Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people shouldn't own dogs

135 replies

JamSandle · 18/06/2023 10:52

I love dogs but I think a lot of owners:

  • infantalise their dogs and treat them like babies, not animals who have instincts and needs.

  • don't train them. Let their dogs bark, howl and growl all day long.

  • don't look them properly. Walk them, trim nails, clean them, look after teeth.

Good dog owners are amazing people. But so many people have dogs and don't put the effort into training them or understanding the animals needs.

I dont really think most people should be dog owners.

OP posts:
BunnyBettChetwynnd · 18/06/2023 17:15

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts Bum. I knew someone on Mumsnet would prove my 'always works' method has a flaw. It definitely works on lots of dogs though, so worth a try except perhaps for scent hounds.

Avondale89 · 18/06/2023 17:11

SpareHeirOverThere · 18/06/2023 15:11

OP and many on here sound like my elderly father and his friends. I love their conversations.

Most people:

Can't control/ care for their dogs.

Ditto their children.

Are not sufficiently active in the community.

Do not have basic manners.

Are dangerous drivers.

Spend too much time on phones.

Do not feed themselves and their families proper, homecooked food.

The list goes on.

Most dog owners I see appear to be doing a good enough job. The dogs usually look well cared for.

I think the same of most parents.

I think most people like to judge rather too much. Those who live in glass houses and all that.

Love this post. The problem is, conveniently, always other people. Although it is rather the theme of this entire forum and we all still come back to read and judge 😂

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 18/06/2023 17:03

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 18/06/2023 16:58

Can I share a tip for recall please? I've never known this not work on any dog (no doubt be proved wrong here)

It's The Back and Forth Game.

Two people stand a few feet apart in a secure garden where the dog can't bolt. One of you calls the dog - really cheerfully with a hand signal. When she comes you ask her to sit and when she does you give her the tiniest little bit of her favourite treat and some good praise. Then the other calls and you repeat half a dozen times.

Repeat daily and gradually, as the dog 'gets it', the two people move further apart. When you're getting a good result 100% of the time you can move it out of the garden.

If you teach the dog a 'come and sit' command using a hand signal you can get your dog to recall and sit without even having to make a sound in noisy places or over a long distance where you can't shout.

I'm going to use my own dog as a prime example of this not working Grin

He's a scent hound - his recall is perfect until he gets a scent - which unfortunately happens quite around here. Then it's nose down, ears off and away he goes. Hand signals are pointless as he's staring at the ground and voice/sound commands are ignored as he's so focused on the scent. He's a beagle and has been bred to do this for literally hundreds of years - no amount of sausage and hand commands will change it Wink

So unfortunately for him he has to be kept on the lead the majority of the time.

He's perfect in the house/garden though!

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 18/06/2023 16:58

Can I share a tip for recall please? I've never known this not work on any dog (no doubt be proved wrong here)

It's The Back and Forth Game.

Two people stand a few feet apart in a secure garden where the dog can't bolt. One of you calls the dog - really cheerfully with a hand signal. When she comes you ask her to sit and when she does you give her the tiniest little bit of her favourite treat and some good praise. Then the other calls and you repeat half a dozen times.

Repeat daily and gradually, as the dog 'gets it', the two people move further apart. When you're getting a good result 100% of the time you can move it out of the garden.

If you teach the dog a 'come and sit' command using a hand signal you can get your dog to recall and sit without even having to make a sound in noisy places or over a long distance where you can't shout.

Artycrafts · 18/06/2023 16:50

clpsmum · 18/06/2023 16:16

Haven't rtft sorry if it's been said but I'm so sick of everywhere being bloody dog friendly too. I don't want to go to a meal in a restaurant full of dogs no matter how cute they are

So don't go those restaurants and go somewhere else.quite easy isn't it?

EdithStourton · 18/06/2023 16:49

From my experience, the terrible owners are definitely a minority. I'm not saying they don't exist, because I've come across a few, but the majority do a decent job. I'm on a breed page and the biggest issue is pulling on lead, which does at least tell you that they dogs are being walked, even if they aren't being trained.

The most frequent issues I see I the dogs locally are poor recall and dogs being overweight. Most dog owners I know look after their dogs adequately, in that they exercise them regularly, feed them sensibly and obviously love them and give them lots of attention. The dogs are social, happy and not remotely neurotic. They can be off-lead together without any issues.

However, there is a sizeable minority that just doesn't understand that some dogs desperately need some sort of fulfilment for their genetic drives. With most people I think it's ignorance rather than not being bothered, but it does annoy me. You have Google at your bloody fingertips. Don't get a Malinois or a Vizsla out of working parents or a JRT and expect a dog whose greatest ambition is to be a sofa cushion.

DiscoDragon · 18/06/2023 16:42

The older I get the less I agree with the whole concept of pet ownership in general. I think the breeding of animals for profit should be banned and the only pets people are allowed to get are ones from shelters.

I seem to be surrounded by people who "collect" cute animals but aren't able to provide or care for them adequately. There is one family on our street who have dogs, cats, rodents, lizards and birds all crammed into their little house with all of their children. The chickens have apparently not been cleaned out in over a year and the garden is infested with rats, the dog keeps escaping and running about the road etc. They clearly cant cope with all of these animals, it shouldn't be so bloody easy for them to get their hands on them.

Badbudgeter · 18/06/2023 16:42

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/06/2023 16:10

Theres some failure to imagine situations outside your personal experience here.

A labrador walked on pavement probably will self trim except for the dew claws and some will nibble them down themselves. One of my dogs does this, she chews down her own claws or they're taken care of by pavement walks.

Two of my dogs do not - they both have rather flat feet and the nails grow almost straight out, not down to the ground. Combine that with much of our walking being on soft grass/forest floor, and their nails NEVER get worn down and easily over-grow. So I clip them myself, but then I have a grooming table and I taught them from an early age to stand on it or to lie upside down in my lap for that.

My partner is absolutely useless at nails, hes terrified of catching the quick so is quite panicky about doing it and as a result is more likely to catch the quick or worry the dog - he would be better having a groomer do it.

Some dogs coats really need a proper bath, blaster dryer to remove undercoat, professional dryer etc, or they will take DAYS to fully dry. Lots of the very popular poodle mixes fall into this category, having coats the owners were not expecting/could not predict.

I wash our hound, he is a stinky bastard if I don't and no amount of brushing fixes that, he dribbles on himself and delights in developing revolting stalactites round his face-flaps. It's only once every six weeks or so, and he is outraged by it but also really likes the treats and also the paw massage (getting the matted bits of crap from between his pads) that goes with it!

I have taught my dogs to enjoy grooming though - many people don't bother, assuming that the groomer will do it and that is unfair and unkind, and leaves dogs suffering. Of course the groomer says 'Oh yes Fido was fine' to their client... unless Fido has actually taken off a few fingers... because they know thats what the client wants to hear. They'd have no business if they said 'well actually, Fido was fucking terrified, tense and uncomfortable the whole time and we did worry at one point if he'd have a heart attack in the bath, he also tried to bite a few times so we strapped his face shut and suspended him in a sling so he couldn't throw himself around'...

Fair enough. I always thought of myself as a fairly experienced dog owner. I think I’ll change that to fairly experienced lab owner. In my defence had I ever considered another breed I would have done some more research.

Poor Fido

LolaSmiles · 18/06/2023 16:38

That said, I think a lot of people are in over their heads and have chosen breeds based on appearance or status. A busy family in a small home without time for long walks have no business getting a Border Collie, a Husky, or a German Shepherd. A family with small excitable children should not have an American Bully or a Cane Corso. A family who love hiking and biking with their dog shouldn't have a chihuahua.
I'd agree with that.
I think people should be realistic about what their lifestyles are like and what their interests are.

Just like people shops for clothes based on their aspirational self, I think some people get a dog on the grounds that it will help them get fit, it will help them have family time, they'll get their steps in walking the dog, the kids will love playing with the dog in the garden and that will occupy them.
They forget that if the kids don't like playing outside, the chance of them playing outside with a dog is slim. If they don't like being outdoors and don't walk much now, the chance of the dog transforming years of laziness and/or sedentary lifestyle is slim. If they don't have much outdoor family time now, the dog isn't going to bring the family closer together.
Dogs shouldn't be bought as a tool to fix human problems/as a self improvement tool.

