Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That teachers should be held legally responsible for erroneously teaching children they can change sex?

216 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/06/2023 01:18

https://www.tiktok.com/@urgalcrystall*/video/7245383841873923355?r=1&&t=8dEqrgzepeE&socialsharing=v5

Listening to this ridiculous teacher today bullying two students, isn't it time that we started holding teachers responsible for indoctrinating children into thinking they can identify as anything they feel like?

How did we get to this point where kids are so afraid to speak up because of being bullied by classmates or even by teachers?

YABU - I identify as a cat
YANBU - teachers should face the legal consequences for encouraging children to identify out of their biological sex.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 20:23

Teachers don’t have to promote nonsense.

I simply don’t believe that you actually care about the pressure teachers may or may not be under. It’s just a convenient distraction tactic from the topic: a teacher telling young women that they cannot have their own views and must subscribe to gender identity ideology wholesale.

None of that has anything to do with teachers being under pressure. In fact, if teachers are worried about being black balled from their profession, then teachers like the one being discussed here are The Problem.

The Secretary of State for education has not instructed anyone to teach that there are 3 biological sexes or that identity is the only thing that matters. No Secretary of State has done that.

L3ThirtySeven · 18/06/2023 20:16

IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 20:11

The curriculum doesn’t tell them to teach biologically illiterate nonsense or that no one is allowed to question someone identifying as a cat.

even if stonewall and other lobby groups have tried to convince schools otherwise.

Thinking you’re a cat isn’t the issue and you do wrong to present this issue one in which teachers aren’t under serious pressure.

Teachers are under economic duress to comply or be sacked and, in this case barred from the profession. Career 8-balled. Black listed.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-oxfordshire-65688163

Joshua Sutcliffe

Oxford transgender row teacher banned from profession

Joshua Sutcliffe did not treat pupils with dignity and respect, the Teaching Regulation Agency says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-oxfordshire-65688163

IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 20:11

The curriculum doesn’t tell them to teach biologically illiterate nonsense or that no one is allowed to question someone identifying as a cat.

even if stonewall and other lobby groups have tried to convince schools otherwise.

L3ThirtySeven · 18/06/2023 20:07

YABU- teachers are simply teaching the curriculum they are directed to teach while under economic duress. Many teachers have been sacked for refusing to or failing to teach the curriculum. If anyone is to be held responsible it should be the Secretary of State for Education at the time that the curriculum was implemented as mandatory.

whereaw · 18/06/2023 20:05

@Madeintheshade can a white person identify as a person of colour? If not, why not?

IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 20:04

Th example of domestic abuse is not relevant to whether women should have to share showers or changing rooms or prisons with biological men though.

Heterosexual humans have relationships, and cohabiting/bringing up a family together should be a social good. The problems of abuse in families are complex and women need support to recognise abuse and escape abusive relationships.

There’s simply no reason why biological men need to be in the female changing rooms. None.

AlisonDonut · 18/06/2023 19:54

Madeintheshade · 18/06/2023 18:12

No one would wish assault on anyone, but we accept “one isn’t too many” in many areas of life where we balance risk with rights and freedoms. You might not be conscious of it, but you, yourself likely accept many of these already.

For instance, the majority of assaults on women happen in domestic settings, with husbands/partners guilty of a huge number. We attempt to reduce this, but we don’t say men and women in a relationship shouldn’t live together because “one is too many”.

We do try to educate womenon red flags and offer refuges for them to escape don't we?

IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 19:24

For example, whether or not they want to identify as TRAs, we all recognise - identify! - them as TRAs.

Their behaviour and arguments fit the category ‘TRA’ which makes it possible for the social group to identify them as such.

Even if some TRAs try to present themselves as not TRAs - how many threads have we seen with ‘in as GC as they come, but…’ 🙄 - we are able to identify them as such.

That is actually how identity works.

IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 19:19

BlackForestCake · 18/06/2023 19:15

Being a man or a woman isn't a matter of identity, it's a matter of physical reality.

The gender identity enthusiasts on this thread also don’t seem to understand the nature of identity.

identity isn’t some innate essence that defines you. It’s a set of social ideas and categories that the rest of the world sorts you in to. You might start to believe that’s your identity, but it’s imposed from without and more or less well internalised.

That is why the sentence ‘I identify as …’ is so ridiculous. And egotistical.

