Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no child benefit/tax credits are unfair on apprenticeships?

89 replies

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 12:52

Thanks to a post on here I've found out that as my DD is going to do an apprenticeship I will no longer get child benefit or tax credits for her (I'm currently still on TC due to be UC from November ish but she still won't count as a dependent)

She will be earning £5.28 an hour and I will now have to ask her to make up the difference despite the fact she is 16 and on such a small wage. Her wage will need to cover all her transport and work clothes etc.

We have a very tight budget and no ability to get better jobs or more hours due to disability in the household.

It just seems unfair that if she isn't classed as a dependant anymore she isn't entitled to minimum wage.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 17/06/2023 15:07

@16notanAdult “learning” isn’t actually compulsory until age 18 at all.
The 3rd option (from the government website) says work a minimum of 20 hours a week while in part time education or training.
So a 16 year old could get a full time job (40 hours) and be “training on the job” - not an official government apprenticeship but just whatever staff training the company does. If the company pays more than minimum wage as standard a 16 year old would probably earn less than older employees because that’s standard but could be more than an apprenticeship wage.
Is that an option she could go for? A relative of mine dropped out of college at 17 (November birthday so during the first term). Changed his weekend retail job to full time, learned on the job and at age 22 is part of the management training program.

Babyroobs · 17/06/2023 15:05

Op maybe you should look at whether you would be better off moving to UC now if you have rent to pay. If you don't currently get housing benefit then you could be significantly better off on Uc and there is no deduction on the Uc rent element until a young adult living with you turns 21 which is helpful to many families with young people still living at home.

flagpie · 17/06/2023 15:03

Surely the £147 is way more than the child tax credit and child benefit for her so I can't see what the problem is,

The money is paid to the DD, not OP, is the problem

Babyroobs · 17/06/2023 15:00

Surely the £147 is way more than the child tax credit and child benefit for her so I can't see what the problem is, especially as you say she is continuing with some weekend work as well, although I appreciate that is going to be hard.

x2boys · 17/06/2023 14:58

Absolem76 · 17/06/2023 14:47

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.
I might be missing something's but why would you have to ask her to pay rent? Did you use the child.benefit/tax credits for rent? I thought that would be used for her clothes, books,lunch money other personal expenses etc and now you don't need to give her any money for those things as she can pay for them herself.

This may blow your mind but many people don't have separate little pots of money to pay for separate things so.My child benefit ,child tax credits all.go on one big pot and all goes towards paying for utilities ,food ,rent ,everything my children need .

Mummysatthebodyshop · 17/06/2023 14:57

Honestly why does it come as a shock to so many that the money stops when they turn 16/18. If only the cash cow moves straight out at that age too huh. What a burden.

Scarlettpixie · 17/06/2023 14:54

If she pays you the equivalent of her CB and pays for all her own stuff like clothes, phone, haircuts, travel and spending money, how much are you actually losing out on by not getting the CTC?

At 15 (summer born) back in the late 80's I got a YTS and from that paid my parents the equivalent of CB which was about a quarter of my income at the time. I paid for all my own stuff and they continued to put a roof over my head (which they would have been paying anyway and for some of my food. I thought that was fair and would do the same with DS if he chose to get an apprenticeship.

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:54

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:40

Driving is a luxury for many. I agree with all you say about the disadvantage of not learning. Haircuts are also a luxury, it isn't appalling to not have the money it is the realistic life of many.
Interesting your use of the word 'fault' regarding money. So many on MN are certain that the poor must be bone idle work shy fuckers. Sometimes the best laid plans go awry.

No, because currently I'm with you on a low income after a spectacularly shitty divorce and having to change careers because I would have killed myself otherwise. What I have done however, is understood what will happen when my kids reach certain ages and planned appropriately. So in the next 3 years when my eldest hits 18 I'll have completed a part time masters done over many years to make it manageable and got enough experience in my new field to hopefully be able to walk back into a highly paid job, just like I had before things went pear shaped. None of this happened overnight and its taken me 5 years to date to turn things around including giving up lots of time to associated volunteer roles to enhance my CV while I'm in a low paid job. None of this shitshow has been the fault of my children and hopefully they haven't missed out on too much compared to their wealthy friends with two high earning parents. It's my job to set them up for a happy and fulfilling life and my job to keep the whole show on the road until they are settled into being an adult. I fully intend to let them be as carefree as possible until they leave Uni (or whatever) and then it's over to them.

Whenisitsummer · 17/06/2023 14:53

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:23

Then she should be paid a proper wage. There appears to be this understanding that she won't be earning her money. She will be doing the same job as people over 18/25 that are on the higher NMW.

She will be paid the same amount as the majority of apprentices in their first year. Its more than 147 per week, it’s approx 800 per month as the college day is also paid.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 17/06/2023 14:49

Absolem76 · 17/06/2023 14:47

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.
I might be missing something's but why would you have to ask her to pay rent? Did you use the child.benefit/tax credits for rent? I thought that would be used for her clothes, books,lunch money other personal expenses etc and now you don't need to give her any money for those things as she can pay for them herself.

I'm not the OP, but I use the CB/UC towards the gas, electric, food bill. If I stop getting the CB/UC then the DC will have to pay towards those.

Absolem76 · 17/06/2023 14:47

But this money goes into the household, I will now have to ask her to pay rent, which seems shit at 16.
I might be missing something's but why would you have to ask her to pay rent? Did you use the child.benefit/tax credits for rent? I thought that would be used for her clothes, books,lunch money other personal expenses etc and now you don't need to give her any money for those things as she can pay for them herself.

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:44

I'm not sure it's unfair - or at least, not any more unfair than it would be to not have a difference. And while it's hard for your household, I only think it's shite in general if there has been an expectation set up that it would be just her money and doesn't involve that contribution to the household.

It is my fault for not looking more into this, as naively thought as learning is now compulsory until 18 it would be covered (she could get £10per hour but with no apprenticeship so no hope of further improvement. )

I just hoped that she'd get a chance to get some money behind her, it just takes away her chances.

OP posts:
JulieHoney · 17/06/2023 14:43

She is getting minimum wage, @16notanAdult .

The Apprentice wage and the NMW for 16 and 17 year olds are exactly the same - £5.28.

My daughter is doing A-Levels and has weekend work, she earns the same rate. Yes, it's extremely low, but it is the legal wage for that age group.

At that level of income (£147 a week) with no expenses except transport and lunch, I would expect her to copntribute to household costs. I did at her age.

Putdownthecake · 17/06/2023 14:41

An apprenticeship isn't comparable to someone else on a proper wage because they have the qualification. It's a way of getting qualified whilst earning a small living. Yes it should arguably be more but she can easily afford her spends.
The problem is op you're reliant on money that has an end date. I also think it's wrong to ask a 16 year old to pay rent. I worked from 15 and always paid for my own hair, phone, driving lessons, fancier shampoo etc. I think that's just general parents teaching their kids if you want nicer things to work for them.

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:40

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:34

Well there was a bit more to it than that 🙄 but having to bust a gut working on top of doing 4 A-levels to pay for what all my friends parents just did automatically was a nail in the coffin. I'm a single mum and to me being realistic is providing for my kids and allowing them to focus on their future. Driving lessons are absolutely not a luxury as you are limiting both life and career choices of you can't get yourself wherever you need to be. It is not your daughter's fault there is no spare money. I can't believe anyone would make their school age child pay for a haircut, that's just appalling! It's not me that needs to be more realistic, you need to take more responsibility I'm afraid!

Driving is a luxury for many. I agree with all you say about the disadvantage of not learning. Haircuts are also a luxury, it isn't appalling to not have the money it is the realistic life of many.
Interesting your use of the word 'fault' regarding money. So many on MN are certain that the poor must be bone idle work shy fuckers. Sometimes the best laid plans go awry.

OP posts:
RamblingEclectic · 17/06/2023 14:40

It can be difficult, especially if you weren't planning for it.

I'm not sure it's unfair - or at least, not any more unfair than it would be to not have a difference. And while it's hard for your household, I only think it's shite in general if there has been an expectation set up that it would be just her money and doesn't involve that contribution to the household.

I suggest, if possible, to discuss her applying for better paying apprenticeships. In my area there are more coming out around this time for September starts. The minimum wage for apprenticeships is low and in some fields it is a lot harder than others to get above that minimum, but there are Level 2 and Level 3 apprenticeships that pay well and have good training.

With my teens, we discussing the needs of the household, their own needs, and what their time is worth (minimum for 32 hours is very different to 45), and we set a minimum salary for searches and only go below that if it ticks every single other box and/or has other compensation that counteracts it like a higher amount of holiday time (which has only happened once). I'm wary of apprenticeships that pay the absolute minimum, especially if it's a larger company or they have far more listings than fits their size, it just gives a feeling of taking advantage to get staff at low costs and there have been quality questions and horror stories out there. They should be learning on the job, not just working. Apprenticeships - especially for a 16 year old - should be training focused.

Needmorelego · 17/06/2023 14:37

@16notanAdult but she is going to be getting a wage at 16. A low wage yes but a wage plus a second wage if she keeps her weekend job.
So she/your household will have wage + wage but if she went to 6th Form/College it would be child benefit + wage. Still 2 lots of money.
It’s always been that CB stops when a 16 year old leaves education and gets a job. The job (in her case the apprenticeship) replaces the CB.
(I do agree apprenticeship wage is low and also think it’s ridiculous that full minimum wage doesn’t kick in until age 22)

Mumoftwoinprimary · 17/06/2023 14:34

How does your current tax credits / child benefit compare with the £147 a week she’ll get? (Less the travel costs.) I don’t think it is appropriate for her to be able to save her wage whilst the tax payer covers her living costs. As an A level student can’t do this. But - as a household - your family shouldn’t be worse off because she is doing the apprenticeship.

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:34

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:26

Thankfully my daughter is a little more realistic.
I can not believe that you hate your mother because she made you pay for haircuts and driving lessons. My DD has been paying for haircuts/extras since she started working at 15 as there is no money. Driving lessons are a luxury.

Well there was a bit more to it than that 🙄 but having to bust a gut working on top of doing 4 A-levels to pay for what all my friends parents just did automatically was a nail in the coffin. I'm a single mum and to me being realistic is providing for my kids and allowing them to focus on their future. Driving lessons are absolutely not a luxury as you are limiting both life and career choices of you can't get yourself wherever you need to be. It is not your daughter's fault there is no spare money. I can't believe anyone would make their school age child pay for a haircut, that's just appalling! It's not me that needs to be more realistic, you need to take more responsibility I'm afraid!

flagpie · 17/06/2023 14:33

There appears to be this understanding that she won't be earning her money. She will be doing the same job as people over 18/25 that are on the higher NMW.

So is every 16 year old in work. Unless they have been exceptionally lucky to get a job that pays them more than the NMW

titchy · 17/06/2023 14:33

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:21

You absolutely can't ask her for rent and the financial black hole is your problem not hers. I had a mother like you and was expected to pay for for my own glasses, hair cuts and driving lessons while at school and it's ruined our relationship for life. She is not some sort of cash cow she is your daughter, it is your job to support her until she is well in the right path into adulthood, and at age 16 she is nowhere near that.

Of course she can! She's not at school, she's working. Is it fair that a 16 year old has several hundreds of pounds a month to spend on Nando's and makeup, and OP has no disposable income at all?

She's presumably chosen the apprenticeship rather than college - that's the consequence. When kids could leave education at 16 a few years back, no one expected that they wouldn't contribute to the household once they were earning.

Oliotya · 17/06/2023 14:29

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:08

But that should be hers. I will have to ask for her to pay rent at 16, because I still have all the expenses that I would if she was at school or college.

Yes but what do you think she should be spending her money on other than living expenses?

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:28

Needmorelego · 17/06/2023 14:25

The whole point of an apprenticeship is it is a job.
It is a job that you are learning while working and getting paid to do it.
I agree that apprenticeship wages are low but it will be enough for most 16 year olds to live on. You will (or should) no longer being paying for things like their clothes, toiletries, snacks, phone bills, gym membership etc. I don’t think you should be asking for ‘rent’ as such but say you need a small contribution towards the family food bill if you are eating meals as a family (if not they can buy their own food). If they want snacks, takeaways etc they pay themselves. Basically you provide a roof over their head and (some of) the food they eat.
They use their wages for everything else.
You will be making up for your financial loss by not having to pay for the “everything else”.

This is more or less what will happen and I completely agree from 18, but 16 seems a harsh. She will have no chance to save etc.

OP posts:
MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 17/06/2023 14:28

Yanbu.

16notanAdult · 17/06/2023 14:26

TheSnootiestFox · 17/06/2023 14:21

You absolutely can't ask her for rent and the financial black hole is your problem not hers. I had a mother like you and was expected to pay for for my own glasses, hair cuts and driving lessons while at school and it's ruined our relationship for life. She is not some sort of cash cow she is your daughter, it is your job to support her until she is well in the right path into adulthood, and at age 16 she is nowhere near that.

Thankfully my daughter is a little more realistic.
I can not believe that you hate your mother because she made you pay for haircuts and driving lessons. My DD has been paying for haircuts/extras since she started working at 15 as there is no money. Driving lessons are a luxury.

OP posts: