Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no child benefit/tax credits are unfair on apprenticeships?

89 replies

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 12:52

Thanks to a post on here I've found out that as my DD is going to do an apprenticeship I will no longer get child benefit or tax credits for her (I'm currently still on TC due to be UC from November ish but she still won't count as a dependent)

She will be earning £5.28 an hour and I will now have to ask her to make up the difference despite the fact she is 16 and on such a small wage. Her wage will need to cover all her transport and work clothes etc.

We have a very tight budget and no ability to get better jobs or more hours due to disability in the household.

It just seems unfair that if she isn't classed as a dependant anymore she isn't entitled to minimum wage.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 17/06/2023 14:25

The whole point of an apprenticeship is it is a job.
It is a job that you are learning while working and getting paid to do it.
I agree that apprenticeship wages are low but it will be enough for most 16 year olds to live on. You will (or should) no longer being paying for things like their clothes, toiletries, snacks, phone bills, gym membership etc. I don’t think you should be asking for ‘rent’ as such but say you need a small contribution towards the family food bill if you are eating meals as a family (if not they can buy their own food). If they want snacks, takeaways etc they pay themselves. Basically you provide a roof over their head and (some of) the food they eat.
They use their wages for everything else.
You will be making up for your financial loss by not having to pay for the “everything else”.

drpet49 · 17/06/2023 14:24

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:23

Then she should be paid a proper wage. There appears to be this understanding that she won't be earning her money. She will be doing the same job as people over 18/25 that are on the higher NMW.

Because it is an apprenticeship! Not hard to understand OP.

drpet49 · 17/06/2023 14:23

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:21

You absolutely can't ask her for rent and the financial black hole is your problem not hers. I had a mother like you and was expected to pay for for my own glasses, hair cuts and driving lessons while at school and it's ruined our relationship for life. She is not some sort of cash cow she is your daughter, it is your job to support her until she is well in the right path into adulthood, and at age 16 she is nowhere near that.

Great post.

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:23

Whenisitsummer · 17/06/2023 14:11

I think it’s reasonable that child benefits stop when a child is no longer in full time education. The apprenticeship wage is enough to pay for her transport and own clothes. One 16 year old won’t be making a massive difference to household bills which would all still need paid anyway. Getting used to a household income without child element top ups is something that will have to happen at some point.

Then she should be paid a proper wage. There appears to be this understanding that she won't be earning her money. She will be doing the same job as people over 18/25 that are on the higher NMW.

OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:23

Ariela · 17/06/2023 14:14

Why is it shit at 16? Back in the day it was expected you contributed from your Saturday job at 14/15 towards the household expenses.

Not amongst anyone I know it wasn't. I was always in trouble at school for working too many hours waitressing when I should have been studying for exams!

drpet49 · 17/06/2023 14:23

Oliotya · 17/06/2023 13:54

So she'll have like £400 left after transport and board equivalent to child benefit? That's plenty. What other expenses are there that she wouldn't have at school/college?
Apprecentices are paid, college/a-level students aren't. That's why the child benefit rules are different.

This. It is right child benefits are stopped.

EasterBreak · 17/06/2023 14:21

I did it. Earned 800 and gave my mum 400. Easy.

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:21

You absolutely can't ask her for rent and the financial black hole is your problem not hers. I had a mother like you and was expected to pay for for my own glasses, hair cuts and driving lessons while at school and it's ruined our relationship for life. She is not some sort of cash cow she is your daughter, it is your job to support her until she is well in the right path into adulthood, and at age 16 she is nowhere near that.

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:21

Buyyouflowers · 17/06/2023 14:16

You can’t do that! She’s a kid .. you should work more to make up the money!!

You have no idea.

I will have no choice. It isn't possible to magic money

OP posts:
16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:19

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 14:11

But other 16 year olds doing a-levels are spending those hours in school so can't earn at all during that time.

Regard the apprenticeship as continuing her education & equivalent to her attending school each day. If she wants extra money for spends, can she get a weekend/evening job in a shop or cafe like sixth formers do?

If she did A levels I would still get the benefits.
I've said that she will be keeping her weekend job. It just feels unfai- she will be working four days a week, working not learning.

OP posts:
Doggymummar · 17/06/2023 14:18

I paid a quarter of what I earnt from age 16 and had to buy my own non school items. I worked in a shoe shop on a Saturday and did waitressing in the evening. Once family allowance stopped I had to make up the shortfall, noone deserves a free ride

flagpie · 17/06/2023 14:17

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 14:13

Your main issue here is that you are thinking of the apprenticeship as her working & earning money. Really it is not, its a different form of education.

Between you, you should not be worse off as a household with a sixth former studying.

No the main issue is OP is about to lose a substantial amount of benefit each month.

Buyyouflowers · 17/06/2023 14:16

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:06

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.

You can’t do that! She’s a kid .. you should work more to make up the money!!

Ariela · 17/06/2023 14:14

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:06

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.

Why is it shit at 16? Back in the day it was expected you contributed from your Saturday job at 14/15 towards the household expenses.

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 14:13

Your main issue here is that you are thinking of the apprenticeship as her working & earning money. Really it is not, its a different form of education.

Between you, you should not be worse off as a household with a sixth former studying.

Whenisitsummer · 17/06/2023 14:11

I think it’s reasonable that child benefits stop when a child is no longer in full time education. The apprenticeship wage is enough to pay for her transport and own clothes. One 16 year old won’t be making a massive difference to household bills which would all still need paid anyway. Getting used to a household income without child element top ups is something that will have to happen at some point.

ContinuousProcrastination · 17/06/2023 14:11

But other 16 year olds doing a-levels are spending those hours in school so can't earn at all during that time.

Regard the apprenticeship as continuing her education & equivalent to her attending school each day. If she wants extra money for spends, can she get a weekend/evening job in a shop or cafe like sixth formers do?

Waitingforsummer75 · 17/06/2023 14:11

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:06

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.

But if she stayed at school/college which is the only other option at 16 she wouldn't be earning anything.
I don't see it as paying rent, and DS didn't either. Have you spoken to her?

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:08

Oliotya · 17/06/2023 13:54

So she'll have like £400 left after transport and board equivalent to child benefit? That's plenty. What other expenses are there that she wouldn't have at school/college?
Apprecentices are paid, college/a-level students aren't. That's why the child benefit rules are different.

But that should be hers. I will have to ask for her to pay rent at 16, because I still have all the expenses that I would if she was at school or college.

OP posts:
16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:06

Waitingforsummer75 · 17/06/2023 13:59

DS was going to do a post 16 apprenticeship. When we looked at the finances it worked out that roughly the same amount of money would be coming into the household, just in a different way. The child element of UC is about £290 and CB is roughly £100 a month. This will no longer be paid to the parent but to the child.

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.

OP posts:
16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:04

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/06/2023 13:38

OP what was your plan for her when she became 18 and was no longer eligible for CB and WTC? she wouldn't be immediately moving out, or walking into a high paying job, so if the money is that tight, it would have been just as tight in two years time right?

That she would contribute to the household, that whilst I know many never ask their kids to pay it would at least feel as if I'm asking an adult.
It's not just CB, it is tax credits as well.

OP posts:
Waitingforsummer75 · 17/06/2023 13:59

DS was going to do a post 16 apprenticeship. When we looked at the finances it worked out that roughly the same amount of money would be coming into the household, just in a different way. The child element of UC is about £290 and CB is roughly £100 a month. This will no longer be paid to the parent but to the child.

Oliotya · 17/06/2023 13:54

So she'll have like £400 left after transport and board equivalent to child benefit? That's plenty. What other expenses are there that she wouldn't have at school/college?
Apprecentices are paid, college/a-level students aren't. That's why the child benefit rules are different.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/06/2023 13:38

OP what was your plan for her when she became 18 and was no longer eligible for CB and WTC? she wouldn't be immediately moving out, or walking into a high paying job, so if the money is that tight, it would have been just as tight in two years time right?

twinkletoesimnot · 17/06/2023 13:37

Sissynova · 17/06/2023 13:36

The expectation is not that she will support herself it’s that a 16 year old should still be supported by their parents.

What are you expecting her to pay for? I think the bus and things like that would be normal but I wouldn’t expect an apprentice to chip in for the food shop.

But how should OP afford to if a chunk of her income has vanished?

Swipe left for the next trending thread