Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect some level of household contribution from my 12/13 year olds?

112 replies

Guiltridden12345 · 16/06/2023 08:34

I’m being driven nuts. I work part time, at home, 3-4 days. The extra day I spend doing all the usual household shit, mental load stuff of meal planning, shopping, cooking, washing, organising etc. partner works massive hours for good pay which allows me to work part time. I accept the drudge responsibility as a quid pro quo but am starting to expect more from my family as they grow up.

I expect the kids to make their beds, empty their laundry into laundry basket, and clear up after themselves - ie don’t leave shoes/socks/bags/dirty plates etc around. I occasionally get them to wash up etc after a family meal, empty dishwasher, sweep up but it’s not daily or even weekly if I think about it. But they leave a trail of mess like Hansel and gretel breadcrumbs. I am like a broken record. Jam pots left with no lid in height of fly season. Shoes thrown off wherever. Socks removed and dropped wherever they fall. Dirty plates left on side etc. glasses/plates/wrappers left around/ wet towels on floor. Lights left blazing on when nowhere to be seen. And so on.

had a gentle word with both kids last night, saying pls clear up after yourselves, explaining that their hidden message is ‘mum will do it’ when they leave their shit around. Which is insulting to me. This morning - socks still over floor from last night that I’d ask to be cleared, lid left off jam with a fly in it and I finally lost my shit when my 13 year old left her breakfast things next to me as I loaded the dishwasher I had just emptied. She said ‘alright mum, it’s just a plate’ but it’s not just a fucking plate, it’s all the plates and my constant job of clearing up after two people who think they have a maid. They are busy with activities and socials (which I rank as v important for teens esp post covid) and I often find myself doing stuff like picking up socks while they are out so they don’t delay bedtime when they are back. Realise this isn’t helping but I don’t want one issue (mess) impacting another (the constant nag to pack bag, have a shower, get ready for bed at a decent time or leaving for school on time which is another constant bloody nag.

Don’t even get me started on having to micro manage homework, they don’t get a lot but if I didn’t chase them - and say no socials at weekends til it’s done- I’m pretty sure it would be overlooked.

I do phone bans as a sanction for bad behaviour. But I’m fed up with sanctions and nagging and negativity - I just want my children to stop being so bloody entitled and at least look after themselves/stop creating a personal mess?

i am fed up to the back teeth of nagging. I’m absolutely emotionally exhausted by it. I wonder if my expectations are unreasonable with their naturally selfish developing frontal lobes?

AIBU? If not, please tell me how to get them on board in a more positive, conciliatory way which doesn’t just get ignored after a day or create resentment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Doone21 · 18/06/2023 15:41

You should have been on this from the start, not waiting til they were teenagers!
It's about raising them to have lifeskills. Share workload, responsibility for doing and thinking.
I've no idea how to turn it around at this late stage but you're not unreasonable to expect it of them. You are unreasonable to expect it of them when you've raised them to be lazy selfish brats.
Start being a bit more of a disciplinarian and set expectations and stick to them I guess.

TrishTrix · 17/06/2023 23:24

Another one to think about is them cooking.

my friend’s 16yo DS and I trade recipes. He cooks one night a week during the school holidays.

we are both similarly unenthusiastic cooks that like food. Roasting tin book is my saviour.

he is going to be a good ‘un to share with at Uni.

purplehair1 · 17/06/2023 23:09

Dotjones · 16/06/2023 09:10

I think YABU to expect anything different given their ages. Give it another decade or so and they'll grow out of it but meantime you have to just accept that this is a phase while they grow into adults.

You end by saying you're fed up with negativity and nagging. If that's the problem, you have the power to solve it - stop being negative, stop nagging. There's a great book by the Arbinger Institute you should read about "thinking outside the box" - basically people get worked up because of their expectations of others are never met, the simple way to solve this is to accept responsibility for whatever task you expected them to do, that way it's no longer their fault so you no longer have to waste your energy getting upset at them.

