Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not invite friend because of SEN child

539 replies

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 11:54

I know I’m going to get roasted here so I will try to give all the information.
Myself and a few friends have been discussing getting a villa for a holiday next summer. There are 5 families all with children aged 6 to 13. We all went to uni together with another friend who has two boys. Her eldest (10 years old) is on the pathway and I feel fairly confident that he is neuro-diverse. Maybe autism or ADHD but has traits of both. So far, we haven’t invited her but now we are looking for villas we need to make a decision if we are going to or not. She is a lovely, sweet woman and we would have no question if it wasn’t for the impact on the group that her eldest has. He is not safe to be left unsupervised with the other kids. In the past there has been constant issues ranging from rough play, making threats and impulsive unsafe actions to punching and throwing things at the others.
He’s very bright, articulate and thoughtful boy and thrives on adult interaction. Away from other kids, I enjoy spending time with him a lot.
During play dates and get togethers we tend to take it in turns to supervise the kids and he is generally much better behaved when watched and any major danger can be stopped. It’s also easy to spot triggers like competitive games. He is also better when there are fewer kids. If we go to a villa (with a swimming pool) supervising him will be impossible and we want to have a break and just let the kids have a bit of freedom. The other children are all old enough and sensible enough to listen to instructions, such as you can’t go to the pool area.
His mother does her best but when she supervises him his behaviour is much worse for her. Her youngest is well behaved so I don’t feel it’s particularly bad parenting, just a stressed out single parent with few resources left to deal with a very hard to parent child. She also has a physical disability which can sometimes stop her being able to intervene. If he was my child I would take him for regular breaks, providing calming strategies, give clear boundaries and follow through but he isn’t and I can tell her how to parent.
I don’t think she realises how bad it is because this has always been her situation, but it’s constant. The group get on so well when he’s not there. There is no need to get involved, other than the occasional requests for food etc and it’s really relaxing. When he is there it is drama the entire time. I think he just doesn’t have the social skills to mix in a big group and he get’s overstimulated. However, I know my friend would be devastated if she thought they were being excluded.

YABU - You are being unreasonable to exclude someone because of SEN

YANBU - You are not being unreasonable to want a relaxing holiday and only invite who you want to

OP posts:
GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 12:20

Caszekey · 17/06/2023 12:15

Well you know she's going to be devastated when you don't invite her, so not sure what yo u want from this thread. Presumably you're all in agreement that her son isn't welcome.
Presumably this is only going to keep on happening as the kids get older and more independent and her son doesn't keep pace so perhaps it's better making the break now so she can find friends who can support her

We aren’t all in agreement. There are one family that are particularly against inviting them. They have a Dd who has been injured by him in the past. He pushed her at the top of a climbing frame because she would get out of his way and she fell off.
Im on the side of inviting them to preserve the friendship and I feel so sad at the idea of him be excluded (he’s honestly the sweetest boy). Maybe we have to re-think the whole thing.

OP posts:
electriclight · 17/06/2023 12:20

Unless he is physically violent, I would invite them and make it tactfully clear that this is a relaxing holiday and an opportunity for the children to swim and have some freedom unsupervised.

Then it is her choice - join you but know that she will be the only parent heavily supervising her child, or make an excuse because it will be too difficult.

Personally, I would rather be invited and make the choice myself than be excluded. You will also then be able to maintain the friendship even if she doesn't come.

I suppose you would be taking the chance that she might come and not be able to supervise him enough, or that there would be conflict between the children, but there are so many of you that this would be diluted and I would rather risk that that devastate her, end a friendship and show my kids that it's ok to exclude a friend in a tough position.

Normative · 17/06/2023 12:20

Oh gosh this sounds very tricky and awkward.
I have a difficult child and am aware that he changes the dynamics of a group he’s in and have started to decline invitations to things like this as the other children get easier with age and he gets more challenging.
Have you had conversations with her about his behaviour before or has it all been glossed over?

MrsPerfect12 · 17/06/2023 12:20

Could she actually afford to go?

BMW6 · 17/06/2023 12:19

Well obviously it's a terrible dilemma and there doesn't appear to be a one-size-fits-all solution.
It's very sad that ND children are so often excluded but other children's safety must be paramount also.

winewolfhowls · 17/06/2023 12:19

I think you should invite her.

If it was just a few people having a restful holiday no would be ok but with loads of people including kids it's not going to be a relaxing style holiday anyway really.

He doesn't sound all that difficult tbh, and as you said the kids were old enough to be trusted with instructions then they are old enough to follow instructions like no competitive games.

I would be absolutely devastated if I was this lady and you left her out.

titchy · 17/06/2023 12:19

If the other 10 adults plan a rota to focus on him, and the younger/older kids (whichever he feels more affinity with) - take them out for the morning, play football with them, play water polo, then each adult should in theory get five or six days of relaxation knowing the difficult kid is being looked after by someone else. Could that work?

ExtraOnions · 17/06/2023 12:18

Another day, another thread of ableist bullshit.

It’s lonely enough being the parent of a child with additional needs, without your friends excluding you

If you know his triggers do something else with him.

TBH his behaviour doesn’t sound that different to lots of other children of that age (ASD or not), kids fall-out, fight, and can react before they think. I take it you are one of those parents whose children have never misbehaved.

so leave her out, let her find some new friends who’s are much much much less judgey than you and your “parenting strategies”

My (now 17 year old) ASD daughter was very much like this, luckily for me instead of excluding me, my family and friends realised thar my need for support was greater than their desire to be sat back with a glass of Prosecco.

Excluding your stressed out, single parent, physically disabled friend … and making it seem like you are the victim .. wow

Annoyingnamechangerperson · 17/06/2023 12:17

I think if you do this you’re basically removing her from the friendship group.
If I were her I’d never speak to any of you again.
I’m not even saying YABU as it sounds like a really difficult situation.

I imagine excluding someone because their child has SEN behaviours that they can’t help would be pretty hard to get over as a parent.

Mrsjayy · 17/06/2023 12:17

Surely it Is going to be chaos with that many people anyway it doesn't sound 1 bit relaxing so your friend and son would be in the chaotic mix, I think you will damage your friend ship if you don't invite them, I would be hurt if it was my family you were leaving out.

Carrusa · 17/06/2023 12:16

btw it is normal in a group that some of the older ones start gravitating away from the kids towards the adults as they hit puberty. Just be mindful that things may shake out differently as they grow up. There's. phase where "the kids" are a gang together and can be supervised as a group, but they do move past that. If it doesn't work well this year, it doesn't mean it won't in future.

Caszekey · 17/06/2023 12:15

Well you know she's going to be devastated when you don't invite her, so not sure what yo u want from this thread. Presumably you're all in agreement that her son isn't welcome.
Presumably this is only going to keep on happening as the kids get older and more independent and her son doesn't keep pace so perhaps it's better making the break now so she can find friends who can support her

InsomniacVampire · 17/06/2023 12:15

I can assure you she realises extremely painfully how bad things are.

Londonlassy · 17/06/2023 12:14

Just realise if you do this it will most likely irrevocably alter the friendship. So you need to decide what’s more important a group holiday or this friendship. As a mother of a ND child I could not maintain a friendship with so - called friends if they did this to me. I also wonder if you realise OP how many- multiple times ND children and their families are excluded it’s relentless and crushing

forrestgreen · 17/06/2023 12:14

You sound like you know how to deal with his issues well, but do the other adults?
How will they feel having to take their turns?

My arse is on the fence, I can see why it would be more fun and easier without him

How will friend react? Is there any chance of dad having him for a week, or grandparent. It's def give mum the needed break

TolkiensFallow · 17/06/2023 12:13

I wonder if she’d actually want to come? Could you moot “we were all thinking of a holiday” without specifying hotel/apartments or a big shared villa. She might think the idea of taking him abroad is hell on earth and not want to come… in which case you can get the villa. Whereas if she wanted to come you could look at separate apartments or hotel?

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 12:13

BMW6 · 17/06/2023 12:10

Is it possible to go to the same place without all staying together? So you all get a break from each other and can meet up in smaller groups too?

That's a thought. Does he enjoy being around lots of children himself or does he prefer small groups or no other children?

His behaviour is mostly fine with adults. He will gravitate towards the kids so part him him clearly prefers the company of kids he just doesn’t seem to be able to cope with the dynamics.

OP posts:
WolfFoxHare · 17/06/2023 12:13

I don’t think you’re unreasonable for wanting a relaxing holiday where the kids play happily amongst themselves without drama. But the cost of that will probably be your friendship, or at least the cost will be that you get what you want while deeply hurting your friend.

MedievalMadness · 17/06/2023 12:12

What a difficult situation. If you all go together no one really gets a break. If you go without your friend and her DS, they don’t get a break. Holidays are expensive and YANBU to go only to be frazzled and unrested. I’d hate to leave my friend out so think I’d just abandon the idea of a group holiday for the time being, even though that’s a shame.

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 12:12

MuchuseasaChocolateTeapot · 17/06/2023 12:09

I know this isn’t a nice thing to ask but could he stay with his father while your friend and younger DC comes with you? It doesn’t sound much fun for the eldest if new situations/extra children make him worse and it sounds like his mum and sibling could use a break.

He wouldn’t have him even if we did suggest it

OP posts:
BMW6 · 17/06/2023 12:10

Is it possible to go to the same place without all staying together? So you all get a break from each other and can meet up in smaller groups too?

That's a thought. Does he enjoy being around lots of children himself or does he prefer small groups or no other children?

neverbeenskiing · 17/06/2023 12:10

If he was my child I would take him for regular breaks, providing calming strategies, give clear boundaries and follow through but he isn’t and I can tell her how to parent.

You lost me at this. I've spent my whole adult life working with children and families including those with SEN. I thought I knew it all, until I had my own child with SEN and I realised that a lot of the advice I'd happily been dishing out for years was bollocks. Well intentioned bollocks, but bollocks nonetheless. So many of the "strategies" that are claimed to benefit ND kids are devised by NT adults and do not work in reality. It's so easy to give advice, or to think you know what you would do but the 24/7 reality of parenting a child with SEN is something you really can't understand until you've lived it.

You are entitled to have the holiday you want, so YANBU to leave her out of it if you don't think it's going to be a good fit. But it does sounds like you judge her parenting and I'd be willing to bet she's not oblivious to this.

GameOverBoys · 17/06/2023 12:10

Hellishforest · 17/06/2023 12:09

It’s very unfair to exclude her if the rest of the group are going. Could you stay somewhere where each family has their own space so it’s not so intense and people can retreat as necessary.

This is a good idea

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 17/06/2023 12:10

Not inviting her is a terrible idea.
There are lots of adults around, and in a villa with a pool the children should NEVER be unsupervised - telling them to not go near the pool isn't supervision, it’s the very opposite. I would never put a close friend in this position.

Carrusa · 17/06/2023 12:10

"However, I know my friend would be devastated if she thought they were being excluded."

This is the nub of it. However you justify it to yourselves, whatever the poll says or how many people tell you YANBU, there is no way to exclude your friend and her family without it being extremely hurtful. It IS personal, and there's no use pretending otherwise.

It's possible she wouldn't even want to go, but that wouldn't stop the sting at all.