Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL telling DD how babies are born

241 replies

7whiteclouds · 17/06/2023 22:17

My DD (6) has just said to me “when I had a sleepover at MIL’s a couple of weeks ago - MIL said to me that me and siblings were born by you having your tummy cut open but daddy was born by coming out of her vagina”.

AIBU to be really annoyed that MIL has told DD this information without 1) asking me if it was okay to have this conversation, 2) considering whether I wanted her to know this information yet and 3) whether it was ok for her to be the one to share this information?

I am all for giving my children honest information about human biology, in an age appropriate way and at a time, that I as a mother, feel is best for my children.

if DD had asked me how she was born then I would have explained to her, in the way that I want her to be taught. But DD didn’t ask MIL this question - MIL just told her this info (not sure the context of the conversation). I was waiting for my DD to come to me to ask this question - she previously had at a younger age and I’d just light heartedly said to her “through a special door on my tummy” (partially true for a CS) - until she was ready for more information. She’s not asked me for a while but if she had come to me now and asked, then yes I would have explained how babies come out.

I think it’s really selfish and insensitive for her to have shared not only my personal information with DD, but the important conversation that I believe a mother should have with her DD - not the MIL. I remember when I found out how babies were born (at around DD’s age)that I was felt really uncomfortable and embarrassed about it - I didn’t want DD to feel the same; hence why I was waiting for her to ask me the question and for me to be able to explain to her in a way that suits my DD.

AIBU to say something to her about this or should I just stay quiet?

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 17/06/2023 22:46

Adult tells child scientific fact. Oh, the HORROR!

WeWereInParis · 17/06/2023 22:44

I’m assuming you know MIL and her intentions well then?

It sounds like you have reasons for thinking your MIL had ulterior motives here.

Mummy08m · 17/06/2023 22:43

Yanbu OP- my own mil would never do this.

Also, my MIL (and everyone who cares about me) knows that I'm sensitive about my car crash birth experience and I'd be beyond furious if anyone went behind my back and said something like "Well I had your baby out of my vagina but your mummy had to be cut open". There's no shame in c sections of any kind, they're a medical marvel. But it wasn't what I'd wanted. She may not have meant it like that but that's how I'd have taken it. Your birth story is your private story to tell.

I'd maybe, maybe think it was OK if she kept it general "some mums have vaginal births, some have c-sections". Or mention a famous person eg the Queen had a c-section and 3 vbacs. But not to tell your birth story, it crosses a line.

As for people mocking you for the special door. Sure that is silly but no more silly than "tummy". Babies do not gestate in tummies, they gestate in wombs, even my 2yo knows that word.

My lovely MIL would have deflected with "ask your mummy, she'd want to tell you about it herself" and/or "I'll tell you in the morning" before a quick text to me about what I'd rather she said.

7whiteclouds · 17/06/2023 22:42

thepresureofausername · 17/06/2023 22:29

This is just MIL bashing. She had a perfectly fine conversation with her granddaughter.
Poor woman. She lovingly had your daughter over for a sleepover, I bet she made sure she had a great time and I hope you enjoyed your child free night and now you want to tell her off?

I’m assuming you know MIL and her intentions well then?

OP posts:
7whiteclouds · 17/06/2023 22:41

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/06/2023 22:29

why did she just randomly tell her this information without DD asking her first?

There’s no way that’s what happened.

You obviously don’t know my MIL then by making this assumption.

OP posts:
WeWereInParis · 17/06/2023 22:41

parliamoglesga · 17/06/2023 22:20

People may disagree with you on here but I agree with you.

my BIL and SIL gave their son (my nephew) a graphic description of periods and what they are and their purpose when he was about 5. He started to tell my DSs (then aged 6 and 3) over dinner and my DH told him to stop in no uncertain terms. It wasn’t the time or the place and I don’t think a 6 and 3 year old need to know about periods.

Of course they don't need to know, and I can understand why someone wouldn't want a conversation about blood etc over dinner. But I can't think of any reason why it would be bad for them to know.

Besides this is different to the OP, because an explanation from a 5 year old is likely to be a less accurate description. Which I can understand wanting to avoid, even if I disagree with your general view that children of that age shouldn't hear about periods.

2lsinllama · 17/06/2023 22:40

I get that it might have been something you wanted to tell DD about so MIL may have overstepped the mark a little, but I wouldn’t be bothered about it unless this is something she does regularly.
When DS was about 10 we were watching one of those real life midwife programmes and it explained what happens in a c section. I was a hero in his eyes for quite a few weeks after!

titchy · 17/06/2023 22:40

RudsyFarmer · 17/06/2023 22:37

Do you think your MIL was making a judgement about it in the telling? Ie she had her child ‘the right way’ and you didn’t.

Gosh careful you don't put your shoulder out with that reach Hmm

I'd be fairly sure your MIL didn't suddenly decide to tell her - your dc must have asked. And she answered - very well imo.

MIL should have mentioned to you though I'll give you that.

7whiteclouds · 17/06/2023 22:40

Weal · 17/06/2023 22:28

I agree with @AnneLovesGilbert about the “special door” thing. It’s just makes no sense.

I wouldn’t worry about the special door thing…it was a light hearted comment I’d had with 2 of my children and it was fine for us all. Personally I didn’t want to scare them with the idea at the age of 3 that childbirth meant being cut open.

OP posts:
isthisit83 · 17/06/2023 22:38

YABVU I can't imagine this didn't have wider context. It sounds like your MIL handled it perfectly and in an age appropriate manner.

You may have been "waiting" for your DD to ask you, but she didn't... she asked your MIL The moment questions are asked or something comes up and it's in context is the best time to share the information. If you leave it or defer it, it makes it's a bigger deal than it actually is.

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 22:38

Be warned, once kids are at school, they hear all sorts from other kids and you simply cannot control it all.

RudsyFarmer · 17/06/2023 22:37

Do you think your MIL was making a judgement about it in the telling? Ie she had her child ‘the right way’ and you didn’t.

Dacadactyl · 17/06/2023 22:36

YABU. Your mother in law has done nothing wrong IMO.

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 22:36

Blimey i told my son almost exactly this when he was 5 (after a series of confusing questions), he could easily have told any of his mates at school. Once we had to share a very compact changing cubicle at swimming and he said loudly "which hole do babies come out of?"

I find it best to demystify this stuff and make it boring, inane knowledge. If you make it a forbidden topic they wil only ask you about it more.

parliamoglesga · 17/06/2023 22:36

booksandcats22 · 17/06/2023 22:32

Tbh I feel sorry for your nephew in that story how on earth is a child supposed to understand the extent to which other parents beyond his own want to teach their children. It would've been better surely for your husband to say something to your BIL and SIL then take it out on a child.

my BIL and SIL were not there and my DH asked him to stop. “Taking it out on him” is a massive overstatement and very typically mumsnet 😂 you can politely but firmly ask someone to stop and change the conversation.

I don’t want a 5 yr old telling my kids about periods.

Caffinefree · 17/06/2023 22:33

Might MIL have thought she already knew? I doubt it would occur to me that this was something not previously spoken with or in any way a sensitive topic.

hattyhathat · 17/06/2023 22:33

Would you have been so annoyed if your births hadn't been different?

Blessedbethefruitz · 17/06/2023 22:32

I told my ds (then 2 almost 3) how the Dr unzipped my tummy because he was up the wrong way - ahead of his baby sister's vbac. Partly to reduce questions about how babies get out of tummies, and partly to reduce any concerns about me being missing overnight! A couple of months later we got a play dr kit and he learned how to use a scalpel on the tummy, which alarmed dp, who was missing the context!

But it's absolutely your right to explain what and when.

booksandcats22 · 17/06/2023 22:32

parliamoglesga · 17/06/2023 22:20

People may disagree with you on here but I agree with you.

my BIL and SIL gave their son (my nephew) a graphic description of periods and what they are and their purpose when he was about 5. He started to tell my DSs (then aged 6 and 3) over dinner and my DH told him to stop in no uncertain terms. It wasn’t the time or the place and I don’t think a 6 and 3 year old need to know about periods.

Tbh I feel sorry for your nephew in that story how on earth is a child supposed to understand the extent to which other parents beyond his own want to teach their children. It would've been better surely for your husband to say something to your BIL and SIL then take it out on a child.

hattyhathat · 17/06/2023 22:32

If DD didn't ask then that's odd

Testina · 17/06/2023 22:32

“I was waiting for my DD to come to me to ask this question - she previously had at a younger age and I’d just light heartedly said to her “through a special door on my tummy” (partially true for a CS)”

Good on your MIL for not spouting that sort of nonsense 🤣
A special door? God help us. “Age appropriate” doesn’t mean lying, it means simplifying. Special doors are nonsense, and more complex than the simplified truth.

JudgeRudy · 17/06/2023 22:32

I don't think you're unreasonable to share your views with your MIL but I do think you're unreasonable to be so outraged. What does your OH think?
I doubt your MIL set out to have a talk with your child about this, I'd imagine it was part of a wider conversation that came up and your MIL gave further information. I don't really think it's anything to get worked up about.
What is it ghat irritating you? Do you feel this was an inappropriate conversation to gave with a young child or are you annoyed because you wanted this 'special conversation'?

Redglitter · 17/06/2023 22:31

I think your MIL explained it pretty well. But both my nieces have asked me about babies and both time i referred them back to their Mum. I felt it wasn't my place to have that conversation & I didn't know how my brother & SIL were planning on telling them

ThanksAntsThants23 · 17/06/2023 22:30

Maybe mil just assumed dd already knew babies came out of a vagina. I’d assume most 6 years olds know this. Has it never come up in conversation at home?

WeWereInParis · 17/06/2023 22:30

But DD didn’t ask MIL this question - MIL just told her this info (not sure the context of the conversation).

Are you sure she didn't ask? It wouldn't bother me, but it does seem a very random thing to just come out with.