Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
Titsywoo · 18/06/2023 10:47

I was a bit of a shouty parent (not mean just very firm) - my kids are grown and gave me no shit through their teen years. They wouldn't dare be rude to me Grin Several of my friends complain about how their kids shout at them and call them names. Not a chance in hell would I tolerate that. They still just say 'please don't talk to me like that it isn't kind'. Being meek and feeble like that doesn't work with kids who need rules and boundaries as they figure themselves out.

Guiltridden12345 · 18/06/2023 10:46

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 10:35

It's instead of saying "don't cry" or "it's ok, everything's fine! You're just not getting the iPad" which teaches kids to bottle up their feelings and people please. So what it achieves is letting my kid know he can feel whatever emotions he feels and also role models that it's ok to hold his own boundaries and not people please. It's totally fine if you don't think this is enough but I think it is for our family. My main point of my post is to say I think you can gentle parent and still not be completely passive and it's not the same as letting your kid run riot.

I think the issue is that your kind of parenting doesn’t encourage either resilience in the face of real life actions - taking turns, iPad going off, time to put shoes on even though existentially you don’t as a two year old feel you should have to wear shoes - creates future engrained problems for peers, carers, teachers and the wider world that will come into contact with your kid. Imagine a teacher having 30 x 4 year olds who needed a long discussion and a hand-hold when told it’s tidy up time - it’s unworkable, even if you have the time to make it ‘work’ for you in your own home.

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 10:35

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 10:23

What is the 'it's ok to be sad' really adding if it's said as a general mantra, though? If you're just saying it in a token way then it's quick but meaningless. If you're genuinely going to 'sit with them through their feelings' every time you need to turn off the iPad then it is quite time-consuming. I also think it gives them a distorted idea of how reasonable their feelings are. I think that showing and modelling what is and isn't a big deal, rather than 'validating' every disappointment, is an important part of parenting.

I forgot one of the main reasons that people seem to go a bit less 'gentle' with kid no 2 - which is that it seems to concentrate the mind a bit when the child that's being snatched off or who is at the sharp end of 'ungentle hands' is also yours. It turns out that a lot of people find that behaviour that they felt it was reasonable for their child's peers to absorb in the name of long-term emotional development suddenly find that when it's their baby it's not so reasonable.

It's instead of saying "don't cry" or "it's ok, everything's fine! You're just not getting the iPad" which teaches kids to bottle up their feelings and people please. So what it achieves is letting my kid know he can feel whatever emotions he feels and also role models that it's ok to hold his own boundaries and not people please. It's totally fine if you don't think this is enough but I think it is for our family. My main point of my post is to say I think you can gentle parent and still not be completely passive and it's not the same as letting your kid run riot.

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 10:23

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 10:12

I think people are right that me and my DH have been able to gentle parent, hold boundaries and talk about feelings with our kid because we only have one so we have enough time and attention for that. No idea what our parenting style will be like when our next child is born but I know that we intend to do the same since it worked so well with our first and it's given us such a lovely and calm family dynamic.

My friend has 3 kids and does the same style as us (gentle parenting which includes strict boundaries and routine) and it seems to have worked for her. The chats about feelings aren't especially long they're basically "it's ok to be sad that you aren't getting more iPad but I told you that was the last episode so the iPad is going away" I don't really see how it's much longer than telling your kid off that you already told them the iPad was going away but like I said I only have one kid at the min so who knows what I'll be like with two.

What is the 'it's ok to be sad' really adding if it's said as a general mantra, though? If you're just saying it in a token way then it's quick but meaningless. If you're genuinely going to 'sit with them through their feelings' every time you need to turn off the iPad then it is quite time-consuming. I also think it gives them a distorted idea of how reasonable their feelings are. I think that showing and modelling what is and isn't a big deal, rather than 'validating' every disappointment, is an important part of parenting.

I forgot one of the main reasons that people seem to go a bit less 'gentle' with kid no 2 - which is that it seems to concentrate the mind a bit when the child that's being snatched off or who is at the sharp end of 'ungentle hands' is also yours. It turns out that a lot of people find that behaviour that they felt it was reasonable for their child's peers to absorb in the name of long-term emotional development suddenly find that when it's their baby it's not so reasonable.

