Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not invite friend because of SEN child

539 replies

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 11:54

I know I’m going to get roasted here so I will try to give all the information.
Myself and a few friends have been discussing getting a villa for a holiday next summer. There are 5 families all with children aged 6 to 13. We all went to uni together with another friend who has two boys. Her eldest (10 years old) is on the pathway and I feel fairly confident that he is neuro-diverse. Maybe autism or ADHD but has traits of both. So far, we haven’t invited her but now we are looking for villas we need to make a decision if we are going to or not. She is a lovely, sweet woman and we would have no question if it wasn’t for the impact on the group that her eldest has. He is not safe to be left unsupervised with the other kids. In the past there has been constant issues ranging from rough play, making threats and impulsive unsafe actions to punching and throwing things at the others.
He’s very bright, articulate and thoughtful boy and thrives on adult interaction. Away from other kids, I enjoy spending time with him a lot.
During play dates and get togethers we tend to take it in turns to supervise the kids and he is generally much better behaved when watched and any major danger can be stopped. It’s also easy to spot triggers like competitive games. He is also better when there are fewer kids. If we go to a villa (with a swimming pool) supervising him will be impossible and we want to have a break and just let the kids have a bit of freedom. The other children are all old enough and sensible enough to listen to instructions, such as you can’t go to the pool area.
His mother does her best but when she supervises him his behaviour is much worse for her. Her youngest is well behaved so I don’t feel it’s particularly bad parenting, just a stressed out single parent with few resources left to deal with a very hard to parent child. She also has a physical disability which can sometimes stop her being able to intervene. If he was my child I would take him for regular breaks, providing calming strategies, give clear boundaries and follow through but he isn’t and I can tell her how to parent.
I don’t think she realises how bad it is because this has always been her situation, but it’s constant. The group get on so well when he’s not there. There is no need to get involved, other than the occasional requests for food etc and it’s really relaxing. When he is there it is drama the entire time. I think he just doesn’t have the social skills to mix in a big group and he get’s overstimulated. However, I know my friend would be devastated if she thought they were being excluded.

YABU - You are being unreasonable to exclude someone because of SEN

YANBU - You are not being unreasonable to want a relaxing holiday and only invite who you want to

OP posts:
susie25 · 17/06/2023 22:31

Absolutely never said anybody ought to be responsible for making life "fairer" or indeed the anybody should be expected to babysit....

Actually, lots of people said they should draw up a babysitting rota whereby all the adults took turns each day to supervise him. I think that is a ridiculous idea. I do fully agree however that they should have discussed this with her first. Everyone is assuming she would be happy with this plan but several parents in this thread have rightly stated they’d be deeply uncomfortable with handing over responsibility of their child to someone else whilst on holiday, especially if they exhibited challenging behaviour. Many also said they’d have no interest going anyway in which case it’s a moot point.

Screwballs · 17/06/2023 22:27

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 22:23

Absolutely never said anybody ought to be responsible for making life "fairer" or indeed the anybody should be expected to babysit....

This was in response to a post where the general desire was a right to a holiday and leave the other children roaming about the pool unsupervised which seems wholly unrealistic. This in itself is a ridiculous expectation to me.

Further ridiculous was that a group of friends have gone as fa as sourcing a holiday villa they like and already decided who it will/won't suit, without considering one of their friends. Ridiculously sad.

I agree it's sad. I agree it's unfair. I just also think there are no winners here full stop, they don't take her, they feel shit but the holiday is better, they do take her, the holiday is shit but they feel better. Life is genuinely unfair. It fucking sucks. I get that.

SoccerStars · 17/06/2023 22:26

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 21:56

It’s not selfish to want to prioritize their own families and themselves at times. They matter too, their children matter too. So do you and yours.

By the sounds of it you all do regularly include her, but that doesn’t mean that everything has to revolve around her. It’s perfectly reasonable to want to relax on holiday and not be constantly on guard to the degree they would have to be if her child was there.

I agree all the children matter. I was a ND kid and far from shoving people out the way I was anxious about getting in the way or tripping up due to coordination issues etc. being around a child like the OP describes -would have really set me on edge and feeling rushed the whole time in case I moved too slow for his liking. But because I wasn’t vocal about my needs and masked a lot, like many girls, I’d just have been sitting there silently stressed.

Hopefully none of the kids there have those issues and aren’t going to be feeling on edge.

I really hope it all works out for everyone!

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 22:23

susie25 · 17/06/2023 22:18

Just imagine never being able to contemplate a coffee break never mind a holiday away in a vila..... oh wait

I don’t get this perspective at all. So, because you can’t have a coffee break no one else is allowed to ever go on a relaxing holiday with their families? They should be punished so as to make life “fairer” in some way? The OP has already said they help their friend out by regular babysitting and having him overnight so she can have a break but that’s clearly not good enough right? They should all act as his full time nanny on holiday as well and let their kids get hurt or injured because you don’t get a coffee break. Don’t be so ridiculous.

Absolutely never said anybody ought to be responsible for making life "fairer" or indeed the anybody should be expected to babysit....

This was in response to a post where the general desire was a right to a holiday and leave the other children roaming about the pool unsupervised which seems wholly unrealistic. This in itself is a ridiculous expectation to me.

Further ridiculous was that a group of friends have gone as fa as sourcing a holiday villa they like and already decided who it will/won't suit, without considering one of their friends. Ridiculously sad.

susie25 · 17/06/2023 22:18

Just imagine never being able to contemplate a coffee break never mind a holiday away in a vila..... oh wait

I don’t get this perspective at all. So, because you can’t have a coffee break no one else is allowed to ever go on a relaxing holiday with their families? They should be punished so as to make life “fairer” in some way? The OP has already said they help their friend out by regular babysitting and having him overnight so she can have a break but that’s clearly not good enough right? They should all act as his full time nanny on holiday as well and let their kids get hurt or injured because you don’t get a coffee break. Don’t be so ridiculous.

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 22:18

Screwballs · 17/06/2023 21:57

Just because that is your reality, doesn't mean it should be everyone else's.

Entirely correct.

That said, equally correct is the genuinely most sad reality here is that a complete discussion in a large group of "friends" has occurred along with this thread, all while this parent is in the dark.
In this poor woman's shoes and with "friends" like this I think OP and her friends' are doing her a favour.

Majority of SEN parents as so eloquently described upthread are used to their own children because there's no choice and also are used to exclusion, the judgement and woeful lack of understanding shown consistently on threads such as these. The lack of humanity from so many, specifically "friends" though is what stings hardest.

Merryoldgoat · 17/06/2023 22:09

I’m not a single parent but I’m the parent of two autistic boys, 10 & 5.

I would love a holiday with friends but wouldn’t even consider taking my boys and they don’t have the negative behaviours described.

Have you actually spoken to her? If she were me and you came to me suggesting that I’d laugh, thank you for thinking of including me but give it a hard pass.

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 22:00

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 21:52

It’s unclear. I think everyone feels guilty and loves our friend and would be devastated if she felt left out. But selfishly feel the holiday would be a totally different thing if they come.

And tbh I don’t think it is unclear. If they wanted her there I think they’d be quick to vocalize that. Based on what you’ve said it seems obvious they don’t want her there, but don’t want to say it outright.

Screwballs · 17/06/2023 21:57

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 21:48

Just imagine never being able to contemplate a coffee break never mind a holiday away in a vila..... oh wait

Just because that is your reality, doesn't mean it should be everyone else's.

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 21:56

OP you sound worse and worse with every post.
So he threatens and hits other children?
It's obvious that, as a group, you are not 'exclusive' of this woman and her son. But consider whether a group holiday situation with this child is a good idea.
So what if someone gets injured on of the 'other' parents watch. Will that parent of the child forgive them?

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 21:56

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 21:52

It’s unclear. I think everyone feels guilty and loves our friend and would be devastated if she felt left out. But selfishly feel the holiday would be a totally different thing if they come.

It’s not selfish to want to prioritize their own families and themselves at times. They matter too, their children matter too. So do you and yours.

By the sounds of it you all do regularly include her, but that doesn’t mean that everything has to revolve around her. It’s perfectly reasonable to want to relax on holiday and not be constantly on guard to the degree they would have to be if her child was there.

FelisCatus0 · 17/06/2023 21:55

SomethingNastyInTheGenePool · 17/06/2023 21:45

@FelisCatus0 You’ve missed my point by a mile, unsurprisingly.
So let me spell it out. I wasn’t saying I regard the little girl as an obstacle. I was trying to show how a neurodiverse child who is hyperfocused on an objective might be seeing things at that moment.

There is no evidence this boy is ND. I think the OP did a disservice writing SEN in the title. From what I read, it's his mother's parenting perhaps with ADHD.

Even if he had ASD, they can still be taught to watch out for other obstacles, er, people.

pinkginfizz9 · 17/06/2023 21:54

I think whiif you dont invite him she will be hurt and angry and MIGHT end the friendship, but unlikely as she will still want your support.
People's faults are magnified 100x when yu are living with them. You will very likely all resent this child being there by the end of teh week , if it adbersely affects yours or yor children's enjoyment.Dont invite them.Dont make her problems yours!
Not your circus.Not your monkeys!

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 21:52

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 21:46

Is there group consensus that the friend should be invited?

It’s unclear. I think everyone feels guilty and loves our friend and would be devastated if she felt left out. But selfishly feel the holiday would be a totally different thing if they come.

OP posts:
BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 17/06/2023 21:52

I wouldn't blame the boy if I was the girls parent but I wouldn't risk my daughter being hurt again. If that meant I was excluded so be it but I would also start reconsidering friendships in that case.

Thinkbiglittleone · 17/06/2023 21:51

He isn’t malicious or mean he just does stuff in the moment. So, for example, if one of the kids has something he wants and he can’t wait he will threaten them or sometimes hits out. He gets upset if he isn’t first to play with something or doesn’t win or he needs to wait for stuff. But he can be very loving and kind. He will give his sweets away or help one of the others do something. Also he is hilarious and has a lot of fun energy

This is nice that you acknowledge he isn't doing it maliciously as you have said before. And there are simply elements he struggles with due to his autism. It also nice that you acknowledge that you believe it's not due to "bad parenting" as a lot of people who don't understand Autism, see it as.

I do understand a PP mentioning the "moving an obstacle out of the way". Obviously to the majority of other people that would be pushing another child out of the way to get to the top first, which is obviously unacceptable. And while some children with Autism will know that is wrong and unacceptable, some simply don't process the empathy to see the child as little person will get hurt, they see their end goal, wholly focus and attempt to achieve it. But every case of ASD is different.

OP sounds like you have made a good choice in inviting everyone with different cabins and see who wants to come.

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 21:50

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 21:48

Just imagine never being able to contemplate a coffee break never mind a holiday away in a vila..... oh wait

Why? The friend having it rough isn’t their fault, and it’s not something they have to ‘make up’ to her by having a holiday they don’t enjoy.

Kanaloa · 17/06/2023 21:48

And it really doesn’t matter a bit whether he pushed her to hurt her or because she was an ‘obstacle.’ The end result is that a young girl was pushed off a climbing frame. And from the sounds of this boy (who threatens to hurt people when they won’t give him something) he is aware of his actions and their impact. Either way not acceptable. There were times when my son unfortunately just wasn’t able to access play parks at busy times because he would hurt others. It wasn’t his fault as such. He simply could not control himself to behave appropriately. That did not and does not lessen the impact it has on other children if they’re hurt or terrorised by my child. So we went to the parks crazy early or a bit late, or just accepted that they weren’t suitable for my son’s needs while he was still hurting other people.

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 21:48

ripplingwater · 17/06/2023 13:37

I agree. This doesnt sound like a holiday, it sounds like work. Its hard enough keeping an eye on your own kids on holiday let alone other people's.

Just imagine never being able to contemplate a coffee break never mind a holiday away in a vila..... oh wait

Kanaloa · 17/06/2023 21:46

BungleandGeorge · 17/06/2023 21:06

How old was this child when he shoved the girl out of the way? He’s 10 now so presumably under 10 so it wouldn’t be assault as children of that age aren’t legally culpable due to immaturity of thought. And how old was the girl? Old enough to be at the top of a climbing frame without supervision? It’s not exactly unusual for one child under 10 to shove or knock another one out of the way. There’s lots of ways adults could have prevented it

It’s not usual or acceptable for 10 year olds to hit, push others off climbing frames, or threaten to hurt others when they want something from them. It’s not something anyone has to tolerate. It would be doing everyone, including the boy, a huge disservice to give the impression that it’s ok to be hit, hurt, or scared by him.

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 21:46

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 21:44

No, but they are the ones who are more against. I think they would probably be persuaded by the group consensus

Is there group consensus that the friend should be invited?

SomethingNastyInTheGenePool · 17/06/2023 21:45

@FelisCatus0 You’ve missed my point by a mile, unsurprisingly.
So let me spell it out. I wasn’t saying I regard the little girl as an obstacle. I was trying to show how a neurodiverse child who is hyperfocused on an objective might be seeing things at that moment.

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 21:44

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/06/2023 21:04

OP, have the parents of the girl who was hurt said they definitely won’t go if the other woman and her DC are invited?

No, but they are the ones who are more against. I think they would probably be persuaded by the group consensus

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 17/06/2023 21:43

Donkeyotey · 17/06/2023 21:36

I think this is one of those situations where you just have to do the right thing. It's going to mean a crappier holiday for all the rest of you but I think you've got to just suck it up and be kind.

Most people's lives are like a non-stop holiday compared to a lot of special needs parents' lives. Be a friend, invite her, spend time supervising and engaging with the child on the holiday. Don't worry about the other children - it will be a lesson for them in how to be kind and tolerant (a much better lesson than the one you would be teaching them if you exclude this child and your friend).

Why shouldn’t the worry about the other children? Does their enjoyment of the holiday not matter? Is it acceptable for them to shoved, threatened and injured?

People always say that it’s a lesson in kindness and tolerance, yet equally it can be a lesson in simmering resentment, and even ensure out and our dislike of the person well intentioned parents are encouraging tolerance of.

quitefranklyabsurd · 17/06/2023 21:41

”I don’t think she realises how bad it is because this has always been her situation, but it’s constant.”

believe me she realises. And your list of things you’d do if he was your son!?! Jog on love. He’s not and you’ve no idea what her day to
day life is like.

she’ll feel isolated enough as it is without you planning your relaxing holiday without her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread