Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
Lifescary · 17/06/2023 18:46

MumUndone · 17/06/2023 18:35

You know what, a couple of years ago I would have agreed with you but we are basically forced to gentle parent my DS4 as he is demand avoidant (no diagnosis as yet but obvious to us and to staff at preschool that there is some neurodiversity there) and telling him off or not to do something simply doesn't work; we have to persuade, cajole, bribe, appeal to his better nature, or else risking a complete meltdown. Other people probably think we're complete pushovers and that DS4 is a complete spoilt brat. But they don't experience the meltdowns we do.

Thank you. You have reminded me of the important need to keep an open mind. Good luck with DS4.

Hollyppp · 17/06/2023 18:45

flightless55 · 17/06/2023 15:46

That's not gentle parenting that's passive parenting ... ie. Not parenting!

This!

You absolutely have boundaries in gentle parenting and it’s not a rule you can never say no?!

MumUndone · 17/06/2023 18:35

You know what, a couple of years ago I would have agreed with you but we are basically forced to gentle parent my DS4 as he is demand avoidant (no diagnosis as yet but obvious to us and to staff at preschool that there is some neurodiversity there) and telling him off or not to do something simply doesn't work; we have to persuade, cajole, bribe, appeal to his better nature, or else risking a complete meltdown. Other people probably think we're complete pushovers and that DS4 is a complete spoilt brat. But they don't experience the meltdowns we do.

KarmaStar · 17/06/2023 18:33

Yanbu.gentle parenting is no boundaries parenting so the children have no idea what they are supposed to do.
They should get off their backsides and give them a solid upbringing with guidance and consequences.
And teach them some manners.

MrsCarson · 17/06/2023 18:25

That's not gentle parenting, that's not parenting at all.

Thesearmsofmine · 17/06/2023 18:22

They are permissive not gentle. It seems that people have jumped onto the ‘gentle’ bandwagon without really understanding what it means. Many seem to think the child should never be upset, hear the word no or have boundaries set which means the kids do whatever they like without recourse.

I fit the gentle parent stereotype but don’t like to be associated with it really because of these type of parents who claim to be gentle when they are just a bit lazy.

johnd2 · 17/06/2023 18:00

Some great posts on this thread already, thanks to those posters who have taken the time to explain the what and the why calmly.
I think one of the key things for me is that the consequences should be something that I could see him doing of his own initiative in the same situation.

So he feels overwhelmed, ok find somewhere quiet.
He hits someone, ok take a deep breath and say sorry are you ok and repairs things
He spills something, ok get a cloth and clean it up
Etc etc.
I don't want his inner voice shouting no/what did you do that for/you're so clumsy/etc at him when he makes a mistake as that's not constructive.

Also it helps me to think about whether things really matter.

Boundaries are very important to model on behalf of your child. My son hates people swooping in to wipe his nose, to pick him up without warning, to be accosted for a hug by relatives, refuses to say sorry when he's not feeling that way. But I consider that is his boundaries and his authentic self. And parenting in this way has made me respect him more. And in turn he respects me more.

VivaVivaa · 17/06/2023 18:00

I agree that you have to adapt the parenting style to the child. I think I’m relatively ‘gentle’ in my overall approach, but 3 yo DS is a very high energy child who doesn’t naturally want to please or obey instructions. If you have one of these placid types maybe gentle redirection always works. DS hears the word ‘no’ a lot, often for his own safety or the safety or comfort of others, which I won’t compromise on.

catmothertes1 · 17/06/2023 17:59

WimpoleHat · 17/06/2023 15:39

He’s going to find school an interesting experience……

I used to teach kids like this,in a secondary school! It was not fun.

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 17:48

2bazookas · 17/06/2023 17:16

I would never say “no”. You cannot teach when a child is disregulated, they simply do not have the ability to learn then as that part of the brain is shut off

Do please explain what neurological or physical process shuts off part of the brain when it hears the word No.

That’s not what I said. I said when they are emotionally disregulated you cannot teach anything because that part of the brain is shut off.

Nothing to do with the word “no” Confused

BertieBotts · 17/06/2023 17:46

I do think sometimes people who start off with an attachment parenting type style for babies can struggle to transition from this very baby-led style to adults directing and making what can feel a bit like "arbitrary" boundaries. I know that I probably did and I recognise it in others sometimes.

Like for example if you've always just breastfed a baby on demand then you can get into a pattern where you're still offering little bits of food constantly rather than having clear boundaries around mealtimes which is basically for the parents' convenience. I think sometimes it can be a bit unclear that it's "OK" to establish things which are primarily for parental convenience, until you get to the point where you're totally overwhelmed and disregulated yourself as the adult, and then it's a problem, because being regulated enough yourself to be able to co-regulate the child is essential. In reality, it's important to protect your own sanity and part of this is putting into place rules which are designed to make your life easier. I think a lot of people do this naturally without necessarily having to think about it, and if you do this and also have a child who is fairly easily regulated anyway, then the combination works together. But if you're not particularly on top of this/don't notice until it's too late AND have a child who needs a bit more help with co-regulation, then that can be a difficult combination.

contrary13 · 17/06/2023 17:46

SleepydogLies · 17/06/2023 16:48

You want to try teaching these kids.

If we don't have enough challenges as teachers, this whole new 'gentle parenting' craze has taken hold and behaviour in schools is the worst it's EVER been.

'No' is a fact of life. 'No' builds resilience.

Teach your kids NO, please. Before there's no one left to teach them!

^^ This!

When my 18 year old was 6, he had a playdate with one of his friends from school. Now, the boys have known one another since they were 2 and at nursery together, so I knew that the friend could be a little... wild, shall we say? A little naughty, a bit cheeky, but generally a really sweet little boy. I knew the parents, actually liked the parents, but we were friendly because our sons were friends. So, I collect the two boys from school, we walk home and they're both telling me about their days, who had crisps in their lunchbox that day, who got to push the lunch trolley from the classroom to the canteen, who'd played what games with them during break... typical 6 year old chattering. We get in - and this was the first time this boy had been to our home - and I set them up at the table with the after school snacks that my son and his sister always had pre-supper: crackers, some cheese, sliced apple pieces and a beaker of milk or water, and the TV on in the background as a treat. My oldest is 8 years older, so I thought I had playdates under control...

Oh, how mistaken I was! The friend insisted that they bounce on the sofa, whilst eating their snacks. I was in the kitchen trying to deal with my then senior school age child's latest problem and pondering what to feed them with for supper, because I'd been given a long list of things that the friend would/wouldn't eat. The giggling alerted me to sticking my head round the door to check on the boys - as they were bouncing on the sofa.

HUGE "no-no" as far as my house rules were concerned. The sofa was brand spanking new, we had a trampoline outside that they were told they could go on when they were finished with their snacks, and they still had shoes on. My son clocked the dog slinking into his crate, turned his head and saw me silently eying the scene before me... and he stops mid-bounce. Off the sofa like a little rocket. The friend keeps bouncing. So I go over, and I'm trying to be kind thinking that he doesn't live here, how could he know the house rules, he's too little to understand that bouncing with food in your mouth's a massive choking hazard, not my son, be kind 13, be kind...! I explain to him that in our house, we don't jump on the sofa, not even with our shoes off, not even because it looks bouncy... if he's done with his snack, they can go outside and bounce on the trampoline... and i go to lift him off the sofa. For him to spit the chewed up cheese in his mouth into my face and tell me to fuck off...

Well, it's a good job his shoes were on, I can tell you, because he was being marched to his house after that, playdate cut short, me mentally banning him from darkening my doorstep ever again and how to convince my own son (who really liked this boy) from being friends with him... His mother answered the door, all surprised - yet I suspect not - to see us on the doorstep. So I told her why her son was being returned within 30 minutes of school kicking out for the day... to have her go ":tinkly laugh, oh, we don't ever tell (friend) that he's not allowed to do or say things - it damages his self-esteem and it's really unkind to him!"

The boy never set foot in my house again, although they tried to instigate more playdates - "oh, I have to take (older child) to the dentist, and I've no one to look after (friend)..." got a resounding "not my problem!" response (but then, they're a 2 parent household, and mine is a 1 parent household, so if one of my tribe had an appointment somewhere, we all trogged along to the waiting rooms!). Didn't stop my son from being friends with him, but I certainly didn't encourage it either, and... eventually the problem resolved itself, because in Yr 8, friend was expelled from their senior school because his mother had allowed him to take her craft knife into school one day!!! Of course, it wasn't their fault - it was the school's fault for being so strict for a one time offence (although I have my suspicions that there were a lot of minor infractions building up to this major one), or it was the fault of the other boys in the friendship group for making him feel so insecure and vulnerable...! The boy ended up in our local school for kids that are excluded for all sorts of reasons for a few months as his parents desperately tried to find another school to take him. The only one that was willing to give it a go was the one his parents had sneered at for being "too working class for (them)!".

I'm still sort-of-friendly with his mother, who still can't see that her inability to tell her child "no" and to teach him to have basic respect for other people, their belongings, their right not to have a craft knife brandished about them was precisely what caused her son to end up a lonely, virtually friendless (the school he was seemingly too good for - which is a decent school, actually; I have friends who went there, and a godson who was there when this boy was, and they've all turned out decent members of society - is 10 miles away, so he couldn't have friends home, and he never seemed to go to friends houses after school), unhappy individual. He sits in the front room his parents "gave" to their sons (so that they didn't have to spend time with them, I suspect) and online games all day, every day. My son gets the odd text from him, and has gamed with him in the past, but... even he says the lad's too entitled for his taste. And it's actually really sad, because he was a nice little boy - until his permissive/gentle/absentee parents ruined him by not giving him the basics of how to behave in the wider community/society. They allowed him to truly think that he's never to blame, never at fault, for anything... it's always someone else's fault. Sad

Achwheesht · 17/06/2023 17:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

literalviolence · 17/06/2023 17:41

Pooterlie · 17/06/2023 16:25

@tothelefttotheleft the idea is that you try and work with the child to figure out what's wrong rather than policing and punishing.

So for eg if my DD (who is now 6) is getting stressed and cross we talk about why and try and find the reasons and the solutions.

Or if we disagree about something we try and find a compromise (assuming it's something we can compromise about)

When she was tiny if she was doing something that upset someone else I would say. Oh dear, I can't let you do that and would take her off or distract her. I would empathise with the emotion not accept the action.

For us it worked like a dream and I can only recall her having about 3 meltdowns (all exhaustion related).

Honestly that sounds like normal good parenting to me. I don't consider myself to have gentle parented but what do gentle parents think others are doing?

Achwheesht · 17/06/2023 17:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Achwheesht · 17/06/2023 17:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

TizerorFizz · 17/06/2023 17:37

@CremeEgg1983 I agree. Far too complicated for the very young. My Dc learned all of those things but we kept it simple. I didn’t give numerous food options too. No choices.

@azimuth299 My DC did all of those things! It really is not producing superior children with all this explaining and negotiating. I did obviously negotiate and give options when they were older but at 3/4 I didn’t.m very often. They did like choosing dresses though! Being more direct doesn’t stop Dc being able to do anything! DD1 is a barrister and spends her life advocating for others! Clear expectations, and carrying out what you say, mostly stops them being unbearable though.

BertieBotts · 17/06/2023 17:36

The manic behaviour is dysregulation (overstimulation) IME, DS1 did it a lot especially when we were around other people. It was a nightmare to deal with TBH and trying to be strict just made it even worse. DS2 is the same. I didn't really understand what caused it when DS1 was little. He is 14 now and chilled as anything and not unpleasant at all, so I really don't think it was bad parenting.

Compromising, sitting down and talking does work, a raised voice doesn't add anything to this interaction, and if they were taking toys away then that is consequences. Yes perhaps they were a bit lax about general rules about bouncing, sitting in one place etc but perhaps they have chosen to choose their battles and these seem like minor issues compared to whatever they are working on at the moment.

(I don't like using the term "gentle parenting" any more because there are hundreds of possible definitions for, it, it makes more sense to talk about the actual parenting practices rather than an unhelpful label).

Improbablecat · 17/06/2023 17:31

That's permissive aka shit parenting, not gentle parenting.

I'd say we gentle parent. There are lots of boundaries to do with safety etc. We do probably have fewer arbitrary rules at home (e.g. I have no issues with my sofas being bounced on) but my child is perfectly able to tell where she has to change her behaviour. And she gets told no, with an explanation. The key thing for me is having consequences that actually make sense to a 4yr old brain. It sounds like this kid of your friends has no consequences to his behaviour at all!

CremeEgg1983 · 17/06/2023 17:27

@azimuth299 My personal feeling is that it is far too much for a child to process all that - such as the options to ask for the toy etc. I feel the lesson needs to be simple, as in if someone else has the toy, you wait until they have finished with it. I don't think they really need to know more than that when very young.

Weedoormatnomore · 17/06/2023 17:27

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

This made me laugh sorry so the patents don't use the word no and don't raise their voices but their 4yr old son shouts no at them 🤣

azimuth299 · 17/06/2023 17:24

TizerorFizz · 17/06/2023 17:17

@ApplesInTheSunshine You must spend hours doing this! My DC never had to listen to all that. I had clear expectations. Fairly easy to understand. By and large Dc understood.

Parenting these days seems to be confused with being a psychiatrist. You don’t need to do all that explaining! Most dc I see with all this going on either don’t understand or ignore. Mostly both. It’s perfectly ok to say, no. Stop doing that. That’s not ok. And mean it!

It's harder and more time consuming in the moment but in the long run it's great because you are literally teaching the children what to do in these situations, so they learn how to navigate for themselves. So they will learn from you that if they want a toy they shouldn't snatch (which is where the lesson ends in classic parenting), but also that they can ask the person with the toy for the toy, they can negotiate for a turn with the toy, they can ask to play together with the child and toy, they can find a similar toy etc. You model what to do in those situations.

Plus, they learn that if they don't get what they want then it's understandable to feel frustrated and disappointed, and they might work through those feelings by seeking comfort or going somewhere quiet. You're teaching them good social behaviour.

azimuth299 · 17/06/2023 17:18

2bazookas · 17/06/2023 17:16

I would never say “no”. You cannot teach when a child is disregulated, they simply do not have the ability to learn then as that part of the brain is shut off

Do please explain what neurological or physical process shuts off part of the brain when it hears the word No.

She's not saying that the brain switches off when it hears no, if you actually read what she says, she's saying that very disregulated (e.g. experiencing very high emotions) children are unable to learn and process information.

TizerorFizz · 17/06/2023 17:17

@ApplesInTheSunshine You must spend hours doing this! My DC never had to listen to all that. I had clear expectations. Fairly easy to understand. By and large Dc understood.

Parenting these days seems to be confused with being a psychiatrist. You don’t need to do all that explaining! Most dc I see with all this going on either don’t understand or ignore. Mostly both. It’s perfectly ok to say, no. Stop doing that. That’s not ok. And mean it!

2bazookas · 17/06/2023 17:16

I would never say “no”. You cannot teach when a child is disregulated, they simply do not have the ability to learn then as that part of the brain is shut off

Do please explain what neurological or physical process shuts off part of the brain when it hears the word No.

Swipe left for the next trending thread