Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not invite friend because of SEN child

539 replies

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 11:54

I know I’m going to get roasted here so I will try to give all the information.
Myself and a few friends have been discussing getting a villa for a holiday next summer. There are 5 families all with children aged 6 to 13. We all went to uni together with another friend who has two boys. Her eldest (10 years old) is on the pathway and I feel fairly confident that he is neuro-diverse. Maybe autism or ADHD but has traits of both. So far, we haven’t invited her but now we are looking for villas we need to make a decision if we are going to or not. She is a lovely, sweet woman and we would have no question if it wasn’t for the impact on the group that her eldest has. He is not safe to be left unsupervised with the other kids. In the past there has been constant issues ranging from rough play, making threats and impulsive unsafe actions to punching and throwing things at the others.
He’s very bright, articulate and thoughtful boy and thrives on adult interaction. Away from other kids, I enjoy spending time with him a lot.
During play dates and get togethers we tend to take it in turns to supervise the kids and he is generally much better behaved when watched and any major danger can be stopped. It’s also easy to spot triggers like competitive games. He is also better when there are fewer kids. If we go to a villa (with a swimming pool) supervising him will be impossible and we want to have a break and just let the kids have a bit of freedom. The other children are all old enough and sensible enough to listen to instructions, such as you can’t go to the pool area.
His mother does her best but when she supervises him his behaviour is much worse for her. Her youngest is well behaved so I don’t feel it’s particularly bad parenting, just a stressed out single parent with few resources left to deal with a very hard to parent child. She also has a physical disability which can sometimes stop her being able to intervene. If he was my child I would take him for regular breaks, providing calming strategies, give clear boundaries and follow through but he isn’t and I can tell her how to parent.
I don’t think she realises how bad it is because this has always been her situation, but it’s constant. The group get on so well when he’s not there. There is no need to get involved, other than the occasional requests for food etc and it’s really relaxing. When he is there it is drama the entire time. I think he just doesn’t have the social skills to mix in a big group and he get’s overstimulated. However, I know my friend would be devastated if she thought they were being excluded.

YABU - You are being unreasonable to exclude someone because of SEN

YANBU - You are not being unreasonable to want a relaxing holiday and only invite who you want to

OP posts:
SpudleyLass · 17/06/2023 23:35

I would decline OP - given that you had the conversation with me. I would appreciate that you had the fortitude to actually discuss it with me.

If you choose to keep the woman in the dark about this holiday, well only you know your friend on here - we don't. I would personally end friendships over not being told. Perhaps your friend would feel differently.

I don't think the group as a whole are being totally unreasonable in respect of this particular child .

Fwiw though, my DD who is disabled in a similar way, went abroad with cousins (all NT) for the first time in May.

She was never a problem - THEY were. You and your friends will probably find they won't get much of a holiday in, regardless.

Palomabalom · 17/06/2023 23:34

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 23:04

Yeah, this is a better solution.,..

Agree. You can’t go through with the idea because it means leaving your friend and her son out which would be really upsetting. I don’t think I could forgive that myself. Unless you are relaxed about hurting her and her son deeply and losing the friendship- you need to rethink. The idea isn’t compatible with the dynamics in your group. Just book in smaller apartments or just go on holiday where you can have the odd meet up. Staying together will be difficult with so many I’d imagine and the wants and needs, the frustrations.

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 23:30

It's not exactly ethical but it solves both issues, unless of course she is loaded in which case this isn't going to help as she will probably say yes.

If she was loaded, wouldn’t she be able to not only get a diagnosis of sorts for him without likely having to deal with the 2 year wait and hire someone to help her with him?

Sheselectric77 · 17/06/2023 23:25

@AscensionToCheese she is lucky compared to some people with sen dc yes.

She is very cheeky to expect her friends to deal with challenging behaviour because it’s easier for her. She is not being a good friend to the op or the other people in the group. I’d be absolutely mortified if my dc hurt my friends dc and I would make damn sure I was on my feet at every meeting to prevent it happening again. Does she not care about the op dc or other dc in the group? Does she not consider the feelings of her friends? If that’s true it’s no wonder people want to exclude her. If she was actively doing everything to prevent others getting hurt or threatened then there would be no problem and this thread wouldn’t exist. If there was the occasional incident but she dealt with it and stepped up I’m sure the group would be more understanding and not even questioning inviting them but evidently the problem lies because she decides not to parent her dc.

DragonCatcher · 17/06/2023 23:24

I have read all the replies but this would be my idea...

You could invite her but tell her the price is far higher than it is. She will probably decline the invite due to cost and you've got the no you wanted. I'd also sell it as we're going to relax, etc. Maybe she will realise it's not suitable as a destination for her eldest and decline?

It's not exactly ethical but it solves both issues, unless of course she is loaded in which case this isn't going to help as she will probably say yes. If she does say yes, obviously don't overcharge her! Just say you calculated wrong and you're so glad she can come.

FelisCatus0 · 17/06/2023 23:17

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 22:48

@FelisCatus0 if you are frightened to talk to them they you aren’t friends. That isn’t how friendship works.

That sounds great in theory, but that theory taken to it's logical conclusion; mumsnet wouldn't really exist. Or least Relationships/AIBU wouldn't exist because so many women post on here about problems with their husband that they're too afraid to talk to their husband about. Also MILs. Parents. And, yes, friends. So unless we're saying your spouse, mother/father, MIL etc aren't your friends, your sentence makes sense in theory but not in practice.

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 23:16

Kanaloa · 17/06/2023 23:07

Yes, if a hypothetical child didn’t know that shoving someone off a climbing frame hurt that child then it wouldn’t be assault as such. However, it would then be the parent’s fault as they had left a child with no understanding of others in a very unsafe position. Either way it’s of course not acceptable!

No it isn’t acceptable, and this mum may well not be supervising this kid properly but it’s irritating that so many posters presume that all ND kids are prone to this type of thing and have parents who think it’s okay, and the NT kids don’t do it (largely because they are better parents).

It’s a false and depressing assumption

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 23:11

giraffetrousers · 17/06/2023 16:41

I agree with this 100%. There was a point when my dad had severe dementia, and my mum had died and I was trying to care for him and work full time and juggle two kids aswell as dealing with horrific perimenopause anxiety that I was on the verge of having a nervous breakdown. There is absolutely no way I would have been able to take on the responsibility of supervising another person's child with challenging behaviour on holiday. I simply couldnt physically or mentally handle it. It has nothing to do with "being kind" or whatever, I was at my absolute stress limit and it would not have been possible for me to do that.

I'm also a bit surprised that people are suggesting a different person supervise him every day on holiday- that seems like a recipe for disaster to me- a different parenting approach for him to cope with every single day for a child who already struggles with new situations and boundaries. Its not comfortable at all disciplining someone else's child when you arent familiar with their triggers or personality. I can see this turning into an absolute disaster and actually being really detrimental to the boy in question thus making his behaviour worse, not better.

The thing is, parents of ND kids go through all these life stresses AND have a ND child to care for at the same time.

I agree caring for him on a rota is daft though… apart from anything, poor kid knowing he is such a burden people have to draw straws for the job of being with him!

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 23:10

Sheselectric77 · 17/06/2023 23:04

To add to my earlier post and my experience is that most parents on sen dc will be the ones to manage them and supervise them. As I said my dc dies not display these challenging behaviours but if she did and any extra care of supervision she does need is my problem and up to me to do. I wouldn’t dream of sitting back and expecting others to deal with care or unwanted behaviour. That is my dc and my responsibility. It is selfish if op friend to do this to her friends. I get she is probably exhausted and needs a break but she is being very unkind to her dc and her friends group. regardless of nd or anything else it sounds like some of this boys behaviour is down to passive parenting. I would not tolerate spending time with someone who can’t be bothered to parent their dc and expects others to step in. That would be more reason not to invite her than the actual behaviour.

I would invite her though and as I said I wouldn’t mind helping with dc who genuinely have additional needs but in this situation I would expect the parent to be doing the care and supervision and if she knows he is likely to hurt anyone then she needs to be on top of him all the time. If she fails to do this and he is hurting others or making threats then I’d have no problem having a conversation with her clearly stating that she needs to supervise ds as he is hurting the other dc and we will not continue to tolerate that. I’m sure she would anyway because I find it hard to believe that a parent will just sit back while her dc hurt others, if this is honestly what she does then she is not a person I would consider a friend.

Op surly you can invite her knowing she will look after her dc. If not then she is not your friend anyway she is a cf.

Actually, compared to most of the other SEN parents on here who are isolated, excluded with no help. OP's friend is extremely lucky indeed!
OP has babysat, one of the other couples 'has him loads'. Friend does get a break seeing as she 'gladly steps away'. All OP's words.
They have play dates and get togethers...

It's just this holiday.

Kanaloa · 17/06/2023 23:07

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 23:04

Yeah, but she didn’t say this particular kid, she made a general statement. I’m just pointing out that as a general statement it’s untrue.

Yes, if a hypothetical child didn’t know that shoving someone off a climbing frame hurt that child then it wouldn’t be assault as such. However, it would then be the parent’s fault as they had left a child with no understanding of others in a very unsafe position. Either way it’s of course not acceptable!

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 23:04

Kanaloa · 17/06/2023 23:01

A child who is able to threaten to hurt other children who don’t do as he likes does understand cause and effect though. So in this case it’s irrelevant. In fact, in any case it’s irrelevant, because if a child doesn’t understand that pushing others hurts them then they must always be extremely closely supervised to stop others being hurt.

Yeah, but she didn’t say this particular kid, she made a general statement. I’m just pointing out that as a general statement it’s untrue.

Sheselectric77 · 17/06/2023 23:04

To add to my earlier post and my experience is that most parents on sen dc will be the ones to manage them and supervise them. As I said my dc dies not display these challenging behaviours but if she did and any extra care of supervision she does need is my problem and up to me to do. I wouldn’t dream of sitting back and expecting others to deal with care or unwanted behaviour. That is my dc and my responsibility. It is selfish if op friend to do this to her friends. I get she is probably exhausted and needs a break but she is being very unkind to her dc and her friends group. regardless of nd or anything else it sounds like some of this boys behaviour is down to passive parenting. I would not tolerate spending time with someone who can’t be bothered to parent their dc and expects others to step in. That would be more reason not to invite her than the actual behaviour.

I would invite her though and as I said I wouldn’t mind helping with dc who genuinely have additional needs but in this situation I would expect the parent to be doing the care and supervision and if she knows he is likely to hurt anyone then she needs to be on top of him all the time. If she fails to do this and he is hurting others or making threats then I’d have no problem having a conversation with her clearly stating that she needs to supervise ds as he is hurting the other dc and we will not continue to tolerate that. I’m sure she would anyway because I find it hard to believe that a parent will just sit back while her dc hurt others, if this is honestly what she does then she is not a person I would consider a friend.

Op surly you can invite her knowing she will look after her dc. If not then she is not your friend anyway she is a cf.

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 23:04

Sillybanana · 17/06/2023 23:03

I would honestly rather forget the whole thing rather than lose a friend or at the very least hurt her feelings terribly. Maybe just go on holiday with one of the other families rather than all of them.

Yeah, this is a better solution.,..

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 23:04

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 22:57

OP literally said this:

I’m seeing one of the other couples tomorrow and I’m going to suggest cabins or something similar where we can all have our own space. If the couple who are most against don’t want to come then I think that’s preferable to the alternative.

But don’t let that stop you from criticising her..

I stand by what I said - she is minimising the potential risk to other children, and putting this friend above the couple whose daughter was hurt.
PP have expressed this more eloquently than me if you go back to previous posts.

Sillybanana · 17/06/2023 23:03

I would honestly rather forget the whole thing rather than lose a friend or at the very least hurt her feelings terribly. Maybe just go on holiday with one of the other families rather than all of them.

Kanaloa · 17/06/2023 23:01

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 23:00

Shoving is only intentionally hurting someone if the person understands cause and effect. If they don’t understand that shoving someone = the person getting hurt then they aren’t intentionally causing harm.

A child who is able to threaten to hurt other children who don’t do as he likes does understand cause and effect though. So in this case it’s irrelevant. In fact, in any case it’s irrelevant, because if a child doesn’t understand that pushing others hurts them then they must always be extremely closely supervised to stop others being hurt.

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 23:00

FelisCatus0 · 17/06/2023 21:32

@SomethingNastyInTheGenePool I forgot to add this and posted too quickly ; shoving IS intentionally hurting someone. It is the opposite of accidentally bumping them.

Two, it is very obvious from what OP has said that this most definitely is the result of bad parenting. She doesn't even watch her own son or respond to him.

Shoving is only intentionally hurting someone if the person understands cause and effect. If they don’t understand that shoving someone = the person getting hurt then they aren’t intentionally causing harm.

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 22:57

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 21:56

OP you sound worse and worse with every post.
So he threatens and hits other children?
It's obvious that, as a group, you are not 'exclusive' of this woman and her son. But consider whether a group holiday situation with this child is a good idea.
So what if someone gets injured on of the 'other' parents watch. Will that parent of the child forgive them?

OP literally said this:

I’m seeing one of the other couples tomorrow and I’m going to suggest cabins or something similar where we can all have our own space. If the couple who are most against don’t want to come then I think that’s preferable to the alternative.

But don’t let that stop you from criticising her..

Zanatdy · 17/06/2023 22:53

I voted YABU but I don’t think you are unreasonable really. I just think the impact on her of not being invited will be huge and potentially devastating when I’m sure she would use all the friends she’s got. But I get it that you want a break too.

AscensionToCheese · 17/06/2023 22:50

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 22:23

Absolutely never said anybody ought to be responsible for making life "fairer" or indeed the anybody should be expected to babysit....

This was in response to a post where the general desire was a right to a holiday and leave the other children roaming about the pool unsupervised which seems wholly unrealistic. This in itself is a ridiculous expectation to me.

Further ridiculous was that a group of friends have gone as fa as sourcing a holiday villa they like and already decided who it will/won't suit, without considering one of their friends. Ridiculously sad.

But they haven't 'sourced a villa'. They've only looked at options. So a group holiday isn't a done deal.
Having already established that suitable villas exist and are financially viable, the next step is setting expectations.
Holidays are expensive - if people don't want to spend all that money then deal with friend's son they are well within their rights. I don't think the kids are going to have ZERO supervision. But a child that needs to be watched extra closely because he has no impulse control is very different from kids that you can keep half an eye on, especially if they will be with older children.

I suspect this will all fall apart, and people will all go on their individual holidays, or maybe in smaller groups. Which is the best all-round solution IMO.

BananasandPiglet · 17/06/2023 22:48

FelisCatus0 · 17/06/2023 16:12

People saying they should talk to the parent. But as shown on here, parents of children with SEN get their backs up and are very defensive. And, often victim-blame other children. OP might feel to frightened to speak to her friend, I know I would be, just by the way SEN parents on here act. It's no wonder she sought (what she thought would be) a safe space on here to seek guidance.

@FelisCatus0 if you are frightened to talk to them they you aren’t friends. That isn’t how friendship works.

VestaTilley · 17/06/2023 22:43

YANBU, and your first priority needs to be the safety of your own DC. But, if I were your friend I’d be devastated, and it would be really hard to stop her finding out. Why do you need to go away as a big group? Can’t you just go away with one other friend or your own immediate family?

DoubleShotEspresso · 17/06/2023 22:35

Screwballs · 17/06/2023 22:27

I agree it's sad. I agree it's unfair. I just also think there are no winners here full stop, they don't take her, they feel shit but the holiday is better, they do take her, the holiday is shit but they feel better. Life is genuinely unfair. It fucking sucks. I get that.

Exactly no winners whosoever, I suspect the fact that this conversation has happened whilst this mother remains oblivious. In her shoes his is what I suspect she will find most hurtful, she is already well used to the rest I am sure.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/06/2023 22:34

I feel like this needs to be said again: if mum is getting no break then that is DAD’S fault.

It’s outrageous that one of this friendship group getting called all sorts of names has this kid overnight when his own father doesn’t.

Where is the outrage for the male parent, rather than the women who apparently have to parent a random child or else they’re selfish bitches?

angelicaelizapeggy · 17/06/2023 22:32

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 17/06/2023 16:27

I don’t understand why some posters on here seem to think that stress is exclusive to being a ND child parent, and therefore the need of a holiday is greater for that woman than anyone else. Someone posted a link to it being comparable to a soldier in combat.

Sure. It is unbelievably stressful.

But so is dealing with illness, suspected illness, a dying parent, a dependent parent with Alzheimer’s, job stress, impending threat to employment, divorce, mental health issues…

No one here knows what the other families are dealing with, or how much they might need a holiday. Why does this woman have to be prioritised above the safety and needs of everyone else? It seems like some posters seem to think as they experience the stress of having an ND child, nothing can be ‘worse’ or make someone ‘more deserving’ than they. And that’s wrong.

But generally parents of SEN children will also face those sorts of issues at the same rate as everyone else.

So yes, generally speaking SEN parents are having a tougher time than NT parents, all those other examples effect all types of parents.