Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That teachers should be held legally responsible for erroneously teaching children they can change sex?

216 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 01:18

https://www.tiktok.com/@urgalcrystall*/video/7245383841873923355?r=1&&t=8dEqrgzepeE&socialsharing=v5

Listening to this ridiculous teacher today bullying two students, isn't it time that we started holding teachers responsible for indoctrinating children into thinking they can identify as anything they feel like?

How did we get to this point where kids are so afraid to speak up because of being bullied by classmates or even by teachers?

YABU - I identify as a cat
YANBU - teachers should face the legal consequences for encouraging children to identify out of their biological sex.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ElmTree22 · 18/06/2023 12:49

@RudsyFarmer

"Brilliant. Let’s terrify the kids about climate Armageddon instead. What a time to be alive."

Well burying their heads in the sand isn't going to do much good is it? It certainly hasn't done a whole lot of good while we've all done it!

PSNonsense · 18/06/2023 11:46

pikkumyy77 · 18/06/2023 10:51

Please stop putting this stuff in AIBU or other areas of mumsnet. Its absolute poison. I can ignore the roiling cesspit that “feminism” has become but I can’t block all the other topics and still enjoy the site.

What is poison? You know you don't have to open and comment on threads if you don't want to...

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 11:46

pikkumyy77 · 18/06/2023 10:51

Please stop putting this stuff in AIBU or other areas of mumsnet. Its absolute poison. I can ignore the roiling cesspit that “feminism” has become but I can’t block all the other topics and still enjoy the site.

"Cesspit"

Cesspit, that's what you think about women talking about the safeguarding of women and children?

How lost you must be.

OP posts:
PSNonsense · 18/06/2023 11:45

Climate change is a genuine issue though. Can't bury our heads in the sand about it.

An gender ideology nonsense isn't? Christ.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 11:42

@WonderingWanda

That's great if you don't - I'm not sure where you got the idea that I think ALL teachers do this - especially when I already mentioned that I know teachers who are afraid of losing their jobs. That's like coming on to a thread and saying "Not all men."

Maybe wasn't your intention.

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 18/06/2023 11:40

It's not a picture of democracy or liberalism that I recognise Farmageddon.

Farmageddon · 18/06/2023 11:31

Tabletable · 18/06/2023 10:22

My whole staff room agrees with you. However, the teachers would all be risking our jobs if they’re told to teach it and refuse to. Luckily they haven’t been. Yet.

Can we just think about this for a minute.

Even if you remove the actual topic of discussing here, can we please acknowledge the dangerous implications of how this is being dealt with. We are in a situation (in a supposedly open and democratic society) where ordinary people are afraid to say something truthful and factual, or challenge something untruthful in public lest they risk losing their jobs. It's completely ridiculous.

How are so many people ok with this? Do they really think this MO wont be used in other ways to manipulate, now it's been demonstrated how effective it is.

Whether or not you agree or disagree with the issue, shutting down debate or conversation or indeed threatening people's livelihood and reputation is disturbing.

Even worse is how many people don't seem to care, as it doesn't affect them directly. People like pikkumyy77 who want to cover their eyes and ears and pretend it will all just go away if we don't look at it.

Thelondonone · 18/06/2023 11:17

I’m very gender critical but am happy to support students that are trans, despite knowing they can’t actually change their sex. However, im stuck between a rock and a hard place. All bar one of our trans students are asd, very intelligent but perhaps haven’t found their people (all bar 2 are f to m). Id be hauled over the coals if I suggested they aren’t trans (statistically, they can’t all possibly be trans) and just need help addressing their nd or sometimes mental health - I’d be out of a job. The government need clear guidelines that link directly to the medical profession. We are doing these kids a disservice but how do I know if the parents are like me or if they buy into this nonsense? I don’t. I wouldn’t be caught out like the teacher in this case though, I’d agree with the girls that their views are protected by law.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 11:11

There is no law preventing people from taking photographs in public. This includes taking photos of other people’s children. If you are taking photographs from private land, you need to have the land owner’s permission. Taking a photo of a person where they can expect privacy, such as inside their home or garden, is likely to cause a breach of privacy laws.

The best I can find is from Avon and Somerset police. Schools are on private land and most have a blanket ban on photography unless express permission is given by the subject of the photograph and their responsible adult if the subject is a child. But, equally, nobody has an expectation of privacy in a classroom so it is likely a civil rather than criminal matter.

Report someone taking photographs in a public place | Avon and Somerset Police

There is no law preventing people taking photographs in a public place, providing they are not considered to be indecent.

https://www.avonandsomerset.police.uk/report/taking-photographs-in-public-places/#:~:text=There%20is%20no%20law%20preventing,have%20the%20land%20owner's%20permission.

Asiatoyork · 18/06/2023 11:11

I believe it is illegal, yes, to record someone without their permission, and then post that recording online with identifying information. I am willing to be corrected if wrong

I've gone down the rabbit hole! From what I’ve read, recording without consent is not illegal, but sharing or publishing it is a grey area, and depends on the intent. I really want a lawyer to tell us.

But I agree with the broad point that it’s not really a suitable topic at all, and feel really sorry in general for teachers getting caught in the middle of it.

SunnyEgg · 18/06/2023 11:03

I believe it is illegal, yes, to record someone without their permission, and then post that recording online with identifying information. I am willing to be corrected if wrong.

I‘m not sure about this as we see so many people end up in recordings - the Starbucks incident, today a video on partying is out, so many more that don’t come to mind atm

Would be good for someone in the know to clarify

FourTeaFallOut · 18/06/2023 11:02

This never happens

No you can't have a copy of the teaching materials

That kid is lying

All those kids are lying

Ha, your kid will be suspended for recording the thing that never happens.

WonderingWanda · 18/06/2023 11:01

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 10:28

@WonderingWanda

But do you teach children that they can change their biological sex?

No and nowhere have I suggested I do. Why do you think that I do this based on one tik toc video you've found?

ResisterRex · 18/06/2023 10:58

pikkumyy77 · 18/06/2023 10:51

Please stop putting this stuff in AIBU or other areas of mumsnet. Its absolute poison. I can ignore the roiling cesspit that “feminism” has become but I can’t block all the other topics and still enjoy the site.

Certainly, what's being taught might be regarded as "poison"

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12189041/Twelve-year-olds-taught-anal-sex-school-nine-year-olds-told-masturbate.html

It's a parenting website. Parents can discuss these things if they want.

whereaw · 18/06/2023 10:57

@pikkumyy77 can't you just pretend the threads on gender ideology don't exist?

nolongersurprised · 18/06/2023 10:56

pikkumyy77 · 18/06/2023 10:51

Please stop putting this stuff in AIBU or other areas of mumsnet. Its absolute poison. I can ignore the roiling cesspit that “feminism” has become but I can’t block all the other topics and still enjoy the site.

As I scroll through AIBU many topics don’t interest me. I’m not sure if you aren’t aware of this, but you don’t actually need to click on and comment on topics that you don’t want to. It’s not like a work email

EnidSpyton · 18/06/2023 10:56

Asiatoyork · 18/06/2023 10:11

They have totally disrespected this teacher's privacy and I wouldn't be surprised if they were suspended or even expelled for it. There are better ways to challenge and raise questions about this issue than to behave illegally like this

I grant that it’s not respectful behaviour, but I’m not sure it’s illegal is it? Also, it’s not really private when teaching a full class of kids.

I believe it is illegal, yes, to record someone without their permission, and then post that recording online with identifying information. I am willing to be corrected if wrong.

And if you listen to the recording and read the explanation, this conversation happened after class. It was a private conversation between the teacher and the two pupils who she had asked to stay behind to discuss their behaviour during the lesson. It was not in the context of a lesson. Which still wouldn't be ok to record without the participants' permission anyway.

The teacher was not aware she was being recorded. She did not give her permission to be recorded. She did not give her permission to be named and have this recording of what she believed to be a private conversation posted online. Regardless of the issues being discussed, this is not acceptable and the girls will be punished for it - in my last school, this would have been expulsion worthy behaviour.

We have to remember we don't know the context of what is going on behind the scenes in this school. The teachers might have all been instructed to stick to the party line of self ID and TWAW and sex is changeable etc the teacher is advocating. We don't know what consequences there are for teachers who don't advocate this. We don't know whether there have been issues in this school with children self-ID-ing and pressure being put on the whole community to support this choice. We don't know what the parent community have been advocating for. There are a lot of unknowns. As I said in my previous post, it's an area with no official guidance and schools are being forced to make it up as they go along. Depending on the liberality of the school's leadership, each school is going to go down a different route on this issue because there are no other structures in place to guide them other than individual leaders' own moral stance on the topic. Personally I don't think it should be on the curriculum at all. There are no facts in the matter to teach. It is not the same as teaching them about sexuality. Transgender identities are rooted in complex psychological issues that have no place on the PSHE curriculum.

nolongersurprised · 18/06/2023 10:55

YANBU, OP. It’s thought police territory, very scary.

But I disagree strongly with this :

It won't offend cats. Cats don't have any specific rights in law, and don't have any protected characteristics

Cats are frequently offended, and it’s up to their owners to fawn over them until the misdemeanour is corrected

Silverseas1 · 18/06/2023 10:54

XGenX · 18/06/2023 10:06

Does this mean I could identify as a dog and enter crufts? Think I’d be quite could on the agility course!

🤦‍♀️🤣

Isitsixoclockalready · 18/06/2023 10:54

RudsyFarmer · 18/06/2023 07:24

Brilliant. Let’s terrify the kids about climate Armageddon instead. What a time to be alive.

Climate change is a genuine issue though. Can't bury our heads in the sand about it.

SunnyEgg · 18/06/2023 10:52

pikkumyy77 · 18/06/2023 10:51

Please stop putting this stuff in AIBU or other areas of mumsnet. Its absolute poison. I can ignore the roiling cesspit that “feminism” has become but I can’t block all the other topics and still enjoy the site.

Can’t you just hide the thread?

pikkumyy77 · 18/06/2023 10:51

Please stop putting this stuff in AIBU or other areas of mumsnet. Its absolute poison. I can ignore the roiling cesspit that “feminism” has become but I can’t block all the other topics and still enjoy the site.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 10:50

Doesn’t sound like it’s illegal though as that poster said.

I don’t think so either, but I don’t know for sure. Plenty of illegal things only result in suspension in school (eg punching someone).

whereaw · 18/06/2023 10:48

I would be taking my cat in to school on Monday if I was the student.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 10:47

This is now fast becoming a safeguarding issue where teachers are affirming the mental illness and self harm of children.

Up until the Cass report teachers were being told that affirmation was the correct approach, and that was the approach taken by the NHS. Teachers should be able to trust the flipping doctors, and it isn’t our fault they were wrong. (Yes, some of us always believed they were wrong and have been campaigning about it, but at work we have no right whatsoever to teach our personal opinion as fact or to present our views with equal weighting to the medical experts.)

I don't feel sorry at all for teachers who behave like this. They are teachers - they know what they are doing.

Don’t be daft, teachers simply cannot be experts in everything. This teacher stepped way over the line, of course. She is teaching anti-science (3 sexes ffs) which is plain wrong, and the way she speaks to the pupils is unacceptable. But to claim the average teacher understands the nuance in the debate around gender identity is ridiculous. And even if they do understand it, any approach to teaching it means taking a political stance in a classroom - which is wrong. Failure to teach it is not an option either, schools are legally required to teach gender identity. Teachers are being thrown under the bus on this.

If a teacher affirms an autistic child who says they are a cat - that's abuse, plain and simple.

This one I agree with. Tbh, if a child is serious that they are a cat and honestly believes it I’d be putting in a safeguarding referral.