Doesn’t that last bit just imply that you accept cleaning up after them?

lifebeganwhenhefuckedoff · 17/06/2023 17:46

When mine were around this age (13 & 14) we sat around the table and worked out four areas that needed to be done every week - laundry, kitchen (daily dishwasher etc), bathrooms and something else that escapes me but was probably keeping the main living areas clear. We worked on a rota, myself and exh included and committed to spending a bit of time on Sunday pm where all four of us would come together and make sure all was properly cleaned for the weekly handover. The kids were also responsible for planning and cooking one meal a week too. I had a box where I threw things that were left lying around and things were claimed on Sunday. I don't remember having to chase people after that.

Both went off to uni and were horrified at peers who didn't know how to cook, clean and use a washing machine so it seemed to work out ok Smile

aloris · 17/06/2023 15:11

What has worked for me is focusing on one small skill at a time. Picking up socks is one skill. Putting away your cereal box is another etc. They have to "learn" to see the mess, if you see what I mean.

Bigger skills too. Doing your laundry is a skill. Cleaning the kitchen table is a skill. Sorting the recycling is a skill. I try to rotate the skills so that their chores are not just being added to, but switched around so the focus is on learning something new.

ConsuelaHammock · 17/06/2023 14:46

Sit down around the table and discuss why it’s good to have a clean , tidy and organised home. Write down all the things you do as well as working and how long it takes to do them all.
Then start to divide out the jobs into daily and weekly ones.
Children can decide which ones they want to do at the weekends and you write a list of daily jobs which they must do. Do not offer money for these jobs - who pays you to do them? Take away their phones and put a stop to all activities until they do what is expected of them.
I say this as if it’s easy but it isn’t and I still have to nag a little bit it’s much better than it used to be at my house. I’m not their servant and I was fed up doing it all. We take turns cooking dinner too.

Swrigh1234 · 17/06/2023 14:41

It’s not clear from your posts OP why your children won’t do what they are being told to. When and how did it become the case that your children get to ignore your instructions. Yes, not requests, but instructions.

Needing to negotiate with children with what rules they need to follow and when points to something being very wrong.

Guiltridden12345 · 17/06/2023 14:32

celticprincess · 17/06/2023 13:42

I could have literally written this myself. We had tears last jog her from the kids as I got so cross. They’re 10/13. 13 is ASD. But no learning disabilities and generally an able child. 10 year old will do things when reminded but I suspect she has adhd as she starts projects and never finishes them and leaves stuff everywhere. They don’t have laundry baskets in rooms as they still dumped on the floor so we have one on the bathroom now. I had to ask them to get their stuff sorted last night so I could put a load on. Then this morning, clear your plates out of your bedroom/lounge which they did but left next to the dishwasher rather than put in!! I’m single parent though so no other help. I work part time but I still have lots to do on my days off with a voluntary position I hold. My 10 year old will do extra things like weeding the garden for extra money but I don’t associate other chores to pocket money. The pocket money was to help manage sweets and treats so I wasn’t constantly buying and they can take responsibility for their own spending in that respect. I’ve probably enabled a lot of this myself as when they’re at their dad’s I might blitz their rooms a bit.

I don’t think an inability to finish a task is necessarily a sign of adhd, it’s very normal for kids, teens and also adults, esp when tech is ever present and designed to reel us in and no one follows through to say ‘put that down and concentrate on task a’. I am card carrying neurotypical and I’m constantly distracted because I allow myself to be.

i feel your pain though and wish you luck with all these tips.

OP posts:
celticprincess · 17/06/2023 13:42

I could have literally written this myself. We had tears last jog her from the kids as I got so cross. They’re 10/13. 13 is ASD. But no learning disabilities and generally an able child. 10 year old will do things when reminded but I suspect she has adhd as she starts projects and never finishes them and leaves stuff everywhere. They don’t have laundry baskets in rooms as they still dumped on the floor so we have one on the bathroom now. I had to ask them to get their stuff sorted last night so I could put a load on. Then this morning, clear your plates out of your bedroom/lounge which they did but left next to the dishwasher rather than put in!! I’m single parent though so no other help. I work part time but I still have lots to do on my days off with a voluntary position I hold. My 10 year old will do extra things like weeding the garden for extra money but I don’t associate other chores to pocket money. The pocket money was to help manage sweets and treats so I wasn’t constantly buying and they can take responsibility for their own spending in that respect. I’ve probably enabled a lot of this myself as when they’re at their dad’s I might blitz their rooms a bit.