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 10:14

I guess maybe there are other forms of gentle parenting which include discussion and compromise with kids which we definitely don't do... We hold firm boundaries.

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 10:12

I think people are right that me and my DH have been able to gentle parent, hold boundaries and talk about feelings with our kid because we only have one so we have enough time and attention for that. No idea what our parenting style will be like when our next child is born but I know that we intend to do the same since it worked so well with our first and it's given us such a lovely and calm family dynamic.

My friend has 3 kids and does the same style as us (gentle parenting which includes strict boundaries and routine) and it seems to have worked for her. The chats about feelings aren't especially long they're basically "it's ok to be sad that you aren't getting more iPad but I told you that was the last episode so the iPad is going away" I don't really see how it's much longer than telling your kid off that you already told them the iPad was going away but like I said I only have one kid at the min so who knows what I'll be like with two.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/06/2023 09:26

There are some parts of gentle parenting I do follow but I can't get behind all the debating and discussion with toddlers. I agree, they can barely manage two stage instructions and yet your supposed to have these long monologues with them?

Sometimes you do just need to put your coat and shoes on and go, there isn't time to have a debate about it.

Guiltridden12345 · 18/06/2023 09:25

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/06/2023 20:42

I have started doing this with my 2 and 3 year olds and although it requires a bit more active intervention to step in quickly if any toy snatching starts, they have really quickly picked up that they need to ask for a turn, or play together, or offer a swap. It does not happen every time and it's usually the older one who finds it more difficult. The acknowledging feelings and "helping" her to hand the toy back actually calms her much more quickly. It really does work better than either shouting at her or putting her in time out or telling her off which were all things that we tried previously. The key is that you gently physically enforce whatever the boundary is - you don't waffle on while letting them do what they want

As opposed to things like shouting, threats, punishment, manipulation, shaming, you enforce your boundary in a respectful way.

See this is where I have a problem with this kind of parenting. It doesn’t seem to encapsulate any kind of ‘no’, it’s always a dilution of that message and I believe that’s the problem. This post suggests that it’s ok for a child to want a toy that someone else is playing with and seek to secure it immediately rather than the much better life lesson of ‘it’s not available, move away and find something else’. Toddler groups were full of toys and yet many parents had long conversations with tiny tots about ‘asking billy to share, ask if you can have a turn’ etc when poor bloody little billy just picked up the toy and shouldn’t have to dilute his own enjoyment just because another toddler is immediately demanding it.

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 09:23

5128gap · 18/06/2023 09:18

People always say the same on these threads 'that's not gentle parenting, that's no parenting' when that's clearly not the case, given the OP tells us that the parents do engage, with long conversations and compromise. Which in fairness takes a lot more effort than a sharp 'no'.
Personally I think gentle parenting is very controversial. People (with children too young to assess its ultimate outcome) insist on its benefits, with little weight given to the possibility they may simply have a child with a compliant personality. Evidence of poor behaviour resulting from it is glossed over or parents are blamed for not doing it right, which just results in a closing down of debate. If the only response is a hard 'it works or you must be doing it wrong' it's impossible to have any discussion on the benefits and pitfalls.

I agree - there's a very strong 'no true Scotsman' thing going on with gentle parenting. And as you say a lot of insistence that the benefits will be seen in adulthood, which is possible but also unprovable. I think the same thing about attachment parenting - a lot of people seem genuinely convinced that if they are slavish enough in infancy/toddlerhood/often a good bit beyond then they'll have teens and adults who are perfectly emotionally balanced, which just isn't a realistic expectation of human beings. I've said this before but I think the future 'but we took you to stately homes!' will be 'but we talked about your feelings!' - ie 'I did it all correctly so why are you still so disappointingly flawed'?

5128gap · 18/06/2023 09:18

People always say the same on these threads 'that's not gentle parenting, that's no parenting' when that's clearly not the case, given the OP tells us that the parents do engage, with long conversations and compromise. Which in fairness takes a lot more effort than a sharp 'no'.
Personally I think gentle parenting is very controversial. People (with children too young to assess its ultimate outcome) insist on its benefits, with little weight given to the possibility they may simply have a child with a compliant personality. Evidence of poor behaviour resulting from it is glossed over or parents are blamed for not doing it right, which just results in a closing down of debate. If the only response is a hard 'it works or you must be doing it wrong' it's impossible to have any discussion on the benefits and pitfalls.

