Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 20:21

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 18:59

So what do YOU do if your kid hits another?

Mercifully, this only ever happened to me between my own kids, so I didn’t have another parent to whom I needed to make apologies. But I spoke in firm tones (I was cross and she knew I was cross) to the hitter - and told her that we never hit. That I do not hit her and she does not hit her sister. And that if she hit her sister again, then she would not be going to a party tomorrow and that she needed to apologise for hitting her. And her sister needed to hear that there’d been some appropriate reaction to being lumped round the head and needed to receive the apology. If I’d taken the hitter into another room, all soft tones and cuddles - “I know you’re angry…..” - it sets entirely the wrong tone and feels like some sort of justification. (They’re now much older and happily get on very well. Any altercation is usually pretty effectively dealt with with “Enough!” in a raised voice!)

I’m afraid the problem with the “I know you’re angry but you can play if you don’t hit” approach is that it sends mixed messages. That it’s okay because you’re angry. That your feelings matter more than someone else’s. And that’s a dangerous precedent to set. Self importance isn’t attractive on a toddler, but people make allowances for it. On a 9/10 year old, it’s really not attractive at all. And at secondary school, the world is brutal.

I’m afraid the problem with the “I know you’re angry but you can play if you don’t hit” approach is that it sends mixed messages. That it’s okay because you’re angry.

But it's literally the opposite of what you're saying! It's not "It was okay to hit because you're angry" it's "It's okay to be angry but it's unacceptable to hit".

I think most of the issue here is people not understanding what gentle parenting actually is, and think that it means no boundaries, no rules, no consequences. There are plenty of lazy permissive parents out there, and they are somehow being lumped in with gentle parenting. Maybe the concept needs to be rebranded to make it clearer what it is.

5128gap · 18/06/2023 20:12

As far as I have observed people in general are not overly prone to believing their feelings are invalid or to sacrificing their own needs in order to be people pleasers. Quite the reverse in fact. Some are of course, but I'd hardly feel its so endemic in the population we need to overhaul parenting styles to prevent it. Seems a little like a solution looking for a problem to me.

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 19:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

BeverlyBrook · 18/06/2023 19:22

Yep I've seen that in action. Sanctimonious clap trap. If course children need to be told no. Else they turn into little shits. As you see happening in front of you. Just don't go round. And don't invite them to your house or it will get trashed

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 19:21

Not a good lesson for any children involved to go about things like it is a dirty secret though?

On one level, no. On another level, they learn how the world actually works! (Ironically - I’m actually more direct than most people and my kids would agree with that! In this particular case, the father was opining on the poor manners of some members of the class in the earshot of my older DD (not the classmate of this child). She was particularly amusing on the subject when we got in the car to go home - “has that man actually ever met his own daughter?”. I’m ashamed to say that I laughed uproariously.

Oblomov23 · 18/06/2023 19:19

That's not gentle parenting, it's no parenting. Twats.

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 19:17

Have you ever tried to calm an angry autistic and adhd toddler in the middle of a busy playgroup with 20 kids

No. And that’s because you’re positing a completely different scenario. Anyone would accept that a child with special needs may need to be treated differently. A child without special needs because it suits a particular parenting style will be seen in a different light.

johnd2 · 18/06/2023 19:16

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 19:06

In seriousness though, you're allowed to feel bored and embarrassed waiting twiddling your thumbs. Of course parents will prioritise themselves and their children and if they shoot themselves in their foot and no one wants to hang out with them, then they have done a bad job at prioritising themselves. Not everyone gets on with everyone.
Maybe they will learn from those consequences.

Generally, they don’t. Because we’re British and we’re conflict avoidant. My kids are much older now and I’m studiously avoiding making arrangements with one mother because we all think her DD is, not to put too fine a point on it, fucking obnoxious. But of course my DD doesn’t say “no way do I want to play with you”, because she’s too polite. And I don’t say, “after last time, there’s no way I’m having your rude child in my house”. We say “oh, that’s a lovely idea - I’ll look at the diary/we’re away for most of the summer but will definitely arrange something when they’re back at school” or whatever. Which is cowardly, really, but everyone does it. So that parent probably goes away thinking we’re a bit flaky/disorganised/incredibly busy. She won’t think “gosh - I bet they think my kid is badly behaved”. Human nature isn’t like that.

