Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sudden act of aggression

189 replies

Itismeghan · 16/06/2023 21:32

I need some advice on what to do please. Been with husband over 15 years. There’s been no violence or abuse in this time. Then tonight when my 10yo was taking ages to have her drink/snack before bed, ignoring him telling her to hurry up, he lost it and grabbed hold of her and pulled her across the room. She banged her arm on a table and got a red mark. I comforted her and told him he shouldn’t have done that and he said sorry to her and we put the kids to bed. I’ve confronted him about it and he said he shouldn’t have done it but didn’t think it was as serious of an issue as I was making out. He’s upstairs in bed because I said I didn’t know if I could move on from it.

OP posts:
flagpie · 17/06/2023 08:24

@PoseyFlump

And yet you took my comment to @Dita73 as referring to you when I was talking about the 2am poster that had just addressed them. Not you.

I didn't take it to mean me specifically. But you were talking plurally so I did think it included me.

Stop hijacking the thread and accusing @Dita73 of 'being in a similar situation'.

It wasn't an accusation it was a 'I wonder if...?'

I'm not hijacking the thread btw, I have as much right to post as anyone else. I'm not trying to shut anyone down either. I may not agree with others but I don't have the right to tell people not to post, neither do you. Repeatedly posting the same thing in the hope that someone somewhere stops defending violence against children isn't hijacking.

You've clearly never been on the receiving end of a truly violent man.

Correct. I heeded the warning signs.

PoseyFlump · 17/06/2023 08:19

Im not the subject of the thread though

And yet you took my comment to @Dita73 as referring to you when I was talking about the 2am poster that had just addressed them. Not you.

Stop hijacking the thread and accusing @Dita73 of 'being in a similar situation'. You've clearly never been on the receiving end of a truly violent man.

Itismeghan · 17/06/2023 08:07

AcrossthePond55 · 17/06/2023 01:30

If this truly was a one off, I think a key factor here is how he behaves tomorrow. By that I mean that he should be able to have a calm and rational discussion with you about this incident and about his behaviour. He should be able to listen to you calmly express your feelings about what happened without becoming defensive, rationalizing his actions, or defending his behaviour. He should be willing to explore what may have made him react the way he did and accept that the responsibility for it is all on him, not on DD for 'acting up'.

If he becomes angry, if he tries to sweep it under the rug, or tries to DARVO, those are red flags.

But I agree with others that you need to consider his past behaviour very carefully. Not simply whether or not he's ever become violent with you/DD in the past but also yelling, sulking, or 'disappearing' because he's angry/unhappy. Also patterns of behaviour outside the home. I'm talking about road rage (including yelling inside the car), anger/problems with coworkers, arguments/grudges with friends or relatives. People with nasty tempers are very good at directing them towards certain people they perceive as 'safe' (ie won't fight back) or during certain events. The problem is that they can't always control it and it often spills over into other 'channels'.

Good advice. I will do this today. There’s no yelling or road rage of anything, the only thing he does, maybe once a year, is sulk, if we argue about something.

OP posts:
Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 08:04

johnd2 · 17/06/2023 07:59

Yes the dynamic is certainly different because the child is vulnerable and physically and mentally incapable to stand up for themselves.
Surely that doesn't make it better?
Yes you can get away with it with a child - with an adult you'd be more likely to have a reckoning upcoming, for example they would go no contact.
Just because a child doesn't have the same options as an adult doesn't mean that it's not essential to have a reckoning in the same way as with an adult.

So in the situation I saw that I described her with the mother and preschooler - would you have called police and social services and described her as violent and assaulting her child? Would you want the desired outcome to be no further contact with her child / children?

What would you have done in this dynamic where her child was vulnerable and the mother exasperated? Would you have stepped in yourself in the moment to protect the child and separate from the child from their mother?

Itismeghan · 17/06/2023 08:02

Thanks for all of the advice. It’s been helpful to read, mostly. To the posters making assumptions that I’m soft on my child and let her get away with things that’s absolutely not the case. She’s well behaved most of the time, it’s not often situations like this arise.

OP posts:
johnd2 · 17/06/2023 07:59

Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 07:25

I agree too that being physically aggressive in the heat of the moment is different than doing something with the intention to harm.

The other day in the store I saw a mother who was clearly exasperated with her young 3ish year old child pick him up and plunk him into the cart with far more physical force than was necessary. In that moment she was clearly physically aggressive due to her frustration and wanted to send him a message. Was what she did wrong - yes. Do I think it means her child should be removed from her care and she should be charged with assault and seen as an abuser and denied any further parental role - no.

