Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Man 'sexually assaults' woman then throws her and a friend off bridge into ravine at German tourist spot

217 replies

IsThereAnEchoInHere · 16/06/2023 14:46

https://amp.lbc.co.uk/news/women-thrown-off-bridge-germany-neuschwanstein-castle/

21 year old lost her life because of male
entitlement.
I’m sick of this.

When will this end?
Name the problem.

Man 'sexually assaults' woman then throws her and a friend off bridge into ravine at German tourist spot

https://amp.lbc.co.uk/news/women-thrown-off-bridge-germany-neuschwanstein-castle/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
RosaGallica · 17/06/2023 13:02

Maddy70 · 17/06/2023 09:01

It is a mental health issue though. No-one of sound mind plans to murder or cause harm to another

Is that the openly recognised excuse now? At least it’s come out of the closet. Hitler must have had mental health issues, as must Alexander the Great, Genghis Khan, Attila the Hun, Cortes and Pizarro, …., And all the men who willingly, even joyfully followed them.

It’s an excuse. That’s all.

Densol57 · 17/06/2023 12:46

Oh god this is vile
Those poor girls 😢

3BSHKATS · 17/06/2023 12:45

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 12:40

I think he deserves to die and of course if anyone hurt my children I would want to tear them limb from limb with my bare hands.
I still think the death penalty is counterproductive, it sends a message that if you have enough power you can take someone's life and that's what men do they take someone's life because they feel they have the power to.
In countries where they have the death penalty are things better, is there less violent crime?
The problem of what to do with people who won't obey the rules is thorny and intractable.

I think for this kind of crime, the death penalty which is purely about vengeance. Nothing to do with rehabilitation is literally the only solution.

It does send a very strong message that this behaviour won’t be tolerated.

As far as I’m concerned, if you touch hair on a child’s head, hurt a vulnerable person, or murder Anyone you know longer have a place in society, and I will not lose any sleep over removing you from it permanently.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 12:45

Chucking him in the ravine would be fair punishment and might actually deter some other men
Then again that sector of men who truly believe that women deserve to die if they reject men's advances would likely have overwhelming impulses to kill more women in punishment for the death of their comrade.
I also feel he ought to be chucked off the ravine but at the same time I know that violence only begets more violence.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 12:40

Inkyblue123 · 17/06/2023 09:24

They do it becouse they get away with it. That Colin Pitchfork was released after raping and murder of 2 teenage girls. We need a far more robust judicial systems. Since having my daughter I have changed my mind about the death sentence, I know not everyone thinks the same but the systems we have in place assume that all criminals can and want to be rehabilitated and deserve a second chance. I don’t belive that is the case.

I think he deserves to die and of course if anyone hurt my children I would want to tear them limb from limb with my bare hands.
I still think the death penalty is counterproductive, it sends a message that if you have enough power you can take someone's life and that's what men do they take someone's life because they feel they have the power to.
In countries where they have the death penalty are things better, is there less violent crime?
The problem of what to do with people who won't obey the rules is thorny and intractable.

Oversharingnamechanged · 17/06/2023 12:37

beguilingeyes · 17/06/2023 11:18

Two women a week are murdered by their current or ex- partner. It's hardly an aberration. Quite often they kill the children too. This story is on the news this morning. No details yet but I'm willing to bet it's a murder-suicide.

BBC News - Four people found dead in Hounslow flat
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-65937795

Since covid I believe its now 3 a week roughly, I've heard podcasters/YouTubers now use that as a statistic but I've not googled for myself, quite honestly even thinking about it makes me sick.

Men fear we will laugh at them, women fear men will kill them, Margaret Atwood said I think? 😔

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 12:23

That wanker travelled all the way from the US to kill a young girl just starting out in life
Men become enraged that women aren't under their dominion, that they can live their lives for themselves rather than subordinate themselves to and forever be in the service of men.
Can't tolerate a woman being better than a man in any way shape or form so has to kill her.
This is what's behind so many men wanting to identify as women, they are seeing that women have more options to be successful and to have real power and they want to jump ship and try and get some of those benefits for themselves whilst retaining the essence of their masculinity of course, and taking any opportunity they can to denigrate and attack women.

beguilingeyes · 17/06/2023 11:18

Two women a week are murdered by their current or ex- partner. It's hardly an aberration. Quite often they kill the children too. This story is on the news this morning. No details yet but I'm willing to bet it's a murder-suicide.

BBC News - Four people found dead in Hounslow flat
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-65937795

Staines Road, Bedfont

Four people found dead in Hounslow flat

Four people, including an 11-year-old girl and a three-year-old boy, are found dead in a flat in west London.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-65937795

FlindersKeepers · 17/06/2023 11:07

I live in Bavaria.
This case is absolutely shocking, especially as Bavaria has a pretty low crime rate in general (high investment in police and high visibility).

My personal experience (not sure if helpful!) is that street harassment is low here.
The comments above about enforcement of child support aren't relevant here as the German states will cover outstanding payments and recover the money from the non-payer directly, including a requirement to work and significant penalties. The amount due is based on the Duesseldorfer Tabelle, a sliding scale taking all children into account.

Is Bavaria perfect? Clearly not, as this happened here.

It's bad that the Daily Mail has published the victims' names, they would be suppressed here, the police are not even confirming the nationality of the victims as they don't see it as relevant to the public.

3BSHKATS · 17/06/2023 10:53

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 17/06/2023 10:39

What can men do? Oh, poor men. It's not as if have political and social power they could use to fix those things.

Not forgetting of course that education, healthcare and mental health services also fail women (and often to a greater extent - physical amd mental health care for women is considerably worse than for men). And yet ...

Don’t forget the legal system as well as literally setup to fuck women over financially because most of them can’t afford legal representation in divorce cases. It might be a little bit biased towards women in residency custody cases. You can have the kids but nobody is gonna give you the funds to raise them. Nor enforce child-support.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 17/06/2023 10:51

The CSEW figures for violence do not include homicide, do not include sexual assault (add another 3%), do not include domestic abuse (add another 6%) and also don't include anyone older than 59.

And those the the percentages for 1 year, 'ever experienced' will be much, much higher.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/crimeinenglandandwales/yearendingdecember2022

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 17/06/2023 10:39

Alexandra2001 · 16/06/2023 16:49

My mum, a victim of DV, told me that (some) men despise women, nothing i ve seen in my almost 60 years makes me believe otherwise.

But what can men do, so much is to do with failings in Education, Health care and MH in particular.

But ultimately, in most cases its women who do the majority of the childcare, thats on us.

What can men do? Oh, poor men. It's not as if have political and social power they could use to fix those things.

Not forgetting of course that education, healthcare and mental health services also fail women (and often to a greater extent - physical amd mental health care for women is considerably worse than for men). And yet ...

Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 10:28

falsepositivenervous · 17/06/2023 09:36

So two opinion pieces and two small sample studies from the Americas that have found only a weak association. No correlation and no causation. No comparison to historic rates of violence whatsoever.

Did you expect me to send you hundreds of links? To sift through everything out there to present to you, here on mumsnet on a Saturday morning? Would you have preferred I write a review article, just for you? Cop on now.

Also, I saw your comment about how you "travelled the world" and only ever asked random men for help in remote areas, how you run alone at night, how you manage to pick only amazing and godly men to be around you. It reads like a fantasy novel blurb, written by men's rights activists. If you did all those things, you're bloody lucky you survived. I work in a large poor country for a few months every year in very rural areas (field work), and the safety rules for females especially are extremely strict, because in these areas women and girls go missing all the time. Almost all the time we make sure that there are men and women working together, but I remember once I was working with three female students, we had no men with us, and I was absolutely terrified every time I heard a car coming down the road, because I knew that I could not defend myself or my students if any of the men got an idea to do anything to us. I will never forget that. I wouldn't let any of the girls go off a little way into the bushes to pee.

It's great that you have no fear and have lived a magical life, and somehow have this supernatural ability to know that the men around you are all good ones who won't hurt you, but it really reads very condescendingly when you say "you must have chosen to have bad men around you so it's your own fault".

Out of curiosity, how would you have avoided this man's seemingly random attack in Bavaria? Would you just have assumed he was safe like every other man you've laid eyes on? Maybe if you had been there he wouldn't have done it, because men don't do bad things when you're around?

I think you are replying to two different people but I am the one who travelled.

Your view is so skewed that you try to deny me my own life experience or insult me and deflect by claming I must be MRA since to you it isn't humanly possible for a woman to be independent or not be harmed. To you a woman walking out her front door is the sme as being led into a stadium of straving lions - that danger is everywhere and it is very unlikely she will get through the gauntlet of men on that walk home unscathed. That is a skewed perspective. It isn't supported at all by statistics nor the life experience of many. The culture of fear is somethign that women seem to desperately want and why you attack me. You want me to be scared for my life, you want women to live in fear - you want to catastrophize the actual issue into something the means women just spend their lives alone huddling in closed spaces in terror. The reality of the world is not that dystopian.

If you read my post you would see that I said that some violence is entirely unpredictable and that there is risk in life. I did not say I live a magical life, I actually live a very normal life - for decades - and in that normal life have encountered hundreds (maybe thousands?) of men and not been harmed. I don't assume every man or woman is safe or that harm is impossible or that I could never be harmed in any way at all or that I can prevent all harm. Reread my post. The reality is as a woman one can live a normal life without being in a state of fear. I do.

Lazylikeasundaymorning · 17/06/2023 10:26

@HRTQueen to be fair L3 is quoting the CSEW which is based on surveys not police reports, however I don’t believe the stats she is quoting include sexual offences (@L3ThirtySeven perhaps you can clarify your source?) so not that helpful when discussing male violence against women. CSEW is carried out using face to face interviews and considered fairly unreliable in capturing the extent of sex crimes I believe as people are unlikely to want to share that information in that scenario.

HRTQueen · 17/06/2023 10:05

L3ThirtySeven · 17/06/2023 07:17

It is really low though. 1.6% of adults being the victim of a violent crime, with 75% of that being men and 25% being women. That’s 0.4% of women being the victim of a violent crime, with 95% of these being attacked by a man, gives us 0.38% of men being violent towards women.

Thats less than 1%, the very definition of a few men. And there aren’t lots of men ignoring it- who fills our prisons? Men who have done violent crime. Who arrests violent men? The mostly male police.

Look, the world isn’t perfectly safe but having been a young woman when the above rates of violence against women was 400% higher, I object to this narrative building up that implies that right here, right now is the worst it’s been, and is some sort of massive ever increasing problem with men doing nothing about it.

It’s not increasing, it’s been going down for decades and men are in fact part of why it has decreased.

that is reported crime

vast majority of sexual assault goes unreported,
not all domestic violence is reported and when it is it’s rarely the first incident

I have never said it’s the worse it’s ever been but I am not going along with this nonsense poor men get a terrible time NAMALT narrative the issues is far far too many men are and this is what needs to be addressed as this is the problem

and why aren’t all those nice men helping women it’s women that fight for changes

falsepositivenervous · 17/06/2023 09:36

So two opinion pieces and two small sample studies from the Americas that have found only a weak association. No correlation and no causation. No comparison to historic rates of violence whatsoever.

Did you expect me to send you hundreds of links? To sift through everything out there to present to you, here on mumsnet on a Saturday morning? Would you have preferred I write a review article, just for you? Cop on now.

Also, I saw your comment about how you "travelled the world" and only ever asked random men for help in remote areas, how you run alone at night, how you manage to pick only amazing and godly men to be around you. It reads like a fantasy novel blurb, written by men's rights activists. If you did all those things, you're bloody lucky you survived. I work in a large poor country for a few months every year in very rural areas (field work), and the safety rules for females especially are extremely strict, because in these areas women and girls go missing all the time. Almost all the time we make sure that there are men and women working together, but I remember once I was working with three female students, we had no men with us, and I was absolutely terrified every time I heard a car coming down the road, because I knew that I could not defend myself or my students if any of the men got an idea to do anything to us. I will never forget that. I wouldn't let any of the girls go off a little way into the bushes to pee.

It's great that you have no fear and have lived a magical life, and somehow have this supernatural ability to know that the men around you are all good ones who won't hurt you, but it really reads very condescendingly when you say "you must have chosen to have bad men around you so it's your own fault".

Out of curiosity, how would you have avoided this man's seemingly random attack in Bavaria? Would you just have assumed he was safe like every other man you've laid eyes on? Maybe if you had been there he wouldn't have done it, because men don't do bad things when you're around?

MissFancyDay · 17/06/2023 09:28

The test of how men view and treat women is, as a poster commented on upthread, how they treat them when they can get away with it.

You only have to look at how men treat women in a war situation, when they are most likely to go unpunished, to see the truth.