The consequence still happens even if people are too British to actually mention what it is.

Not a good lesson for any children involved to go about things like it is a dirty secret though?

NotEverORNever · 18/06/2023 19:16

Much easier to be a gentle parent with one kid 😅. A bit trickier with 4 under 6. My kids were all mellow and naturally well behaved but I still occasionally had to tell them off. I never shouted but I did tell them off and punish them.
I did all the normal talking, explaining and reasoning shite and it worked most the time but on occasion I needed to tell them off.

I found some of my gentle parenting friends had terribly behaved kids and some may not have shouted but used guilt trip'ing instead. Things like saying how they would be disappointed in their kid if it did something naughty. I found that way more fucked up than simply telling a kid that they aren't allowed to do something,

babbscrabbs · 18/06/2023 19:13

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 16:21

Child is currently at a Montessori nursery, not sure what they’ll do when it’s time for a regular school, or whether those ones go up to school age too?

I suppose part of me wondered whether it is acceptable to let kids jump on sofas, I mean it’s her property and they’re obviously okay with it, it’s just not something I would ever let my child do. We went out for tea one night and he was climbing all over the furniture there too which obviously he would because he’s allowed to at home. It made me feel like I was perhaps a bit uptight with my parenting but I wouldn’t ever let my child (past baby years) bounce on a sofa. I know that’s only a very tiny thing regarding the behaviour but how blasé they were about it all had me feeling like I was wrong to feel it was inappropriate!

It sounds more like different standards / attitudes towards what's on and the child's personality than gentle parenting itself causing the issues tbh.

I don't see anything wrong with parenting that doesn't use shouting, shaming, threats or bribes to make a child conform, which is what I consider gentle parenting.

You can be a strict gentle parent or a permissive gentle parent.

I wonder why you wouldn't let your children bounce on a sofa? Mine had great fun jumping from chair to chair playing floor is lava, rearranging all the sofa cushions to make forts etc

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 19:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Redebs · 18/06/2023 19:07

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

That's not gentle parenting

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 19:06

In seriousness though, you're allowed to feel bored and embarrassed waiting twiddling your thumbs. Of course parents will prioritise themselves and their children and if they shoot themselves in their foot and no one wants to hang out with them, then they have done a bad job at prioritising themselves. Not everyone gets on with everyone.
Maybe they will learn from those consequences.

Generally, they don’t. Because we’re British and we’re conflict avoidant. My kids are much older now and I’m studiously avoiding making arrangements with one mother because we all think her DD is, not to put too fine a point on it, fucking obnoxious. But of course my DD doesn’t say “no way do I want to play with you”, because she’s too polite. And I don’t say, “after last time, there’s no way I’m having your rude child in my house”. We say “oh, that’s a lovely idea - I’ll look at the diary/we’re away for most of the summer but will definitely arrange something when they’re back at school” or whatever. Which is cowardly, really, but everyone does it. So that parent probably goes away thinking we’re a bit flaky/disorganised/incredibly busy. She won’t think “gosh - I bet they think my kid is badly behaved”. Human nature isn’t like that.

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 18:59

So what do YOU do if your kid hits another?

Mercifully, this only ever happened to me between my own kids, so I didn’t have another parent to whom I needed to make apologies. But I spoke in firm tones (I was cross and she knew I was cross) to the hitter - and told her that we never hit. That I do not hit her and she does not hit her sister. And that if she hit her sister again, then she would not be going to a party tomorrow and that she needed to apologise for hitting her. And her sister needed to hear that there’d been some appropriate reaction to being lumped round the head and needed to receive the apology. If I’d taken the hitter into another room, all soft tones and cuddles - “I know you’re angry…..” - it sets entirely the wrong tone and feels like some sort of justification. (They’re now much older and happily get on very well. Any altercation is usually pretty effectively dealt with with “Enough!” in a raised voice!)

I’m afraid the problem with the “I know you’re angry but you can play if you don’t hit” approach is that it sends mixed messages. That it’s okay because you’re angry. That your feelings matter more than someone else’s. And that’s a dangerous precedent to set. Self importance isn’t attractive on a toddler, but people make allowances for it. On a 9/10 year old, it’s really not attractive at all. And at secondary school, the world is brutal.

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 18:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

johnd2 · 18/06/2023 18:51

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 18:02

If my child hit someone I would immediately remove him from the space/room/situation to somewhere he couldn’t hurt anyone else-

This sounds marvellous. But if you’re in my house for a play date, you’ve effectively left the room you’ve been invited to sit in and unilaterally decided to take your child elsewhere in my house while my child and I sit and wait for you. (If we’re in your house, then you’ve left your guests unattended and twiddling their thumbs.) And it’s boring as hell sitting around listening to someone cajoling and earnestly making speeches to a child who clearly doesn’t give a shit. I’m being slightly facetious here, but it underlines the point that this is a style of parenting that consistently prioritises you and yours at the expense of those around you. Which in many scenarios just ends up as plain bad manners. (My neighbour had this approach with her son. I remember watching, quite aghast, as he decided he didn’t want to go for his swimming lesson. The instructor stood on the side, as she spent 20 minutes quietly reasoning and cajoling and getting nowhere. The swimming instructor was not, it was clear for all to see, very impressed with this - and I can’t say I blamed her. They may not have meant to be, but they were rude and disrespectful of her time. Neighbour also regularly removed her son from parties, presumably for some similarly earnest discussion, but on one occasion caused quite some distress as the party parent didn’t know where they’d gone and was genuinely concerned that she’d lost someone. They were very nice people - and he was a sweet little boy (if rather out of control) - but it became a commonly held opinion that they weren’t people with whom one would choose to make arrangements.)

Yes a good clip round the ear is much quicker all round. Spare the rod, spoil the child!

In seriousness though, you're allowed to feel bored and embarrassed waiting twiddling your thumbs. Of course parents will prioritise themselves and their children and if they shoot themselves in their foot and no one wants to hang out with them, then they have done a bad job at prioritising themselves. Not everyone gets on with everyone.
Maybe they will learn from those consequences.

SerfnTerf · 18/06/2023 18:47

FilthyforFirth · 18/06/2023 18:22

Genuine question, everyone that never says no, when does that stop? At what age is it acceptable to tell them no? 13, 16? Never? Is it ok to tell other adults no?

No

Wink
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 18/06/2023 18:37

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 18:02

If my child hit someone I would immediately remove him from the space/room/situation to somewhere he couldn’t hurt anyone else-

This sounds marvellous. But if you’re in my house for a play date, you’ve effectively left the room you’ve been invited to sit in and unilaterally decided to take your child elsewhere in my house while my child and I sit and wait for you. (If we’re in your house, then you’ve left your guests unattended and twiddling their thumbs.) And it’s boring as hell sitting around listening to someone cajoling and earnestly making speeches to a child who clearly doesn’t give a shit. I’m being slightly facetious here, but it underlines the point that this is a style of parenting that consistently prioritises you and yours at the expense of those around you. Which in many scenarios just ends up as plain bad manners. (My neighbour had this approach with her son. I remember watching, quite aghast, as he decided he didn’t want to go for his swimming lesson. The instructor stood on the side, as she spent 20 minutes quietly reasoning and cajoling and getting nowhere. The swimming instructor was not, it was clear for all to see, very impressed with this - and I can’t say I blamed her. They may not have meant to be, but they were rude and disrespectful of her time. Neighbour also regularly removed her son from parties, presumably for some similarly earnest discussion, but on one occasion caused quite some distress as the party parent didn’t know where they’d gone and was genuinely concerned that she’d lost someone. They were very nice people - and he was a sweet little boy (if rather out of control) - but it became a commonly held opinion that they weren’t people with whom one would choose to make arrangements.)

So what do YOU do if your kid hits another?

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 18:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

FilthyforFirth · 18/06/2023 18:22

Genuine question, everyone that never says no, when does that stop? At what age is it acceptable to tell them no? 13, 16? Never? Is it ok to tell other adults no?

Longdarkcloud · 18/06/2023 18:12

Sooner later children need to be introduced to the rules on which boundaries are based. It appears that many posters feel this is an anathema and the opposite to gentle parenting.
Society is based on its members recognising boundaries, especially those enforced by law. Why do we observe traffic regulations — because we’ll suffer the consequences if we get caught and or have an accident. Why do we show respect to our employers, state officials etc? Because there will be consequences for not doing so. Johnny May feel he can disrespect his teacher because mum will support him, but try doing that to the judge

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 18:02

If my child hit someone I would immediately remove him from the space/room/situation to somewhere he couldn’t hurt anyone else-

This sounds marvellous. But if you’re in my house for a play date, you’ve effectively left the room you’ve been invited to sit in and unilaterally decided to take your child elsewhere in my house while my child and I sit and wait for you. (If we’re in your house, then you’ve left your guests unattended and twiddling their thumbs.) And it’s boring as hell sitting around listening to someone cajoling and earnestly making speeches to a child who clearly doesn’t give a shit. I’m being slightly facetious here, but it underlines the point that this is a style of parenting that consistently prioritises you and yours at the expense of those around you. Which in many scenarios just ends up as plain bad manners. (My neighbour had this approach with her son. I remember watching, quite aghast, as he decided he didn’t want to go for his swimming lesson. The instructor stood on the side, as she spent 20 minutes quietly reasoning and cajoling and getting nowhere. The swimming instructor was not, it was clear for all to see, very impressed with this - and I can’t say I blamed her. They may not have meant to be, but they were rude and disrespectful of her time. Neighbour also regularly removed her son from parties, presumably for some similarly earnest discussion, but on one occasion caused quite some distress as the party parent didn’t know where they’d gone and was genuinely concerned that she’d lost someone. They were very nice people - and he was a sweet little boy (if rather out of control) - but it became a commonly held opinion that they weren’t people with whom one would choose to make arrangements.)

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 16:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

johnd2 · 18/06/2023 16:29

Not wishing to stir things up even more, but what do people think about the parent's feelings in all this?
There's a lot of emphasis on doing this, reflecting this, taking the child away, but not a lot of focus on when you as a parent are stressed and ready to have your own meltdown!
How do you deal with that situation?

Interestingly (as context) I was videoing my child and feeling stressed by what happened during the video, but only didn't react because I was videoing at the time.
Then I watched the video back that evening and time must have slowed down because the actual event was a total non event and dealt with in about 0.5 seconds by my child. So parents emotions clearly are just as important as the child's to influence the situation when parenting.

HousePlantNeglect · 18/06/2023 15:52

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 08:51

There is a reason that so many proponents of this (including Philippa Perry) have only one child. It's a lot easier to do it this way if you always have one on one time. It's also a lot easier to turn every time a child has to share or play nicely into a full dramatic performance if that's something that happens only when you're out rather than 42 times a day...

When I see people doing the full-on talking about feelings it's normally to their young toddler PFB and then what strikes me is just how inappropriate it is in terms of the child's language development. You get this two year old who can't yet follow two stage instructions with a parent giving them a lengthy monologue and the kid, pretty clearly, isn't following a word of it.

I really enjoyed Philippa Perrys book but this was my first thought too. There was a bit about her kid wanting to stop and examine things on a walk (if I remember rightly) and that was something she encouraged her to do rather than rush her along. Which I’m totally down with if you have the time. But what if this is DC2 and DC1 needs to be in school in 3 minutes and DC3 is in the sling crying for milk!? In that situation I don’t even have the time for an explanation about why we can’t stop and our feelings about the situation. It’s more of a ‘sorry we don’t have time, in the pram please’ situation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread