Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do doctors run in families?

69 replies

Beafortea · 16/06/2023 20:56

Why do doctors' kids often all end up being doctors? You seem to find that doctors are usually from families of multiple generations of doctors. Why is that?

Curious because you'd think with the state of things for junior doctors, parents would be encouraging their kids to pick another career?

OP posts:
maybemedmum · 22/06/2023 08:33

Interesting reading. DD wants to be a doctor.

We are in publishing (me) and a director at an NHS trust (her dad). DH's dad was a doctor and totally put him off it - both explicitly, by telling him he wasn't tough enough(!), and implicitly, by obviously finding life so difficult as a doctor (though it was absolute vocation for him).

DD will have some of the advantages of a kid from a typical medical background - we're both Oxford educated, with good contacts and (ancient) experience of tricky admissions processes and her dad will be able to sort shadowing/work experience for her. My impression on reading admissions criteria etc is that med schools are trying hard to make it more open to people from all backgrounds (e.g., valuing customer service experience as much as/instead of shadowing/direct work experience), but I'm not sure how much this is reflected in reality.

Also, it's five years of tuition fees/placements/not a lot of time to work in the holidays. We're reevaluating our medium term spending on the basis that we'll potentially be supporting DD for several years longer than we had planned. We're in a position to do that, but I know a lot of people aren't - it definitely feels like a fairly affluent person's game!

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 22/06/2023 08:29

Loads of families seem to have the same jobs - I'm a third generation academic, my step sister is a fourth generation midwife. I don't think either of us were particularly encouraged to go into those lines of work - it just happened. I guess maybe there was a level of familiarity to the life/career path/what you needed to do which made it easier?

Anyotherdude · 22/06/2023 08:24

In the same way as Musicians and Artists do.

Moraxella · 22/06/2023 08:23

I’m the first Dr in my family, I’m not going to dissuade my kids because then that will make them definitely want to do it. Instead I’m going to play the indifference card. I really really hope they don’t do it

Lapland123 · 22/06/2023 08:21

Just to point out the reality that doctors generally can’t afford private schools- this was different a generation ago. You’ll find the majority of doctors with school age children now do not send them to private school as they cannot afford this.

The only ones I know who send private are married to partner in finance/ business/ high paying career or have family money. It’s not affordable from the doctor’s salary which has seen 35-40% pay erosion while private school fees have jumped in line with inflation.

Obliv · 17/06/2023 00:26

Is it only me who read this title and pictured a family of doctors at a park run? Grin

weareallout · 17/06/2023 00:19

Hairbrushhandle · 16/06/2023 21:26

You have to be pretty privileged to get into medical school, you need to have had opportunities and had space to study. Networks remain incredibly important. Like any profession it comes with a language and if you can speak the language then you look like you fit so you're more likely to be selected.

THIS

weareallout · 17/06/2023 00:18

Money. And their kids can get the work experience needed

Trying2understand · 16/06/2023 23:55

I regularly taught students in medical school a particular topic/course and can confirm there's lots of multi-generational Dr's! I have had students where all their siblings, parents, grandparents and at least one aunt/uncle on each side are. Why? Confidence, money to study, the fact there's many different areas you can go into depending on your interests, private schooling with strong sciences and interpersonal skills, knowing at the end of it there is a decent job and good salary if you keep progressing. Tho there are some appealing conditions for junior Dr's.

I do think medicine is trying to change with more physicians that aren't from privilege. I think those families may have less of a intergenerational element.

Lapland123 · 16/06/2023 23:18

No exposure to anything other than medicine as a career choice... given the young age you start medical school at. If you’ve no exposure to anything other than doctors, you’ll end up doing that ...

I’ve been realistic about it to my kids who I hope won’t go into it, not in this country (UK) anyway.

GameofPhones · 16/06/2023 22:49

Clergy families too, so it can't be for the money. At one religious discussion session I attended at Uni, virtually all the students came from clergy family. Some were quite badly behaved too, giggling and sniggering at the speaker. I was quite shocked at their behaviour. This group monopolised the chaplaincy facilities as well.

Beafortea · 16/06/2023 22:37

Thanks for all the replies! Really interesting reading all your experiences.

OP posts:
JamSandle · 16/06/2023 22:33

Family pressure.

Theoldgreygoose · 16/06/2023 22:23

I can't think of any doctors I know whose children have become doctors, although I'm sure there are some but it doesn't seem to be so common here.

Notagardener · 16/06/2023 22:16

Our state college arranges a lot of events for A level students interested in medicine, involving visiting unis, having doctors come in to give talk etc.
A lot more than the private school my older DC went to....

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 16/06/2023 22:16

Expectation
I know two doctors socially, who were always expected to continue the family line of doctors, and they never thought of being anything else.

Bunbuns3 · 16/06/2023 22:13

I have a friend who is a gp. She is so down to earth and normal, both her parents were gp's and they put a lot of pressure on her to become one also. She took a career break to bring her son up until primary school and this infuriated her parents who thought she could just put her son in a nursery and carry on. I get the feeling it is just a job for her and not something she is mad passionate about.

Daisy12Maisie · 16/06/2023 22:00

Because its so incredibly hard to become a dr if you are not from a family who are drs or have connections. My 14 year old is desperate to be a dr.
He has started volunteering in several things which was easy to organise but i cant get a dr for him to shadow/ work with. Also we only know about Ucat due to googling. Im not going to be able to help him with his ucas form and interview as i have no idea and we dont know anyone who can help. Im going to work overtime to pay for him to go on the medics mentors summer school because otherwise i dont see how realistically he has a fair chance of getting in.
He doesnt go to private school so doesnt get any extra help with applications.
Most teenagers from not well off familes have to get part time jobs so that would be a struggle to get all A's plus volunteering plus working 20 hrs a week in asda or whatever. So its just a lot easier/ harder for some people to get into medical school. He is desperate to do it as he is kind, wants to help people and loves science but unfortunately that is not enough.

Toomanycaketins · 16/06/2023 21:54

You get vet families too, similar factors I guess

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 16/06/2023 21:51

well, apart from a tough initial period, there’s an excellent career ahead for medics- great money & progression, plus rewarding and fulfilling role. Most jobs you get one or the other, rarely both. So no wonder it runs in families.
Medics children will also have an advantage over peers and therefore more likely to actually get a place- in terms of the educational opportunities that their parents profession will provide, inherited academic aptitude, and frankly priceless help with experience and applications.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 16/06/2023 21:47

My parents are both in medicine and they both put me off for life at a very young age Grin

KohlaParasaurus · 16/06/2023 21:47

I was the first doctor in my family on either side and the only one in my own generation. None of my own children or my cousins' children have gone into medicine or any branch of health care. My children's father was also the only doctor in a large extended family. However, it's true that often doctors cluster in families.

MissTrip82 · 16/06/2023 21:45

Inter-generational privilege.

I’m a doctor but from a working class family. I was unusual in my year group.

My work is intense and meaningful. I resuscitate people for a living. I don’t dissuade my kid from pursuing this or any other kind of meaningful work, no matter how hard.

dickheed · 16/06/2023 21:40

I went to school with a lot of children of doctors and a significant number of them went on to be doctors. Things are possibly changing now but it has always been seen as a prestigious career, ensuring a secure financial future.

  1. People need work experience to get into medical school and that can be more easily arranged if you have parents who are doctors
  2. Parents talking about their work at home probably sparks the interest of the children
  3. Some parents of the girls I went to school with expected nothing less than that their child would go into medicine, whether they really wanted to or not - this was particularly the case of families originally from India, Pakistan and Bangladesh
  4. Once children are at the age of applying to medical school, the parents are higher up the career ladder and have possibly forgotten about the junior doctor hell, or see it as a means to an end.
  5. Most children of doctors have academic advantages in that a) aptitude for scientific subjects does tend to run in families and b) the parents have the financial means to ensure the child receives the support they need to do well - independent school, tutoring to enter grammar school, tutoring during the secondary years.
Angelina1972 · 16/06/2023 21:36

Nurses run in families too!

my grandfather and his brother were doctors but my mum and uncle both read history at Uni. Even though my mum was very clever she hated science.

Swipe left for the next trending thread