babbscrabbs · 17/06/2023 12:10

Haven't read full thread but:

Sit down with them and ask them what they think is reasonable they do

Write it as a list

Come up with your own list

Review it together constructively and compromise and agree

Ask them what should happen as a consequence should they not do the list you have agreed

If they need some gentle prompting OR if they do their jobs, use declarative language eg

"Your socks are on the floor" - reminding them what needs to happen with zero nagging

"I notice all the dirty plates are in the dishwasher" - acknowledging their efforts without praising them for stuff that frankly they should be doing without needing praise

Guiltridden12345 · 17/06/2023 12:05

WhoToBeToday · 17/06/2023 10:14

I found (during lock down actually) that post-it notes were my friend for any additional jobs/reminder jobs.
Mine have regular jobs (dishwasher/packed lunches/chickens). And occasionally I have to remind them to "human" retrieve an abandoned lunch box/school bag.

Sometimes though, there is just a pile of jobs that we all need to pitch in with. Putting shoes away, emptying the airer, taking a pile of stuff upstairs, emptying the bins...that kind of stuff. I found if I just wrote a list of them all at once, on a post it note and then called them down to it, it worked better. I tended to do this whilst I was cooking tea. It meant:
They got to agree who did which chore (and fastest down could sometimes bagsie the "best" chores). I don't care, as long as they are done.
Because I was busy cooking children could see I was not just sitting around)...felt more of a shared burden.
The Post-It jobs were a "do them all now" thing. Not a do them at some point today/later...because they would forget. But all in one go meant children did not feel they were doing jobs "all the time".
It made it less personal weirdly...it was the post-it note with the list of chores...not me. I only had to write it down once....and then direct the DC to the post it note.

Funnily enough I have tried post it’s and agree they work. Except I did one this week and got home to find her watching tv and no jobs done. Which really pissed me off as it’s just lazy. Hence it’s all come to a head.

so we are having a family mtg today. Partner leading it so demonstrates it’s a team decision and we’re on the same page (there were pleas to dad to intervene, which were swiftly closed down). We will lay all this out:

Expectations re personal responsibilities like homework and own plates/socks/clearing up after themselves and their friends.

regular jobs like animal care and we are going to delegate bins too (they did them earlier in week as partner away and he usually does, we agreed they can take this forward.

fanily meals - everyone chips in, someone lays table, gets drinks etc if parents cooking, everyone clears away together til it’s completely finished (this was a real gem of advice from a poster)

Phones/tech away after school until homework and jobs done - as a habit.

lifts/favours/socials/phones/allowance will be dependent on cooperation. Having to remind them or nag them will count as a fail as it’s the constant nagging we are trying to get rid of.

we have cherry picked the stuff we think will work for us and would like to thank everyone for their really helpful suggestions. It’s genuinely helped and shows the power of Mumsnet (even on AIBU!) when it’s collaborative and supportive rather than judgey and accusatory. So thank you all.

OP posts:
CorruptAppleYard · 17/06/2023 10:52

@DorritLittle mine don't do their own laundry as we have a central collection point for it, ie everyone's blacks go into one tub, whites in another etc. So it is presorted and I hate double handling anything, so I am not rummaging through a laundry basket in each bedroom to find whites. I have a laundry rota. But from primary age my children strip their beds on a set day and their bedding goes in the washing machine. There were picture instructions that I made and printed off in the utility as to where washing powder goes and the machine setting. I cut the laundry scoop down to the correct dosage so they didn't have to measure. Then I just put it on the landing when dry and they put it back onto their beds. They worked as a team to do it so elder one helped the younger. Same with their bathroom towels, they fold them daily and put them on a heated towel rail. Each child has their own colour hand towel and bath sheet. If one is missing everyone knows whose it is.

Homework we had a time slot so no tech until then. If no homework (secondary) then broaden the knowledge of a topic they are covering in school. Youtube was their favourite educational resource. We tried to make learning enjoyable not a chore. We watch Youtube stuff together too as a family.

Bins are also their responsibility, one has the kitchen waste bin, the other recycling. On 2 set days a week bins get emptied into the wheelie bins. One of those days is the bin collection day so if it is their bin they take it to the end of the drive when leaving for school and would bring it in on their way home from school. I am responsible for bathroom bins. Routine is important rather than waiting for a bin to be full, it never gets too full. This all works for us.

I think being in the kitchen whilst dinner is prepared means they can help with small tasks that build up to them making family dinners. It is age dependent but a great place to chat and listen to music or podcasts together. However, I should point out that I am a long term sahm due to disability so I am not frazzled from working and trying to get a meal on the table.

DorritLittle · 17/06/2023 10:26

CorruptAppleYard · 17/06/2023 06:06

@Guiltridden12345 as a child I was given a lot of responsibility at an early age. I swore I wouldn't burden my children with the same. But gradually I just added to the expectations of what they were responsible for. A toddler can put clothes into a laundry basket.

I would have a really good think about how you expect this to go from now on but the one piece of advice I will give is at least at the start don't do the ad-hoc stuff, just get them into a routine of doing things, just like they brush their teeth every day. As your two are now at secondary they can empty the dishwasher, stick a rota up on the fridge. If you get each one to do a Sunday and a Monday then they both cover a weekend load. In this house I empty the dishwasher one day a week, the children do alternate days. When Ds1 is at uni, Ds2 keeps his usual days and Dh and I cover Ds1's turns.

I don't agree with ever paying children to do chores, this gives them the impression of choice. No one pays an adult to tidy and clean. I also don't agree with allowing them the choice of having dirty clothes, some children will not give a shit about wearing stained, food encrusted clothes. I was not going to allow my children the chance to think this was acceptable. I also never yell, I calmly point out the things that aren't done. Then they do it. I think calm and stern works better than angry yelling.

We also had high standards for homework, it was done to a good standard or there would be consequences. I know people say well they have to live with the consequences but you really want your child to have a shitty life with no money and would watch them do that?

It makes it sound like our household wasn't ever fun. The whole everyone clear down the kitchen was done to music (linked dining room and kitchen speaker) or a podcast or everyone just chatting. If you gradually add in chores as they go then it doesn't suddenly become a mountain of tasks they didn't have to do before. So have a list of expectations on the fridge, everyone knows what it expected of them and all activities, phones etc are a privilege not a right. To put it in the most basic terms, if I get what I want, you get what you want. Same as a job, the company gets what they want from you in terms of tasks, you get what you want which is the money for your work. You might also want to list all the things you as parents do from meal planning, to food shopping, to rotating food in the fridge, just to show them where they are expected to be in later life.

This is really sensible advice.

There is no way my kids are doing their own washing yet. I am grateful that they put their dirty washing in a basket and clean washing away and that happened gradually. I plan to add dishwasher emptying soon. Homework and tidying room/sorting their stuff for the next day is one of their main requirements.

WhoToBeToday · 17/06/2023 10:14

I found (during lock down actually) that post-it notes were my friend for any additional jobs/reminder jobs.
Mine have regular jobs (dishwasher/packed lunches/chickens). And occasionally I have to remind them to "human" retrieve an abandoned lunch box/school bag.

Sometimes though, there is just a pile of jobs that we all need to pitch in with. Putting shoes away, emptying the airer, taking a pile of stuff upstairs, emptying the bins...that kind of stuff. I found if I just wrote a list of them all at once, on a post it note and then called them down to it, it worked better. I tended to do this whilst I was cooking tea. It meant:
They got to agree who did which chore (and fastest down could sometimes bagsie the "best" chores). I don't care, as long as they are done.
Because I was busy cooking children could see I was not just sitting around)...felt more of a shared burden.
The Post-It jobs were a "do them all now" thing. Not a do them at some point today/later...because they would forget. But all in one go meant children did not feel they were doing jobs "all the time".
It made it less personal weirdly...it was the post-it note with the list of chores...not me. I only had to write it down once....and then direct the DC to the post it note.

