Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect some level of household contribution from my 12/13 year olds?

112 replies

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 08:34

I’m being driven nuts. I work part time, at home, 3-4 days. The extra day I spend doing all the usual household shit, mental load stuff of meal planning, shopping, cooking, washing, organising etc. partner works massive hours for good pay which allows me to work part time. I accept the drudge responsibility as a quid pro quo but am starting to expect more from my family as they grow up.

I expect the kids to make their beds, empty their laundry into laundry basket, and clear up after themselves - ie don’t leave shoes/socks/bags/dirty plates etc around. I occasionally get them to wash up etc after a family meal, empty dishwasher, sweep up but it’s not daily or even weekly if I think about it. But they leave a trail of mess like Hansel and gretel breadcrumbs. I am like a broken record. Jam pots left with no lid in height of fly season. Shoes thrown off wherever. Socks removed and dropped wherever they fall. Dirty plates left on side etc. glasses/plates/wrappers left around/ wet towels on floor. Lights left blazing on when nowhere to be seen. And so on.

had a gentle word with both kids last night, saying pls clear up after yourselves, explaining that their hidden message is ‘mum will do it’ when they leave their shit around. Which is insulting to me. This morning - socks still over floor from last night that I’d ask to be cleared, lid left off jam with a fly in it and I finally lost my shit when my 13 year old left her breakfast things next to me as I loaded the dishwasher I had just emptied. She said ‘alright mum, it’s just a plate’ but it’s not just a fucking plate, it’s all the plates and my constant job of clearing up after two people who think they have a maid. They are busy with activities and socials (which I rank as v important for teens esp post covid) and I often find myself doing stuff like picking up socks while they are out so they don’t delay bedtime when they are back. Realise this isn’t helping but I don’t want one issue (mess) impacting another (the constant nag to pack bag, have a shower, get ready for bed at a decent time or leaving for school on time which is another constant bloody nag.

Don’t even get me started on having to micro manage homework, they don’t get a lot but if I didn’t chase them - and say no socials at weekends til it’s done- I’m pretty sure it would be overlooked.

I do phone bans as a sanction for bad behaviour. But I’m fed up with sanctions and nagging and negativity - I just want my children to stop being so bloody entitled and at least look after themselves/stop creating a personal mess?

i am fed up to the back teeth of nagging. I’m absolutely emotionally exhausted by it. I wonder if my expectations are unreasonable with their naturally selfish developing frontal lobes?

AIBU? If not, please tell me how to get them on board in a more positive, conciliatory way which doesn’t just get ignored after a day or create resentment?

OP posts:
GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 17/06/2023 07:21

My son is exactly the same it drives me nuts.

Augend23 · 17/06/2023 07:21

I agree with the natural consequences points.

I'd also suggest doing a list (once) of all the things you expect them to do. Laminate it if you can, or put it on a whiteboard or let them make a copy on their phones.

i.e.

Check house for my possessions
Check house for my washing up
Put washing in washing basket
Put away clean washing
Check homework diary for new homework
Do new homework

Do it at a really granular level. They then have a thing they can check every day. I would either then put it in a really prominent place, and to start with ask them to check the list once a day (for example after school, once they have had a snack) at a time when there's time to work through the list.

I have vivid memories of being left in the house as a teenager and my mum coming back and asking "why haven't you hung the washing out/hoovered/done this other thing" - they were all things she saw needed doing but at that age I just really didn't notice it. Whereas as an adult I have a mental list of all the things I need to check if they need doing and can just run through it. So I wonder if a physical list might be the stepping stone while they haven't got to the point that they have the mental list?

Combine that with no lifts etc etc and you'll get somewhere. I do suggest you make the consequences clear beforehand though - if your daughter thought she was okay to do homework Sunday (because she would have been before) and is now missing a day out, then that will be mighty frustrating for her. But if she's had advance warning that she needed to do it before the weekend because she's going to be too busy to do it then then that's her lookout.

