Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 17/06/2023 23:44

@SnackSizeRaisin COVID has been an issue for young children. No doubt about that.

As DD1 is 30 I can assure you behaviour policies were far more sophisticated than you suggest! As I worked in education before she was born I can tell you behaviour policies have not featured humiliation for quite a while. Sanctions were used but mostly being sent to the head! Not much different now. Plus a load of warnings. Behaviour policies concentrate firmly on promoting good behaviour. I think that’s right for young children. Schools will work with parents but parents who will not take any responsibility are a pain. Most are not like of course.

literalviolence · 17/06/2023 22:55

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 19:25

Gentle parenting is authoritative parenting.

You’re confusing authoritative and authoritarian. They’re two very different parenting styles.

Yes sorry. Authorities parenting is what I meant.

PracticallyFlooredZero · 17/06/2023 22:28

I genuinely think my niece has never heard the word no. She scratched my son’s face, smacked him in the head then pushed him over because he touched one of her toys (that she wasn’t even playing with at the time!) and her parents took her aside and talked about how her feelings must have been hurt when he touched her toy and how they understood how she had big feelings but that is wasn’t very kind to hurt him. I just stood there open mouthed. I consider myself a pretty gentle parent as they go but if any of my children behaved like that they would be immediately taken home and properly told off. Apparently she has no friends at nursery and they can’t understand why!!

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/06/2023 22:22

TizerorFizz · 17/06/2023 19:37

So if all these wonderfully detailed parenting styles that work so well, why are schools reporting more and more Dc unable to start school ready for school? Something is wrong. My DDs were ready for school. They never had snatched things. Didn’t have melt downs at 4. Could listen and follow instructions. Could make friends and play happily. I never gave any of this stuff a moment’s thought! Maybe others did but from what I could see, hardly any DC were poorly parented. Most parents just got on with parenting and it was common sense.

Probably due to COVID if in recent years. The other factor is that schools own discipline is much less strict. 50 years ago teachers could give you a physical punishment if you misbehaved. 30-40 years ago that wasn't really done any more at primary level at least, but there was still plenty of standing facing the wall if you misbehaved, shouting, fear based punishment. Not great for learning or enjoying school but a quick fix for naughty children.

BertieBotts · 17/06/2023 21:55

Well actually, one of the ideas behind not saying no constantly is so that when you do use it for something dangerous and urgent, it really stands out. A lot of children are told no so often that they tune it out.

Like everything parenting is about balance really.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/06/2023 20:42

azimuth299 · 17/06/2023 17:24

It's harder and more time consuming in the moment but in the long run it's great because you are literally teaching the children what to do in these situations, so they learn how to navigate for themselves. So they will learn from you that if they want a toy they shouldn't snatch (which is where the lesson ends in classic parenting), but also that they can ask the person with the toy for the toy, they can negotiate for a turn with the toy, they can ask to play together with the child and toy, they can find a similar toy etc. You model what to do in those situations.

Plus, they learn that if they don't get what they want then it's understandable to feel frustrated and disappointed, and they might work through those feelings by seeking comfort or going somewhere quiet. You're teaching them good social behaviour.

I have started doing this with my 2 and 3 year olds and although it requires a bit more active intervention to step in quickly if any toy snatching starts, they have really quickly picked up that they need to ask for a turn, or play together, or offer a swap. It does not happen every time and it's usually the older one who finds it more difficult. The acknowledging feelings and "helping" her to hand the toy back actually calms her much more quickly. It really does work better than either shouting at her or putting her in time out or telling her off which were all things that we tried previously. The key is that you gently physically enforce whatever the boundary is - you don't waffle on while letting them do what they want

As opposed to things like shouting, threats, punishment, manipulation, shaming, you enforce your boundary in a respectful way.

CeliaNorth · 17/06/2023 20:29

What is so wrong with telling a child no? What do you do if they are about to touch the hot oven door, just let them burn their hands ?

Sometimes a firm No! or Stop! or Come here now! is necessary, for the child's own safety. They need to hear it, and learn to take notice of it, because one day it might be really, really important that they do as they are told at once, without explanation or negotiation.

Anotherblueday · 17/06/2023 20:28

Hermione101 · 17/06/2023 20:01

I have a very energetic, not very gentle, and strong willed 6 year old, who is often seeking to push boundaries. He’s not always calm and obedient. Gentle parenting would never work for us, he needs very clear boundaries.

He gets told “no” all the time. He has clear consequences and we follow through. We talk about everything too, but in the moment he gets very clear messages, otherwise he would walk all over us.

Gentle parenting is all about clear boundaries

Longdarkcloud · 17/06/2023 20:24

A very enlightening thread. Recently I had a discussion re parenting, attachment etc with a younger family member who has a senior position in child SS. We have always basically agreed on the need for boundaries but I was surprised when she stated these were not very important and she was basically describing gentle parenting as described here , though she didn’t name it as such. Talked about disregulation and brain development and seemed to regard me as a complete dinosaur, though we’ve known about infant brain development etc for about 30 years.
Im rather depressed at the situation because I am only too well aware from my work experience how the lack of boundaries damages outcomes for children and the breakdown in family relationships.

Hermione101 · 17/06/2023 20:01

I have a very energetic, not very gentle, and strong willed 6 year old, who is often seeking to push boundaries. He’s not always calm and obedient. Gentle parenting would never work for us, he needs very clear boundaries.

He gets told “no” all the time. He has clear consequences and we follow through. We talk about everything too, but in the moment he gets very clear messages, otherwise he would walk all over us.

nobodysdaughternow · 17/06/2023 19:55

I have a family member who practised gentle parenting. I'm not sure I knew what it was at the time, but I did know her kids never sat down to eat, made a massive fuss about what they ate and were dreadful for my kids to play with.

It was a pain in the arse when they were younger but now the eldest is a teenager and utterly wild. She won't go to school, doesn't eat family meals and sets her own bedtimes.

I have 3 kids with Sen so boundaries are absolutely crucial, otherwise they loose the plot (as do I). This family member believes that her dc needs time out of school to 'therapeutically heal' so she is home alone not learning anything.

It's really sad but thankfully not my problem.

helpfulperson · 17/06/2023 19:52

There is so much bollocks talked about gentle parenting. It doesn't mean not not saying no and not having boundaries. That's just not parenting at all. Gentle parenting is very different.

Theunamedcat · 17/06/2023 19:50

I had someone who claimed to be a gentle parent she literally would not remove her child's dummy from him until he decided he wanted to give it up, fine, except it was effecting his speech BADLY so I told him he could only come into my house if he gave it to me at the door (he was almost five at this point) he handed it over fine then demanded it back I said no you can have it back outside when we go out cue a tantrum he was telling me to "uck off" (couldn't form and "f" because he usually had his dummy in and talked around it) "uck off itch" was another gem told his mum to get it back bust her up etc etc mum was sat there wringing her hands powerless if she had said give it back to him I would have but it was interesting to see she literally wouldn't challenge ANYONE

Anyway we left for group I gave it back (as agreed) got to group he proudly told the staff there to "uck off" too she wanted a referral to speech and language but they refused saying remove the dummy he will talk properly (she said she didn't want her staff subject to abuse his mouth was vile) eventually a social worker got involved and forced her to potty train him and remove the dummy

Fucking ridiculous, but he can talk now to tell people to FUCK off

YoucancallmeKAREN · 17/06/2023 19:44

What is so wrong with telling a child no? What do you do if they are about to touch the hot oven door, just let them burn their hands ? These children turn into the spoiled bullies that nobody wants their children near.

Abouttimemum · 17/06/2023 19:44

I would probably say we gentle parent to an extent (I don’t feel the need to shout tbh and only say no to important things otherwise it becomes background noise) but our 4 year old behaves nothing like you describe! It doesn’t mean he doesn’t get disciplined so I think in your friend’s son’s case it’s probably a lack of boundaries and consequences rather than being shouty etc.

TizerorFizz · 17/06/2023 19:37

So if all these wonderfully detailed parenting styles that work so well, why are schools reporting more and more Dc unable to start school ready for school? Something is wrong. My DDs were ready for school. They never had snatched things. Didn’t have melt downs at 4. Could listen and follow instructions. Could make friends and play happily. I never gave any of this stuff a moment’s thought! Maybe others did but from what I could see, hardly any DC were poorly parented. Most parents just got on with parenting and it was common sense.

Pooterlie · 17/06/2023 19:28

@literalviolence I came on the thread because for me parenting gently has been brilliant. But I agree it doesn't need a label.

@tothelefttotheleft yes thats the idea. Phillipa Perry who is a psychotherapist says that in the main people end up in therapy because as children they were firmly told that their negative feelings were wrong. Or even shamed or punished for being angry / upset. As adults without that ability to validate their feelings they often feel depressed and stressed. So the idea is if you affirm your child and don't shame them for being angry, whining, or their inconvenient behaviour they do learn to understand how they feel, label what is happening and why and learn to self regulate.

I guess we will find out if this approach works in about 30 years Grin

SongThrushFeather · 17/06/2023 19:26

It’s not just the child who will find school difficult unfortunately. It’s also the teacher, teaching assistant and the other children in the class with him (I am a TA).
It seems to be very common parenting style now though. So many children coming to school saying they can do what they want, other their children must play their game and only they can set the rules. It honestly seems don’t teach their children any compassion or consideration for others. Any unkindness to others is viewed by the parents as their child just being a strong powerful character whereas in reality their child is unkind and self centred.

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 19:25

literalviolence · 17/06/2023 19:07

Sure. But if you're not formally gentle parenting, that doesn't mean you're authoritative parenting. I think I'm rallying against all the new names and the idea that parents have to put themselves in a parenting style box.

Gentle parenting is authoritative parenting.

You’re confusing authoritative and authoritarian. They’re two very different parenting styles.

ApplesInTheSunshine · 17/06/2023 19:23

KarmaStar · 17/06/2023 18:33

Yanbu.gentle parenting is no boundaries parenting so the children have no idea what they are supposed to do.
They should get off their backsides and give them a solid upbringing with guidance and consequences.
And teach them some manners.

You have absolutely no idea what gentle (authoritative) parenting is. I wouldn’t be so proud of your ignorance if I were you.

Rainsdropskeepfalling · 17/06/2023 19:18

Different approaches for different kids I guess. I happily admit though that when the child runs out in front of a car, the discussion about "whether running out was a sensible things to do and maybe they should have waited for the rest of us to catch up as we had asked.." seems like it's missing the boat. Maybe the first time it works but when the kid is 9 I think they've had this chat before. But I recognise I'm old fashioned this way.

I do feel for the teachers. Possibly the teachers in the private school where said child will be going because they are too head strong to go to a state school.

Isolationendurance · 17/06/2023 19:11

Permissive parenting is not a particularly gentle experience for anyone.

tothelefttotheleft · 17/06/2023 19:08

@Pooterlie

As an adult I often don't know why I'm stressed and cross so not sure if a child can articulate their feelings.

On the other hand maybe if I'd been patented like this I would be better at working out what was going on in my head.

literalviolence · 17/06/2023 19:07

Pooterlie · 17/06/2023 19:03

Hi @literalviolence I live on a housing development and all the kids play together. I see a lot of parenting at close range.

What I see is authoritarian parents - so - lots of demands for compliance and punishments meted out for things like not listening, being rude, not obeying instructions. I've seen shouting, counting down from 3, very firm instructions etc etc.

These are loving parents so I'm not in any way criticising but it's not gentle parenting.

Sure. But if you're not formally gentle parenting, that doesn't mean you're authoritative parenting. I think I'm rallying against all the new names and the idea that parents have to put themselves in a parenting style box.

Pooterlie · 17/06/2023 19:03

Hi @literalviolence I live on a housing development and all the kids play together. I see a lot of parenting at close range.

What I see is authoritarian parents - so - lots of demands for compliance and punishments meted out for things like not listening, being rude, not obeying instructions. I've seen shouting, counting down from 3, very firm instructions etc etc.

These are loving parents so I'm not in any way criticising but it's not gentle parenting.