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 16:34

OneMoreChapter · 18/06/2023 14:13

It’s the dog owners who can’t stop their dogs jumping up at people when they are off the lead that wind me up. ‘Oh he’s just being friendly’ they say. I find it really stressful. Sometimes it leaves scratch marks or muddy paw prints on my clothes. I hate it! The owners always get so defensive when I point out that if they can’t control the dog they should keep them on the lead. I’ve even been told I shouldn’t go out if I don’t like it! Madness.

Yep I just posted about this earlier in another thread someone has about an out of control neighbours dog - I had a neighbours dog jump up and scratch me and they had the nerve To say it was out of their control! Also had muddy paw prints once years ago and I had to turn back and text the friends I was meeting to say I was going to be late as I had to go back and change.

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 18/06/2023 16:33

The thing is, absolutely nothing can prepare you for dog ownership in the same way that nothing can prepare you for parenthood.

I know they are not children - but the commitment SHOULD be the same. Unfortunately, when people realise what hard work dogs are, it's very easy to either mistreat with with neglect, or fob them off to a rescue centre.

There should be stricter rules. A licence. Insurance should be mandatory, and maybe something along the lines of a healthy pet plan, so that they are checked 6 monthly by a vet and parasite treatments are kept up to date.

My dog is not perfect - unfortunately I over socialised him as a pup, and now he expects attention from everyone. However, I'm not a member of the 'he's friendly' gang - I stick to 'I'm really sorry, he's over friendly' as he anchors himself to the ground in front of them if they do much as maintain 3 seconds of eye contact with him.

He's a work in progress.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 18/06/2023 16:32

QueenMegan · 18/06/2023 16:12

There are loads of dogs with anxiety and poor recall because they've never been socialised or trained

I would also argue that lots of dogs are anxious because other people don't recall or train their dogs. I see so many badly trained dogs bombing around and running up to other dogs whose body language is screaming "please leave me alone".

Only a few weeks ago I was out with two on-lead dogs when an out-of-control terrier ran up to them and bit my dog on the back of the neck. He was very good and didn't respond in kind, but it still terrified him.

StuffedCompletely · 18/06/2023 16:32

I dislike dogs bu this is a refreshing read. Clearly there are lots of good dog owners around who take responsibility and don’t let their dogs run and jump at others. It restores my faith a bit!!

LadyJ2023 · 18/06/2023 16:32

I kindof agree. I train my dogs and I hate when people let them howl or jump on you if you don't know there dogs or latest one I was walking with hubby in a field with our dog on lead and next thing 2 dogs came charging over from nowhere growling and owner eventually appeared and no recall whatsoever

SoShallINever · 18/06/2023 16:25

EmeraldEagle · 18/06/2023 16:04

As someone who has 3 dogs and works with dogs I 100% agree with you!
I see about 50 dogs a week and at least half of them have at least one of the following:
Never go out for walks
Are overweight
Have terrible teeth
Are matted
Have infected ears
Have weeks worth of eye boogies
Have no training
Have poo and or wee caked to their fur

These people would absolutely claim to love their dogs 😢

Well we pass on all of these, except the training. He did go to classes but absolutely refused to learn reliable recall. Therefore he is only off lead where there is absolutely no chance of him absconding.

JonahAndTheSnail · 18/06/2023 16:20

I'm probably guilty of 'babying' my dog when we're at home, in that I talk and sing to him in a soft voice and have lots of silly nicknames for him. He also seems to enjoy a fuss on a night (face, ear and belly rubs) before he settles down to sleep. He's an older greyhound and feels the cold in winter, so he does wear a sweater when it's very cold and likes to be covered in a blanket. He will literally whine and try to pick the blanket up with his teeth to try to cover himself up.

He's rarely left alone for more then a couple of hours, only if we go out to eat or something, otherwise he's always with me or DH. We've never allowed him to bark endlessly and disturb the neighbours.

I do wonder about one of our neighbours who seems to have several dogs that seem to stress him out a great deal. He's always yelling at them to shut up when they're out in the garden barking and he just doesn't seem to enjoy having them!

clpsmum · 18/06/2023 16:16

Haven't rtft sorry if it's been said but I'm so sick of everywhere being bloody dog friendly too. I don't want to go to a meal in a restaurant full of dogs no matter how cute they are

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 18/06/2023 16:13

I agree op but I generally think there are far too many dogs now and they are far too easily accessed. As another poster pointed out it should be far more stringently monitored and licensed. Make it as expensive and as inconvenient as possible and then you could possibly be left with those who are willing to actually spend the time and money needed to look after a dog.

QueenMegan · 18/06/2023 16:12

There are loads of dogs with anxiety and poor recall because they've never been socialised or trained

MooseBreath · 18/06/2023 16:11

I wouldn't say most dog owners shouldn't own dogs. You tend not to notice the ones who have been trained to a high standard and treated like an animal as opposed to a child.

That said, I think a lot of people are in over their heads and have chosen breeds based on appearance or status. A busy family in a small home without time for long walks have no business getting a Border Collie, a Husky, or a German Shepherd. A family with small excitable children should not have an American Bully or a Cane Corso. A family who love hiking and biking with their dog shouldn't have a chihuahua.

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/06/2023 16:10

Theres some failure to imagine situations outside your personal experience here.

A labrador walked on pavement probably will self trim except for the dew claws and some will nibble them down themselves. One of my dogs does this, she chews down her own claws or they're taken care of by pavement walks.

Two of my dogs do not - they both have rather flat feet and the nails grow almost straight out, not down to the ground. Combine that with much of our walking being on soft grass/forest floor, and their nails NEVER get worn down and easily over-grow. So I clip them myself, but then I have a grooming table and I taught them from an early age to stand on it or to lie upside down in my lap for that.

My partner is absolutely useless at nails, hes terrified of catching the quick so is quite panicky about doing it and as a result is more likely to catch the quick or worry the dog - he would be better having a groomer do it.

Some dogs coats really need a proper bath, blaster dryer to remove undercoat, professional dryer etc, or they will take DAYS to fully dry. Lots of the very popular poodle mixes fall into this category, having coats the owners were not expecting/could not predict.

I wash our hound, he is a stinky bastard if I don't and no amount of brushing fixes that, he dribbles on himself and delights in developing revolting stalactites round his face-flaps. It's only once every six weeks or so, and he is outraged by it but also really likes the treats and also the paw massage (getting the matted bits of crap from between his pads) that goes with it!

I have taught my dogs to enjoy grooming though - many people don't bother, assuming that the groomer will do it and that is unfair and unkind, and leaves dogs suffering. Of course the groomer says 'Oh yes Fido was fine' to their client... unless Fido has actually taken off a few fingers... because they know thats what the client wants to hear. They'd have no business if they said 'well actually, Fido was fucking terrified, tense and uncomfortable the whole time and we did worry at one point if he'd have a heart attack in the bath, he also tried to bite a few times so we strapped his face shut and suspended him in a sling so he couldn't throw himself around'...

MissingMoominMamma · 18/06/2023 16:09

My dog wouldn’t mind being dressed up because that involves being touched, which is his favourite thing. I don’t though, I just stroke him a lot.

I bloody love my dogs, and cat. I wouldn’t ever call them furbabies, but they are very much part of my family.

I do agree on nail clipping/grooming/feeding/walking and the other important stuff though.

EmeraldEagle · 18/06/2023 16:04

As someone who has 3 dogs and works with dogs I 100% agree with you!
I see about 50 dogs a week and at least half of them have at least one of the following:
Never go out for walks
Are overweight
Have terrible teeth
Are matted
Have infected ears
Have weeks worth of eye boogies
Have no training
Have poo and or wee caked to their fur

These people would absolutely claim to love their dogs 😢

Badbudgeter · 18/06/2023 16:00

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 18/06/2023 15:50

You'd be surprised.

As a dog walker I see a LOT of dogs left in crates all day while their owners are out at work. Owners leave around 8.30am, I pop in at lunchtime, owners aren't back until 4-5pm. Apart from the hour so they're out with me, the dogs are shut in crates.

Many are also shut back in them overnight.

That is so sad actually. My dog would be really upset at being shut away.

LolaSmiles · 18/06/2023 15:53

People have different thresholds for what they consider babying dogs though.

We sometimes have relatives comment that we baby our dogs. I don't think we do. We just chose to have dogs and part of that means we've chosen a lifestyle that is dog friendly. That means we don't do lots of random weekends away, don't plan long days out over the weekend that aren't dog friendly, and don't believe that 'just put them in a kennels' / 'can you not give them a run outside' is an acceptable solution.

Would we pass the puritan cat's bum face types on here who think everyone should WFH every day, walk 10 miles a day, never leave them for more than an hour? Of course not. But I think like most owners we do a reasonable job and are responsible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread