Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect some level of household contribution from my 12/13 year olds?

112 replies

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 08:34

I’m being driven nuts. I work part time, at home, 3-4 days. The extra day I spend doing all the usual household shit, mental load stuff of meal planning, shopping, cooking, washing, organising etc. partner works massive hours for good pay which allows me to work part time. I accept the drudge responsibility as a quid pro quo but am starting to expect more from my family as they grow up.

I expect the kids to make their beds, empty their laundry into laundry basket, and clear up after themselves - ie don’t leave shoes/socks/bags/dirty plates etc around. I occasionally get them to wash up etc after a family meal, empty dishwasher, sweep up but it’s not daily or even weekly if I think about it. But they leave a trail of mess like Hansel and gretel breadcrumbs. I am like a broken record. Jam pots left with no lid in height of fly season. Shoes thrown off wherever. Socks removed and dropped wherever they fall. Dirty plates left on side etc. glasses/plates/wrappers left around/ wet towels on floor. Lights left blazing on when nowhere to be seen. And so on.

had a gentle word with both kids last night, saying pls clear up after yourselves, explaining that their hidden message is ‘mum will do it’ when they leave their shit around. Which is insulting to me. This morning - socks still over floor from last night that I’d ask to be cleared, lid left off jam with a fly in it and I finally lost my shit when my 13 year old left her breakfast things next to me as I loaded the dishwasher I had just emptied. She said ‘alright mum, it’s just a plate’ but it’s not just a fucking plate, it’s all the plates and my constant job of clearing up after two people who think they have a maid. They are busy with activities and socials (which I rank as v important for teens esp post covid) and I often find myself doing stuff like picking up socks while they are out so they don’t delay bedtime when they are back. Realise this isn’t helping but I don’t want one issue (mess) impacting another (the constant nag to pack bag, have a shower, get ready for bed at a decent time or leaving for school on time which is another constant bloody nag.

Don’t even get me started on having to micro manage homework, they don’t get a lot but if I didn’t chase them - and say no socials at weekends til it’s done- I’m pretty sure it would be overlooked.

I do phone bans as a sanction for bad behaviour. But I’m fed up with sanctions and nagging and negativity - I just want my children to stop being so bloody entitled and at least look after themselves/stop creating a personal mess?

i am fed up to the back teeth of nagging. I’m absolutely emotionally exhausted by it. I wonder if my expectations are unreasonable with their naturally selfish developing frontal lobes?

AIBU? If not, please tell me how to get them on board in a more positive, conciliatory way which doesn’t just get ignored after a day or create resentment?

OP posts:
Opaque11 · 16/06/2023 14:10

Dotjones · 16/06/2023 09:10

I think YABU to expect anything different given their ages. Give it another decade or so and they'll grow out of it but meantime you have to just accept that this is a phase while they grow into adults.

You end by saying you're fed up with negativity and nagging. If that's the problem, you have the power to solve it - stop being negative, stop nagging. There's a great book by the Arbinger Institute you should read about "thinking outside the box" - basically people get worked up because of their expectations of others are never met, the simple way to solve this is to accept responsibility for whatever task you expected them to do, that way it's no longer their fault so you no longer have to waste your energy getting upset at them.

What utter nonsense. So op just needs to wait it out, and allow them to be lazy people while she skivvies around them. No wonder!
Op Yabu to have gentle words with them. Be firm and have consequences. My dc are much younger and even my 6yo will take his plates to the kitchen and scrape off after eating. He can unpack the dishwasher except cutlery. Excusing them because they are teens and have activities is just pathetic, They are 12 and 13!!

LolaSmiles · 16/06/2023 14:10

Well the latter is linked to the former, so baby steps I suppose?
Yes, they're linked.
You'll be able to achieve compliance on specific chores long before a meaningful or genuine attitude change happens.

It means there's probably going to be an annoying phase where they'll do the bare minimum that you put on a chore list, probably to the bare minimum standard, but then still leave their cups around the place/socks on the floor etc. In that phase they're doing what you ask them to as their contributions, but either through stubbornness, immaturity or because they've not made the link yet they don't see how their other stuff is still an issue.

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 14:06

LolaSmiles · 16/06/2023 14:04

To me there's two linked issues and one is harder to fix. The first is whether the DC do chores. The second is an attitude they have been taught, probably unintentionally, for life: that they can display ridiculous levels of laziness and someone else (probably mum) will clean up after them.

In the short term it's easier to get them doing specific tasks each week. That's easier because it's a simple yes/no answer to 'has this job been done'.

The difficult one is going to be how to change their mindset from begrudgingly doing chores (probably whilst leaving their stuff around still) to accepting they have a responsibility as part of the household to not leave trails of crap behind them

Well the latter is linked to the former, so baby steps I suppose?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 16/06/2023 14:04

To me there's two linked issues and one is harder to fix. The first is whether the DC do chores. The second is an attitude they have been taught, probably unintentionally, for life: that they can display ridiculous levels of laziness and someone else (probably mum) will clean up after them.

In the short term it's easier to get them doing specific tasks each week. That's easier because it's a simple yes/no answer to 'has this job been done'.

The difficult one is going to be how to change their mindset from begrudgingly doing chores (probably whilst leaving their stuff around still) to accepting they have a responsibility as part of the household to not leave trails of crap behind them

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 14:03

Appleofmyeye2023 · 16/06/2023 13:47

I am going to show them this - message through humour is surely stronger?

OP posts:
doubleoseven · 16/06/2023 13:59

Meh. I remind mine a couple times during the week they have to bring down dirty dishes (and wash them since they've been there days) and rubbish, put laundry in the bin. Natural consequences if they don't. No clean school clothes or glasses for juice (I have my own they're not allowed to use!) . It doesn't affect me if they get a telling off at school. Don't care if they leave beds unmade, it's not me getting into it at bedtime, they do have to strip and change covers once a week. If still not done at end of week I just go in and tell them in my special tone to get it done now. Usually works. I'm not up for constant nagging, it's exhausting and doesn't work anyway.

CeliaNorth · 16/06/2023 13:56

Some things you will just have to do - like the jam lid.

Why? Why is it too much to expect a 12/13 yo to put the lid on a jamjar?

Unless op is following them round the house, by the time she finds the jar with the lid off it's too late anyway and the food is wasted. Waste is waste, regardless of whether op 's family can afford to throw away jars of jam.

I agree with pp, no more jam, or op buys it only for herself and dh.

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 11:57

Esmereldapawpatrol · 16/06/2023 11:33

My 10 and 8 year old have some responsibilities as I am their Mother not their bloody slave!

They make their own beds, take it in turns each morning so one feeds the Guinea Pig and one packs the lunch boxes (I make their sandwiches but don't see the point being stood their asking what flavour crisps/fruit they want when they are quite capable). They bring their empty plates/dishes to the dishwasher after meals, help set the table and clear away. They might grumble sometimes but generally they just get on with it. I feel it's really important to teach kids early that they are responsible for themselves (obviously while being age appropriate) and they shouldn't rely on someone else coming in to pick up and clean up after them.

It's how man-child's are made when they don't have to lift a finger, ever, and the world has enough of those!!!!!!

Completely agree but it’s not men-children - mine are both girls and I don’t want being lazy flat mates/friends/partners either!

OP posts:
Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 11:56

2bazookas · 16/06/2023 11:15

You could just go for Operation Shock and Awe.

Tell the kids they will have no phones, pocket money or taxi service for one week starting today. They have seven days to start pulling their weight in all the ways already requested many times . So, you're not going to list them again. They are on their own. There will be no negotiations, no giving in.
Either, they EARN their privileges, or there will be none.

This is awfully tempting. Maybe with a final warning first? See, I’m shit at this. I do so want them to be both happy and not lazy little shits, such a bloody conundrum.

OP posts:
L3ThirtySeven · 16/06/2023 11:53

2bazookas · 16/06/2023 11:15

You could just go for Operation Shock and Awe.

Tell the kids they will have no phones, pocket money or taxi service for one week starting today. They have seven days to start pulling their weight in all the ways already requested many times . So, you're not going to list them again. They are on their own. There will be no negotiations, no giving in.
Either, they EARN their privileges, or there will be none.

That sounds more like Operation Blow Up to Create Resentment

Esmereldapawpatrol · 16/06/2023 11:33

My 10 and 8 year old have some responsibilities as I am their Mother not their bloody slave!