Guiltridden12345 · 18/06/2023 09:16

There is a lot of this around these days, spreading like a trend. A secondary school deputy head said to me recently that behaviour at the good school in her middle class advantaged area was through the floor and what used to be exceptional bad behaviour, stemming from family/social difficulties/deprivation, is now the norm. Middle class kids who just can’t behave, attention seek, disrupt, won’t sit still, are rude, no respect for teachers. No wonder teachers are leaving (I’m not a teacher), they can’t actually teach for all the low level disruption.

Many of my kids’ friends over the years have had zero boundaries and dreadful behaviour that parents either ignore or laugh off or, worse still, think is cute. The kids are genuinely unpleasant to be around and we have had to stop seeing ‘friends’ because we and our kids can’t stand their kids (or their parenting) and its effects on us (won’t share with our kids, won’t sit at table, are rude, break toys, hit and kick their parents and other kids, have tantrums way past tantrum age, kick windows and doors, jump on sofas, insist on going first in games and winning (and being facilitated by parents) etc etc. The list goes on, several families not just one, no social issues just very weird hands off utterly crap parenting.

it’s the kids I feel sorry for. They are utterly unpleasant but it’s genuinely not their fault.

Floofydawg · 18/06/2023 09:07

Gentle parenting?! What fresh hell is this FFS.

Stillawake2023 · 18/06/2023 09:07

I have a nearly four year old who could be described in the same way. We have boundaries and say no. However, he was five months old when Covid hit, and these kids didn’t have the advantage of play groups and interaction with kids from a young age. There simply wasn’t anywhere open to take them. It’s all very well criticising the parents, and that may be correct. However my kid is behind in his emotional development and social interaction. If you haven’t raised a pandemic baby then try not to judge. These little ones missed out and it will take time to catch up. My DS could easily get over excited in a social situation and it’s on us as parents to expose him to as much as possible now, but don’t forget they have missed out.

MassiveSalad22 · 18/06/2023 09:05

That sounds like permissive parenting, not gentle parenting.

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 09:01

Incidentally we do let the kids clamber all over our sofa, but they know they can't at other people's houses, including either set of grandparents.

TizerorFizz · 18/06/2023 08:56

Why do posters keep thinking “gentle parenting” avoids tantrums? My DC had so few I can only remember one. They learnt I chose the shopping! I never let them choose sweets or chocolate. We never bought them when they were present and rarely anyway. You can avoid possible tantrum situations as well.

Not every child is prone to tantrums. I didn’t spend time exploring their feelings. I’m slightly amused that Dc have such advanced brains that they understand and react appropriately to all of this detail about their inner feelings and responses at 3 years old. If they are still having tantrums when they go to school surely that is evidence of nothing much working?

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 08:51

Thistooshallpsss · 18/06/2023 08:41

I don’t see how the amount of time needed to gentle parent eg taking off to a quiet place talking about feelings etc is possible if you have several young children/ babies all needing attention at the same time. You have to prioritise.

There is a reason that so many proponents of this (including Philippa Perry) have only one child. It's a lot easier to do it this way if you always have one on one time. It's also a lot easier to turn every time a child has to share or play nicely into a full dramatic performance if that's something that happens only when you're out rather than 42 times a day...

When I see people doing the full-on talking about feelings it's normally to their young toddler PFB and then what strikes me is just how inappropriate it is in terms of the child's language development. You get this two year old who can't yet follow two stage instructions with a parent giving them a lengthy monologue and the kid, pretty clearly, isn't following a word of it.

BertieBotts · 18/06/2023 08:46

I do think there is a discipline crisis in schools. They are (rightly) not allowed to hit or humiliate children, but a lot of the discipline systems are still based on the framework of "Behave because of fear of a terrible punishment" except that the punishments are no longer terrible, and this doesn't work because the kids who need to behave differently don't care about these non-terrible punishments (and/or aren't sufficiently frightened by them to override other causes of their behaviour), and may even be more riled up and push back more. The ones that are deterred by them don't need them. If you want a system that relies on threat, then the threat must be credible and it must be ever-present. That's why old school teachers used to have the cane visible as a kind of reminder of what could happen if you stepped out of line.

Add this to the mess that is mainstreaming everyone without the necessary support systems, and you have an extreme problem. Now leading to the point where so many teachers are burnt out and you can't hire new ones because nobody wants to do it.

Discipline systems in schools need replacing with new systems (there are several to choose from) that don't rely on threat in the first place, and schools need much much better support and integration and funding for children with SEN, inclusing in the early years where many children won't yet be diagnosed or may be on the cusp because of developmental delays which will correct themselves given time.

But there doesn't seem to be any funding for any of this.

Thistooshallpsss · 18/06/2023 08:41

I don’t see how the amount of time needed to gentle parent eg taking off to a quiet place talking about feelings etc is possible if you have several young children/ babies all needing attention at the same time. You have to prioritise.

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 08:31

We gentle parent our kid (2, will be 3 in September) - but doesn't sound anything like what the OP described.

We have strict boundaries and routine, and he hears no all the time. The great thing is though he knows that if he has a tantrum about us saying no to something (eg: he asks for chocolate at the shop and I say no, not today) I mean it and no amount of crying will change that. The gentle part is that I'll tell him it's ok to be sad and disappointed that he isn't getting chocolate today but if mummy says no chocolate that means no chocolate and he gets comforted and cuddles. Amazingly it means when he asks for chocolate at the shop and I say no not today he just puts it back and doesn't ask again or do anything remotely like a tantrum.

Gentle parenting gets a bad rep because I think people use it as an excuse to give into their kids tantrums and not hold any boundaries or teach them consequences. I think what's really worked for us is being people of our word - I've told my husband if we say anything to DS we have to follow through. This can be a discipline thing (eg threatening to take something away for misuse) or a nice thing (so if I say he can have iPad after dinner, he does get it after dinner! Otherwise I just shouldn't say it)

I guess this is a really long way of me saying that some people think they're gentle parenting but they're not they're just not holding boundaries to try to make their lives easier in the short term but they're actually making it a million times harder in the long term

DancingShinyFlamingo · 18/06/2023 08:20

Bluevelvetsofa · 17/06/2023 15:50

That’s a child who will find school a very difficult place to be. I’d lay money that his parents will blame the school too.

Have a child whose parents have this style in one of my kids classes. The parents are constantly moaning and considering changing schools. Ironically their child loves the school and is enjoying the boundaries kindly but firmly put in place. They’re actually sweet natured but their behaviour alienates most other children and they have no idea why.

Wenfy · 18/06/2023 08:17

I gentle parent. DD has ASD, she can’t always contextualise. If I say no to something she will never do it again (ie no to jumping and she won’t jump when she needs to at school). Conversely if I say no to DS he will throw a tantrum, argue and will get so upset it will take up to an hour to calm him & he won’t listen anyway.

Kids are all different and so parenting needs to be different. With DD I have to explain everything, with DS it’s far better to distract him away from what he’s doing.

evuscha · 18/06/2023 08:11

PracticallyFlooredZero · 17/06/2023 22:28

I genuinely think my niece has never heard the word no. She scratched my son’s face, smacked him in the head then pushed him over because he touched one of her toys (that she wasn’t even playing with at the time!) and her parents took her aside and talked about how her feelings must have been hurt when he touched her toy and how they understood how she had big feelings but that is wasn’t very kind to hurt him. I just stood there open mouthed. I consider myself a pretty gentle parent as they go but if any of my children behaved like that they would be immediately taken home and properly told off. Apparently she has no friends at nursery and they can’t understand why!!

It’s like you’re talking about my niece. She occasionally hears a word no but then has such a meltdown that it quickly gets changed into a yes, so…..
And she also struggles with making friends at the nursery and they wonder why.

Simonjt · 18/06/2023 08:09

We do a mix of gentle parenting and attachment parenting, our eight year old is well behaved and polite, he obviously had his odd moment, but they’re fairly rare and nothing major or extreme. Gentle parenting involves very clear and consistent boundaries. So what the ops friend is doing isn’t gentle parenting.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 18/06/2023 07:54

The joy of summer is that I get to listen to neighbours fall over themselves trying to performance gentle parenting. The kids misbehave and run riot and never once is the word no used. It is quite amusing listening to the nonsense they come out with.