Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nottingham Incident: Relatives should be given privacy, not be expected to attend public events

83 replies

tttigress · 17/06/2023 13:30

Obviously it is hard to imagine what relatives of those killed in Nottingham this week are going through.

But surely the best thing to do is give them privacy, not arrange public events and expect them to attend and even speak?

I guess some might say it's their choice to attend. But if you organise an event and give them the option to attend, they might agree while not being in a fit mental state to make a decision. So therefore best not to have an event.

OP posts:
Eleganz · 17/06/2023 15:27

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:24

I will stop commenting then.

But all I will say is that it will take 2, 3 or maybe even more years for the families to really know if they wanted to be put in the position by the event organisers.

You have assumed they were put in that position by the "event organisers" - but do you have any evidence for that?

I lost a close friend and colleague to suicide whilst we were studying for our PhDs. I know from firsthand experience that nothing the University organised around that terrible incident was done without fully engagement and agreement with the family.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/06/2023 15:27

LegendsBeyond · 17/06/2023 14:01

I’m finding it quite odd that they’re speaking at these public events. One was the day after the killing. I’d just want to hunker down with my family, but I guess people react differently.

You've no idea how you might feel or react unless you've been in that situation. Stop judging.

titchy · 17/06/2023 15:25

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:18

But I think I am showing empathy.

If this happened to one of my loved ones I would want to curl up in a ball and not leave the house. I know everyone grieves differently but I think 90% of people would be the same/ similar to me.

RE: Funerals. I have "spoken elequently" at the funerals of a couple of grandparents, while at the same time feeling like I was dying inside and not wanting to be there. Again I think must people are similar to me in this regard.

Yeah well maybe they're the 10% that want to show publicly how much their children meant to them.

FFS. Do not ever ever ever criticise grieving parents for the method of their grief.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:24

I will stop commenting then.

But all I will say is that it will take 2, 3 or maybe even more years for the families to really know if they wanted to be put in the position by the event organisers.

OP posts:
Merkins · 17/06/2023 15:23

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:18

But I think I am showing empathy.

If this happened to one of my loved ones I would want to curl up in a ball and not leave the house. I know everyone grieves differently but I think 90% of people would be the same/ similar to me.

RE: Funerals. I have "spoken elequently" at the funerals of a couple of grandparents, while at the same time feeling like I was dying inside and not wanting to be there. Again I think must people are similar to me in this regard.

This is not showing empathy, this is saying, “this is how I’d react so other people should react that way too”.

Brianna Ghey’s mum was interviewed the other day and said she was really lifted by the support of the community after her daughter’s murder and really felt the love that was being shared. Until she came on Mumsnet and saw how people were talking about her family. Maybe think on that?

Eleganz · 17/06/2023 15:21

Those two fully grown adult men chose to speak at that event through their own volition. I think it was incredibly brave of them to do so and their speeches about their children were eloquent, heartfelt powerful and deeply moving. There was absolutely no suggestion whatsoever that they were coerced into being there or were somehow reluctantly speaking.

You have absolutely no right to police their grief or decide how and where they should be present in public.

EssexCat · 17/06/2023 15:20

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:18

But I think I am showing empathy.

If this happened to one of my loved ones I would want to curl up in a ball and not leave the house. I know everyone grieves differently but I think 90% of people would be the same/ similar to me.

RE: Funerals. I have "spoken elequently" at the funerals of a couple of grandparents, while at the same time feeling like I was dying inside and not wanting to be there. Again I think must people are similar to me in this regard.

You’re not. Hope that helps.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:18

But I think I am showing empathy.

If this happened to one of my loved ones I would want to curl up in a ball and not leave the house. I know everyone grieves differently but I think 90% of people would be the same/ similar to me.

RE: Funerals. I have "spoken elequently" at the funerals of a couple of grandparents, while at the same time feeling like I was dying inside and not wanting to be there. Again I think must people are similar to me in this regard.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 17/06/2023 15:14

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:07

@RedGreenBlueSky I actually think is related to the fact that this is every parents worst nightmare.

Therefore the other contributors (for good reason) don't want to think about it, and just want it to not be visible. Therefore the best course of action is to shout at me, without even reading what I wrote. I guess if you had to think about what I wrote, you would have to put yourself in the position of those parents, which obviously you don't want to do because it is so horrible.

What an odd comment when it seems your the one who doesn’t want it to be visible!

Butchyrestingface · 17/06/2023 15:13

Therefore the other contributors (for good reason) don't want to think about it, and just want it to not be visible. Therefore the best course of action is to shout at me, without even reading what I wrote. I guess if you had to think about what I wrote, you would have to put yourself in the position of those parents, which obviously you don't want to do because it is so horrible.

What a load of patronising rubbish. Hardly surprising though, given the way you've consistently tried to infantilise the families, total strangers to you, and deprive them of any agency.

EssexCat · 17/06/2023 15:11

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:07

@RedGreenBlueSky I actually think is related to the fact that this is every parents worst nightmare.

Therefore the other contributors (for good reason) don't want to think about it, and just want it to not be visible. Therefore the best course of action is to shout at me, without even reading what I wrote. I guess if you had to think about what I wrote, you would have to put yourself in the position of those parents, which obviously you don't want to do because it is so horrible.