They make their own beds, take it in turns each morning so one feeds the Guinea Pig and one packs the lunch boxes (I make their sandwiches but don't see the point being stood their asking what flavour crisps/fruit they want when they are quite capable). They bring their empty plates/dishes to the dishwasher after meals, help set the table and clear away. They might grumble sometimes but generally they just get on with it. I feel it's really important to teach kids early that they are responsible for themselves (obviously while being age appropriate) and they shouldn't rely on someone else coming in to pick up and clean up after them.

It's how man-child's are made when they don't have to lift a finger, ever, and the world has enough of those!!!!!!

2bazookas · 16/06/2023 11:15

You could just go for Operation Shock and Awe.

Tell the kids they will have no phones, pocket money or taxi service for one week starting today. They have seven days to start pulling their weight in all the ways already requested many times . So, you're not going to list them again. They are on their own. There will be no negotiations, no giving in.
Either, they EARN their privileges, or there will be none.

Bunnycat101 · 16/06/2023 11:07

I am somewhat comforted that other people have this issue too. I am having major problems with my 7yo trashing the place and not clearing up after herself at the moment but also doing things to push boundaries a bit I think. I’ve had lots of conversations about why it’s not fair, how can we make it easier for her to remember etc. She’s much worse than my 4yo and I’m slightly terrified she’ll still be like this as a teenager (or worse).

As an example, she leaves wet towels on the floor, dirty pants etc whereas the little one puts things in the washing basket. She is super creative but I have never seen a child as messy in their play. I wouldn’t mind if she then tidied up afterwards but she can trash a room in about 3 minutes.

The other evening she was supposed to be tidying her room and instead decided to get glitter out and then dropped it, smashing the large pot and just left it with no care in the world. I have never seen so much sparkly shit in my entire life. It is literally everywhere and I’ve already vacuumed. I am trying to take tips from this thread as it’s driving me bonkers and I hate nagging all the time.

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 11:06

Appleofmyeye2023 · 16/06/2023 10:55

observations really

-my eldest was chronically messy. Still is. In his late twenties. He is like pigpen and leaves a trail of detritus wherever he goes. No amount of threats, punishments, rewards, please made an iota of difference. He is now but only since he had to live on his own or live with people that were also dirty. Whereas my youngest was never like that, naturally tidy . Didn’t treat them any differently to encourage younger one to be tidy. Same sex, not that big a difference in ages . Sometimes it is about how people are- some are just the types of people who need order and see mess naturally. The rest can put up with mess till it becomes a burning platform so to speak. My eldest’s burning platform was living on his own and finding his mess accumulated to a level even he couldn’t stand

-I got a cleaner for this reason. Housework is soul destroying imho. Chaos theory and entropy and all that. No sooner than you’re done and have a clean house than it starts to deteriorate. It comes from skin cells shedding, normally bodily functions, the acts of cooking annd eating, windows open with nsects coming in people walking n form outdoors, maybe pets, etc etc . , There is nothing you can do to control that, zilch. Other than live on your own with just one body making your own mess 🤣. If you are, like most women today, working and used to doing something that is a bit constructive in your day job, it is just so bloody hard to have one day per week when your life is reduced to the completely unconstructive task of cleaning. when you’re cleaning you know it will be unclean again by the next week and so on to infinity. No wonder it would drive anyone to exasperation. Seeing all your hard work being messed up by kids is not for the faint hearted or those that like some degree of control in their lives. You will have constant arguments and rising resentment of your kids , and even dh, all the time you are doing this. If you can afford it get a cleaner-it’s a bloody sight easier ignoring the mess building when you know it’s not you that has to clean it up. It stops a lot of arguments

how much do you earn per hour? If it is more than you pay the cleaner then stop taking time out of your paid employment and pay a cleaner instead- outsource to someone who will get a benefit form these tasks and ensure you pay them fairly. Not only will you be better off in terms of income, it will also make a differnec3 to your future pension, and will help you maintain your progression as part timers are also most always held back on progression. There is literally no point you giving up hours work to do domestic manual labour if you earn more than you could pay for that service. If you are working part time it should be to do the job you need that no money could buy to the standard you’d do yourself - looking after your kids. If they’re school age they don’t need thst during day, so ask to switch to term time working hours to support kids only.

Thank you for this, it made me feel completely understood. M

ironically it’s not the day a week of drudge that kills me, it’s the death by a thousand cuts in between. But I hear you and will think about that too.

OP posts:
Appleofmyeye2023 · 16/06/2023 10:55

observations really

-my eldest was chronically messy. Still is. In his late twenties. He is like pigpen and leaves a trail of detritus wherever he goes. No amount of threats, punishments, rewards, please made an iota of difference. He is now but only since he had to live on his own or live with people that were also dirty. Whereas my youngest was never like that, naturally tidy . Didn’t treat them any differently to encourage younger one to be tidy. Same sex, not that big a difference in ages . Sometimes it is about how people are- some are just the types of people who need order and see mess naturally. The rest can put up with mess till it becomes a burning platform so to speak. My eldest’s burning platform was living on his own and finding his mess accumulated to a level even he couldn’t stand

-I got a cleaner for this reason. Housework is soul destroying imho. Chaos theory and entropy and all that. No sooner than you’re done and have a clean house than it starts to deteriorate. It comes from skin cells shedding, normally bodily functions, the acts of cooking annd eating, windows open with nsects coming in people walking n form outdoors, maybe pets, etc etc . , There is nothing you can do to control that, zilch. Other than live on your own with just one body making your own mess 🤣. If you are, like most women today, working and used to doing something that is a bit constructive in your day job, it is just so bloody hard to have one day per week when your life is reduced to the completely unconstructive task of cleaning. when you’re cleaning you know it will be unclean again by the next week and so on to infinity. No wonder it would drive anyone to exasperation. Seeing all your hard work being messed up by kids is not for the faint hearted or those that like some degree of control in their lives. You will have constant arguments and rising resentment of your kids , and even dh, all the time you are doing this. If you can afford it get a cleaner-it’s a bloody sight easier ignoring the mess building when you know it’s not you that has to clean it up. It stops a lot of arguments

how much do you earn per hour? If it is more than you pay the cleaner then stop taking time out of your paid employment and pay a cleaner instead- outsource to someone who will get a benefit form these tasks and ensure you pay them fairly. Not only will you be better off in terms of income, it will also make a differnec3 to your future pension, and will help you maintain your progression as part timers are also most always held back on progression. There is literally no point you giving up hours work to do domestic manual labour if you earn more than you could pay for that service. If you are working part time it should be to do the job you need that no money could buy to the standard you’d do yourself - looking after your kids. If they’re school age they don’t need thst during day, so ask to switch to term time working hours to support kids only.

Yousee · 16/06/2023 10:55

I feel you, OP. We have DSD for the whole summer holidays and I'm dreading it as she just leaves tides of crap in her wake, rubbish falls where it falls, dishes left wherever, shoes carefully positioned at the bottom of the stairs as a trip hazard, she will finish the loo roll and not get more from the cupboard etc etc.
She's 11 and at a stage of absolutely having to have certain tops or leggings to wear on particular days so she's always checking up with me on whether her laundry is done. She's not getting the message that I will not be Searching her room/bag for washing and if it's not in the basket then it's not getting washed.
Her 3 year old brother proudly chucks his clothes in the basket so I'm pretty sure it's not a wildly age inappropriate expectation.
I've told DH he will have to get serious with her as I'm returning to work after mat leave soon and I don't have the bandwidth to be picking up after people who are old enough to do it themselves.
She's a good kid, not a bad bone in her body, it's just a blind spot she's got that nothing is her responsibility. Doesn't make it less frustrating!

Jennna · 16/06/2023 10:52

The 2 things that stood out to me was the "gentle word" and the fact that they know "mum will do it".

My kids when at the same age done all of this themselves and their homework, because they were taught they need to. And firm enough for them to believe me. They do the dishwasher regular as well, they will hoover round without being asked, just because they know that not much is asked of them anyway so they help when needed. In the grand scheme of things it's probably less than an hour a week (excl homework) they spend each doing these things but keeping on top of it. It's really not a lot to ask.

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 10:29

stealthninjamum · 16/06/2023 10:15

mine are about that sort of age and have got better as a natural consequences, a tiny bit of shouting (that I try not to do) and general education on housework - kids don’t naturally know how to tidy or declutter so they need to be taught.

They have to see the benefits of doing it and if my house isn’t tidy then they can’t have friends over. If their clothes aren’t in a washing basket they don’t get washed. If dd2 leaves her discarded clothes / towels in the bathroom I put them in a corner of her bedroom out of my sight. I don’t nag them to do homework - teachers do. My dc have autism and adhd and if they forget things or get overwhelmed my job is to support them to get over these problems, it’s not easy and sometimes I will let things slide. Tomorrow dd1 has a friend over so we meal planned and wrote the shopping list together. Tonight dd1 will tidy her bedroom and if the dishwasher is already turned on she’ll wash the mugs in her room up by hand or she won’t get another play date.

I would just let them wear stinky clothes, ignore the mess in the bedroom, move any objects left lying around the house back to their bedroom in a pile. If they’re making too much mess having endless snacks stop buying the snacks. Dd2 won’t wash up yogurt pots after she’s eaten them so I have temporarily stopped buying them. I haven’t nagged her about this, next week I’ll buy more and have one conversation about her washing the pots up. If she doesn’t I’ll stop buying them for another fortnight. The cycle will quietly repeat until she does it.

also find jobs they do like and congratulate them. Dd1 sometimes goes food shopping for dinner on her way home from school. She’s been able to cook a basic meal from about the age of 11. She is in a gardening club at school so has been repotting and watering plants for me too.

Gosh that sounds like it’s worked? I do wonder whether their stacked calendar and lift requirements, on top of a demanding (albeit part time) role means I am constantly low level impatient. I’m aware that stacked diary might be limiting the amount of patient conversations we can have. It’s trying to fit this stuff in around too much. Food fir thought.

I like the idea of no tidy/no jobs = no lifts/social. I did it once and felt terrible guilt, but I did it in anger. If it’s a set consequence, and it’s delivered calmly, i honestly think it has more chance of getting through. I have become white noise.

OP posts:
IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 16/06/2023 10:28

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 09:28

I think this will work but worry they’ll just wear stinky clothes and that would probably upset me more than the socks.

Stinky clothes is their problem, not yours. Time to toughen up and let them start solving their own problems. If nothing else, peer pressure will rapidly sort them out.

I once had a lodger who had finally left home at the age of 29. I had to explain to him how to separate lights and darks, and how to work a washing machine. Don't let your children grow up like him.

stealthninjamum · 16/06/2023 10:15

mine are about that sort of age and have got better as a natural consequences, a tiny bit of shouting (that I try not to do) and general education on housework - kids don’t naturally know how to tidy or declutter so they need to be taught.

They have to see the benefits of doing it and if my house isn’t tidy then they can’t have friends over. If their clothes aren’t in a washing basket they don’t get washed. If dd2 leaves her discarded clothes / towels in the bathroom I put them in a corner of her bedroom out of my sight. I don’t nag them to do homework - teachers do. My dc have autism and adhd and if they forget things or get overwhelmed my job is to support them to get over these problems, it’s not easy and sometimes I will let things slide. Tomorrow dd1 has a friend over so we meal planned and wrote the shopping list together. Tonight dd1 will tidy her bedroom and if the dishwasher is already turned on she’ll wash the mugs in her room up by hand or she won’t get another play date.

I would just let them wear stinky clothes, ignore the mess in the bedroom, move any objects left lying around the house back to their bedroom in a pile. If they’re making too much mess having endless snacks stop buying the snacks. Dd2 won’t wash up yogurt pots after she’s eaten them so I have temporarily stopped buying them. I haven’t nagged her about this, next week I’ll buy more and have one conversation about her washing the pots up. If she doesn’t I’ll stop buying them for another fortnight. The cycle will quietly repeat until she does it.

also find jobs they do like and congratulate them. Dd1 sometimes goes food shopping for dinner on her way home from school. She’s been able to cook a basic meal from about the age of 11. She is in a gardening club at school so has been repotting and watering plants for me too.

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 10:13

Paq · 16/06/2023 10:09

Also, just to add, your partner should be equally involved in getting the kids to pitch in. It’s not just mums who raise kids to be tidy adults.

And he does, when he is here.

OP posts:
Paq · 16/06/2023 10:09

Also, just to add, your partner should be equally involved in getting the kids to pitch in. It’s not just mums who raise kids to be tidy adults.

Lcb123 · 16/06/2023 09:54

If you have boy(s), this is even more important given how rubbish a lot of adult men seem to be at doing their share.

Lcb123 · 16/06/2023 09:52

Of course they should, and should have done since they were much younger. Would it help to have specific tasks rather than general ‘contribution’? Agree together then there should be consequences if they don’t to the tasks, like reduced pocket money

Swipe left for the next trending thread