Moopyhereagain · 17/06/2023 07:16

My sons were the same. A decade on they still sort of are - they just don’t see it until they are ready to see it. I spent a lot of time getting in turns angry /taken for granted / sad/ frustrated. It started to become the whole tone of our relationship. Eventually I backed off, got a cleaner and sort of lived with it. I do sometimes reflect and wonder if actually the part of parenting that is sort of trying to ‘train’ kids has any value at all and ever makes any difference. They are either messy or tidy? You can smooth the edges but that’s it? Maybe I should have approached differently but they are now both lovely, successful, popular and we are very close. They are really messy though and I could not live with them now! (shudder)

Zanatdy · 17/06/2023 07:08

You’re not being unreasonable and they are perfectly capable of doing what you asked. I haven’t got involved in homework since my kids started secondary, I’ve always left them to manage it, and natural consequences if it’s not done (detentions where it gets done). Fortunately both kids have excelled and do their homework as they want to do well rather than as I’ve nagged. Give them some self responsibility around homework as the school will deal with it if they don’t do it.

Hoaryragwort · 17/06/2023 07:05

All these people saying “start them young”; I did! My two had set chores from the age of seven to fourteen - everything from emptying the dw, helping dust annd hoover, doing the recycling, walking the dog, making their beds - and they did them enthusiastically with hardly any prompting.

BUT the minute adolescence arrived; they didn’t lift a finger and it got to the point where I was driven mad by their laziness and it caused a really negative atmosphere in the house, and the fact that their dad had no interest in enforcing domestic rules made it worse! I felt I was battling him as well!

So I gave up! For eight weeks! And no one lifted a finger in that time. I did the basics like dw and rubbish and kept the fridge hygienic and that was it. No one had clean clothes except me. The crap built up on every horizontal surface. Clothes appeared on bedroom floors. Empty loo rolls and shampoo bottles appeared in the bathroom. The hall was jammed with bags and step ladders , tools and cardboard boxes. We had lots of takeaways.

I wish I could say that everything worked out well after that. It did in the sense that my dh took over the food shopping and cooking and my teens now take care of their rooms and their own laundry and they occasionally cook a meal too. I am the one who still cleans the bathrooms and the kitchen, I do all garden maintenance, and I do the tidying up and cleaning in the “shared rooms” , mostly look after the fog, and I carry the mental load I suppose of keeping the show on the road in that I organise holidays and days out and any diy that needs to be done. The house is not at the same level of organisation when I was in charge by myself but it’s just about ok.

Certainly everyone appreciates now how much time goes in to doing the maintenance cleaning jobs but my view is that unless you have a partner who cares as much about the housework as you do, especially clearing up after themselves, you are fighting a losing battle I’m afraid.

BCBird · 17/06/2023 06:27

Pulares= plates kids on jam jars= lids. 🙈

BCBird · 17/06/2023 06:26

I remember when I was a teenager- 4 decades ago,we all had specific chores to do. These were linked to allowing us to go out. Pilates would not be allowed upstairs OP. I also would not be prepared to put kids on jam jars etc. They must do their bit. I think the problem is,if u have always done it,they are probably thinking,why now do we have to start doing this stuff? I think all of u,including your husband need to sit down and talk about what can be done for smooth running and harmony at home. Perhaps before the 'meeting'yiu can all have a think about one thing u could do that would make a difference. My sister has put a white board in the kitchen where she writes a message if anything additional needs to be dine. She has waited on her family for years- it is helping. Good luck OP

CorruptAppleYard · 17/06/2023 06:06

@Guiltridden12345 as a child I was given a lot of responsibility at an early age. I swore I wouldn't burden my children with the same. But gradually I just added to the expectations of what they were responsible for. A toddler can put clothes into a laundry basket.

I would have a really good think about how you expect this to go from now on but the one piece of advice I will give is at least at the start don't do the ad-hoc stuff, just get them into a routine of doing things, just like they brush their teeth every day. As your two are now at secondary they can empty the dishwasher, stick a rota up on the fridge. If you get each one to do a Sunday and a Monday then they both cover a weekend load. In this house I empty the dishwasher one day a week, the children do alternate days. When Ds1 is at uni, Ds2 keeps his usual days and Dh and I cover Ds1's turns.

I don't agree with ever paying children to do chores, this gives them the impression of choice. No one pays an adult to tidy and clean. I also don't agree with allowing them the choice of having dirty clothes, some children will not give a shit about wearing stained, food encrusted clothes. I was not going to allow my children the chance to think this was acceptable. I also never yell, I calmly point out the things that aren't done. Then they do it. I think calm and stern works better than angry yelling.

We also had high standards for homework, it was done to a good standard or there would be consequences. I know people say well they have to live with the consequences but you really want your child to have a shitty life with no money and would watch them do that?

It makes it sound like our household wasn't ever fun. The whole everyone clear down the kitchen was done to music (linked dining room and kitchen speaker) or a podcast or everyone just chatting. If you gradually add in chores as they go then it doesn't suddenly become a mountain of tasks they didn't have to do before. So have a list of expectations on the fridge, everyone knows what it expected of them and all activities, phones etc are a privilege not a right. To put it in the most basic terms, if I get what I want, you get what you want. Same as a job, the company gets what they want from you in terms of tasks, you get what you want which is the money for your work. You might also want to list all the things you as parents do from meal planning, to food shopping, to rotating food in the fridge, just to show them where they are expected to be in later life.

Weenurse · 17/06/2023 06:06

We had a family meeting and pointed out we all work/ study full time.
we all contributed to the mess so we all needed to contribute to the running of the house.
Chores were then discussed and a roster agreed to and posted on the kitchen door. Roster took into account part time work and sport commitments.
First few weeks everyone did their chores at the same time and they could see that we were a team.
Became routine after that.
They did their own washing and bathroom. Cooked 1 night a week and cleaned kitchen 2 nights a week. Fed animals etc. Seeing their Dad checking the roster each night for his chores also reinforced things.
good luck

Splishsploshsplash · 17/06/2023 05:52

I’d be incredibly blunt…. I’m not your maid, I don’t exist to clean up after you. If you are not prepared to do the basics I won’t be driving you to your extra curricular/social events (or whatever is the appropriate consequence).

My seven and nine year olds don’t get away with what you are enabling. Their big thing is mine craft so dirty plates left on the counter, beds unmade etc. means no game time that day.

OhcantthInkofaname · 16/06/2023 23:53

How about instead of taking away devices you make them earn the use to start with?

hettie · 16/06/2023 23:02

Ours have set tasks and general please clean up after yourself lines...I make them come and pick up every last sockk/plate/wrapper every time and instantly no matter what they are doing. It's painful for them and is slowly gaining traction. I also refuse point blank to tidy up after them and tell them I'm not "Dobby the House Elf". If they don't put stuff in the wash (including school clothes and PE kit) it won't be clean.
Homework... Well I create the conditions and ask but it's on them. They want to piss their teachers off/get detentions/crap qualifications thats on them. They know they won't be getting hand outs or financial help if they can't be fucked to take the opportunities they've been given (good school/nice area/parental support). Thus far this is working ok, they take responsibility and agree generally good kids. Autonomy and natural consequences mostly....

lunar1 · 16/06/2023 22:33

My children are too old for a jobs list at 14 and 12, they live in our family home where we are all responsible for keeping it nice. They look after their rooms.

They know how to do all the housework and will do what needs doing like the rest of us.

They can cook a family meal, which includes cleaning up as they go.

My eldest will go do a food shop.

They aren't doing me favours and don't see it as such. I promised myself when I had two sons that I wouldn't be responsible for sending useless men out into the world!

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 22:03

CorruptAppleYard · 16/06/2023 21:57

Yes she stays home to do the homework. That is what you said, stand by it, don't be swayed by the crying. I am sure if you had work to complete in work time and pissed around then cried when you were asked to do that work, your boss wouldn't say of course you can just do a half arsed job of it, you go and have fun.

Basically your children just ignore what you say, you ask them to do things, they don't, you then pick it up anyway or yell at them and still do it. Stop doing it. I told mine to stop balling their socks when they took them off, they didn't so I made them stop mid game (deliberate) and unball a week's worth of school socks each. That was in primary school.

Have a family meeting and tell them you are tired of being disrespected, that they need to clear up after themselves, you will no longer be doing it and if that means they miss an activity or meeting up with friends then that is the consequence of their actions. Ask them to think what a consequence will be for leaving the lid off the jam jar? It might mean coming back to another family meeting a day later when everyone has had time to digest the information.

I stood over mine when they were little re putting dirty clothes into the laundry, tidying their rooms etc and now have children who have tidy rooms. I shared a room as a child so we were tidy as the space was really small and my Mum was a stickler for tidying.

Not always easy but if you all eat together, then everyone is involved in meal prep or table setting, at the end of the meal everyone clears everything off the table, it goes into the dishwasher or gets hand washed. Everything gets dried and put away, units wiped down, table wiped down. No one sits down or leaves the kitchen until it is all complete. That is how young children learn and appreciate all the usually unseen tasks parents do.

This is incredibly good advice. I am going to do this. Why should they go off while we clear up? No more! Crikey we’ve been really shit.

OP posts:
Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 22:01

I think for us we want to hit her where it hurts - in the socials. It is making me feel incredibly anxious and upset. But I will stand firm.

she’d gone to bed in a rage (we were both in a rage, her at my decision, me at her utter inability to accept any part in this happening) and she got up again, apologised, said she didn’t want to go to bed on a bad note, cried, tried to get around me, and then stomped off again when I said thank you for the apology, I love her too but we are standing firm. I have clearly caved too many times previously and she thinks she can get around me. I am now realising that I am doing her no favours being so flip-floppy.

OP posts:
whatkatydid2013 · 16/06/2023 21:57

kids can be hugely irritating and they vary so much in how well they manage different tasks. My youngest is great at doing her bedroom and keeping it mainly tidy. My eldest is great at volunteering to help with jobs round the house. Both of them are slower and do it less well than us so I have to hold myself back from just doing it for them.

CorruptAppleYard · 16/06/2023 21:57

Yes she stays home to do the homework. That is what you said, stand by it, don't be swayed by the crying. I am sure if you had work to complete in work time and pissed around then cried when you were asked to do that work, your boss wouldn't say of course you can just do a half arsed job of it, you go and have fun.

Basically your children just ignore what you say, you ask them to do things, they don't, you then pick it up anyway or yell at them and still do it. Stop doing it. I told mine to stop balling their socks when they took them off, they didn't so I made them stop mid game (deliberate) and unball a week's worth of school socks each. That was in primary school.

Have a family meeting and tell them you are tired of being disrespected, that they need to clear up after themselves, you will no longer be doing it and if that means they miss an activity or meeting up with friends then that is the consequence of their actions. Ask them to think what a consequence will be for leaving the lid off the jam jar? It might mean coming back to another family meeting a day later when everyone has had time to digest the information.

I stood over mine when they were little re putting dirty clothes into the laundry, tidying their rooms etc and now have children who have tidy rooms. I shared a room as a child so we were tidy as the space was really small and my Mum was a stickler for tidying.

Not always easy but if you all eat together, then everyone is involved in meal prep or table setting, at the end of the meal everyone clears everything off the table, it goes into the dishwasher or gets hand washed. Everything gets dried and put away, units wiped down, table wiped down. No one sits down or leaves the kitchen until it is all complete. That is how young children learn and appreciate all the usually unseen tasks parents do.