But yes if I saw an adult pick up another adult using physical force and fling them into a chair in a physically aggressive manner, I would have a different reaction to it. Parent-child dynamic is not the same as adult-adult.

Yes the dynamic is certainly different because the child is vulnerable and physically and mentally incapable to stand up for themselves.
Surely that doesn't make it better?
Yes you can get away with it with a child - with an adult you'd be more likely to have a reckoning upcoming, for example they would go no contact.
Just because a child doesn't have the same options as an adult doesn't mean that it's not essential to have a reckoning in the same way as with an adult.

flagpie · 17/06/2023 07:39

PoseyFlump · 17/06/2023 07:33

Did I always get it right? Fuck no. Absolutely not. What I didn't do was hurt my children, physically or mentally.

In your opinion. We might judge your actions differently if we knew what you did 'wrong'. It's heartening to see most posters here agree that expecting a relationship to end over this event is an overreaction. Yes, a serious chat needs to be had but LTB? Don't be silly.

Im not the subject of the thread though, so your judgement on me is irrelevant.

Make your judgement on the violent man in question without using other peoples behaviour to justify it.

Me saying I'm not perfect is simply because so many people are sarcastically saying people must be perfect to make a harsh judgement here. No, no I'm not but it doesn't matter either way because it makes no difference to the child in the OP, the only thing that will make a difference to her is her mother's protection. It's all too common situation and the replies on this thread alone just highlight how women are so quick to minimise and excuse the red flags as they start to be raised.

PoseyFlump · 17/06/2023 07:33

Did I always get it right? Fuck no. Absolutely not. What I didn't do was hurt my children, physically or mentally.

In your opinion. We might judge your actions differently if we knew what you did 'wrong'. It's heartening to see most posters here agree that expecting a relationship to end over this event is an overreaction. Yes, a serious chat needs to be had but LTB? Don't be silly.

Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 07:25

I agree too that being physically aggressive in the heat of the moment is different than doing something with the intention to harm.

The other day in the store I saw a mother who was clearly exasperated with her young 3ish year old child pick him up and plunk him into the cart with far more physical force than was necessary. In that moment she was clearly physically aggressive due to her frustration and wanted to send him a message. Was what she did wrong - yes. Do I think it means her child should be removed from her care and she should be charged with assault and seen as an abuser and denied any further parental role - no.

But yes if I saw an adult pick up another adult using physical force and fling them into a chair in a physically aggressive manner, I would have a different reaction to it. Parent-child dynamic is not the same as adult-adult.

Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 07:21

If every parent who had ever gotten angry at their child and verbally yelled at them or physically manouvered them in anger was removed from the home, there would be a lot of parentless children.

When I was stroppy teen, my mother lost it one day. She threw a number of objects at me and said some really horrible things to me. I can still vividly remember it to this day as it was so out of character for her to lose it. And even then, I did realize my role in it and that I had pushed her too far. However do I think she should have been removed from the home and cut off from myself and my siblings - no. We have a very good relationship as adults.

OP, if this was rooted in his childhood (versus stress or a poor relationship with your daughter or an anger management issue) it might be good for him to get some counselling. I am sure he feels horrible about it, even if he minimized it in the moment of being accused. Talk to him and talk to your daughter and find a way forward. How would you want him to react if you lost it one day and pulled your child by the arm or screamed at her?

goosebumps · 17/06/2023 07:16

hotpotlover · 16/06/2023 22:26

If he's genuinely remorseful and it was a one off and he's feeling bad about it, I think it can be forgiven.

I think every single parent in this world had their moments they aren't proud of and where they could have done things better.

That's just my opinion and I'm aware most people on this thread won't agree with me.

I do agree with this too. If it really was a one off and he's apologised to her and explains to her it was very wrong and will never happen again, then surely it doesn't need to be the end of your marriage. If he keeps dismissing it as not a big deal, then that's a different situation. Good luck, it's a horrible situation for you.

pastelmagenta · 17/06/2023 06:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

flagpie · 17/06/2023 06:27

@Dita73 I wouldn't bother replying to them. There's some batshit crazy replies on here. Probably drunk 😂

I'm not drunk, I obviously have a different opinion to many (not sure why when we are talking about a man hurting a child) but that doesn't mean I am drunk. Why is it that no one seems to be able to converse about this without resetting to put downs towards others?

You are right. This is not a situation for massive overreaction. If half the posters on MN are to be believed, there must be a lot of mental pressure on people in real life to be perfect.

I'm not perfect. I don't think anyone is. It's possible to be less than perfect without resorting to violence though. Violent men are dangerous. That's an absolute fact that cannot be denied.

I also agree with the PP who said they've seen punishment threads on MN that are more worrying. Cold, calculated behaviour rather than heat of the moment.

Yeah I'm not a fan of that weird need to control children by being horrible to them either. It's not a one of the other situation. I managed to raise mine without dishing out cunty punishments or violence. Did I always get it right? Fuck no. Absolutely not. What I didn't do was hurt my children, physically or mentally.

MisschiefMaker · 17/06/2023 06:24

Goodness me. Big overreaction by the OP. I think it's clear why your DD knows she doesn't have to respect your boundaries. Good luck for the teenage years...

PoseyFlump · 17/06/2023 06:04

@Dita73 I wouldn't bother replying to them. There's some batshit crazy replies on here. Probably drunk 😂

You are right. This is not a situation for massive overreaction. If half the posters on MN are to be believed, there must be a lot of mental pressure on people in real life to be perfect.

I also agree with the PP who said they've seen punishment threads on MN that are more worrying. Cold, calculated behaviour rather than heat of the moment.

medicallycomplicated · 17/06/2023 05:46

GottaGirlcrush · 16/06/2023 23:38

If this was a frazzled mother it would be a case of a thread full of supportive posts

Nobody would be telling her to leave

Yep!

CockyTeeHunz4Eva · 17/06/2023 05:43

Toenailz · 17/06/2023 03:55

I agree, some massive overreactions here, by lots of people acting like they have never got cross and behaved in not the best light.

I doubt dad was just angry she was taking too long to eat/drink before bed. Does no one think kids of that age are clever enough to purposefully drag out the time it takes to do a task before bed, to avoid bedtime? Give over. I tried it on when I was a kid (and got put right pretty fucking quickly!) OP said herself 'she was ignoring him', and from the tone of the post I'm willing to hedge a bet it happens a lot that she ignores her parents, and mum defends children, and dad lost his temper today. I also think he's being treated a lot differently than if it were a woman that lost her temper with her child, going from posts I've seen, including ones where they've smacked their children, and still been told by mumsnet 'it's okay, no ones perfect'.

There's a lot of bratty-ass children being raised, to ignore their parents/those responsible for them. I don't think the go to answer should be dragging them across the room, of course, though I can certainly see how it happens to children who choose not to respect what their parents say and behave obnoxiously toward them. Parents are, after all, responsible for setting rules for children. The kids don't get to choose on some of them, thems the breaks.

I'd be questioning why she was ignoring her dad, and what I and he could do to prevent that behaviour next time, and move on from it. I have a feeling they take the piss out of him, and you encourage them by being soft on them.

I don't condone hitting, dragging, or anything of the sort. Simply saying, I understand how it can happen, this wasn't a smack. He told her to do something, she ignored him, he took her arm and walked fast the direction he'd told her to go, and her arm got accidently knocked. Maybe none of this would have happened if a) you and him were on the same page as to how to deal with these behaviours, b) he maybe educates himself on how to deal with the behaviours and c) then you together, work on your children not ignoring their parents.

I think you and your husband need a good chat tomorrow. His behaviour needs to be addressed, but also yours and your children. See how, as a family, you can work together to create harmony.

This. 💯.

CockyTeeHunz4Eva · 17/06/2023 05:41

hotpotlover · 16/06/2023 22:26

If he's genuinely remorseful and it was a one off and he's feeling bad about it, I think it can be forgiven.

I think every single parent in this world had their moments they aren't proud of and where they could have done things better.

That's just my opinion and I'm aware most people on this thread won't agree with me.

Agree. I would be really cross but as a one-off I could comfortably write this off to heat/moment of madness. He didn’t swing at her. Once in 15 years, yes I think you’re overreacting (but good to be clear to him that physical contact in anger is not ok).

Dita73 · 17/06/2023 05:28

@Fisharejumping no I’m not. If you read the thread I’ve already said that I’ve never been in a situation where I’ve been hit

johnd2 · 17/06/2023 05:14

Honestly there's a good range of opinions on this thread already but here's my 2p.
I don't think dragging itself is wrong if it's done with best interests at heart. And the dragging should be a self prompt to think things through later and try to come up with a solution that doesn't involve dragging. If the dragging involves high emotion then that's a second reason to think things through.

I've dragged lots of times, sometimes justifiable (stops walking in the middle of the road, going to miss a doctor's appointment) and sometimes not justifiable (he's constantly chattering and not getting ready for bed and I'm tired and want to pass out on the sofa) although I try to say you've got 5 second to do whatever it is before I help.

As long as I can think it through, repair properly (sorry for X, I was feeling Y, next time I will Z, is that ok?) then it should be alright in the long term.
Having a partner I can talk things through without judgement really helps.

I think in your partner's case he needs to understand what his emotion was telling him and you can think through a technique to use when he gets closer to that stage in future. No point in saying "don't..." something, think about ideas what to do in that situation. It could be too say "I'm too angry to deal with this" and go outside to cool off. Or it could be too have a hug. Or if it's early enough before the anger it could be "you've got 10 second to start going upstairs or I'll help" and that 10 seconds is enough to calm down on both sides so any dragging happens in a gentle way rather than an angry way

Good luck, all that is my 2p and I know it won't work for everyone. Especially given each family dynamic will have it's own unique set of emotions triggered by it all.

Coffeetree · 17/06/2023 05:01

Quveas · 16/06/2023 21:56

I absolutely won't excuse it, because there is never any reason for violence. But if there has never been any previous history, it may be the heat. People are notably more aggressive in heat - that's why rioting happens more in summer than in winter. There's a name for it but for the life of me I can't recall it, but there are a number of articles about it, eg https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200817-the-sinister-ways-heatwaves-warp-the-mind

I won't excuse it, but here's an excuse.

Toenailz · 17/06/2023 03:55

I agree, some massive overreactions here, by lots of people acting like they have never got cross and behaved in not the best light.

I doubt dad was just angry she was taking too long to eat/drink before bed. Does no one think kids of that age are clever enough to purposefully drag out the time it takes to do a task before bed, to avoid bedtime? Give over. I tried it on when I was a kid (and got put right pretty fucking quickly!) OP said herself 'she was ignoring him', and from the tone of the post I'm willing to hedge a bet it happens a lot that she ignores her parents, and mum defends children, and dad lost his temper today. I also think he's being treated a lot differently than if it were a woman that lost her temper with her child, going from posts I've seen, including ones where they've smacked their children, and still been told by mumsnet 'it's okay, no ones perfect'.

There's a lot of bratty-ass children being raised, to ignore their parents/those responsible for them. I don't think the go to answer should be dragging them across the room, of course, though I can certainly see how it happens to children who choose not to respect what their parents say and behave obnoxiously toward them. Parents are, after all, responsible for setting rules for children. The kids don't get to choose on some of them, thems the breaks.

I'd be questioning why she was ignoring her dad, and what I and he could do to prevent that behaviour next time, and move on from it. I have a feeling they take the piss out of him, and you encourage them by being soft on them.

I don't condone hitting, dragging, or anything of the sort. Simply saying, I understand how it can happen, this wasn't a smack. He told her to do something, she ignored him, he took her arm and walked fast the direction he'd told her to go, and her arm got accidently knocked. Maybe none of this would have happened if a) you and him were on the same page as to how to deal with these behaviours, b) he maybe educates himself on how to deal with the behaviours and c) then you together, work on your children not ignoring their parents.

I think you and your husband need a good chat tomorrow. His behaviour needs to be addressed, but also yours and your children. See how, as a family, you can work together to create harmony.

Ottersmith · 17/06/2023 02:43

Get him to read "The Book You Wish Your Parents Read" by Phillipa Perry. To find the underlying cause.

YRGAM · 17/06/2023 02:39

Cailleachian · 16/06/2023 23:37

This is not a serious assault.

This is poor parenting and recklessness. He had no intention of harming her, and the injury was minimal. He recognises it wasnt good behaviour, hence the apology, but at the same time, you are making a mountain out of a molehill.

Agreed. It's not great, but put it this way, OP would be doing far more damage to her child than this incident if she were to divorce her husband because people on Mumsnet told her to

Deathbyfluffy · 17/06/2023 02:20

Itismeghan · 16/06/2023 21:49

That’s not the case. Trying hard to think, but nothing comes to mind.

I’d ignore this reply - for some reason MN’ers seem to think there’s a decade of violence behind every outburst.
Not always the case!