Sadly for my community we are thinking about. We are having to think about it. We have no choice about it being visible.

And I still think you should be shouted at for being a judgemental prick with not empathy for how your thread might come across if the families saw it.

FKATondelayo · 17/06/2023 15:08

I think YABU and lacking empathy. Attending public events and speaking in public is a natural response to grief and death in many different cultures. Funerals usually take place very quickly in Muslim and Jewish communities for example so the public business of grieving and delivering eulogies takes place in the very early shock period. It's also have noticed this during Black Lies Matters protests - family members speak in public even when the loss is very raw. The response is to raise questions in public and ensure that the victims are not forgotten.

Being with your child's peers and other grieving families so you can talk and digest your emotions may have felt right for the parents. Their children were murdered in a shocking and unexpected way and perhaps the fathers wanted to assure the student community and provide them with leadership and calm the situation down.

Staying at home with your immediate family and keeping your mourning private - this is one way to grieve but not right for everyone. Do you know many parents who have lost children? They will grieve every day of their lives - there will never not be a moment that passes without them thinking about it. They will never be over it, never. The notion that you have to follow the 'steps' and do it in the right order so you will process it properly is a fairly toxic one.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 15:07

@RedGreenBlueSky I actually think is related to the fact that this is every parents worst nightmare.

Therefore the other contributors (for good reason) don't want to think about it, and just want it to not be visible. Therefore the best course of action is to shout at me, without even reading what I wrote. I guess if you had to think about what I wrote, you would have to put yourself in the position of those parents, which obviously you don't want to do because it is so horrible.

OP posts:
Sweetlily99 · 17/06/2023 15:05

YABU

Years ago a friend and colleague died age 27. His mother spoke eloquently at his funeral as we were all.in bits and subsequently came to work to feel/ see where he had spent his days with us.

People process things differently.

They genuinely might be getting comfort from being there and indees bwing with the other families. It's thier choice

EssexCat · 17/06/2023 15:05

And yes I know people are saying ‘it’s down the organisers’ but what if the families requested these events so they can have a chance for a tribute to their beloved children.

Should they have been denied that cos some twat on mumsnet thinks they’re doing grieving wrong?

EssexCat · 17/06/2023 15:03

And as for the child in question. He wants everyone to hear about his sibling and how amazing they were. Let the people close to him who actually KNOW him make decisions for him.

EssexCat · 17/06/2023 15:02

I’m not being ‘weirdly’ harsh. I think they’re a judgemental prick who should think how they would feel if they were being criticised for speaking at a memorial to their murdered child.

RedGreenBlueSky · 17/06/2023 14:58

Everyone's being weirdly harsh on the OP. It feels like one of those threads where the first couple of replies set the tone for everyone else's posts and if the first couple had been in more agreement then there would have been a more mixture of opinions being posted.

I agree with you OP. It's not that the family should not be allowed to do these things but being asked by organisers of the events to appear at a time when they are incredibly vulnerable feels exploitative. Especially when some of the grieving family being filmed for extended periods of time are still children themselves. I don't have any blame or judgement on the family themselves but more on the media / event organisers.

Sirzy · 17/06/2023 14:57

They made the decision that felt best for them at the time. That’s all anyone can do especially at times of grief.

trying to pick apart intention doesn’t help anyone it just leads to unnecessary judgement.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 17/06/2023 14:56

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:40

To be clear I am not saying they were visibly coerced.

What I am saying is it is very possible they were asked to attend and they very clearly agreed and were very positive in their agreement.

However even in their very clear agreement, they may not have made a decision in their long term best interests, the reason they may have been temporarily mentally impaired in their decision making, was because there kid died the day before.

The University/ Council/ Police thus failed in their duty by asking them to make difficult decisions while they were vunerable.

Of course they were invited to attent O_o How odd would it be to hold a memorial and not invite the families. Apparently the Dads decided they wanted to speak, they were not asked by the organisers.

It sounds like they found the support for their children incredibly moving and got to connect with others who cared for them.

Why are you trying to turn a negative spin on an already awful series of events? You sound like an absolute doom merchant.

RoseDeWittBukatter · 17/06/2023 14:52

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:47

Can we just agree these a families are in a vunerable state?

Can you just please stop? Are you enjoying this or something? I find your comments quite upsetting.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:52

My point is if you are in a vunerable state you should not be expected to do much / make any decisions that affect you (your mental health) long term.

OP posts:
cptartapp · 17/06/2023 14:51

As a parent of a student at Nottingham I suspect they just want to be where their DC lived and were making a life for themselves. It must make them feel close to them.
My DM was killed tragically and the support of virtual strangers who were part of her life gave great comfort.
They will still be deep in shock. I certainly couldn't have stood in public and spoken, but I can see how others would and would find it helpful to talk so intimately about those they have lost.

EssexCat · 17/06/2023 14:48

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:47

Can we just agree these a families are in a vunerable state?

So why the fuck do you think you’re helping by this.

People like you make me sick with your faux concern while judging hard.

tttigress · 17/06/2023 14:47

Can we just agree these a families are in a vunerable state?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread