Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think sometimes gentle parenting is taken too far?

238 replies

GPgonewrong · 17/06/2023 15:34

This week I’ve spent a few days with friends, their baby and son who’s almost 4. I have DS who is a few years older.

They gentle parent (which I also do, to an extent) but it means their toddler never hears raised voices, I didn’t ever hear “no”, everything was dealt with through a compromise or sitting down with him. All sounds fine, until you experience the behaviour. He bounced on every single chair and sofa, constantly pulled out furniture, wouldn’t sit down for a meal, eating little bits and buggering off running round, never ate a full meal but fed on demand. He shoved me out of the way several times, complained every time he was explained to why he shouldn’t be doing that, which he shouted back “NO! You can’t say that”. Completely unable to share, always snatching off the other kids, and didn’t say goodbye when we left. He is almost four but still won’t play nicely, instead his idea of play was destructive, throwing things around and knocking things over.

AIBU to think it’s gentle parenting taken too far and no discipline? Or maybe a separate issue?

OP posts:
azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 23:36

Screamingabdabz · 18/06/2023 23:32

It should be actively respectful of other people’s comfort too. Children need to learn about consideration for others otherwise they become self serving. No isn’t just a one way street.

It is though. So I can't engage further with you because you're just making things up. It's like playing chess with a pigeon.

Screamingabdabz · 18/06/2023 23:32

azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 23:10

It teaches really well about consent because it is actively respectful of children's comfort. It's the gentle parents who are telling children that they don't have to kiss Aunt Marigold if they don't want to. It's the gentle parents who stop tickling when their child laughs and says stop. It's actively pro bodily autonomy.

Again, I'm not sure it's really worth engaging with these people arguing against gentle parenting when they don't actually know what it is and are really looking for gotchas rather than trying to learn about it.

It should be actively respectful of other people’s comfort too. Children need to learn about consideration for others otherwise they become self serving. No isn’t just a one way street.

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 23:22

Sorry, @azimuth299 - I missed your earlier post. I take the idea of natural/linked consequences - but often the actual consequences are either unpalatable or aren’t easy to explain to a small child. So - to take my example upthread - you wouldn’t have said to my DD “if you bite your sister, you won’t be going to the party” because parties and biting have nothing to do with each other. But presumably the actual natural consequence of biting her sister would be to let her sister bite or hit her back? And I don’t want a descent into violence, so I step in and nip it in the bud. And “if you bite your sister, she will remember it and you may, little by little, irreparably damage a relationship which will be really important to you in later life” won’t have a lot of resonance with a three year old. Same with “if you don’t wear your coat you’ll be cold”. That’s fine if you’re prepared for your toddler actually to be cold. Otherwise you presumably take the coat with you (and you have to carry it) and then there’s no actual consequence as they get to have it on at a time of their own choosing and don’t have to learn to follow that instruction. And when a teacher in school says “coats on”, they are unlikely to go through the same rigmarole…..

azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 23:10

It teaches really well about consent because it is actively respectful of children's comfort. It's the gentle parents who are telling children that they don't have to kiss Aunt Marigold if they don't want to. It's the gentle parents who stop tickling when their child laughs and says stop. It's actively pro bodily autonomy.

Again, I'm not sure it's really worth engaging with these people arguing against gentle parenting when they don't actually know what it is and are really looking for gotchas rather than trying to learn about it.

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 22:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Screamingabdabz · 18/06/2023 22:27

SwordToFlamethrower · 18/06/2023 22:19

If we don't teach our kids the word NO, then how are we supposed to teach them about consent?????

I dread these kids becoming adults. I can see so much sexual assault happening.

Exactly - this is how Brene Brown couched it to Russell Brand when he said he felt bad saying no to his daughter. She said if your dd doesn’t learn the word no, what will she draw on when she’s 16 and in the backseat of her boyfriend’s car? Definitely putting it in a context RB would understand!

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 22:27

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

SwordToFlamethrower · 18/06/2023 22:19

If we don't teach our kids the word NO, then how are we supposed to teach them about consent?????

I dread these kids becoming adults. I can see so much sexual assault happening.

Trying2understand · 18/06/2023 22:07

I know several people like this and they really don't see they are doing their children a massive disservice in life.

I also think gentle parenting doesn't mean you don't have firm boundaries - it's how you deal with it when the boundaries are crossed that can be more gentle, but should still have logical consequences etc.

Hardbackwriter · 18/06/2023 21:42

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Absolutely no one has said that you shouldn't explain things to children. I just believe that it should be age appropriate and proportionate to the situation, which I don't think a lot of these monologues about feelings every time the child has the slightest disappointment are. If I'm honest, I think they're much more for the benefit of the parent than the child.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 18/06/2023 21:40

Louise is throwing toys about on a playdate.

1."Stop that right now you little shit!"

2.Mum grabs her by the arm and smacks her bottom . "WE DO NOT THROW!".

  1. "No! Louise! No! Stop that!" Firm voice, mum stare.
  1. "Louise , if you do that again we're leaving !" - and they do leave.
  1. "Louise come here " - they go off or stay to have a chat about behaviour and throwing

6.Louise no darling." in a simpery voice . "If you do that again I'll x,y,z" - x,y,z never happen

7.Parent ignores or "awww isn't she spirited? She has such great imagination. Who knew you can use toy trucks that way?"

Spot the shit parenting. Spot the gentle parenting. Hint.. they don't overlap.

TizerorFizz · 18/06/2023 21:39

“Do not” is pretty similar to “No”. I agree that asking Dc to consider others is important. However very young Dc don’t get this concept easily. They are me me me people until around 3 plus. Sometimes 4. So they might understand their feelings in detail but possibly not. Why do so many DC have these poor behaviour traits when playing? Mine didn’t.

Alwayswonderedwhy · 18/06/2023 21:31

Yanbu. Gentle parenting often equals spoilt little brat in my experience.

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 21:31

I’ve given you several explanations and examples… you seem to be ignoring all explanations which don’t fit into your own narrative.

You’ve given examples of children with special needs where they need to be accommodated differently. Which is entirely fair enough. But it’s a very different scenario.

MagpieSong · 18/06/2023 21:29

switswoo81 · 17/06/2023 16:02

Saw a meme on social media that gentle parenting works on gentle children and I would agree with this. My first is feral and needs strict boundaries she wouldn't have cared if I used gentle explaining..my second is autistic with a speech delay and it would have been so unnecessary to spend ages explaining because she did not have the language to engage with it

I have taught children who have never heard the word no (I know this because a couple of parents have told me) and school is horrible. There isnt always time for an explanation and sometimes ther isn't one. Just no is enough.

I find the ‘No’ thing so weird. No is such an important word! Why on earth would we ban ‘No’? No is so effective in stopping toddlers doing something dangerous.
Even in adult life, it’s so important:
’No, I will not take more hours at work.’
’No, thank you, I’m full/don’t want another drink.’
’No, I will not have sex.’

I never learnt about gentle parenting because I heard so much of the anti-No stuff, it put me off. I explain and try to help them understand their emotions, but I also say no. I actually had a debate about this subject in a baby group a while ago. We should never feel embarrassed or unable to say, ‘No’.

In this case, it sounds as though they might not manage his behaviour brilliantly. Although, I’m sure sometimes mine appear a bit feral. Fingers crossed he will

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 21:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

EnaSharplesStout · 18/06/2023 21:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 18/06/2023 21:15

Screamingabdabz · 18/06/2023 21:06

I might be ancient but does nobody teach their DC to consider others? Instead of all this introspective ‘what are we feeling?’ bollocks we should be saying (in stern voice) ‘you don’t snatch other people’s toys because that is mean and makes them sad’ or ‘you don’t scream like that as it hurts peoples ears’ or ‘we don’t bounce on Aunty Susan’s sofa because that’s disrespectful’ - you should teach your child consideration for others when dealing with their behaviour. Empathy is so important for civilised societies.

Ironically some posters would moan about that too as being too wordy and "explainy" and not actually using the word NO. Grin

azimuth299 · 18/06/2023 21:09

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 20:43

I think most of the issue here is people not understanding what gentle parenting actually is, and think that it means no boundaries, no rules, no consequences. There are plenty of lazy permissive parents out there, and they are somehow being lumped in with gentle parenting. Maybe the concept needs to be rebranded to make it clearer what it is.

What is it then? Because the woman I describe sure as hell thought she was one. And every time it comes up on here, that’s the answer “oh no, they weren’t doing it properly”. (Shades of the “that’s not my Brexit, the one I voted for” in modern political discourse.). Presumably everyone who does it thinks they do it well and effectively, or they’d do something else!

Well there are many books explaining it in detail but I can give a broad brushstrokes explanation.

It's based on authoritative parenting so there are firm enforced boundaries based on appropriate expectations for a child's developmental age. No boundaries or unenforced boundaries would be called permissive parenting.

Gentle parenting also discourages random punishments not linked to behaviour (e.g. "If you answer back then no TV for a week"). Instead the emphasis is on natural consequences ("If you refuse to wear your coat then you will be cold") and for older children logical consequences ("If you draw on the wall then I will take away your pencils").

It teaches children that it's okay to have strong feelings about situations (you can be unreasonably angry that the shop is out of your favourite juice, that's okay). But that behaviour that harms others is unacceptable. Emotions and behaviour are dealt with separately - so you will teach children coping strategies for their emotions and help them understand what makes them feel better. Behaviour is dealt with by clear, often-repeated simple and age appropriate rules and the rules are enforced.

There is also more collaboration between adult and child. So if I notice a pattern of behaviour that I don't like, when the child is calm I might say "It seems like when you come out of swimming at the moment you're really cross, do you know why?" And you'd be surprised how often even very little children will have great thoughts about how to stop those patterns!

Screamingabdabz · 18/06/2023 21:06

I might be ancient but does nobody teach their DC to consider others? Instead of all this introspective ‘what are we feeling?’ bollocks we should be saying (in stern voice) ‘you don’t snatch other people’s toys because that is mean and makes them sad’ or ‘you don’t scream like that as it hurts peoples ears’ or ‘we don’t bounce on Aunty Susan’s sofa because that’s disrespectful’ - you should teach your child consideration for others when dealing with their behaviour. Empathy is so important for civilised societies.

NeelyOHara1 · 18/06/2023 20:58

Another case of well meaning liberal idealism leading inadvertedly to negative outcomes for children.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/06/2023 20:46

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 20:43

I think most of the issue here is people not understanding what gentle parenting actually is, and think that it means no boundaries, no rules, no consequences. There are plenty of lazy permissive parents out there, and they are somehow being lumped in with gentle parenting. Maybe the concept needs to be rebranded to make it clearer what it is.

What is it then? Because the woman I describe sure as hell thought she was one. And every time it comes up on here, that’s the answer “oh no, they weren’t doing it properly”. (Shades of the “that’s not my Brexit, the one I voted for” in modern political discourse.). Presumably everyone who does it thinks they do it well and effectively, or they’d do something else!

When people have described 'gentle parenting' to me, it just sounds like.....parenting.

WimpoleHat · 18/06/2023 20:43

I think most of the issue here is people not understanding what gentle parenting actually is, and think that it means no boundaries, no rules, no consequences. There are plenty of lazy permissive parents out there, and they are somehow being lumped in with gentle parenting. Maybe the concept needs to be rebranded to make it clearer what it is.

What is it then? Because the woman I describe sure as hell thought she was one. And every time it comes up on here, that’s the answer “oh no, they weren’t doing it properly”. (Shades of the “that’s not my Brexit, the one I voted for” in modern political discourse.). Presumably everyone who does it thinks they do it well and effectively, or they’d do something else!

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 18/06/2023 20:24

5128gap · 18/06/2023 20:12

As far as I have observed people in general are not overly prone to believing their feelings are invalid or to sacrificing their own needs in order to be people pleasers. Quite the reverse in fact. Some are of course, but I'd hardly feel its so endemic in the population we need to overhaul parenting styles to prevent it. Seems a little like a solution looking for a problem to me.

Have a read through the hundreds of threads on MN where posters are unable to say no or are terrible of confrontation. Plenty of people pleasers on here.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 18/06/2023 20:22

Tbf , shit parenting is shit parenting. Gentle parenting does not automatically mean shit parenting.

Just like we all agree that kids need boundaries and rules and consequences, but some parents take to an extreme and are too strict, controlling or even abusive and so rigid they can't mould themselves to a child's needs.