Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
GottaGirlcrush · 17/06/2023 17:13

Gentle parenting is generally a crock of shit

They wont cope well in school.

OttoGraph · 17/06/2023 17:12

Distraction is great as long as ultimately it prevents repeated unwanted behaviour. Does saying no to a child prevent unwanted repeated behaviour?

azimuth299 · 17/06/2023 17:11

fyn · 17/06/2023 16:58

So say for example your child is taking another’s toys, you are just redirecting continually at the detriment of the child who is having their toys taken? Redirection always seems incredibly self centred and selfish.

All you ever hear at playgroups is ‘let’s use gentle hands’ as they push them off in a different direction only for it to repeat two minutes later. Why is seemingly unacceptable to say ‘no, we do not take toys that other children are playing with. We can play with this toy when they are finished’ is absolutely beyond me.

Well it would really depend on the age of the children involved, but as an example if my child took a toy out of another child's hands I would take the toy and hand it back and say something like "Oh, we don't snatch, Tilly is playing with the car right now. Do you want to play with the car? Shall we find another car?" This is all said calmly with pauses, not one question after the other and hopefully the child lets you know at this point what they want to happen.

If they were still insisting on that toy I would say something like "Shall we ask Tilly whether you can use it after her?" If Tilly says yes then I'd say something like "Okay great, what shall we play with while we're waiting?" or if Tilly isn't having it I would say "Oh it looks like Tilly won't be done for a while, let's find something else."

If my child started becoming too upset at any point and couldn't talk about it then I would lead or carry them to another room to have a break, name their feelings, offer comfort and generally be a calm presence until they were ready to go back.

Saying gentle hands and not doing anything else would be incredibly ineffective I imagine.

2bazookas · 17/06/2023 17:10

What fun they're going to have when he's a teenager.

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 17:09

KnitMePurlMe · 17/06/2023 17:03

I love the idea that you’re not supposed to say no to them but they can be as rude as they want to the parents 🤦‍♀️

Its a crock of shit OP.

Well you’ve just made that up because that isn’t anything to do with authoritarian (gentle) parenting.

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 17:07

fyn · 17/06/2023 16:58

So say for example your child is taking another’s toys, you are just redirecting continually at the detriment of the child who is having their toys taken? Redirection always seems incredibly self centred and selfish.

All you ever hear at playgroups is ‘let’s use gentle hands’ as they push them off in a different direction only for it to repeat two minutes later. Why is seemingly unacceptable to say ‘no, we do not take toys that other children are playing with. We can play with this toy when they are finished’ is absolutely beyond me.

I cannot possibly explain how I react in every single scenario in one post; that was a summary. Different behaviours receive different reactions. There isn’t a one size fits all answer unfortunately.

If she took another child I would say something like “This little girl is playing with this toy now, so let’s find something else fun to do. Oh do you see this doll? What colour hair does she have?”

I would never say “no”. You cannot teach when a child is disregulated, they simply do not have the ability to learn then as that part of the brain is shut off.

So we role play and practice turn taking, being kind, explanations of why we don’t snatch etc at other times when she is calm, happy and able to learn so these situations rarely occur as she already knows how to behave because I’ve shown her.

CremeEgg1983 · 17/06/2023 17:04

I cannot stand this kind of parenting OP. It proper gets under my skin. My kids have always been told no if it was needed and there were expectations on how they behaved.

If someone came to my house and the parent refused to tell their child to get off my furniture, then it would be me telling them off instead.

riotlady · 17/06/2023 17:04

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 16:13

Exactly. It’s actually called authoritative parenting (not to be confused with authoritarian parenting!).

My understanding is that they’re not quite the same? As something like 123 Magic would fall under the authoritative umbrella where you’re like “I’m going to count to 3 and if you don’t get out of the bath you won’t get any tv tonight”

Whereas that wouldn’t work with gentle parenting because it’s not a natural consequence and you haven’t explained, so you have to do the whole “I can see you don’t want to get out of the bath right now, that’s really hard but bath time is over etc etc” spiel

KnitMePurlMe · 17/06/2023 17:03

I love the idea that you’re not supposed to say no to them but they can be as rude as they want to the parents 🤦‍♀️

Its a crock of shit OP.

fyn · 17/06/2023 16:58

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 16:26

I never say no. I role model good behaviour (hello, goodbye, thank you, sorry, hugs when someone is hurt etc.), I distract and redirect poor behaviour (the only exceptions here are if someone is getting hurt eg. biting, hitting, pushing etc.)