Patchworksack · 16/06/2023 21:53

We find ‘The Saturday box’ useful. Anything left lying around get’s unceremoniously flung into a big storage box, the leaver loses it until Saturday. On Saturday the box is upended and anything not returned to its rightful place goes in the bin. This applies to shared areas of the house - they can do what they like in their own room. I only wash clothes that are put in the washing basket and if they have no clean clothes that’s tough. I nag about the dishwasher - it drives me mad that they eat breakfast and leave the dishes on the counter. They have to stop whatever they are doing to come and put them away. It is aggravating but I am not there to be their skivvy. Work in progress but the worst thing is just to pick up after them. If you say you can’t do x until y is done then you need to follow through, every time.

isthewashingdryyet · 16/06/2023 21:48

You are right, hold your nerve.

Or let her suffer the consequences of home work not done, as that is also a natural consequence

just don’t bail her out

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 21:31

So an update. DD13 had a group of friends over tonight. I made them all dinner. Left their stuff by dishwasher and some on table. Told her to clear it and she did it only partly before she had to go to an activity. She hadn’t done another standing chore (animal care) either.

She has a day out tomorrow planned and a sleepover. I said she could go if she’d done her homework. I reminded her during the week. She’s only just got back and is going to bed now. She still hasn’t done any of her homework. She can’t do it Sunday as she’ll be knackered so it’s pointless and will be done badly. this is all part of the same thing isn’t it - not taking responsibility - and I need to woman up?

I’ve said she can go to the sleepover but has to stay home in day to do homework. She’s in bits and I’m the worst mum ever. I can’t bear the crying and I hate the aggression that follows. But I’m right arent I? You have to do your jobs before you get your playtime? And this is all
connected isn’t it, the entitlement and, date i say it, brattishness, and needs knocking on the head?

OP posts:
HollyBookBlue · 16/06/2023 21:20

Go back to natural consequences. Don't buy jam. Tell them all their stuff that's left all over the house will be collected into a bin bag and left in their room. Close their bedroom door on it and don't think about the mess. Don't wash their clothes if not in the laundry basket. When they flip out that the have no clean underwear, their room stinks and they're embarrassed to invite a friend round, gentle parent the fuck out of them! "I understand that you're feeling angry because you don't have clean pants for school, it's a shame you didn't put them in the washing basket, what do you think you could do better next time?"

SpottedOnMN · 16/06/2023 21:20

What worked for me was giving them jobs that got worse if they weren’t done. So one child has to unload the dishwasher every day, and if it’s not empty when I come to load it they have to reload it as well. The other has to unload the airers, fold the laundry and distribute. If the airer isn’t empty when I want to hang my wash out they have to hang the wash out too. To me those are natural consequences.

I must admit they were never bad at leaving their stuff lying round and they have always been pretty good at tidying their rooms and doing their own laundry from mid teens. Can’t claim much credit for that.

I’ve never linked chores to pocket money as they’re not optional, we all have to do them as we all live here.

specialsauce · 16/06/2023 21:07

Opaque11 · 16/06/2023 14:11

If he's old enough to play on the XBox he's bloody old enough to fold up the entire laundry. What a joke, no wonder some adults are so useless !!

Judgemental much🙄

If you take the knives out of the dishwasher your kid should be able to empty the whole thing. He is 6 after all.

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 14:19

im clearly not alone in pandering to my kids! It’s not deliberate pandering though, it’s the frustrated ‘I’d rather do it myself’ approach which at the time seems easier than the ‘spend double the time arguing and get the job done badly’ approach simply because I’m time poor and don’t want to fill that time with conflict. But I can see that this route has the potential to create monsters so I’m keen to change approach and will incorporate many of these very helpful ideas.

OP posts:
Opaque11 · 16/06/2023 14:11

specialsauce · 16/06/2023 09:46

Little tip: start small and build on it.
I'd give my son 2 socks to pair up while he's sat on his xbox. Then a few weeks later 2 pairs of socks etc. Now I can give him all his socks out of the wash and he'll pair them all up without thinking.

If he's old enough to play on the XBox he's bloody old enough to fold up the entire laundry. What a joke, no wonder some adults are so useless !!

Swipe left for the next trending thread