Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
Cakeorchocolate · 18/06/2023 15:33

That's not gentle parenting, it's a lack of discipline.

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 15:31

I’ve made this point on one of these threads before, but the problem with this approach to parenting is that we don’t exist in a vacuum with our kids. So even if other people’s thoughts and feelings don’t matter to you per se, they ultimately can and do have an impact on your child. Your child has a massive tantrum and hits another child. The natural consequence would be that the other child would hit yours back, which wouldn’t be allowed to happen. So you give an “it’s okay to have big feelings, but it’s not kind to hit” speech and think that’s okay. But the other child and his parent probably don’t think that’s okay. But, because we’re all terribly British, they won’t tell you that. They’ll grit their teeth and smile and say it’s all fine and it’s been a lovely play date and that “these things happen with kids”. But the consequence will be that your child won’t be invited back. And that parent will probably tell others about it - and then those people will have formed a negative opinion of your child and that sort of thing gets around. And so there will be a natural consequence of that behaviour, but not one that your child will actually ever see, or understand, or learn from. You’ll just be one of the parents mentioned upthread who can’t understand why their child doesn’t have friends and isn’t invited to parties.

SerfnTerf · 18/06/2023 15:15

SerfnTerf · 18/06/2023 14:41

Oh my sister is like this with her PFB 2 yr old. My own DC are much older now, teens/young adults, but I'm sure I wasn't that fucking feeble when they were toddlers!

It's all, as someone else said, lengthy and totally pointless monologues.

"Come on my little love, that's not very kind is it, look you're making a big mess, we don't do that do we, ah I know you're having fun but look everyone wants you to stop throwing food now, I know, come on, put the plate down, don't hit mummy, look SerfNTerf won't like food on her walls will she so come on let's put it down so she doesn't have a big mess to clean up, owwwwww don't bite me, come on little love you aren't being very kind to mummy, I don't want your pasta in my hair do I darling"

Whereas I'd just take the food away and remove the child from the table after one warning because a) they are 2, all these words are going straight over their heads and b) my life is too fucking short for reasoning with a 2 yr old.

But yunno, wevs. Not my kid. I'm sure she thought I was doing it all wrong too, back when I had toddlers and she was childfree!!

Oh and before anyone comes and tells me "well that's not gentle parenting" - ok fine, I bow to your superior knowledge of parenting labels.

But my sister thinks it's gentle parenting. It's her implementation of all the gubbins she reads in books and online about gentle parenting.

So maybe it isn't gentle parenting as it should be practiced, but it is absolutely being done that ineffective bollocksy way in families up and down in the country in the name of gentle parenting!

Redlarge · 18/06/2023 15:13

Anotherblueday · 18/06/2023 15:08

What do you think this has to do with gentle parenting?

Read the thread,we are discussing lack of patenting as a off shoot to main topic. People who dont want to parent can use the excuse of gentle parent when its no parenting.

Anotherblueday · 18/06/2023 15:08

Redlarge · 18/06/2023 15:01

My friend has never disaplined her child. Child is vile. Violent, rude, greedy no manners.
Even when shes explained to her that 'mummy was upset with bad behaviour' she still gets all the treats/days out without recourse. No punisent ever. The school have called her in continuously about her daughters attitude and disrespect and she says she has anxiety cos its a Tuesday, the sky is blue that kind of thing.
I honestly cant see this child ever holding down a job, friendship or relationship in the future. She truly believes shes the centre of the world and its her way or nothing.
You have to parent. You have to guide you have to educate about manners and consequences. Whining in a baby voice about feelings won't help the poor kid.

What do you think this has to do with gentle parenting?

Redlarge · 18/06/2023 15:03

Bluedabadeeba · 17/06/2023 16:11

But why call it 'gentle parenting', when in fact, it is nothing of the sorts. This is what gives gentle parenting a bad name. If you're a gentle parent yourself, you'll know that.

