Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sudden act of aggression

189 replies

Itismeghan · 16/06/2023 21:32

I need some advice on what to do please. Been with husband over 15 years. There’s been no violence or abuse in this time. Then tonight when my 10yo was taking ages to have her drink/snack before bed, ignoring him telling her to hurry up, he lost it and grabbed hold of her and pulled her across the room. She banged her arm on a table and got a red mark. I comforted her and told him he shouldn’t have done that and he said sorry to her and we put the kids to bed. I’ve confronted him about it and he said he shouldn’t have done it but didn’t think it was as serious of an issue as I was making out. He’s upstairs in bed because I said I didn’t know if I could move on from it.

OP posts:
Freefall212 · 18/06/2023 09:11

Catchasingmewithspiders · 18/06/2023 09:06

I haven't read that thread so Im not replying specifically about it

However, on this thread my concern was that a man dragging a ten year old girl across a room because she didnt behave how he wanted would lead to her thinking that sort of behaviour was normal in adulthood and therefore making her vulnerable to an abusive relationship

If it had been a man dragging a ten year old boy across a room because he didnt behave how he wanted my concern would be that that sort of behaviour might be considered normal by the boy leading him to be abusive in an adult relationship.

Its just as important, if not more important, to model relationships that dont get aggressive when upset or annoyed to little boys.

And as for the 'it wouldn't be okay if it was the mum' comments. I was abused by my mum growing up. No it wouldnt be okay.

Why would the same action and being oulled across a room by an adult lead one child to further victiminization and the other to become an abuser?

flagpie · 18/06/2023 09:07

@Freefall212

Your hatred of men or a misogynist's hatred of women don't actually make your point any stronger - they just make it driven by sexism.

Eh?

I don't like violence, I have said this multiple times.

I don't hate men, in fact I really fucking like men. And women. People in general. I just don't like violent people.

If we could maybe stop making huge assumptions about misogyny and hatred that would be great.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 18/06/2023 09:06

Comfortablechairs · 18/06/2023 07:37

Just reading a current thread from a mother who admits to be 'rough' with her four year old. Such sympathy and understanding from posters

I hate my 4 yr old www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4829369-i-hate-my-4-yr-old

I imagine being rough is ok if it is from a mother but not ok from a father or being physically rough with a four year old boy is ok in some posters eyes although I think a four year old is more vulnerable than a ten year old. It does seem mothers rush to support other mothers but are damning if it is a Dad or perhaps some posters on here think physical punishment is ok if it is directed at a boy?

I haven't read that thread so Im not replying specifically about it

However, on this thread my concern was that a man dragging a ten year old girl across a room because she didnt behave how he wanted would lead to her thinking that sort of behaviour was normal in adulthood and therefore making her vulnerable to an abusive relationship

If it had been a man dragging a ten year old boy across a room because he didnt behave how he wanted my concern would be that that sort of behaviour might be considered normal by the boy leading him to be abusive in an adult relationship.

Its just as important, if not more important, to model relationships that dont get aggressive when upset or annoyed to little boys.

And as for the 'it wouldn't be okay if it was the mum' comments. I was abused by my mum growing up. No it wouldnt be okay.

flagpie · 18/06/2023 09:05

Her thread was titled that she hated her child and could get rough with him.

You have no idea what happened with that child in that house.

Quite, I can only go on what was said.

Juts to be absolutely clear, I'm not defending her actions in any way.

Freefall212 · 18/06/2023 09:02

flagpie · 18/06/2023 08:54

Imagine suggesting therapy to people who can see a violent man for what he is Confused

It's not us that need the therapy Biscuit

Your hatred of men or a misogynist's hatred of women don't actually make your point any stronger - they just make it driven by sexism.

Freefall212 · 18/06/2023 09:01

flagpie · 18/06/2023 08:52

She said I can get rough with him and then later gave one example where she said she pushed him away with her arm and shouted.

He was biting her so she pushed with that arm and shouted. Don't be comparing that action to one of dragging s child across the room.

I don't condone her actions any more than his but let's keep it real. She reacted badly to being hurt. He chose violence because his child wasn't doing what he wanted/

Not the same.

Her thread was titled that she hated her child and could get rough with him.

You have no idea what happened with that child in that house.

Comfortablechairs · 18/06/2023 08:55

I want to make it clear that I don't blame the mother or the father in these two cases and I said so on the first thread. However, in my opinion some posters are much harsher in their attitudes to the treatment of little boys compared to girls.

flagpie · 18/06/2023 08:54

PoseyFlump · 18/06/2023 08:52

There are numerous women on this thread who have experienced violence both as a child and an adult (myself included) who do not think this situation is 'violent' and just needs a good talk between the adults.

I would advise anyone who is projecting their own fears on every little situation in their life and overreacting, to consider therapy. It is very helpful in dealing with the real world of imperfection and to calm hyper-vigilance.

Imagine suggesting therapy to people who can see a violent man for what he is Confused

It's not us that need the therapy Biscuit

Comfortablechairs · 18/06/2023 08:52

I feel sorry for the mother of the four year old but can you imagine the outrage on here if a Dad pushed his four year old daughter and shouted. It is sad that some posters( talking about other current threads on here) think that boys need physical/ emotional punishments. It shows the different attitudes held by some posters with regards to behaviour management of boys and girls.

flagpie · 18/06/2023 08:52

She said I can get rough with him and then later gave one example where she said she pushed him away with her arm and shouted.

He was biting her so she pushed with that arm and shouted. Don't be comparing that action to one of dragging s child across the room.

I don't condone her actions any more than his but let's keep it real. She reacted badly to being hurt. He chose violence because his child wasn't doing what he wanted/

Not the same.

PoseyFlump · 18/06/2023 08:52

There are numerous women on this thread who have experienced violence both as a child and an adult (myself included) who do not think this situation is 'violent' and just needs a good talk between the adults.

I would advise anyone who is projecting their own fears on every little situation in their life and overreacting, to consider therapy. It is very helpful in dealing with the real world of imperfection and to calm hyper-vigilance.

Freefall212 · 18/06/2023 08:47

flagpie · 18/06/2023 08:26

That poster describes being 'rough' as shouting.

These situations are not comparable.

No she didn't.

She said I can get rough with him and then later gave one example where she said she pushed him away with her arm and shouted.

flagpie · 18/06/2023 08:26

Comfortablechairs · 18/06/2023 07:37

Just reading a current thread from a mother who admits to be 'rough' with her four year old. Such sympathy and understanding from posters

I hate my 4 yr old www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4829369-i-hate-my-4-yr-old

I imagine being rough is ok if it is from a mother but not ok from a father or being physically rough with a four year old boy is ok in some posters eyes although I think a four year old is more vulnerable than a ten year old. It does seem mothers rush to support other mothers but are damning if it is a Dad or perhaps some posters on here think physical punishment is ok if it is directed at a boy?

That poster describes being 'rough' as shouting.

These situations are not comparable.

Comfortablechairs · 18/06/2023 07:37

Just reading a current thread from a mother who admits to be 'rough' with her four year old. Such sympathy and understanding from posters

I hate my 4 yr old www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4829369-i-hate-my-4-yr-old

I imagine being rough is ok if it is from a mother but not ok from a father or being physically rough with a four year old boy is ok in some posters eyes although I think a four year old is more vulnerable than a ten year old. It does seem mothers rush to support other mothers but are damning if it is a Dad or perhaps some posters on here think physical punishment is ok if it is directed at a boy?

FelisCatus0 · 17/06/2023 17:26

Was she eating in the lounge room or kitchen or something, OP? I know it's not the main point of the topic but just wondering why she couldn't have just taken her drink and snack to her room. And it was a weekend so it's not like she had to go to bed early.

PToosher · 17/06/2023 17:12

Jibo · 17/06/2023 16:04

Jesus, these posts always bring out the drama llamas. According to your logic nobody born before the mid-Eighties should have been allowed to live with their own parents!

He's apologised, DD is OK, the bump on the table wasn't intended. Move on.

I was about to post the same thing - when I was a child in the late 70's, by this reckoning ALL the children I knew would have grown up in a 'broken home'.

And for what it's worth, it was my mum that used to lose her rag, not my dad.

Jibo · 17/06/2023 16:04

Readyplayerthr33 · 16/06/2023 21:34

It’s never ok. Never.

When your 10 year old is 30 and her husband drags her across the room, will your husband say, “well, it was only once and doesn’t matter?”

Get him out. If he won’t go then pack your stuff, take your child and leave. Now.

Jesus, these posts always bring out the drama llamas. According to your logic nobody born before the mid-Eighties should have been allowed to live with their own parents!

He's apologised, DD is OK, the bump on the table wasn't intended. Move on.

SerafinasGoose · 17/06/2023 14:57

To see this minimized as the heat making a father violent, as the fault of the mother for not instilling discipline, or even worse, as an 'accident', is predictable but unsurprising.

It was not an accident. Nor was it the fault of the mother or the child. Those making these dismissive, incorrect claims are overlooking the straightforward law of cause and effect. The child's father dragged her across the room. As a result of that action, she hit and bruised her arm. His action caused the injury to happen, therefore his action was wholly responsible.

If he can't comprehend this fact, then this is a large red flag that would deeply concern me if this were my husband and daughter.

As to whether his was a 'serious assault', I don't know as I didn't witness it. Some of the posts are doubtless over-reactions to a situation we are not privy to, but @Catchasingmewithspiders's post above is about as measured as it gets on this thread and gives numerous reasons why OP should be concerned.

Some women will do anything to divest men of responsibility for their actions. It's a depressing but persistent theme on this site.

TheoTheopolis23 · 17/06/2023 12:18

*lower, that should be

TheoTheopolis23 · 17/06/2023 12:18

inamarina · 17/06/2023 12:15

She hasn’t listed a litany of assaults on women by her husband either.
I really don’t think that men (physically) attacking other men is such a rare occurrence.

Oh a certain type of man will get violent with other men.

Their numbers compared to men who bully and abuse their female partners and kids (while never challenging other men physically) are much much higher though.

inamarina · 17/06/2023 12:15

TheoTheopolis23 · 17/06/2023 09:19

Ah, that must be why ops listed a litany of assaults on other men by her husband.

She hasn’t listed a litany of assaults on women by her husband either.
I really don’t think that men (physically) attacking other men is such a rare occurrence.

johnd2 · 17/06/2023 12:02

Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 08:04

So in the situation I saw that I described her with the mother and preschooler - would you have called police and social services and described her as violent and assaulting her child? Would you want the desired outcome to be no further contact with her child / children?

What would you have done in this dynamic where her child was vulnerable and the mother exasperated? Would you have stepped in yourself in the moment to protect the child and separate from the child from their mother?

Erm, no to all, it's nothing to do with me, I'm not here to right all the world's wrongs!
I'd probably I'd think "oh dear, they're having a tough time" and carry on with my day.

My point in the above post, in the context of your example - if that lady did that to her partner/sister/friend then they would be more likely to have a "wtf was that?" conversation later and sort it out and discuss it. But because the child is less likely to have that ability, only the adult could initiate the concession, so it is less likely to happen, so it carries on.

Lifescary · 17/06/2023 11:38

Your husband has apologised to your daughter but she still needs to apologise for her bad behaviour.

Itismeghan · 17/06/2023 11:33

zingally · 17/06/2023 11:30

Jesus, all the people telling OP to leave him...

That seems like a MASSIVE over-reaction to an incident that has never happened before.
None of us are perfect, and we've all done things as parents - in the heat of the moment - that we're not very proud of. Frankly, I'd argue that throwing him out of the house would be more traumatic to DD long-term than "I wasn't doing what I was told, so dad lost his temper, pulled me and I bumped my arm."

The alternative is DD sitting there, aged 30, thinking "the one time dad got a bit physical with me, because I was being rude, ended my parents marriage. If only I'd behaved myself." I'd argue that would be far worse.

He has apologised. Let it go. How has DD woken up this morning?

She’s happy, but does have a little bruise size if 5p on her arm.

OP posts:
zingally · 17/06/2023 11:30

Jesus, all the people telling OP to leave him...

That seems like a MASSIVE over-reaction to an incident that has never happened before.
None of us are perfect, and we've all done things as parents - in the heat of the moment - that we're not very proud of. Frankly, I'd argue that throwing him out of the house would be more traumatic to DD long-term than "I wasn't doing what I was told, so dad lost his temper, pulled me and I bumped my arm."

The alternative is DD sitting there, aged 30, thinking "the one time dad got a bit physical with me, because I was being rude, ended my parents marriage. If only I'd behaved myself." I'd argue that would be far worse.

He has apologised. Let it go. How has DD woken up this morning?