BlackForestCake · 18/06/2023 19:15

Madeintheshade · 18/06/2023 17:55

You clearly don’t understand the meaning of identity, regardless of your stance on trans rights.

Being a man or a woman isn't a matter of identity, it's a matter of physical reality.

IncomingTraffic · 18/06/2023 18:42

I don’t care if a man wants to identify as a woman. Why should the rest of the work have to identify him as one?

Why should people get to control other people’s perception of reality like that. Rearrange the whole world to suit yourself and then punish anyone who doesn’t do what you want them to.

‘I have decided that I am a [insert the non-reality you would prefer to be true] and you must adapt your behaviour to fit how I’d like reality to be.’

JemimaTiggywinkles · 18/06/2023 18:22

There is a simple method for reducing the number of women raped in many situations: sex segregation in public spaces where women are particularly vulnerable.

If one special group of male people want privileged access to women’s spaces the onus is on them to prove both:

  • the special group (as a whole, not individually) is significantly lower risk than all the other male people
  • no non-special male people with nefarious intent will be able to exploit the opportunity should it be extended to the special group of males

Until that happens (it won’t, because neither of those things are true) I think we can safely just laugh at the people who are essentially claiming “men are going to rape women anyway, so why not make it easier for them?” It is a ridiculous argument so should be met with derision imo.

Farmageddon · 18/06/2023 18:21

Madeintheshade · 18/06/2023 18:12

No one would wish assault on anyone, but we accept “one isn’t too many” in many areas of life where we balance risk with rights and freedoms. You might not be conscious of it, but you, yourself likely accept many of these already.

For instance, the majority of assaults on women happen in domestic settings, with husbands/partners guilty of a huge number. We attempt to reduce this, but we don’t say men and women in a relationship shouldn’t live together because “one is too many”.

This is such a ridiculous dismissal of the problem, how callous.

We know that a very high percentage of transgender women (i.e. men) in prison have committed sexual offences (about 60%), which is much higher than the general male prison population.

So either there is a strong correlation between being a transwoman and being a sexual offender, or (as many of us suspect) these men are using Self ID to simply gain access to a women's prison.

Therefore they have already shown that they are a high risk to women. But do carry on defending these guys...

Gilmorehill · 18/06/2023 18:20

YANBU. I was impressed at how articulate and confident those pupils were. That teacher should not be in the profession.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/06/2023 18:16

Men aren't women, they have no place in women's single sex spaces - regardless of how they identify. For privacy, dignity and safety.

Madeintheshade · 18/06/2023 18:12

nebulae · 18/06/2023 17:58

One is too many.

No one would wish assault on anyone, but we accept “one isn’t too many” in many areas of life where we balance risk with rights and freedoms. You might not be conscious of it, but you, yourself likely accept many of these already.

For instance, the majority of assaults on women happen in domestic settings, with husbands/partners guilty of a huge number. We attempt to reduce this, but we don’t say men and women in a relationship shouldn’t live together because “one is too many”.

AlisonDonut · 18/06/2023 18:12

Madeintheshade · 18/06/2023 17:57

An incredibly small number (if any) have.

How many raped women would there have to be exactly?

AlisonDonut · 18/06/2023 18:11

Callyem · 18/06/2023 17:50

No, I am genuinely interested in the correlation between those given blockers and not detransitioning.

What I am getting from that is, those who have not been given blockers tend to revert back to their birth gender and those who have, are far less likely to.

I would say that is a sign that only those who are the most emphatic in their gender dysphoria are actually given blockers, rather than the blockers somehow stop children from wanting to revert.

Blockers?

The very same drugs they used to use to castrate paedophiles and homosexuals? Those puberty blockers which devastate a child's development? And which are being used off label to do so? Which are untested in this context and which have not been tracked properly by the clinics administering them?

cardibach · 18/06/2023 18:06

I can’t even watch the video. But no teacher I know is doing what you suggest.

Farmageddon · 18/06/2023 18:04

Callyem · 18/06/2023 17:50

No, I am genuinely interested in the correlation between those given blockers and not detransitioning.

What I am getting from that is, those who have not been given blockers tend to revert back to their birth gender and those who have, are far less likely to.

I would say that is a sign that only those who are the most emphatic in their gender dysphoria are actually given blockers, rather than the blockers somehow stop children from wanting to revert.

Are you kidding me, doctors will give out puberty blockers to pretty much anyone. Thanks to 'affirmation only' policy.
And how do you know that those who are given puberty blockers are somehow 'more emphatic', you cannot possibly have that information. You are projecting to endorse your point of view.

The point is, children do not have the maturity to understand the long term consequences of many of these drugs, if an adult chooses to transition that is their decision. Children should be left alone.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 18/06/2023 18:04

@Madeintheshade feel free to think what you like, I do!

PriOn1 · 18/06/2023 18:03

Callyem · 18/06/2023 17:50

No, I am genuinely interested in the correlation between those given blockers and not detransitioning.

What I am getting from that is, those who have not been given blockers tend to revert back to their birth gender and those who have, are far less likely to.

I would say that is a sign that only those who are the most emphatic in their gender dysphoria are actually given blockers, rather than the blockers somehow stop children from wanting to revert.

When do children desist?

When going through puberty.

What do puberty blockers do?

Block the process during which most children desist.

Can you see any potential problems there?

JustPassingThyme · 18/06/2023 18:02

Those girls should be commended not demonised for their astute recording of that teacher abusing them. Teachers are notorious for covering their own arses at the expense of the child. Many schools have CCTV in the hallways to monitor pupil’s behaviour outside of class, why is it wrong for pupils to have recording devices in the classrooms to monitor the teacher’s behaviour. If teachers aren’t doing anything wrong, then they have nothing to worry about.

Becoming a teacher doesn’t magically except a person from being cruel or from being a fool, like for example the teacher in the recording spouting utter nonsense, then threatening and bullying children. I cannot believe people are actually defending a child abuser.

In the UK we can record conversations we are part of without the other person’s consent or knowledge. I think any parent worried about their children being taught nonsense in school should send their children in with recording devices in their pockets. If a teacher isn’t doing anything wrong, then there is nothing to fear. If anything, it would improve the education the children are receiving, we all remember how different our teachers were when they were being observed and evaluated.

It’s about time teachers left the shelter of the school room and entered the real world and faced the court of public opinion, if not the actual court of law. I don’t recall anyone complaining about how unfair it was for the COO of Wickes to be exposed for his TWAW drivel.

Teachers, if a pupil in your school harshly verbally abused and threatened another pupil who had only spoken the truth, would the bully pupil face punishments? What is good for the goose is good for the gander. I wasn’t aware being a teacher was a characteristic protected by the Equality Act, oh wait, it isn’t.

It doesn’t take a genius to understand there are only two sexes and sex-based rights are important. It isn’t a radical belief, it’s a scientific fact that people can’t change their sex, and they certainly can’t change their species. Those two teenage girls understand that fact and provided their teacher with an eloquent explanation. If that teacher really believes her students can identify as pets, she should be preparing them for Crufts not GCSE’s.

How much guidance is needed for a teacher to understand it’s wrong to bully, gaslight, lie to, and abuse children? Teachers are adults that have at least some semblance of intelligence and social competence. They are perfectly capable of facing the consequences for actions and decisions they freely made. Teachers need to stop passing the blame on to other people, at the end of the day they are the ones abusing children in the classroom by indoctrinating them with this trans nonsense.

If you want to believe in non-scientific believes like there being 3 sexes and a 100 genders, then go and work at Wickes. They support people with bizarre beliefs, and you won’t be abusing children at work every day. They don’t require DBS checks, or an IQ over 100, and teachers can still play with paint all day.

This is how teachers get away with such appalling abuse of children such as transitioning children against parent’s wishes. Teachers always close ranks, protect each other and leave the vulnerable and/or victimised children to the wolves. Why is it ok for the girls to receive abuse online for sharing that recoding? They are children showing the public evidence that they were abused! Yet people are claiming is it wrong for that teacher to face consequences for abusing her students? She should be the one removed from the presence of all children, permanently.

That teacher having to delete her social media and put up with a month of slight discomfort (probably while on publicly funded paid leave) seems a light punishment for her crimes and a small price to pay to protect all the children in the country from being abused, gaslight and indoctrinated into the trans ideology.

She didn’t care about the class full of children she gaslit and taught utter nonsense. She didn’t care about the two girls whom she intended to have punished and their permanent records ruined because they exposed her idiocy and spoke the truth. So why should anyone care about her? Is it’s fine for her to dole out punishments, but not for her to receive them?

Those defending this tragically accurate and appalling example of a teacher reek of hypocrisy and guilt. I have no sympathy for her, or anyone like her.