All behaviour is communication; children aren’t naughty, and any attention on a behaviour will see an increase in that behaviour.

My daughter is very well behaved and I would never allow her to behave the way the child in the OP does.

So say for example your child is taking another’s toys, you are just redirecting continually at the detriment of the child who is having their toys taken? Redirection always seems incredibly self centred and selfish.

All you ever hear at playgroups is ‘let’s use gentle hands’ as they push them off in a different direction only for it to repeat two minutes later. Why is seemingly unacceptable to say ‘no, we do not take toys that other children are playing with. We can play with this toy when they are finished’ is absolutely beyond me.

OttoGraph · 17/06/2023 16:57

He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left

all the children of gentle parenting I’ve come across are physically rough 😂

I often wonder whether the parent would gently deal with me if I behaved the same? Granted I’m an adult but who’s to say I wasn’t a product of gentle parenting

azimuth299 · 17/06/2023 16:56

That's not gentle parenting, it sounds more like lazy parenting than anything. I think a lot of people see ineffective lazy parents and then rant about gentle parenting but it's actually a very specific authoritative parenting style which takes a lot of effort to do properly.

The sofa thing just sounds like a difference in home rules - my kids aren't allowed to bounce on the sofa because our sofa would break, but if we had a sofa that was particularly sturdy or just that was on its last legs so we were planning to replace it so it didn't matter then I might have a different rule.

Gentle parenting does encourage parents to actually think about whether a rule is necessary or whether it's just a rule that you're carrying over from your upbringing - then you focus on the rules that are genuinely important (e.g. hold my hand by the road to keep you safe, apply sunscreen or stay indoors so that you don't burn).

Deciding whether or not children are allowed to jump on the sofa in your own house is just a difference of opinion, two households could easily consider the question and come to two different conclusions.

A lot of the behaviour you describe also just sounds like a very excited three year old who has has friends over to stay. There are extra people in the home, it might be much noisier and much more stimulating than usual (especially if he's the only child in a calm household). He might not be that used to sharing his toys if he's an only child. If that was my child I probably would loosen the reins about things like sitting at the table and what food to eat in that situation, so what you're seeing right now really doesn't resemble their house day to day.

Absolem76 · 17/06/2023 16:53

It's not gentle parenting that's the issue. It's the parents.
Gentle parenting is not allowing your children to run riot.

RedHelenB · 17/06/2023 16:52

WimpoleHat · 17/06/2023 15:39

He’s going to find school an interesting experience……

He'll either flourish under some consistent discipline or else the mother will throw her hands up in horror at the harsh regime and decide to home school.

shivermetimbers77 · 17/06/2023 16:50

Gentle parenting needs a rebrand as he word gentle is misleading and people
misinterpret as meaning ‘never say no’ or ‘don’t set boundaries’. However if you read any of the core proponents of the method such as Sarah Ockwell-Smith or Aha Parenting it actually involves lots of authority and clear boundaries.

BoohooWoohoo · 17/06/2023 16:50

Gentle parenting works if you have a gentle child. That's because they rarely need disciplining and are more tolerant of listening to explanations.

My dc3 has been gentle parented because he's a very easy child to parent. He never went through Terrible Twos or Threenager and even as a teen I can't remember him even slamming a bedroom door in anger in the past year. I've been extremely lucky with his temperament- he's never run into a road or made a mad dash for it because he wasn't in a buggy. When you have a child like that, there's no need to tell them off very much. I use the word no as it's sometimes necessary and I think he'd laugh at the idea that it wasn't a good word to say.

Your friend's child is on the fast track to not making friends or being liked by teachers at school. His peers will be spending their 2s and 3s learning about living with their emotions and regulating them so that by the time that they go to school they will be at the same stage as their peers and make friends. My other 2 kids weren't as easy as their sibling but were able to get along with their peers and with the structure of school so had an easier time there. They were not gentle parented but have turned out to be relaxed and considerate adults who get along with friends and employers.

Lifescary · 17/06/2023 16:49

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 16:40

You can suspect whatever you like. Gentle parenting is thoroughly misunderstood and many people confuse it with permissive parenting.

Many “gentle parents” aren’t actually gentle parenting but permissive parenting.

And again, you can be as sceptical as you like. All behaviour is communication, they’re not being naughty, they’re trying to tell you something. You’re just not listening.

I only want to suspect what is true. It would be ridiculous to suspect things that were false, so I don't understand your first comment. Are you agreeing or disagreeing with me.

I am still sceptical although I am trying to understand. I can see that all behaviour is communication but what if they are trying to tell me is that they don't give a tinker's cuss about anyone else they are just going to do what they want?

SleepydogLies · 17/06/2023 16:48

You want to try teaching these kids.

If we don't have enough challenges as teachers, this whole new 'gentle parenting' craze has taken hold and behaviour in schools is the worst it's EVER been.

'No' is a fact of life. 'No' builds resilience.

Teach your kids NO, please. Before there's no one left to teach them!

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 16:40

Lifescary · 17/06/2023 16:35

I suspect gentle parenting works well for children who behave well.

Where i am sceptical is your belief that children aren't naughty. My first wasn't but boy oh boy, well in fact girl oh girl, my second was. Happily she is now a wonderful woman and my parenting role, for better or worse, is over.

You can suspect whatever you like. Gentle parenting is thoroughly misunderstood and many people confuse it with permissive parenting.

Many “gentle parents” aren’t actually gentle parenting but permissive parenting.

And again, you can be as sceptical as you like. All behaviour is communication, they’re not being naughty, they’re trying to tell you something. You’re just not listening.

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 16:39

The thing is some children are quite naturally calm, placid, not risk takers, compliant and keen to please adults. Oddly enough gentle parenting works pretty well on these children, because they don't really display challenging behaviour! Smug advocates of gentle parenting point to these children as evidence that it "works".

In reality lots of children ignore "explanations" and disregard boundaries and consequences unless they are basically unpleasant ones. "Gentle parenting" is not terribly effective on lots of children.

Gentle parenting also seems to disregard thar children can have wants and desires that are NOT needs, and that not all the emotions they experience need to be validated. Lots of young kids emotions are over-reactions and validating them doesn't teach them about proportional responses.

Summerishereagain · 17/06/2023 16:39

Boundaries and saying no is a core part of gentle parenting. OP your friend is a passive/lazy parent.

Itsbeennice · 17/06/2023 16:36

I have a lovely friend who I now don't invite around because her kids use my house as a playground and it boils my piss that they are not told not to.
My lovely chair was being used as a slide the last time, and it was me who had to ask her child not to.
Can you guess what the child was doing 5 minutes later?
That's the result of permissive parenting, patient explanations of consequence, trying to engage the child in empathic understanding of how other people feel... just fucking look them in the eye, say, "No", give a plausible consequence, and then see that consequence through (is what I wanted to tell my friend).

Lifescary · 17/06/2023 16:35

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 16:26

I never say no. I role model good behaviour (hello, goodbye, thank you, sorry, hugs when someone is hurt etc.), I distract and redirect poor behaviour (the only exceptions here are if someone is getting hurt eg. biting, hitting, pushing etc.)

All behaviour is communication; children aren’t naughty, and any attention on a behaviour will see an increase in that behaviour.

My daughter is very well behaved and I would never allow her to behave the way the child in the OP does.

I suspect gentle parenting works well for children who behave well.

Where i am sceptical is your belief that children aren't naughty. My first wasn't but boy oh boy, well in fact girl oh girl, my second was. Happily she is now a wonderful woman and my parenting role, for better or worse, is over.

Zebedee55 · 17/06/2023 16:32

So called gentle parenting can end up with feral kids.

A happy medium is best.

Callipsi · 17/06/2023 16:31

I have friends who have done the same. Their (3!) children are little shits and I avoid seeing us all together at great lengths, as I spend the entire time trying to deal with the fall out whilst she sits there with a serene smile on her face acting like her children aren’t involved in any of it at all.

It’s clear when her children are a bit older they’re going to be full on bitchy bullies and have zero respect for their parents.