Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nottingham Incident: Relatives should be given privacy, not be expected to attend public events

83 replies

tttigress · 17/06/2023 13:30

Obviously it is hard to imagine what relatives of those killed in Nottingham this week are going through.

But surely the best thing to do is give them privacy, not arrange public events and expect them to attend and even speak?

I guess some might say it's their choice to attend. But if you organise an event and give them the option to attend, they might agree while not being in a fit mental state to make a decision. So therefore best not to have an event.

OP posts:
EssexCat · 17/06/2023 14:46

tttigress · 17/06/2023 13:48

By the way, I would have thought from my comments I am actually putting the families of the victims first.

You’re not. And you should know that.

I’m in the sad situation of knowing one of the teenagers and I can wholeheartedly say that they are 100% comfortable with their decisions and choices.

it is absolutely FUCKING nothing to do with you what they do or don’t do while grieving.

Butchyrestingface · 17/06/2023 14:42

I am critisising the University/Council that organise these events and ask the families to turn up while in a vunerable state. I am also critisising the media, I really would not like to be filmed soon after a child of mine died.

It was an invitation, not a Royal Summons. The families were free not to attend if they didn't feel up to it and no-one sensible would have thought any the worse of them for it. The gentleman's family did not attend the first vigil at the university and I didn't see the deceased female student's' brother there either. Totally understandable.

Given the amount of publicity surrounding public vigils, everyone knows there will be cameras and press and photographers present. It's not like they choose to attend unawares. And, if when they get there, the family feel it's too much for them, they can always leave immediately. Again, no-one is going to think worse of them for it.

On the other hand, some family members mind find it comforting to have a space for public, communal mourning and acknowledgement in the immediate aftermath. So to deprive them of that choice because you, as a total stranger, reckon you know what's best for them, is not appropriate, imo.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:40

To be clear I am not saying they were visibly coerced.

What I am saying is it is very possible they were asked to attend and they very clearly agreed and were very positive in their agreement.

However even in their very clear agreement, they may not have made a decision in their long term best interests, the reason they may have been temporarily mentally impaired in their decision making, was because there kid died the day before.

The University/ Council/ Police thus failed in their duty by asking them to make difficult decisions while they were vunerable.

OP posts:
Lifescary · 17/06/2023 14:38

I am not commenting on the Nottingham incident nor criticising anyone involved. I wish everyone the best in this desperately sad time.

I am commenting on what I think is an increasing trend for some, perhaps many, people to exaggerate the grief they feel on the death of someone they barely knew. Sometimes these distant friends organise public events which will be good for them without considering whether it it helpful for the family.

But it is difficult because even in the same family people grieve so differently.

A couple I knew tragically lost a 12 year old daughter. Her death attracted national press interest. The father's grief was helped by the subsequent publicity, the events and the many memorials. The mother's was not helped at all.

Their daughter's secondary school named a recently built library after the girl. The father attended a ceremony at the school, the mother didn't, but no one had thought of her younger sister who went to the same school and hated the fact the library was named after her much loved and desperately missed sister. It didn't help that young child at all.

Avatartar · 17/06/2023 14:34

I think OP is getting a hard time here. I read it as concern for the families suddenly being in the media after this terrible incident

mumda · 17/06/2023 14:32

You'll be asking next if it's a government policy to have this wave of events offering peace and calm from relatives of the recently bereaved.

This public display of grief putting flowers out started as far as I can remember with the death of Diana. The florists like it I assume.
At the queen's mourning they were removing the wrappings which meant it would be easier to clean up the dead flowers.

Sapphire387 · 17/06/2023 14:19

Oh ffs OP, you sound like one of those people who thinks they know other people's minds better than they know themselves. Wind your neck in, let them grieve the way they need to. They may well be feeling a lot of support from having people around them.

Cyllie33 · 17/06/2023 14:17

continentallentil · 17/06/2023 14:12

You are suggesting that no one would have made the decision the families would have made without coercion. That is both patronising and suggests their decision has been poor. So yes, you are criticising them.

They wouldn’t have been pushed to do anything, but their choice to do what they did is perfectly normal valid.

As for media coverage - I imagine they wanted that to feel some purpose. And as you have consumed it yourself, why do you object?

This. You are saying that the families must have been coerced or pressured in grieving in the way that they are - presumably because you think their decision to speak is a poor one.

No. Just no. You do not have the right to judge and police others responses.

As you can see, your - at best - thoughtless thread is now attracting others who say ‘well if that was me I wouldn’t be doing that/couldn’t imagine doing that’. Well it’s not you. Leave them alone.

continentallentil · 17/06/2023 14:12

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:06

I cannot understand how anyone would think from my comments that I am criticising the families.

I am critisising the University/Council that organise these events and ask the families to turn up while in a vunerable state. I am also critisising the media, I really would not like to be filmed soon after a child of mine died.

You are suggesting that no one would have made the decision the families would have made without coercion. That is both patronising and suggests their decision has been poor. So yes, you are criticising them.

They wouldn’t have been pushed to do anything, but their choice to do what they did is perfectly normal valid.

As for media coverage - I imagine they wanted that to feel some purpose. And as you have consumed it yourself, why do you object?

TooBigForMyBoots · 17/06/2023 14:11

I hate Grief Policing. No one should be shoving a camera in their faces, but they are dealing with this the way they want to.

SoTired12 · 17/06/2023 14:09

I find it strange, the first thing on my mind certainly wouldn't be to give a public speech about love and tolerance, but we're all different.

continentallentil · 17/06/2023 14:08

It’s absolutely none of your business, and it’s extraordinary to suggest that they cannot make decisions for themselves. People make decisions under all sorts of pressure all the time. Their grief doesn’t invalid their right to make choices.

If you’ve lost a child it’s perfectly reasonable to feel you want to connect to people, and to make sure your child’s life isn’t in vain by taking about your experience to celebrate your child and to hope it will help build a sense of community and encourage people to take practical action to try and prevent such a thing happening again.

What on earth is the matter with you??

RoseDeWittBukatter · 17/06/2023 14:08

This thread is terrible, almost picking on the families and questioning their motives for speaking out about their wonderful, beautiful children they have lost, that have been murdered. How dare you question why, at this horrendous time, they would want to speak out. This thread needs to be pulled.

IwishIcouldButIcantSoIwont · 17/06/2023 14:08

LegendsBeyond · 17/06/2023 14:01

I’m finding it quite odd that they’re speaking at these public events. One was the day after the killing. I’d just want to hunker down with my family, but I guess people react differently.

I found that odd, too. I suppose the terrible reality might not have hit them yet.

Caravanheaven22 · 17/06/2023 14:07

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:06

I cannot understand how anyone would think from my comments that I am criticising the families.

I am critisising the University/Council that organise these events and ask the families to turn up while in a vunerable state. I am also critisising the media, I really would not like to be filmed soon after a child of mine died.

Totally agree with all you have said

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:06

I cannot understand how anyone would think from my comments that I am criticising the families.

I am critisising the University/Council that organise these events and ask the families to turn up while in a vunerable state. I am also critisising the media, I really would not like to be filmed soon after a child of mine died.

OP posts:
drpet49 · 17/06/2023 14:05

PuffinsRocks · 17/06/2023 13:34

As adults they can choose to attend or not attend. They seem to be processing the tragedy by speaking out and attending events. Everyone processes grief differently and some people want to know that their loved one's life meant something in this world.

This. I noticed that Barnanbys family and friends seem very outspoken

hattyhathat · 17/06/2023 14:03

Each to their own

LegendsBeyond · 17/06/2023 14:01

I’m finding it quite odd that they’re speaking at these public events. One was the day after the killing. I’d just want to hunker down with my family, but I guess people react differently.

SeeIt · 17/06/2023 13:59

Yeah but my point is they are in a mentally vulnerable place, and then you are having a camera stuck in your face. This does not seem right.

A family we know lost a relative in an incident that was very high profile and they would agree with you. At the time they just did what was suggested, they were extremely vulnerable. A few years on, they wish they’d have dealt with things differently as they do feel as though they were exploited and those things are now there forever. They feel it’s added to their pain. I hope the family of this incident don’t feel that way in the future.

Cyllie33 · 17/06/2023 13:55

Just leave the families alone OP. I find it astounding and just so nasty that people start threads or post on social media criticising the way they are grieving.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 13:48

By the way, I would have thought from my comments I am actually putting the families of the victims first.

OP posts:
tttigress · 17/06/2023 13:46

The point is if you have experienced such a recent trauma. Even if you "choose" you might feel pressured into making the decision, or just generally not be able to think straight.

OP posts:
RoseDeWittBukatter · 17/06/2023 13:44

People deal with and express grief in different ways. Be thankful you are not in their position. Let them be free to express what feels right for them. Ridiculous and thoughtless thread OP, leave them be.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 17/06/2023 13:44

tttigress · 17/06/2023 13:39

Yeah but my point is they are in a mentally vulnerable place, and then you are having a camera stuck in your face. This does not seem right.

Who's sticking a camera in their face?

They could stay home if they didn't want to be interviewed?