Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL too much??

62 replies

123456789jx · 16/06/2023 21:52

I’ve been with my BF 5 years and lived together for almost 3. He moved in due to the lockdown and by the time it was over we we bought our first house together. When the lockdown eased we switched between my family home and his before moving out. It meant we got to know each others families pretty well and got really close.

I really feel as though I am part of their family, as he is with mine. Everyone celebrates everyone’s achievements, birthdays etc. it’s been amazing and I wouldn’t change that aspect but…

Christmas this year was planned to the hour so we could be as fair as possible between all our family. All our siblings, parents, grandparents etc. long story short, last minute changes from MIL meant that they missed out on some of our time. Everything seemed fine at the time so I didn’t think much of it. Had a great Christmas and everyone got on fine.

Anyway, a couple of times in January there were a few comments from her that I didn’t appreciate, e.g. ‘we get you guys next Christmas’ and ‘I can’t wait for our turn to have you all day next year’. She even suggested going abroad as a family for Christmas. I didn’t really think about it as I realise it’s 11 months away.

since then there has been the odd snarky comment. All about how we spend so much more time with my family than his, how we get more excited to see them, how we get them better birthday presents. She has also spoken to extended family members about how disappointed she was over the XMAS issue. I don’t think any of this is true. We stick to budgets and eat dinner once a fortnight with each family. We may be more excited to spend time with my family, but that’s only because my sister lives far away and she often travels down to see us.

now it’s Father’s Day coming up and the obvious thing is for me to spend it with my Dad, and BF to spend it with his. MIL has booked a day out in London including expensive tickets for activities, and has included me in the booking, without asking first. I told her that I would speak to my Dad and see what his plans are and that I was very grateful, however I thought it was assumed that I would not be available that day because I’d be with my own Dad. She told me that my family got me on Christmas, so they get me on Sunday.

BF is obviously on my side with this, and has confronted her saying that it was her own fault for booking without asking me first, and to stop using Christmas as an excuse, but they got in a pretty heated argument. They are now not speaking, and BF has said that he will plan his own thing for his Dad to celebrate Father’s Day, but I can’t help but feel awful. He has 2 little siblings who were looking forward to it, and his dad is the one meant to be celebrated, not punished for his wife’s behaviour??

should I just suck it up and go?? Apologise and make different plans for my dad (who is amazing and laid back and understands the predicament and told me to do whatever I think is best)?? Tell BF that he’s being unreasonable?? AIBU??

OP posts:
CmonYouKnow · 16/06/2023 22:10

God help you if you have children!

saraclara · 16/06/2023 22:09

It's bizarre that she thinks that she had more right to your presence on father's day than your father!

It's unfortunate that is caused a row, but she's being totally illogical.

Going by your OP, it was MIL's last minute change of plan that caused the Christmas issue. Had that been pointed out to her? It's almost as if she's trying to avoid recognising her own fault by trying to balance out your presence.

What's your FIL's take on all this? Does he agree with her?

Frogger8395 · 16/06/2023 22:06

You’ve created a rod for your own back by trying to be fair. Scale it back. Go and see your families on your own sometimes and stop telling her how often you see them or what gifts you bought.

hattyhathat · 16/06/2023 22:04

If you marry or have kids she will be 10x worse

WeWereInParis · 16/06/2023 22:04

Do not go. You're MIL needs to learn that she cannot do this. If you give in she'll do it again.

I would really really stop with the planning everything to make sure everything is even - dinner with each family once a fortnight (would all hell break lose from MIL if you had to miss one of "her" days?), planning Christmas to the hour to make it "fair". You can't keep this up - sometimes you'll see someone a bit more, and I wouldn't have a set up where MIL felt like she could get annoyed and demand more time in return.
If you want children and end up having them with your partner, this will become an absolute nightmare.

SuchiRolls · 16/06/2023 22:02

Do what works best for you. You’ve not done anything wrong and if you pander to her she’ll just move on to something else. She sounds like a petulant child. 🙄

Isolationendurance · 16/06/2023 22:02

You must stick to your guns and go to your dad. Do encourage your partner to make it up with his mum but not at the cost of indulging whatever little power trip she's currently on.

BashfulClam · 16/06/2023 22:01

See your dad, you have finite fathers days so spend them with him. Mil needs to get her head out of get arse and I’d cancel Christmas etc and do what you want. You are not toys that everyone gets a turn with.

takealettermsjones · 16/06/2023 22:01

Go and see your own dad! Your response was more than polite, I think I'd have just said "sorry I can't, I'm seeing my father on father's day."

The Christmas issue is absolutely one of the most annoying things in modern life imo! It's one day and people get hysterical. I went abroad with DH one year and bloody hell, you'd think I'd told them all I hate them rather than I'm spending three days on a city break!

Aria2015 · 16/06/2023 21:59

Honestly, set boundaries now!! You're grown adults, she's not entitled to your time or your partner's. I wish I'd not been so obliging to my now in-laws. 20 years down the line and the expectation is to spend every significant occasion with them. Birthdays, Christmas, Easter, Mother's Day, Father's Day. We have kids now and they have zero consideration for the fact we'd maybe like to do things 'just us' or make our own family traditions. I hate it and I deeply regret setting the precedent that we have.

ConcernedCatmother · 16/06/2023 21:59

No don’t suck it up. The MIL is a self centered cow. Be glad your bf stood up for you, many don’t!

IamSmarticus · 16/06/2023 21:56

No - absolutely don't just suck it up and go! Go and see your own dad, MIL should not have booked anything for you without checking first.

Swipe left for the next trending thread