This is obviously no parenting. Nothing to do with gentle parenting. I would find it VERY hard to be friends/spend time with someone who parents like this!!

I agree. You dont need to scare them or shout but you do need to parent and guide them.

Redlarge · 18/06/2023 15:01

My friend has never disaplined her child. Child is vile. Violent, rude, greedy no manners.
Even when shes explained to her that 'mummy was upset with bad behaviour' she still gets all the treats/days out without recourse. No punisent ever. The school have called her in continuously about her daughters attitude and disrespect and she says she has anxiety cos its a Tuesday, the sky is blue that kind of thing.
I honestly cant see this child ever holding down a job, friendship or relationship in the future. She truly believes shes the centre of the world and its her way or nothing.
You have to parent. You have to guide you have to educate about manners and consequences. Whining in a baby voice about feelings won't help the poor kid.

SerfnTerf · 18/06/2023 14:41

Oh my sister is like this with her PFB 2 yr old. My own DC are much older now, teens/young adults, but I'm sure I wasn't that fucking feeble when they were toddlers!

It's all, as someone else said, lengthy and totally pointless monologues.

"Come on my little love, that's not very kind is it, look you're making a big mess, we don't do that do we, ah I know you're having fun but look everyone wants you to stop throwing food now, I know, come on, put the plate down, don't hit mummy, look SerfNTerf won't like food on her walls will she so come on let's put it down so she doesn't have a big mess to clean up, owwwwww don't bite me, come on little love you aren't being very kind to mummy, I don't want your pasta in my hair do I darling"

Whereas I'd just take the food away and remove the child from the table after one warning because a) they are 2, all these words are going straight over their heads and b) my life is too fucking short for reasoning with a 2 yr old.

But yunno, wevs. Not my kid. I'm sure she thought I was doing it all wrong too, back when I had toddlers and she was childfree!!

DisquietintheRanks · 18/06/2023 14:27

I know several children who were raised by this (non) parenting method. And actually, they mostly turned into pretty fine adults - the world knocked most of their corners off as they grew up. They were deeply unpleasant to be around as kids/teens though (and especially for their dear doormat parents) so its not an approach I'd recommend.

azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 14:23

johnd2 · 18/06/2023 13:52

I've been following this thread with interest, it's amazing to see the different perceptions and realities from different viewpoints.

One thing that strikes me is that the different parent styles, the real crux of the difference isn't in the outward daily appearance of dropping by the park or someone's house or the play date, it's when the child is in full meltdown, the parents are triggered, everyone is starving, the child has snatched a toy and been punched in return, we're out in public feeling judged.
What would you do in the moment and afterwards in each parenting style? That's where the difference is!
Gentle/authoritive parenting has a very different answer from the permissive parenting mentioned on here. Which differs from the authoritarian parenting advocated by others (scares me just thinking about it)

Yeah, if that was me I would (in an ideal world obviously, I don't always do the perfect thing!) my priority would be to move the child to a safe place to have their meltdown. That might be the car, a quiet corner, the best close place. Sit with the child and then as fast as possible support the child to enough emotional regulation to allow us to get home. That might mean a snack or a cuddle or a distraction.

Then get home and again focus on bringing the child back to being well-regulated and doing whatever works for the. I wouldn't bring up the behaviour to talk through it until the child was completely calm, but I absolutely would bring it up, and discuss what happened, why it happened and how we can avoid it in future. Reiterate that it's okay to feel angry but that it's not okay to hit/snatch/whatever. Decide whether we need to make amends (e.g. apologise to a child who was hit). Then move on with the day not holding a grudge or making the child feel like they are in the dog house.

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 14:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

johnd2 · 18/06/2023 13:52

I've been following this thread with interest, it's amazing to see the different perceptions and realities from different viewpoints.

One thing that strikes me is that the different parent styles, the real crux of the difference isn't in the outward daily appearance of dropping by the park or someone's house or the play date, it's when the child is in full meltdown, the parents are triggered, everyone is starving, the child has snatched a toy and been punched in return, we're out in public feeling judged.
What would you do in the moment and afterwards in each parenting style? That's where the difference is!
Gentle/authoritive parenting has a very different answer from the permissive parenting mentioned on here. Which differs from the authoritarian parenting advocated by others (scares me just thinking about it)

Guiltridden12345 · 18/06/2023 13:37

I know someone who simply shouted ‘with love’ when her toddler punched kids full on in the face, nicked their toys, ran around like a lunatic at quiet times. Like you can ever punch someone in the face with love?

Guiltridden12345 · 18/06/2023 13:34

DidyouNO · 18/06/2023 13:14

Children need boundaries. They need boundaries to feel safe and loved. Parents that 'parent' like that tend to end up with wayward, undisciplined children because the children are running about like headless chickens trying to find some safety.
The psychology behind this fact is absolutely fascinating.
A basic gist, Imagine being dropped in a desert, no map, no compass. Nothing. And being told to find your way out. There's people (ie the parents) who know the way, have the compass. But don't give it to you. They just smile while you run about getting more scared and lonely and hot and alone.
That's how children without boundaries feel. Lost, alone and scared. Then when they come into contact with the parent they're usually angry, frustrated and scared that their attempts to communicate their need for direction has been ignored or misunderstood. It's horrifying that it's becoming so prolific under the guise of 'gentle parenting' (which you scenario is not)
Therapeutic parenting is the perfect parenting style in MHO, especially for SEN children.

This is fascinating, and shows it’s really not kind parenting after all.

though I agree I don’t like the shouty/authoritarian parenting either - like most things in life there is a spectrum of happy medium which will achieve the same aim.

DidyouNO · 18/06/2023 13:14

Children need boundaries. They need boundaries to feel safe and loved. Parents that 'parent' like that tend to end up with wayward, undisciplined children because the children are running about like headless chickens trying to find some safety.
The psychology behind this fact is absolutely fascinating.
A basic gist, Imagine being dropped in a desert, no map, no compass. Nothing. And being told to find your way out. There's people (ie the parents) who know the way, have the compass. But don't give it to you. They just smile while you run about getting more scared and lonely and hot and alone.
That's how children without boundaries feel. Lost, alone and scared. Then when they come into contact with the parent they're usually angry, frustrated and scared that their attempts to communicate their need for direction has been ignored or misunderstood. It's horrifying that it's becoming so prolific under the guise of 'gentle parenting' (which you scenario is not)
Therapeutic parenting is the perfect parenting style in MHO, especially for SEN children.

azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 13:00

RedHelenB · 18/06/2023 11:39

But you've " snatched " the toy from your child in their eyes in this example. Doubt they really understand your explanation aged 2 anymore than if you'd just said " no you don't take a toy from another child".

Yes I definitely would "snatch" the toy in this example because otherwise I would be having to deal with Tilly trying to get the toy back while trying to sort out the situation! I think any parent would.

I get what you're saying about understanding, that's why I said at the top that how you would deal with it really depends on the child, their age, maturity and understanding. With a younger child you would probably do more distraction, and if that didn't work then you'd be out in the corridor dealing with the emotions quickly. With an older child you'd be doing more modeling of negotiation.

I don't really think that what I've put it monologuing. After every one of those questions I would be pausing and listening, modeling that I am calm and that there is no rush and that we can problem solve together.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/06/2023 12:40

Evidence of poor behaviour resulting from it is glossed over or parents are blamed for not doing it right, which just results in a closing down of debate. If the only response is a hard 'it works or you must be doing it wrong' it's impossible to have any discussion on the benefits and pitfalls.

I completely agree with this.

I have friends who gentle parent in exactly the way it’s being defined by the “that’s not gentle parenting!” contingent, and their children are all horribly behaved, rude, shouty and aggressive.

If there’s something legit about this practice we’ll know in a decade or so, but I’m highly sceptical.

And I say this as someone whose parents were the opposite of gentle. That is not something I’m advocating!

Anaemiafog · 18/06/2023 11:53

I think the proof is in the pudding. I'd only be interested in hearing from 'gentle' parents whose children are now adults. My youngest DC is now 16 and whilst I never shouted or smacked, but I held strict boundaries and said no. Did the system of never saying no work?
Fellow parents who seemed permissive back then, now have out of control DC who don't respect them as parents. Children are all different. SIL thought she was parent of the year because her DS was so calm and quiet as a young child. The reality was that he was a very gentle child who didn't require discipline. It came from him. The problems came when he got older. She had never had to set boundaries and when she tried he simply didn't respect her or listen. He's completely out of control.

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 11:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Longdarkcloud · 18/06/2023 11:50

There is a world of difference between never telling a child “No” and continually saying “No”. One says to a young child in a gentle smiley voice, “No we dont do that” with maybe a quick reason and then distract, give a snatched object back etc.
In cases where safety is a potential issue the tone of voice attracts prompt attention.
Never saying no is barmy.

zingally · 18/06/2023 11:44

TBH, it sounds within the realms of normal 3-year-old behaviour. But certainly, if his parents are otherwise "normal and sensible", it's also probably a bit of over-indulged and under-disciplined.
When will he start school? If he's NT, they'll soon knock some sense into him.

RedHelenB · 18/06/2023 11:39

azimuth299 · 17/06/2023 17:11

Well it would really depend on the age of the children involved, but as an example if my child took a toy out of another child's hands I would take the toy and hand it back and say something like "Oh, we don't snatch, Tilly is playing with the car right now. Do you want to play with the car? Shall we find another car?" This is all said calmly with pauses, not one question after the other and hopefully the child lets you know at this point what they want to happen.

If they were still insisting on that toy I would say something like "Shall we ask Tilly whether you can use it after her?" If Tilly says yes then I'd say something like "Okay great, what shall we play with while we're waiting?" or if Tilly isn't having it I would say "Oh it looks like Tilly won't be done for a while, let's find something else."

If my child started becoming too upset at any point and couldn't talk about it then I would lead or carry them to another room to have a break, name their feelings, offer comfort and generally be a calm presence until they were ready to go back.

Saying gentle hands and not doing anything else would be incredibly ineffective I imagine.

But you've " snatched " the toy from your child in their eyes in this example. Doubt they really understand your explanation aged 2 anymore than if you'd just said " no you don't take a toy from another child".

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 11:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Wenfy · 18/06/2023 11:07

Titsywoo · 18/06/2023 10:47

I was a bit of a shouty parent (not mean just very firm) - my kids are grown and gave me no shit through their teen years. They wouldn't dare be rude to me Grin Several of my friends complain about how their kids shout at them and call them names. Not a chance in hell would I tolerate that. They still just say 'please don't talk to me like that it isn't kind'. Being meek and feeble like that doesn't work with kids who need rules and boundaries as they figure themselves out.

My Mum was like this. She doesn’t have much to do with us or dc any more as a direct result.

Marmaladebear · 18/06/2023 10:58

Guiltridden12345 · 18/06/2023 10:46

I think the issue is that your kind of parenting doesn’t encourage either resilience in the face of real life actions - taking turns, iPad going off, time to put shoes on even though existentially you don’t as a two year old feel you should have to wear shoes - creates future engrained problems for peers, carers, teachers and the wider world that will come into contact with your kid. Imagine a teacher having 30 x 4 year olds who needed a long discussion and a hand-hold when told it’s tidy up time - it’s unworkable, even if you have the time to make it ‘work’ for you in your own home.

I guess you didn't read anything I wrote! That's fine though - I have a kid that I am teaching emotional resilience and preparing for the world. He is super well behaved and follows routine and instructions. So off to enjoy my Sunday with him and DH.