Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave DH because I want to socialise more

258 replies

MTM2255 · 16/06/2023 14:46

DH is an introvert with no friends of his own (he did have a few when we met but no more)

He's never been into socialising

He never stops me socialising (as long as it's out the house!)

Things like weddings , general get togethers, BBQs etc. Just normal life things. He doesn't want to do it

My friend is getting married in September have had plenty notice , he's known about it forever. He's now throwing daggers in saying he doesn't want to go but he will go to stop a major argument. Okay so he will go but I will feel awkward the whole time so now I feel like going alone anyway.

I brought up about other social occasions, why can't we have people over more, blah blah blah.

He keeps going back to "I never stop you doing anything so why are you telling me what to do"

It's getting really upsetting, as I know that's just who he is , but I am what I am too. I'm very sociable and love to host.

I feel like it's going to be a major issue for my life. We get one life and I don't want to not do what I like doing. I know I can still socialise with my friends alone, but I would quite like every now and then to socialise as a couple and family (we have two DC 9&4)

I'm at my wit's end and considering splitting up but seems.so trivial to split up over

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheCatterall · 17/09/2023 20:15

@MTM2255 so a few weeks have passed - have things changed?

I do wonder what he will be like with regards your children having birthday parties at your house… having groups of friends around etc.

my Nan made it clear with there se and heavy atmosphere that she didn’t want my mum having friends around and it massively affected their relationship as my mum grew up. She left home as soon as she could.

toxic44 · 12/09/2023 22:01

Is he on the spectrum? My DP has Asperger's Syndrome and socialising is a total dead horse. The idea of going into a roomful of people is panic territory. He shies away from meeting anyone, we never eat out and seldom go anywhere there might be 'people.'
I have friends who visit but only one at a time. I give him good warning and a reminder and he goes to his room until (as he puts it) the coast is clear. He never stops me going out or hosting but doing that as a couple doesn't exist. He isn't being a sulky manchild, it's not even his choice. He just can't manage it.

Peopledrivemenuts · 20/06/2023 17:10

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 20/06/2023 15:29

I don't think none of us can say she is being unreasonable or not without establishing the terms of their marriage. It's a contract and did they decide before marriage they would enjoy social activities together inside and outside the home? If not then it defaults to the general terms of whatever marriage they are in.

Earlier on in this thread @Peopledrivemenuts you said that you don't understand marriage and rejected it as a concept as outdated. Well I think that if you only see it as a contract then you would think it outdated.

Most people in marriages don't see it as a contract but as a lifelong commitment of mutual love and care, entered into through choice. Over the course of a very long life together change and flexibility is essential, otherwise how do couples adapt to the arrival of children, changing work circumstances etc. You mention Christian marriage, well the service there actually recognises this change with vows to love in sickness and health, for richer for poorer etc.

You also wrote what happens when her husband decides she is being unreasonable and tells everyone she left him for no reason.

What happens then is that the OP did what was right for her and her life and everyone else can respect her decision and mind their own business.

Marriage is a contract, yes, but it's so much more subtle, nuanced and individual than that. Your quoting contract law on this issue is like me quoting what I've read in a beginners book of space travel to rocket scientists who've had a lifetime of hands on experience.

I'm not talking about Most Marriages as you view them.

I was asking OP about her marriage so to answer her question. What kind of marriage she is in. All people don't think the same. Some enter a polyamerous marriage others enter a marriage of convenience some enter lavender marriages and so on.

I mentioned what Christian marriage would say according to the bible because mumsnet is a UK website and people up until recently mostly married in church. I think a lot of people go into marriage not truely understanding it. I do believe marriage is a legal contract between two people and I do realise people marry for all kinds of reasons not all of them sensible.

Initially I understood OP's question to be asking if she was being reasonable to say her husbands behaviour is unreasonable behaviour with regard to applying for divorce. I don't think that is the case now. I think she just wanted to guage if people would think she is unreasonable for wanting to leave him for that reason.

I hope OP and her husband can work it out, but also she should be free to leave without judgement on her reasons.

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 20/06/2023 15:29

I don't think none of us can say she is being unreasonable or not without establishing the terms of their marriage. It's a contract and did they decide before marriage they would enjoy social activities together inside and outside the home? If not then it defaults to the general terms of whatever marriage they are in.

Earlier on in this thread @Peopledrivemenuts you said that you don't understand marriage and rejected it as a concept as outdated. Well I think that if you only see it as a contract then you would think it outdated.

Most people in marriages don't see it as a contract but as a lifelong commitment of mutual love and care, entered into through choice. Over the course of a very long life together change and flexibility is essential, otherwise how do couples adapt to the arrival of children, changing work circumstances etc. You mention Christian marriage, well the service there actually recognises this change with vows to love in sickness and health, for richer for poorer etc.

You also wrote what happens when her husband decides she is being unreasonable and tells everyone she left him for no reason.

What happens then is that the OP did what was right for her and her life and everyone else can respect her decision and mind their own business.

Marriage is a contract, yes, but it's so much more subtle, nuanced and individual than that. Your quoting contract law on this issue is like me quoting what I've read in a beginners book of space travel to rocket scientists who've had a lifetime of hands on experience.

AcrossthePond55 · 20/06/2023 14:36

sonearly · 19/06/2023 18:18

YABU to build a life with someone and then just unilaterally change the rules part way through in a way that basically abolishes them and their happiness.

I don't want to not do what I like

.

I disagree. It would be wrong to marry someone with a deliberate plan to change the rules after some time has passed I agree. But if one goes into a marriage 'in good faith' believing they can be happy with the 'rules' and later discovers that what they thought would work just doesn't OR if one party changes in later years and becomes unhappy that person has a right to change the rules for themselves. What the other party does is up to them.

My exH never wanted children, he knew I did. He went into our marriage letting me believe he did with a deliberate plan of never having children. This was wrong of him and I left him. But if he had entered the marriage wanting children and later discovered he did not, that in and of itself would not have been wrong of him nor should he have had children with me because that was the plan when we married.

OP entered the marriage with the belief that their level of socializing at that time was fine with her. And it sounds to me as if they DID socialize more pre DC, so it's quite possible that it's her DH who has 'changed the rules' by withdrawing from socializing. She has now realized she's not happy with things as they are. OP has a right to socialize as she sees fit. And it is her home too so she has the right to bring her friends there. She doesn't have the right to demand that her DH socialize with her. He can choose to stay home or absent himself If that doesn't work for either of them, then that person can end the marriage.

Peopledrivemenuts · 20/06/2023 10:02

Annipeck · 20/06/2023 09:51

@Peopledrivemenuts, you have some deeply strange ideas about marriage.

You can tell me what your not strange ideas about it are.

Annipeck · 20/06/2023 09:51

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 14:20

Yes OP can do that, but what happens when her husband decides she is being unreasonable and tells everyone she left him for no reason.

I don't think none of us can say she is being unreasonable or not without establishing the terms of their marriage. It's a contract and did they decide before marriage they would enjoy social activities together inside and outside the home? If not then it defaults to the general terms of whatever marriage they are in.

If OP has simply had enough and realised they will never be combatable then she is free to leave and start a new life by filing for a no fault divorce.

@Peopledrivemenuts, you have some deeply strange ideas about marriage.

sonearly · 19/06/2023 18:18

YABU to build a life with someone and then just unilaterally change the rules part way through in a way that basically abolishes them and their happiness.

I don't want to not do what I like

.

Harrypewter · 19/06/2023 18:04

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/06/2023 18:02

Because he’s a mean spirited arsehole as you would know if you had RTFT

I've read the whole thread thanks.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/06/2023 18:02

Harrypewter · 19/06/2023 17:16

I wonder why the op's husband doesn't like her friends? Seems like a rather harsh overreaction.

Because he’s a mean spirited arsehole as you would know if you had RTFT

Harrypewter · 19/06/2023 17:16

I wonder why the op's husband doesn't like her friends? Seems like a rather harsh overreaction.

MTM2255 · 18/06/2023 21:27

Annipeck · 18/06/2023 20:34

I never got married because it's outdated to me. I read a few of the terms and conditions and thought that's me out. I found it very flawed.

What were you reading? I literally just said I took DH as my husband.

I know right ??? I didn't do any research 🤣

OP posts:
Annipeck · 18/06/2023 20:34

I never got married because it's outdated to me. I read a few of the terms and conditions and thought that's me out. I found it very flawed.

What were you reading? I literally just said I took DH as my husband.

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 18:42

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/06/2023 17:08

@Peopledrivemenuts

I agree with you about marriage. I wouldn’t do it again if my life depended on it.

But married people have as much right to leave a bad relationship with someone who is hurting them as unmarried people. It’s not slavery.

I might have taken an issue with this because A. I ended up in a church yesterday as my car broke down in a remote village and it was the only place to get shade so I read the bible for three hours!! B. THE WEATHER. I saw on another thread a storm like this can warp the mind.

The bible definitely talked about how slaves should behave towards their masters. Parents should be obeyed by their children. It also said the husband is to be obeyed by his wife. It said a lot of other things that are totally outdated and bad, bad, bad.

But yes it doesn't really mean anything anymore if you can just walk out. It's hardly a wed 🔐 . It's more of a legal arrangement until it's decided it's over.

So no I don't think OP is unreasonable as she never got a religious based marriage. I assume a civil one so yes she can enter it and leave based on if she is happy with her husband or not.

MTM2255 · 18/06/2023 18:40

AcrossthePond55 · 18/06/2023 17:41

He says he doesn't stop you going out, but he certainly is stopping you from hosting. So he's stopping 50% of your social life.

If I were you I'd do what I wanted, he certainly is. If you want to host, host. Just give him plenty of 'heads up' and tell him he's free to go upstairs, to a hotel, or to the moon, and the devil take the hindmost. What you can't do is insist he be there, just as he can't insist you don't have friends over. Ok, so if he takes off you'd be hosting alone but if you decide to leave you'll be hosting alone anyway, so no difference there.

I think if you try this it will soon become very clear to you whether you should stay or whether you should leave.

Yes I think this is probably what I will end up doing in the interim

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 18/06/2023 17:41

He says he doesn't stop you going out, but he certainly is stopping you from hosting. So he's stopping 50% of your social life.

If I were you I'd do what I wanted, he certainly is. If you want to host, host. Just give him plenty of 'heads up' and tell him he's free to go upstairs, to a hotel, or to the moon, and the devil take the hindmost. What you can't do is insist he be there, just as he can't insist you don't have friends over. Ok, so if he takes off you'd be hosting alone but if you decide to leave you'll be hosting alone anyway, so no difference there.

I think if you try this it will soon become very clear to you whether you should stay or whether you should leave.

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/06/2023 17:08

@Peopledrivemenuts

I agree with you about marriage. I wouldn’t do it again if my life depended on it.

But married people have as much right to leave a bad relationship with someone who is hurting them as unmarried people. It’s not slavery.

SomethingFun · 18/06/2023 15:28

I’ve a couple of friends who have knobhead husbands like this. The time honoured excuse is they are tired from work and none of us give a shit that they are upstairs, it’s beats them huffing and puffing around you because their wife invited a friend to the house. So don’t let him be upstairs stop you from inviting your friends round, I’m sure they have the same high opinion of him as he does of them.

also it’s no life for my friends and I think they would be happier on their own but you can’t tell people until they are ready to hear.

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 15:27

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/06/2023 15:13

But people come on here all the time and ask if they are BU to leave their husbands for all sorts of reasons from the trivial to the huge.

I have never heard anyone say that you have to stay married because you took a vow of obedience. Firstly it’s factually incorrect that you have to obey your husband. Even in a religious marriage almost no one promises to obey their husband these days and if they did it wouldn’t be legally enforceable.

Secondly the whole point of divorce is to allow people to exit a marriage. There is no longer a need to prove fault in a marriage. You can divorce if you can show the marriage is over.

The fact they are married means there is a legal and financial contract to unwind. But no court (and not even many churches) would sanction a woman for leaving a man who said all her friends were “cunts”.

I don't understand marriage, that is my problem.

If somebody wants to start a thread on what marriage is and get the answer nailed on then I will gladly listen and learn.

I never got married because it's outdated to me. I read a few of the terms and conditions and thought that's me out. I found it very flawed.

OP was coming from a point of if she was being unreasonable. I was coming at it from a point that she signed up to marriage and what do the text book say about it?

If you sign up to it then it doesn't matter anyway because you can just dissolve it.

OP is free to leave... free to go ...he is free to not compromise and I'm passing no judgement on either of them.

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/06/2023 15:13

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 15:00

Put it another way... If OP had asked amI being unreasonable to stop dating my boyfriend because we are incompatible socially. He is social recluse and I'm outgoing then absolutely the answer is clear.

The fact that they are married and are husband and wife makes this a more complex question to answer. It's a good AIBU question because it is interesting 🤔

But people come on here all the time and ask if they are BU to leave their husbands for all sorts of reasons from the trivial to the huge.

I have never heard anyone say that you have to stay married because you took a vow of obedience. Firstly it’s factually incorrect that you have to obey your husband. Even in a religious marriage almost no one promises to obey their husband these days and if they did it wouldn’t be legally enforceable.

Secondly the whole point of divorce is to allow people to exit a marriage. There is no longer a need to prove fault in a marriage. You can divorce if you can show the marriage is over.

The fact they are married means there is a legal and financial contract to unwind. But no court (and not even many churches) would sanction a woman for leaving a man who said all her friends were “cunts”.

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 15:08

MTM2255 · 18/06/2023 14:50

Well firstly he would have no one to tell, that I had been unreasonable leaving him

I think irreconcilable differences would be valid

I didn't have a religious ceremony

Ok so no religious attachment to the marriage.

Do what you want OP. It's your life. No one has to be unreasonable. You just appear to be incompatible. He has a choice compromise or get divorced. Good luck with it OP.

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 15:00

Put it another way... If OP had asked amI being unreasonable to stop dating my boyfriend because we are incompatible socially. He is social recluse and I'm outgoing then absolutely the answer is clear.

The fact that they are married and are husband and wife makes this a more complex question to answer. It's a good AIBU question because it is interesting 🤔

MTM2255 · 18/06/2023 14:54

Another AIBU is my dad's just come over for father's Day lunch, no problem here. We went to my mum's for breakfast yesterday, no problems here (despite there being a lot of problems in the past with him and mum)

It's just down to my friends

OP posts:
MTM2255 · 18/06/2023 14:50

Well firstly he would have no one to tell, that I had been unreasonable leaving him

I think irreconcilable differences would be valid

I didn't have a religious ceremony

OP posts:
BunnyBettChetwynnd · 18/06/2023 14:49

Peopledrivemenuts · 18/06/2023 13:37

If OP is going to go for divorce we have to establish the grounds for unreasonable behaviour and if what her husband is doing fits the bill.

You no longer have to prove unreasonable behaviour when divorcing in the UK.

We don't have to establish anything.

If, when she's weighed everything up, the OP feels her husband's behaviour is unreasonable in their marriage then she can and should do what she thinks and whatever any of us says is irrelevant.

My best advice to the OP having followed this thread from the start, would be that she should stop worrying about whether she's being unreasonable/reasonable and she should follow her heart as she only has this one precious life and she deserves to do it her way and be happy. Life is short - don't waste it. Stuff what anyone else whether it be Mumsnet, the church or whoever.