy like this women had birth is coming abortion or not. A late stage medical abortion is in the act of the pregnancy leaving the women’s body a “birth” in all practical aspects - contractions, pushing, pain, bleeding, afterbirth, midwife present etc - the same as an other vaginal delivery at that gestation - other than the fact a live baby is not the result. It’s a medically caused stillbirth.

I’m not trying to be insensitive in any way to those that have had late term abortions or are considering one, as I don’t think it’s at all useful to ignore biology/ a late term abortion does not remove the physical requirement to labour. The pregnancy tissue has to come out somehow - surgically or vaginally - the pregnancy can’t be made to disappear with a pill. The delivered pregnancy will (other than in some very upsetting conditions) look to the external eye like a (small) baby which is usually welcome to the mother who has had to make the very difficult decision to have a late abortion of a usually very wanted baby who has been found to have a condition not compatible with life.

I do wonder if the women in this case thought that the pill(s) she took would make the pregnancy disappear - she didn’t want anyone to find out - but at 30/32 weeks there is no way she could do that - abortion east access or not she was always going to have to “birth” the baby

Qazwsxefv · 19/06/2023 09:54

HotPenguin · 18/06/2023 21:43

For those saying abortion is effectively on demand in this country, that's not the case. When I was younger, a friend of mine was refused an abortion because the GP considered they had left it too late and should have done it earlier (she was below 24 weeks). Friend ended up having to go private and have an even later stage abortion.

GPs and all HCPs are allowed to consciencely object to signing abortion act paperwork (when there is not a grave risk to life/health/mental health) and I have witnessed some debate if that includes not giving details of alternative ways to patients, however the gmc gives clear guidance that just saying “I don’t do that” isn’t ok and that if the patient is vulnerable you have to arrange for them to see someone else yourself rather than just giving a website etc….

Nowadays women wanting an abortion can generally skip the GP and just contact https://www.bpas.org/ and it is then in the vast majority of instances funded by the nhs (just like the women in the court case did).

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?
Qazwsxefv · 19/06/2023 09:45

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 19/06/2023 00:32

Mental health sections need an AMPH, that person does not necessarily need to be a doctor.

Derail: for most mental health sections two doctors (one who has been on a special course -section 12 approved) and an AMHP are involved. The AMPH is a social worker on an approved list (they may well have to do a special course as well - I don’t know that boy).

the point I was making is that abortion is not a special case where more than one healthcare professional is required to agree.

AIBU to be think that most women would be jailed for their abortions as so many of us embellish?
OrcasFree · 19/06/2023 09:35

SnackSizeRaisin · 18/06/2023 17:12

Most female prisoners are there for drug offences and related low level crime, shoplifting etc. They have short sentences and are often in and out of jail. Think about it if someone is a risk to society they won't be getting short sentences of a few months or a year or 2. Most have experienced abuse which has led to their problems. They are not a direct risk to society. They really need drug services and mental health services not incarceration.

There's also a fair few serving long sentences for violent crimes including murder and crimes of sexual violence.

It's silly to spread misinformation that there are 'only about 4' women in prison who are a risk to the public.

I can think of several high profile cases just in the last few months.

And if you stopped incarcerating anybody who had a history of trauma or drug abuse, you'd have to include 1000s of men.

OrcasFree · 19/06/2023 09:30

Upsetaboutabortionbeingacrime · 19/06/2023 00:32

Mental health sections need an AMPH, that person does not necessarily need to be a doctor.

If the MHA section requires an AMPH it also requires at least one Dr, usually 2.