Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still be seething she made a cake

427 replies

TheCakeConspiracy · 18/06/2023 06:27

We threw a small party a few weeks ago for DS's birthday. My mother had offered to make a cake. This was very kind of her, however it's our child's birthday and we really wanted to provide the cake. Explained this to her and asked if she could make something else instead.

Skip to party day, she turns up with the 'something else' AND a cake! Ultimately the centre piece of a birthday party.

AIBU to still be quietly raging about this?

Yes - get over it, she was just trying to be nice and it's only a cake

No - she didn't listen to you, didn't care what you wanted and tried to take over a little bit

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 18/06/2023 08:19

sodthesodoff · 18/06/2023 07:47

Who knew 'no' actually means 'yes' in some instances. As long as it's your mum (cause hey she might be dead so consider yourself lucky) and it's about cake (cause no one's allowed to have boundaries about cake)

Honestly I don't know what the relationship is like with the ops mum. But the fact she ignored a direct request not to do something speaks volumes. It's not hard to guess this isn't the first time. Her opinions and wishes have been ignored. So yeah it's a cake but it's also the straw that broke the camels back.

And for those saying it's just a cake suck it up, who needs boundaries with cake. That's the thing about boundaries. Anyone with lived experience of abuse/narcissists/general dickheads can tell you it starts with one boundary. Until you have nothing left. It's not as easy as saying oh I'll let them have this one and then they'll leave me alone and respect my other wishes.

Alternative point of view: it's not about boundaries but about rules and control.

My mum would tell you she had strict boundaries with ne growing up. I would tell you it was her way or the highway, and she got so mad about stupid, inconsequential things that really didn't matter, that there was nowhere left for her to go on the big things that did matter.

I remember one of the worst things she did was a punishment because I forgot to go to one half-hour long music lesson which was usually after school but had been moved to lunchtime one week because the teacher had another appointment. I lied and told her I had gone because I knew she would go completely mental and massively overreact, and if there was a chance of her not finding out, I would take it. Of course she did find out, and the punishment was severe.

Did I learn that my mum had strict boundaries that I was not to cross?

No. I learned that she had absolutely no sense of proportion and a complete inability to control her temper.

From that moment on, whenever she got angry, I assumed that it was probably just because she was crazy and not because I had done anything objectively bad. I obeyed her most of the time because I was living under her roof and she was able to control me through things like access to money and lifts (we lived somewhere with little to no public transport). It didn't make me have any more respect for her though.

Now the boot is on the other foot somewhat, in the sense that I am an adult with my own life and my own money, living far away, and she wants to make sure that she gets to see me and my kids, which involves a long journey and a lot of money each time, so she's a lot more careful about falling out with me. I could use this to my advantage and be really controlling of her and her behaviour, but I don't. Because I remember both how it felt and how ineffective it was.

So yes, by all means, have boundaries in place with the people in your life, particularly the people who need boundaries because they don't just behave properly without needing to be told. But bear in mind that if you fly off the handle about cake one week and then the next week your mother flouts your no social media rule by posting a picture of your child naked in the bath to Facebook, how do you communicate the relative severity of these offences when you've already gone straight to level 10 over the cake thing?

You can't.

And then the person will no doubt go around telling anyone who will listen that you are horrible and controlling and you have rules about EVERYTHING, and because they will bring up that time you went mad about cake, everyone will sympathise with them. Whereas if you accepted the cake with a polite smile and a thank you, but went nuclear over the social media thing, there's a much greater chance that the person concerned would take you seriously, or that anyone they told about it would side with you and say, "Actually Linda, she is right. You shouldn't put pictures of children on Facebook if their parents have asked you not to."

Aprilx · 18/06/2023 08:19

I bet your child was delighted to have a second cake. To be seething about this weeks later is incredible to me.

gelijkheid · 18/06/2023 08:19

A sponge cake decorated with fruit is not a child's birthday cake.

Pottedpalm · 18/06/2023 08:18

MustardCress · 18/06/2023 06:39

YANBU. Some people will tell you to turn the other cheek/be kind or some other appeasing guff, but kindness works both ways. She’s had her turn at making birthday cakes and it’s not kind to stop you from having your turn, especially when she knows you want to do it. It’s really sad to see such casual selfishness Flowers

This ‘she’s had her turn’ crap and talk of boundaries … It’s a bloody cake! As others have said, remind her you have the party cake and will keep hers for family tomorrow.

Roundtoedshoes · 18/06/2023 08:18

So you had a cake already and she bought a cake?

All you had to do was say thanks, but we already have one - that will be what we put on the table/blow out the candles on/take pictures with, but we are happy to cut yours up after that as an alternative/extra portions.

I get it’s annoying, but it’s not that big a deal.

LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand · 18/06/2023 08:13

This sounds like a mother crossing boundaries by bringing a birthday cake when op distinctly told her it was sorted. It's not about a cake. To all those who say it was only a cake and why deprive the child if granny makes e, normally a conversation would have happened where mum and granny agreed on that. That wasn't the case here. It's about riding roughshod over plans made. I would have been cross too. I used to make my children's birthday cakes and I would have been annoyed if my mum had brought along a second birthday cake. My daughter makes fabulous cakes for her children. It would never cross my mind to bring a second cake. Does your mum have form for this kind of behaviour? You are now warned and can put plans in place to subvert any more nonsense, not that I think you should have to.

PinkIcedCream · 18/06/2023 08:12

You are being completely ridiculous OP.

It was a sponge cake decorated with fruit, not an extravagantly decorated fairytale castle.

Were you a petulant child too? 😂

debbs77 · 18/06/2023 08:10

Totally understand that!

My ex MIL did this but for her adult son on his 40th. I even offered for her to make the cake as I knew she would love that and is great at baking! Said no, she wouldn't have time.

I spent hours making a cake and I was so proud of it. Only for her to turn up with one. Luckily it was on the birthday day, not the party.

Welcometothecheapseats · 18/06/2023 08:10

I voted yabu but only with the voice of hindsight.

YANBU to be furious - I was when this happening to me after DH bought a massive luxury chocolate cake to a dc bday party after I’d asked him not to as it upstaged my home made but nothing fancy birthday cake. Id asked him to get roulades and puddings for the grown ups but not a cake.

It hindsight it was a stupid thing to lose my mind over. Controlling and high maintenance of me.

If she’s not made a 4 out of raspberries on the top I don’t think she was trying to upstage you. She didn’t listen but grandparents often don’t and in this instance I don’t think it’s a massive crime.

Fandabedodgy · 18/06/2023 08:08

Seething about a cake?

Really?

Ladywillpower · 18/06/2023 08:08

What type of cake was the “usurped” birthday cake? 😀

defi · 18/06/2023 08:07

It just really isn't something I could get worked up about. Surely the more cake the better. Your life must be void of actual problems. Lucky you

YoucancallmeKAREN · 18/06/2023 08:07

So you are hacked off because you wanted to be centre of attention and your Mum burst your bubble. As it was your Son's birthday it should have been about him.

mycoffeecup · 18/06/2023 08:06

Well why didn't you just say 'thanks Granny, but as we told you he has a birthday cake already. Let's put that one aside and we'll use it at home later?'

TallerThanAverage · 18/06/2023 08:04

AIBU to still be quietly raging about this?

I would say speak to your mother but as it was a few weeks ago the opportunity has passed so you seriously need to let it go.

avio · 18/06/2023 08:02

YANBU but people will assume she was acting kindly. My MIL used to do this. Then go on and on about how expensive it was to make it and not buy dc a birthday present citing the cake was expensive to make (they had enough money and we'd rather have not had the cake then grandma turn up without anything other than a cake that inevitably got poked by several dc before dc saw it anyway at the party)
It was quite obvious she wanted to be grandma of the year despite no other actions to show this for the rest of the year,
And a cake in the centre of the attention somehow proved this.

We finally put our foot down and she turned up with nothing at all to dc party that year. She wanted to be centre of attention and didn't get that so she sulked. That is the issue. If you have a kind mil or mum it's very very difficult to understand when you don't ime.

Thegoodbadandugly · 18/06/2023 08:00

Why didn't you use the cake you bought and then used your mother's later, it's not a huge deal really is it?

KTheGrey · 18/06/2023 07:59

Yes, @Ladybug14 , yes.

Cake good. No cake blaming.

Namechangers123484 · 18/06/2023 07:59

Honestly wouldn’t care, don’t sweat the small stuff

Ladybug14 · 18/06/2023 07:57

OK....I'll play.

So... if I look at the argument that this ISN'T about the cake it's about the OPs wishes being ignored and no not meaning no....

  1. Is this the first time it's happened? If so, let it go with grace and keep an eye open for further similar events
  1. Does this type of thing happen all the time? Then the OP will have been expecting a second cake and will have a plan of action in place already. No need for fury as its a regular annoyance and the OP will know how to deal with it.
  1. The OP has a really toxic relationship with her mother, is thinking of going NC and this cake is just the icing on an already intolerable relationship. Then say this. Don't make it about a 2nd cake which is no big deal in and of itself
53andABitPodgy · 18/06/2023 07:57

My MIL used to undermine me at every turn when I was younger and inexperienced in all things hosting. She would publicly strip your confidence and then step in and save the day and announce it was a good job she was there or there or we would all die of starvation.

Over the years I have become a great home cook thanks to Nigella and when I was a SAHM I went on a cake baking and topper course. My MIL used to turn up with a cake that looked pretty grim, and mine would be a 3 tier cake with a different level for Spiderman, Batman and Superman.

She once got very upset none of the DC wanted any of her cake, and then she stopped doing it.

A bit of an extreme reaction for me, but it was worth it. Plus, I make cakes for people I love and they really appreciate it. I've never, nor will ever make her one!

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 18/06/2023 07:56

Who knew 'no' actually means 'yes' in some instances.

And apparently, when someone turns your no in to a yes you should thank them for it.

I do think that a fruit sponge is an odd choice for a 4 year old - it's basically going against your wishes with a way to claim she hasn't.

If she has form for wanting to be at the centre of things I can imagine why it would piss you off even more.

Absolutely hate it when people overstep

Lifescary · 18/06/2023 07:55

If grandma is better at making cakes than you, don't deprive your child of the better cake just because you want to be the centre of your child's world.

Given that most of us love cake I really can't see the problem of 2 cakes. Either put both out or chose which one you want as the centrepiece. Even if grandma's looks better most of us are wise enough to know that you can't judge a cake by its cover and the proof of the cake is in the eating.

If it is not just the cake but grandma insists on taking over everything, then you do have a battle on your hands, but seething won't help. Battles are won by clear heads not seethers and sulkers.

AnImaginaryCat · 18/06/2023 07:51

Did she walk in holding the cake aloft to the sound of Circle of Life?

Though in all seriousness, unless she did do the above (or similar attention seeking behaviour) then there's no reason why it would have been centre piece of the party.

Do you mean it ended up being the cake being the tradtion centre piece because it was the one with the candles on? In this circumstances we probably need more info. (As in if you had planned on the cake and candle thing, why wasn't your cake used. Or if you had planned on the cake candle thing how did it end up happening? Did you mum bring candles too?)

So whether you are being unreasonable or not depends whether it is just about this cake or if its about your mum overriding and being controlling.

If it's the latter then YANBU. You can ignore all the posters that think it is. But you need to understand its not about cake too. You've going to have to work on how your mother's behaviour affects your behaviour. You can't change hers but you can change yours.

PetitPorpoise · 18/06/2023 07:49

YANBU.

I've had similar with my mum. She has a very big garden and my eldest has a summer birthday, so a few times she has suggested thatbwe have a garden party at theirs', and I end up feeling like a guest at my own child's birthday.

I realised that she would try to catch me off guard by asking what my plans were months in advance, so that I'd end up agreeing that her suggestion was a lovely idea etc.

I've had to learn to listen out for such things now and have an answer ready.

Swipe left for the next trending thread