Inkyblue123 · 17/06/2023 09:24

They do it becouse they get away with it. That Colin Pitchfork was released after raping and murder of 2 teenage girls. We need a far more robust judicial systems. Since having my daughter I have changed my mind about the death sentence, I know not everyone thinks the same but the systems we have in place assume that all criminals can and want to be rehabilitated and deserve a second chance. I don’t belive that is the case.

TheoTheopolis23 · 17/06/2023 09:23

It's true that the vast majority of men are kind and loving.

I actually wouldn't agree with that at all.

It's the minority who are truly ok on all fronts.

L3ThirtySeven · 17/06/2023 09:22

falsepositivenervous · 17/06/2023 09:16

So two opinion pieces and two small sample studies from the Americas that have found only a weak association. No correlation and no causation. No comparison to historic rates of violence whatsoever.

falsepositivenervous · 17/06/2023 09:20

It is a mental health issue though. No-one of sound mind plans to murder or cause harm to another

🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄 do you send letters to all the violent men in prison to help keep their morale up? The rapists, the murderers, the child molesters, the domestic abusers? They all can't help it, it's so unfair for them 😭

L3ThirtySeven · 17/06/2023 09:19

falsepositivenervous · 17/06/2023 08:56

Btw, if there is a correlation between violence in films (porn or action), it would seem that the more violent the media we watch is, the less violence then happens in real life.

Many studies have shown that young people are re-enacting what they see in porn, with many school boys thinking it's normal for girls to cry during sex because that's what they always see in porn. Really don't know where you got the idea that porn doesn't influence society, all you need to do is google it. Many researchers are looking into it.

So violent media cannot be causing violence in real life.

Do you really not understand that actors in films are not actually getting stabbed/blown up/strangled on film? Or do you believe that in porn the women aren't actually being penetrated, choked by hands, penises, made to vomit, penetrated by multiple penises at once, etc? Do you think that's all CGI and not being done to actual women?

Just so you know, men don't respect women like you either. Just because you lap up everything they do, even if it hurts women, doesn't mean they won't turn on you some day. No matter what you do, you're still a woman.

So no evidence then, just anecdotes about what you think teenage boys are like.

Most men respect women. I don’t lap up everything they do, don’t be an ass.

falsepositivenervous · 17/06/2023 09:16

@L3ThirtySeven like I said, all you have to do is google it. Here are a few websites and studies on how pornography use is linked to sexualised violence.

scotscoop.com/opinion-pornography-perpetuates-a-culture-of-violence/

www.unitedwecare.com/pornography-and-domestic-violence-two-sides-of-the-same-coin/

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6751001/

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/08862605211055145

CharlotteRumpling · 17/06/2023 09:12

I have travelled alone all over the world. Including in less developed countries. I still know I am at risk. And from whom.

Freefall212 · 17/06/2023 09:10

beguilingeyes · 17/06/2023 07:43

That's a ludicrous comparison. Women don't watch action films (and who's doing the beating and stabbing..is it women?) for the purpose of masturbation. We don't get turned on by this stuff.
It's not just the actual violence, it's the verbal abuse and catcalling. Indecent exposure, which can go in to much more violent crimes (Couzens again) being treated as a bit of a laugh.
Having to think all the time about taking the more brightly lit route home, letting someone know when you've got home safe. Not dreaming of going for a run after dark. It's exhausting.

But we aren't all like that. I have had a very adventurous and low fear life as a woman. I have travelled the world on my own extensively and many times been in very vulnereable situations where I have needed to rely on strangers, men I have only met in that situation for help and I have never been taken advantage of. I have run after dark often and never reported to anyone about getting home. I have taken may risks and put myself in the homes and beds of men unknown to me (in years gone by) and still never been harmed in any way. It changed my view. We are taught that as women, we can't do this or we can't do that as the big bad men will get us but my experience was the opposite. That we need to be filled with fear, but we don't! Time and time again, across the world, all I ran into was great men who helped me, kept me safe, were kind, caring, compassionate, and went out of their way for me. I make thoughtful and smart choices about who I surround myself with in my daily life and in my close relationships.

I am not saying that bad things don't or can't happen, they do. Some are preventable and some are not preventable at all. But fear is a choice. Everyone (men and women) could live in a constant state of fear and stay home and behind locked doors but that is really no way to live. Life involves some risk. We can mitigate that risk without fear. If you have been victimized in a traumatic way, that will shape your view going forward for sure but it also skews your view that everyone is dangerous because one person was.

Swipe left for the next trending thread