Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What an idiot (me)

112 replies

BadMotorhomeParent · 16/06/2023 19:17

I sold my motorhome to some passers-by (it was old, and not used much). I was knocked down on the price I asked.
They said they were "touring" to buy up unwanted motorhomes to take back (to Ireland) for Ukrainians who had nowhere to live/sleep.
They were in a big shiny brand new pick-up, and at first I was dealing with one Irish giant, then one-by-one, three more got out (all brothers). And the 7y.o. son of one of them. Sweet.

Without tax, they put trade plates on and said that they would have a lorry come to transport it, but did drive it away off down the road; it had started well as new battery in April. But I had o real knowledge of it's mechanical soundness (it would overheat if driven stop-start in heat I remember.)
Bank transfer/FP done while they were there.

Two hours later I get a call (fortunately one of them had taken my number), and apparently it had blown up on the "motorway" (I think, the A1), so the discussion was what did I want to do, but also they also spoke to someone who said it was a heap of shit, but it could go to a "yard"/for spares/be fixed (new engine, gearbox etc etc) at great cost.

They (I was not actually sure which brother I was speaking to; they all sounded like one another....) in the end, said - unless I misunderstood - that they would send it for scrap/spares to a nearby yard (with "a man") and I would send their money back - although not the full amount, "for my trouble". (Also had given me 10% in cash - which I didn't know what to do with....)

When I tried to send the agreed amount, the Bank held it up and I had to speak to Fraud - who said, 1) Buyer Beware - so I was not obliged to given them ANY of the money back (!!!!), 2) The motorhome is probably quite all right, and they are looking to get even more of a bargain.....
They also asked me if I felt intimidated or threatened, or was worried that there would be comeback if I stood my ground..... And I said I was only worried about (in my imagination) what would happen if I didn't.

Anyway the Bank lifted the fraud restriction (by now I had had three messages....) and I decided best to just send all the money back.

And I did. And got a call from one of the brothers (NOT the one who said I didn't need to give it all back) and he didn't even mention the fact I had sent everything to them, so now no motorhome (a mixed blessing, possibly?) and none of the money.... I asked him where "he" was (I think they had split up in various directions, and the one I was speaking to was not the one who had been in the motorhome), and he was on the way to Scotland, but the motorhome broke down in Yorkshire. I also struggled with the accents (proper proper Irish, which I do like), so didn't even really push it, trying to find out what and where. I know I am a fool.

Does anyone think I have been suckered? (I do. And the Fraud guy at the Bank thought I was - and that was before I returned the money.)

There is waaaay more backstory to this but I don't want to ramble, and have someone tell me it's too long, or too complicated, or simply not interesting enough to read.

OP posts:
EmpressMoo · 17/06/2023 13:47

I agree with the police in that it is not clear whether a crime has been committed yet. If they do sell the motor home and lied about it breaking down to obtain a refund, I'm pretty sure that would be a crime.

By their reasoning, surely all victims of scams are at fault? They hand over money at their own free will because they believe the scammers tell them. Nice bit of victim blaming by the police.

Could you ask the scammers to return the motorhome as they have had a refund? If they say it has already been destroyed, ask them for the certificate of destruction because you forgot to take the sellers's part of the log book and you don't want to be fined £1000 for not reporting it as destroyed. Don't be fobbed off if they say they will do it, say you would prefer to do it yourself for peace of mind. If they refuse to do either, you probably have a case with the police.

Did you actually sign the log book? If they forge your signature, that would also be a crime... Did you tell the police about the log book?

I would go back to the police and point out that even if you did it willingly, you are a victim of a crime if the car is sold or not scrapped because they have fraudulently told you that it has had to be scrapped to obtain a refund. They have received that refund by deception.

I would probably also talk to the DVLA if you didn't sort out the log book and explain the situation. They may flag it as stolen in case it is sold on instead of being scrapped. As it would be stolen if they have deceived you and it hasn't been scrapped. Or they might register it as scrapped.

BadMotorhomeParent · 17/06/2023 13:23

Fightyouforthatpie · 17/06/2023 13:08

Did this even happen?

God yes.... I couldn't make this up, and would not waste time writing about it if it was just an exercise in "creative" writing.

OP posts:
BadMotorhomeParent · 17/06/2023 13:22

@WiddlinDiddlin I am so "relieved" that it is a well-know scam. Obviously not to me though, of course.

The Police person I spoke to just kept saying I should have refused to pay the money back and called 999 when they showed up. Also, up to me to go to wherever the they were broken down and bring it back, before repaying the money. I know that makes some sort of sense, but at the time, being shouted at in the broad accent about what I am going to do, believing them to be at the side of the A1 at 5pm on Friday - maybe I was just too unsure... and he had said "a man" could come and take it/them away. I could only see the bullshit after that, and the coulda-woulda-shoulda kicked in.
I feel a bit better knowing that it does happen though.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 17/06/2023 13:13

I can well believe it did happen.

This is a well known scam.

They rely heavily on just the number of them, the fact they're blokes etc to intimidate, they do not actually say or do anything threatening, so if a report is made... nothing to be done, it is not a crime to go around with friends or relations being a bit large and slightly intimidating looking.

They won't actually come back and do anything, that would involve far too much effort, you'd call the police, you'd have reg details and so on for them and it would be risky for not much benefit. They still have a vehicle they've paid under the odds for that they will not be spending out on for insurance/mot/repairs and will flog on for a profit. So they're quids in either way, the 'getting most of our money back' element of it is the icing on the cake as it were.

Fightyouforthatpie · 17/06/2023 13:08

Did this even happen?

BadMotorhomeParent · 17/06/2023 13:05

Update - after 1.5 hours on hold, I was told by the Police (or whoever the call handler was....) that it was all my own fault, and no Crime has been committed.

OP posts:
BadMotorhomeParent · 17/06/2023 13:02

@FunkyMonks Thank you are lovely and kind. Yes, I don't really expect much from the Police (I am on hold for 101 - since 11:15), Apart from more "What were you thinking??"
I have mentally waved goodbye to the motorhome and the money... I cannot imagine any insurance would be paid to me, but shall try the Legal Helpline - which I have several of, with motorhome, car, household insurance and the RAC and AA, I am (ha ha) well covered.
It was SORNed, and out of MOT, so that probably invalidates it's insurance though.
I wish there were more people like you in the world.

@InTodaysNews Thank you. And there's another stupid thing I did; In all the fluster of emptying the motorhome, I forgot to get the seller part of the log book, and when I mentioned it to the brother who called me - when the money had been received back to them (they were interchangeable, even though only using one number..... ),he said "Oh it's all all right - he's Trade you know...." and other stuff I couldn't follow. I felt only slight !reassured", and now more than ever I see that I was being brushed off.

@x2boys Ha - maybe I'm right. But honestly, I didn't know for sure - just that my grandmother said it, and then the few genuine Irish people I have know (add four to that now) have had that combination of eye and hair colour.
I have not studied genetics that much - but did wonder how I could have green eyes when all parents and grandparents have/had brown. (I know now....)
I certainly have never wanted to infer anything about the Traveller Community - but, who knows who these guys truly are?

OP posts:
x2boys · 17/06/2023 09:32

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2023 20:19

typical Irish colouring of black hair and bright blue eyes
That's not 'typical Irish colouring' (I'm Irish)

I suspect you mean they were from the Travelling Community.

I'm wondering about all of this. 🤔

My Dad and all.his brothers and sisters are Irish all have or did have ( as they're all in their 70,sand80,) dark hair and blue eyes ,they were from cork ,skibereen in fact ,not from a travelling back ground I don't know wether it's typical Irish colouring but it's typical, of my Irish family

InTodaysNews · 17/06/2023 09:03

Services, not property.

InTodaysNews · 17/06/2023 08:59

Have you changed the log book over yet? If not, I would definitely be reporting it as stolen, which in a roundabout way it has been.
It could be classed under the obtaining goods or property by deception law.
I once sold a car which actually did blow up on the new owner as he drove it home.
He phoned me in a right strop, I told him to fuck off and put the phone down. That was the last I heard of it.

FunkyMonks · 17/06/2023 08:37

All the best Op sadly all the police will do is give you a crime number which may help you try and claim some of the money back through your own bank or perhaps any insurance you have etc.
Or at the most prove that you are also an innocent victim in all this should they have scammed someone else of money to pay you in first place so you cannot be held accountable should the first victim try and claim money off you.

You need to also contact the DVLA as others have said report it as stolen although dare I say if it has been a scam and it has gone back to Ireland likely hood is that won't flag up they will have changed the plates etc to sell on and other dodgy stuff to make it possible to do so.

It happens OP sadly even to those of us that say it would never happen to me it just takes one day for a lapse in judgement or fear of something bad happening that we sometimes just end up doing something that normally we wouldn't and would be wise to realise somethings not right.
Live and learn all that you can do now is just ensure that you have a crime number so that nothing can come back on you and make peace that you've lost the money and the motor home.

BadMotorhomeParent · 16/06/2023 22:43

Thank you for more replies - even the ones re-emphasising what I already think about myself.
(Been out for a bit - have not abandoned the the thread.)

To say again - they did catch me at a weak moment, when I had been mentally dithering for weeks or longer. The thought of it providing some comfort for refugees probably swayed me more to the thought of it going.
I do NOT mean anything at all about their heritage, just that as I saw it and as they told me, there were Irish and from Ireland (rolling eyes....) - certainly two of them were very handsome, if I can say that.
I am not even sure what I could say to be offensive to the Traveller Community --- and I started my own life in a caravan so flimsy it had to be tied down in strong winds, so feel that I have a bit of a nomadic soul.... Like all people, there are good and bad.
(Some of the Travellers that have pitched up not too far away, have left terrible messes, and I do judge them for that, fwiw.)

I didn't know about the trick of receiving from one account and repaying to a different (with yes, the same surname); so is something to look into as well.

I value other opinions, which is why I am on here and listening to MNers, even though I seemingly ignored the advice from the Bank. But I am sure there would have been many more messages had I not given them the money back - and I would be feeling scared this evening, not relatively calm, although angry - at myself as well as them.

I will be contacting the Police tomorrow, but am braced for more derision from them too.

OP posts:
spongebunnyfatpants · 16/06/2023 21:39

Unfortunately it's a common scam.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, you should have made them sign a receipt that stated it was sold as seen and that they would be not refund if anything happened.
Definitely report it to the police, even if it's only for a crime number, which may help you get you money back.

riotlady · 16/06/2023 21:23

Why are you willing to listen to mumsnet telling you this was a bad idea but not the fraud man at the bank, who presumably knows what he’s talking about!

EmpressMoo · 16/06/2023 21:02

I sent the money back to a different account (brother).

Was the surname the same?

Faster payments can be recalled if they are fraudulent. I believe there is a scam where the payment to you is made from stolen bank details then they ask for a refund to a different account, you transfer the money then the real owner of the bank account reports the fraud and the money is taken back.

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2023 21:02

ValenciaOrange · 16/06/2023 20:56

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4824659-car-scam-advice?postsby=HaveIbeenscammed

Same thing happened to another poster recently.
I'm sorry this has happened to you and that you have lost money. It's a horrible feeling knowing you've been scammed.

It's not quite the same. That OP was selling the car, it wasn't a random transaction.

Reading the chain is events there which is a little different, I have read of similar scenarios, carried out by Irish Travellers (not obviously saying all Travellers of course). That probably tallies with OP's description.

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2023 21:00

SheSaidHummingbird · 16/06/2023 20:58

There may be something to using a third person (you) to transfer funds from one man's account into another.

That is a very good point.

Isthisit22 · 16/06/2023 21:00

BadMotorhomeParent · 16/06/2023 20:47

We sat in the motorhome and he - having got my bank details - made a FP, which went in straight away.
I admit I rang the bank afterwards to check that it was genuine and couldn't be clawed back.

All too smooth.

I sent the money back to a different account (brother).

Oh dear. This is probably money laundering as you’ve effectively ‘cleaned’ the money for them and given them a camper van.
Nothing you can do now so no point in dwelling on it. Onwards and upwards

SheSaidHummingbird · 16/06/2023 20:58

There may be something to using a third person (you) to transfer funds from one man's account into another.

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2023 20:56

Ireallywantsomechips · 16/06/2023 20:36

Oh OP how awful for you.

Definitely been scammed but tbh I would have been scared too and given the money back. But clearly there’s much braver people than us on the thread, shame you didn’t have anyone like that around at the time.

what did the bank say when you said you felt threatened/intimidated into making the payment?

That's a bit snide of you - the 'braver posters'.

I'd be easily intimidated too.

So much so there isn't a chance I'd have conducted a major transaction with random men who called to my door!

It's not bravery - it's just basic steps most people would take. I'm not doubting OP just flabbergasted she so easily took all the steps she did.

Also, as you know, she didn't tell the bank she was intimidated - that's the whole point! The bank tried to ask her if she was being.

EmpressMoo · 16/06/2023 20:53

If it is being scrapped, as they claim, I think you can check if there is a certificate of destruction... No idea how long it takes to be processed though.

I think you need to speak to the police. If a car is reported stolen, I believe it is flagged with the DVLA so if they are scammers who sell it on, it will show up as stolen when the new owner tries to register it.

What did you do with the log book?

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2023 20:52

Tessisme · 16/06/2023 20:36

Veering off with the derail here, I and one of my sons have (or had in my case before going grey) black hair and blue eyes. We are Irish. It is one of the typical Irish/Celtic looks. Nothing wrong with OP saying that.

I'm not saying you can't have that colouring & be Irish!

I'm saying it's not typical. Some Irish Travellers do have that colouring.

Most Irish people have pale skin & fair colouring, meaning fair as in light - medium brown hair, fair complexions.

I can't think of a single person I know with black hair & blue eyes. Any very dark-haired people I know have brown / hazel eyes.

BadMotorhomeParent · 16/06/2023 20:47

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2023 20:32

Explain a bit more about the payment bit - how did they make the online transfer?

We sat in the motorhome and he - having got my bank details - made a FP, which went in straight away.
I admit I rang the bank afterwards to check that it was genuine and couldn't be clawed back.

All too smooth.

I sent the money back to a different account (brother).

OP posts:
BadMotorhomeParent · 16/06/2023 20:44

Tessisme · 16/06/2023 20:36

Veering off with the derail here, I and one of my sons have (or had in my case before going grey) black hair and blue eyes. We are Irish. It is one of the typical Irish/Celtic looks. Nothing wrong with OP saying that.

I think my g/ma always told me that - and I had a lovely Irish friend at College who had long black hair and amazing blue eyes.

Maybe I shouldn't have said "typical", if that's an issue.

OP posts: