Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That teachers should be held legally responsible for erroneously teaching children they can change sex?

216 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 01:18

https://www.tiktok.com/@urgalcrystall*/video/7245383841873923355?r=1&&t=8dEqrgzepeE&socialsharing=v5

Listening to this ridiculous teacher today bullying two students, isn't it time that we started holding teachers responsible for indoctrinating children into thinking they can identify as anything they feel like?

How did we get to this point where kids are so afraid to speak up because of being bullied by classmates or even by teachers?

YABU - I identify as a cat
YANBU - teachers should face the legal consequences for encouraging children to identify out of their biological sex.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Asiatoyork · 18/06/2023 10:44

In my school it would be a suspension - the same as if you take and then publicly post photos or videos of other children. Some people (particularly woman and children) are unsafe if their location is widely shared

Fair enough. Doesn’t sound like it’s illegal though as that poster said.

I have a lot of sympathy for teachers being asked to teach this kind of stuff, but this lady was very emphatic about it and spouting nonsense. It makes me think that she believes it.

Ididntknowuntiliknew · 18/06/2023 10:42

Why can't they identify as a cat?
Self id should be self id.

It won't offend cats. Cats don't have any specific rights in law, and don't have any protected characteristics.

These are probably long overdue, and cats would benefit from some specific legislation.

The cats won't be threatened by non cats in the cat shelters.

Calling cats 'cis' should be fine, unless it's mispronounced as 'hiss'. They get called all sorts. They don't seem to get offended, because their names are chosen for them.

Cats won't be upset by humans speaking on their behalf, and making choices for them. It's always been that way.

Then I read this again, and it's just like men making choices on behalf of women.........
Madness really.

Bunbuns3 · 18/06/2023 10:40

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 10:21

Covering this subject and saying completely abusive nonsense to children are two different things.

The teachers not having guidance isn't an excuse for abuse.

This is now fast becoming a safeguarding issue where teachers are affirming the mental illness and self harm of children.

I don't feel sorry at all for teachers who behave like this. They are teachers - they know what they are doing.

If a teacher affirms an autistic child who says they are a cat - that's abuse, plain and simple.

Perhaps this certain teacher is in the minority that actually agrees with the utter nonsense they are being made to peddle.

That aside, it does not alter the fact teachers MUST cover this whether they agree or not. The only options open to parents that strongly oppose is home ed which is becoming increasingly popular, or catholic school, at the moment these are the only two choices that guarantee non exposure to gender ideology education.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 10:28

@WonderingWanda

But do you teach children that they can change their biological sex?

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 18/06/2023 10:25

whereaw · 18/06/2023 09:57

Have I got this right, and I hope I have not.
This conversation ensued as a result of a fellow student identifying as a cat? And the other students said a person cannot be a cat?

If you were to assume that the incident has been accurately described - which could well be a leap then, yes.

But I can well imagine this was more complicated than stated. Perhaps there was both a transgender student in and another student claiming to have a sudden onset cat identity in the classroom which the children used to protest the gender woo by proxy.

Which would be a tricky situation and one that demanded that the teacher attempt to address the situation with the transgender student in mind. I think the teacher does sound genuinely upset at the outset. However that teacher then goes on to say a lot of stuff which is untrue, accuses the girls of being transphobic and then threatens their place in school.

I'm surprised by the number of posters here who are prepared to defend the whole thing, either because they believe that these kids should be told to accept the narrative because the earth is burning or because they feel teachers are hamstrung in these situations. But I'm struggling to believe how anyone could think that was a reasonable response in its entirety.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 10:24

Re my above comment - I don't know if there was an actual student (autistic or not) who is identifying as a cat or the question was theoretical -
But we know from stats that autistic kids are more likely to be the victims of this gender woo.

OP posts:
Tabletable · 18/06/2023 10:22

My whole staff room agrees with you. However, the teachers would all be risking our jobs if they’re told to teach it and refuse to. Luckily they haven’t been. Yet.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 10:21

Bunbuns3 · 18/06/2023 09:31

Not the teacher's fault. They would loose their job if they did not cover this. Lot's of teachers are not comfortable teaching such nonsense. The only way round this madness is to home School or attend a catholic school which will never teach such utter rubbish.

Covering this subject and saying completely abusive nonsense to children are two different things.

The teachers not having guidance isn't an excuse for abuse.

This is now fast becoming a safeguarding issue where teachers are affirming the mental illness and self harm of children.

I don't feel sorry at all for teachers who behave like this. They are teachers - they know what they are doing.

If a teacher affirms an autistic child who says they are a cat - that's abuse, plain and simple.

OP posts:
whereaw · 18/06/2023 10:20

@EnidSpyton very interesting points.

At university all lectures are recorded. Maybe they should do the same in schools. For the benefit of the teachers and the pupils.

Sharing publicly is another thing though...

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 10:15

Asiatoyork · 18/06/2023 10:11

They have totally disrespected this teacher's privacy and I wouldn't be surprised if they were suspended or even expelled for it. There are better ways to challenge and raise questions about this issue than to behave illegally like this

I grant that it’s not respectful behaviour, but I’m not sure it’s illegal is it? Also, it’s not really private when teaching a full class of kids.

In my school it would be a suspension - the same as if you take and then publicly post photos or videos of other children. Some people (particularly woman and children) are unsafe if their location is widely shared.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 10:11

I didn’t realise the teacher’s name had been made public. That is very serious indeed and could have dangerous consequences - I know one teacher in my school who cannot appear in any publicly available photos, videos etc because her violent ex would find her and the children.

Asiatoyork · 18/06/2023 10:11

They have totally disrespected this teacher's privacy and I wouldn't be surprised if they were suspended or even expelled for it. There are better ways to challenge and raise questions about this issue than to behave illegally like this

I grant that it’s not respectful behaviour, but I’m not sure it’s illegal is it? Also, it’s not really private when teaching a full class of kids.

WonderingWanda · 18/06/2023 10:10

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 08:20

I would hope that most teachers subscribe to reality and certainly the teachers I know are dismayed at the behaviour of the Transactivist agenda that is taking over the minds of the vulnerable students in their care, especially the autistic students like my own daughter. However they are afraid of losing their jobs.

Do you teach children that humans can change sex? Because they can't. Not sure if you understand this.

I specifically said that we do not teach sex or gender this way was that not clear?

XGenX · 18/06/2023 10:06

Does this mean I could identify as a dog and enter crufts? Think I’d be quite could on the agility course!

EnidSpyton · 18/06/2023 10:02

It's a minefield for teachers on this issue. There is no official guidance that has been published. There are a lot of resources published by dubious organisations floating around online that schools are using in place of official guidelines and resources. PSHE is a subject that has no specialist teachers. There is no PGCE in PSHE. There is no training to teach PSHE. Teachers are just given a curriculum containing very challenging material and told to get on with it. So without guidance or training, what are teachers supposed to do other than teach what they've been told to?

This teacher does sound like she's repeating a script that's been drummed into her. There is a fear in schools around transgender issues. There are a lot of young people who have bought into gender woo and if they don't like a teacher and want to take them down, they have the power to accuse a teacher of being a transphobe and that would get that teacher in very hot water. I have had a couple of years out of teaching and am returning in September - as someone who doesn't believe transwomen are women and transmen are men, I'm very worried about how to balance my personal views with what I know will be the party line in school. I will refuse to teach children anything I believe is wrong - but if I refuse to teach this topic as instructed, will I get hauled in front of the Head and given a warning? Will I lose my job? Quite possibly.

It's all very 1984. The government urgently needs to act on this in terms of providing clear guidance and expectations, because schools and teachers are currently very vulnerable to individual agendas within their community. We need official guidance to protect everyone's interests.

I will also say that these girls were not wrong in standing up for their views, but they were very wrong for recording the teacher without her knowledge and posting the recording - with the teacher's name - on TikTok. We shouldn't be celebrating/encouraging this kind of behaviour. They have totally disrespected this teacher's privacy and I wouldn't be surprised if they were suspended or even expelled for it. There are better ways to challenge and raise questions about this issue than to behave illegally like this.

AlisonDonut · 18/06/2023 10:00

whereaw · 18/06/2023 09:57

Have I got this right, and I hope I have not.
This conversation ensued as a result of a fellow student identifying as a cat? And the other students said a person cannot be a cat?

Yes. That is what it seems to boil down to.

whereaw · 18/06/2023 09:57

Have I got this right, and I hope I have not.
This conversation ensued as a result of a fellow student identifying as a cat? And the other students said a person cannot be a cat?

whereaw · 18/06/2023 09:51

There is sticking to the guidelines, such as using words like 'uterus haver's' and 'people who menstruate' (which is bad enough and the reason my good friend left the profession). This is not that. The teacher is not only misguided but dangerous in her thinking and what she is telling students.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/06/2023 09:44

And are you compelled to tell students that they are homophobic if they don't believe people can change sex or morph into cat identities? Are you compelled to threaten students with expulsion for not falling into line?

MrsMcisaCt · 18/06/2023 09:38

EVHead · 18/06/2023 07:21

I don’t blame the teachers - they can’t pick and choose which bits of the curriculum to teach.

Blame those further up.

Exactly. I don't choose what to teach. I'm told what to teach.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 09:38

It shouldn’t be allowed to be taught as fact, because it’s not a fact, and there’s no such thing as innate gender identity.

This is exactly the problem. Schools are legally required to teach “the facts” about gender identity. If we ignore that requirement we are absolutely in the wrong. But “the facts” are unbelievably contentious and not at all agreed upon. Lots of people (including some MPs) are absolutely insistent that gender identity is real and to deny that is denying trans people’s right to exist. Regardless of how an individual school or teacher approaches this topic they are picking sides in a political debate and teaching that side to children. Which we are not allowed to do.

Teachers cannot win here, we’ve been put in a catch-22 situation.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/06/2023 09:34

Bunbuns3 · 18/06/2023 09:31

Not the teacher's fault. They would loose their job if they did not cover this. Lot's of teachers are not comfortable teaching such nonsense. The only way round this madness is to home School or attend a catholic school which will never teach such utter rubbish.

Give over. She told the girls that if they don't like it then they need to go to a different school, that's not someone cow towing reluctantly to the script, that's frog marching the girls to silence

TroubleInSchool · 18/06/2023 09:34

I was called to the head's office on Friday for saying in the staffroom at lunchtime that sex is binary and women's spaces should be for women only.

He did say we are entitled to our own opinions but ended the conversation by checking I was NOT sharing this opinion with pupils....

I shut down all conversation in my classroom that turns to this topic - not least because the school employs a teacher who calls herself Mx. Surname that the pupils are quick to complain about.

Bunbuns3 · 18/06/2023 09:31

Not the teacher's fault. They would loose their job if they did not cover this. Lot's of teachers are not comfortable teaching such nonsense. The only way round this madness is to home School or attend a catholic school which will never teach such utter rubbish.

AlisonDonut · 18/06/2023 09:30

Two teens unravel the gender woo nonsense and that's good.

Such a garbled nonsensical argument/catgender being valid/three sexes/both genitals/many genders/re-education - how are teachers supposed to respond when the heads have put them through this nonsense and paid no attention to what they are spouting?

I saw one response on twitter where a parent emailed a complaint to a head and the head responded [to them] in error saying 'X said there would be people like this who were trying to cause trouble'...we have more issues than just the teachers when the heads have fallen hook line and sinker for this crap and put any dissent down to 'causing trouble'. Everyone who objects' cards have already been marked.