Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people shouldn't own dogs

135 replies

JamSandle · 18/06/2023 10:52

I love dogs but I think a lot of owners:

  • infantalise their dogs and treat them like babies, not animals who have instincts and needs.

  • don't train them. Let their dogs bark, howl and growl all day long.

  • don't look them properly. Walk them, trim nails, clean them, look after teeth.

Good dog owners are amazing people. But so many people have dogs and don't put the effort into training them or understanding the animals needs.

I dont really think most people should be dog owners.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TakeMyStrongHand · 21/06/2023 21:43

As a dog owner, I completely agree. I think about 10% of dog owners actually comprehend what is expected and what their dogs are capable of.

I own a powerful dog and take no chances. Most other dog owners around me do and he has been attacked by 4 labradors - 2 in one attack and 1 each time for the others.

EdithStourton · 21/06/2023 12:57

But isn't that again for the benefit of humans? It might make us better people but at what costs to animals.
In the case of many dogs, they benefit. Well-kept domestic pets, and also animals like horses, tend to have much longer and healthier lives than do wild animals (though obviously if we breed animals like eg brachycephalic dogs we cause a host of issues; on welfare ground I have real reservations about extremes like that).

As for farming, I think that could only be to the farm animal's benefit.
Not sure what you mean by that.

redboxer321 · 21/06/2023 12:32

Dealing with other species gives you insights you get no other way.

But isn't that again for the benefit of humans? It might make us better people but at what costs to animals.
Don't get me wrong, I'd hate to be without my dog.

As for farming, I think that could only be to the farm animal's benefit.

MyWishIsMyCommand · 21/06/2023 12:31

JamSandle · 18/06/2023 11:04

Rephrase: most dog owners shouldn't own dogs.

I agree. I think most dog owners are like the ever-so-hated SUV owners, in that they think they/their pets/cars can do no wrong and have more rights than anyone or anything else. Even if they don't think it, they sure act like it.

EdithStourton · 21/06/2023 12:18

redboxer321 · 21/06/2023 11:49

Another way of looking at it is most dogs shouldn't have owners. It's only because we've taken over this world and we've bred dogs to be dependent on us that they need owners.

There's an interesting argument that dogs, as the first domesticate, are the foundation on which rests all other domestication.

No dogs, no farming sort of thing.

And I'd hate to live in a world where humans kept no animals. Dealing with other species gives you insights you get no other way.

redboxer321 · 21/06/2023 11:49

Another way of looking at it is most dogs shouldn't have owners. It's only because we've taken over this world and we've bred dogs to be dependent on us that they need owners.

Oblomov23 · 21/06/2023 11:46

I too think most owners shouldn't own dogs.

redboxer321 · 21/06/2023 11:41

@lieselotte
It's not only for the benefit of the human. My dog would have died if someone hadn't have offered her a home. So I did. It's clearly for my benefit too. She restricts my life somewhat but I love her dearly and wouldn't be without her. I think she is happy too and I do the very best I can for her.
Having said all that, I wish she didn't exist! She has suffered terribly in her life.
I'd like pet ownership to end, all breeding of pets to end, I'd like us to stop using animals full stop - police dogs etc. There are likely a few exceptions.
I'd also like people to stop breeding as the rate they do so land is freed up for the domestic dog's ancestor the majestic wolf.
I read that wild cats have just been introduced in the Cairngorms. Haven't read more than the headline but that seems a wonderful thing to me.

lieselotte · 21/06/2023 11:30

I don't think people should have pets full stop as it's exploitative and for the benefit of the human.

But I've said it on here before, in the past most people who had dogs were doggy people so they knew what dogs needed and how to look after them properly.

Nowadays and particularly since covid. you've got too many people who don't have a clue and can't be bothered. And there is far too much anthropising.

redboxer321 · 21/06/2023 11:24

I agree to an extent @Noorandapples but I think that poor breeding practices have led to 'bad' dogs being bred. Certainly dogs are being bred that the average dog owner would not be capable of training to the required standard.
Not the fault of these poor dogs, all down to greedy, irresponsible, inadequate human beings.

Noorandapples · 21/06/2023 11:15

Absolutely agree. My grandad always had dogs and said there's no such thing as a bad dog, only a bad dog owner. You have to commit the time and effort to teach, train and care properly. I'm not angry at the yappy snarling dog who almost bit my child, I'm angry at the owner who had the lead so loose it could reach us and hasn't trained it. I'm not angry at whatever dog did a massive poo in my front garden, I'm angry at the owner who allowed it and left it. I'm not angry at the dogs leaving wee streams all over the pavement every day, I'm angry at the owners not training them to go in the gutter/against a tree/not in the middle of the pavement or all over my garden edges.

redboxer321 · 21/06/2023 11:09

I think you miss a very important point off your lists, @JamSandle
and that is people refusing to see that their dogs are suffering and need to be pts.
I see so many dogs who clearly don't only have any quality of life but are in discomfort and sometimes pain.
I hear about dogs who are incontinent, have dementia, any number of old age issues that are never going to get better.
I have just seen a poor old dog who can barely walk and limps on all four legs and her owner, who is trying to balance the needs of her young dog with this old lady, calling her and telling her to hurry up. She made some comment about life being a struggle now.
I really think there need to be specialist vets for one your dog gets old that judge quality of life and can insist on euthanasia if necessary.
I've had to make the decision once in my life and I left it too late. I feel terrible shame about it and I will never do it again. Far far better too early than too late.
However hard it is for the human at the time, I think it would be best for them too to have the decision taken out of their hands. The vets would have to be made of pretty stern stuff. I don't know, not an easy problem to fix but something needs to be done.

Katieandthekids · 21/06/2023 06:12

thecatsthecats · 18/06/2023 11:12

I think a vast majority of the "casually bad" dog owners - the under-trained, under-exercised, left at home all day types - as opposed to dreadful neglect/bully dog types, actually want a cat.

They just, for whatever unintelligent reason of their own, think they want a dog.

If you want something furry to love you, if you don't want to train it, if you want it to be OK alone during the day, and to largely exercise themselves - that's a cat.

Exactly. We have a cat. I feed her once a day and she rewards us with casual occasional affection.

Katieandthekids · 21/06/2023 06:11

I absolutely agree with you. I don't have a dog because we couldn't devote the time needed to care for one at the moment but the number of people who don't care for their dogs properly round my neighbourhood is terrible.

FloofCloud · 19/06/2023 07:48

JamSandle · 18/06/2023 11:04

Rephrase: most dog owners shouldn't own dogs.

A lot of dog owners are decent owners IME, just a few idiots out there who shouldn't be dog owners

Azaeleasinbloom · 19/06/2023 07:45

TeenLifeMum · 18/06/2023 11:47

I actually disagree. The majority of dog owners I know are dedicated and loving and the dog is part of the family. But then I don’t know owners who don’t walk their dogs or leave them all day. Everyone I know has done puppy training courses and consider their dog’s needs.

I am with TeenLifeMum. I live in an area with a lot of dogs, and a decent amount of space for them. I meet a lot of them while I am out with my well loved, well looked after, labs.

Most of the dogs are friendly and most of the owners are working hard to keep the dogs happy and well trained.
I
have known a couple of dogs and owners who were clearly not a good fit, but the majority do pretty well.

Not sure what it is in your experience that makes you think otherwise ?

Pugdogmom · 19/06/2023 07:38

Although I posted earlier that I don't put my dogs in outfits, I do put them in jumpers and coats when it's cold/ snowing. My old lurcher girl whines when she's cold, so a jumper or fleecy blanket is needed ( she likes being tucked in).
She also gets a light coat when it's raining because she likes to find the muddiest part of the field and roll in it. 🙈
Then whines if we shower her.

Jemandthehologramsunite · 18/06/2023 23:29

Agree so much with this, but equally the same goes with children too!

JamSandle · 18/06/2023 21:44

FangsForTheMemory · 18/06/2023 20:53

Difference between cats and dogs is that owners train their dogs and cats train their owners. I mean staff.

Very true 🐈

OP posts:
FangsForTheMemory · 18/06/2023 20:53

thecatsthecats · 18/06/2023 20:29

Oh, absolutely! I know, my little heckers run rings around me daily. And they love our company.

But it's definitely a different set of criteria, easier to meet on a daily basis for your average cat compared to your average dog.

The idea that cats are aloof is just asinine - and probably contributes to people wanting the more overtly "slavish" adoration of a dog.

(Disclaimer, yup, great if you're a good dog owner. But if you demonstrably can't meet a dog's minimum needs, don't bother. I promise a cat will love you just as much.)

Difference between cats and dogs is that owners train their dogs and cats train their owners. I mean staff.

Anyotherdude · 18/06/2023 20:35

I have a lovely dog that needs a coat below 6 degrees Celsius or she gets cold. Clearly a double-coated breed can cope without, but long dogs such as whippet, lurcher, greyhounds and IG’s in particular, need coats in the winter.
I think that you have shown that your knowledge isn’t necessarily as good as you think in making this part of your observation, but as for dogs that don’t get exercised enough (the amount differs from breed to breed), or aren’t properly trained, or are not stimulated enough, I do see more dogs around now that are badly behaved, and I also see more un-picked-up dog poo than, say, 10 years ago, so you’re not entirely unreasonable!

thecatsthecats · 18/06/2023 20:29

JamSandle · 18/06/2023 11:13

Absolutely!

A cat, though they still require good ownership of course, is so much easier in general.

Oh, absolutely! I know, my little heckers run rings around me daily. And they love our company.

But it's definitely a different set of criteria, easier to meet on a daily basis for your average cat compared to your average dog.

The idea that cats are aloof is just asinine - and probably contributes to people wanting the more overtly "slavish" adoration of a dog.

(Disclaimer, yup, great if you're a good dog owner. But if you demonstrably can't meet a dog's minimum needs, don't bother. I promise a cat will love you just as much.)

ShandaLear · 18/06/2023 20:25

I think you’re right, OP. Lots of people got dogs during lockdown on my street, and most are fine, but there are one or two that clearly shouldn’t be owners. There’s the dog next door who NEVER goes out and spends the whole day looking out the window barking at passers by, and another who leaves her dog barking outside for an hour at 10pm every night. I’d like to see people go on a course and pass an exam or portfolio so they could get a licence before being allowed to buy a dog. The course could cover breeds, exercise, nutrition, grooming, training, finance, etc. I’m not saying it would be perfect, but it might help some people face the realities of what they were committing to, and ensure they thought it through carefully before they selected a dog.

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/06/2023 20:09

We have a scent hound..

He recalls just fine when he is not following a scent, he has no wilful desire to bugger off, he comes lolloping back, big grin on his face, delighted to do so because he gets paid in sausages.

But when hes on a scent he is clueless as to the world around him, he does not hear a recall, he fully believes we too are following the scent and know where he is, can see him, are right behind him... and when his nose comes up off that track.. he is HORRIFIED and outraged to find we're not there! I have had (helpful geography of hilly field so we could see him!) the joy of actually watching this happen and he turned and followed the scent/his own scent, back to us, in a fair hurry...getting his bustle on!

He thinks we are the wayward ones, we have this awful habit of not keeping up, but he is too clueless to let off in places where he could get to a road, so its secure fields or the long line for him!

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 18/06/2023 17:18

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 18/06/2023 17:15

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts Bum. I knew someone on Mumsnet would prove my 'always works' method has a flaw. It definitely works on lots of dogs though, so worth a try except perhaps for scent hounds.

Beagles are a law unto themselves Grin there's even a section on the Beagle Welfare website about how different scent hounds are to other dogs and how you need to massively re-adjust how you work with them lol.

After all, they were bred to bugger off on their own and hunt, then to bay so we came to find them - they weren't bred to come to us!

Swipe left for the next trending thread