Guiltridden12345 · 17/06/2023 09:20

DebussytoaDiscoBeat · 17/06/2023 09:14

OP why do you feel guilty about following through a consequence that you clearly spelled out more than once? I know it’s not pleasant to see someone crying, but why is your DD’s self inflicted upset more important than your own feelings of upset because she expects you be her skivvy? Just accept that someone is going to be angry/frustrated in this scenario, so it might as well be the person who will genuinely benefit from this lesson in the future. It’s not even like you’ve said she can’t have the sleepover, only that she can’t go out in the day, so you’re still being a bit soft on her really!

You know what they say - insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. Stay firm with your consequences because whilst it might give you temporary relief to give your DD one last chance you’re not actually doing what’s best for her.

You are completely right, thank you for setting that out so clearly. I think I went soft during covid, I saw them lose so much and I genuinely love that they have such freedom and happiness back. But there’s a limit and we’ve reached it. I appreciate we have a responsibility to turn her into a competent adult and that requires work and hard lessons.

she got up at 8 and instead of watching tv she did her maths. She is in good spirits and is working to an earlier release by getting on with the rest. So far so good. This will be the new normal.

OP posts:
DebussytoaDiscoBeat · 17/06/2023 09:14

OP why do you feel guilty about following through a consequence that you clearly spelled out more than once? I know it’s not pleasant to see someone crying, but why is your DD’s self inflicted upset more important than your own feelings of upset because she expects you be her skivvy? Just accept that someone is going to be angry/frustrated in this scenario, so it might as well be the person who will genuinely benefit from this lesson in the future. It’s not even like you’ve said she can’t have the sleepover, only that she can’t go out in the day, so you’re still being a bit soft on her really!

You know what they say - insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. Stay firm with your consequences because whilst it might give you temporary relief to give your DD one last chance you’re not actually doing what’s best for her.

Guiltridden12345 · 17/06/2023 09:00

Wallywobbles · 17/06/2023 08:50

No one leaves a meal until everything is washed up, put away, surfaces wiped.
Everyone cooks together. No one ever gets to watch someone else do the work.
Everyone needs to be competent enough to do everything. And I mean everything. Farm stuff, garden stuff, house stuff. Pay bills, budget, meal plan (and that's hard), food shop.
If I'm putting time into them it's time I don't have to do other stuff. So they need to be putting time back into the household.

Yes I see this. I think I always could but it felt too much like hard work. A 3/4/5 year old putting their dish on the side is one thing but teens that are bigger than you is quite another. The scales have fallen!

OP posts:
Wallywobbles · 17/06/2023 08:50

No one leaves a meal until everything is washed up, put away, surfaces wiped.
Everyone cooks together. No one ever gets to watch someone else do the work.
Everyone needs to be competent enough to do everything. And I mean everything. Farm stuff, garden stuff, house stuff. Pay bills, budget, meal plan (and that's hard), food shop.
If I'm putting time into them it's time I don't have to do other stuff. So they need to be putting time back into the household.

paintingdisasters · 17/06/2023 08:50

One extra thing to add is that if you allow them to live at home without any home responsibilities (as some have suggested) you can be pretty sure they'll take that behaviour into their future relationships.

I was with a man for several years who seemed incapable of picking up after himself. The reason? He'd never done it at home because his mum always did everything. The way I see it, you're training your kids now to be good and considerate partners when they grow up.

paintingdisasters · 17/06/2023 08:45

That sounds exhausting OP! All I can say is that when I was a young teenager my pocket money was linked to a few jobs I had to do each week. I had to make my bed every day, do the dishes (with my sibling) once a week and on Saturdays make sure my bedroom was in a suitable/tidy state. The completion of these tasks 'released the funds'. It was very light hearted but it kept me on track.

Guiltridden12345 · 17/06/2023 08:45

Augend23 · 17/06/2023 07:21

I agree with the natural consequences points.

I'd also suggest doing a list (once) of all the things you expect them to do. Laminate it if you can, or put it on a whiteboard or let them make a copy on their phones.

i.e.

Check house for my possessions
Check house for my washing up
Put washing in washing basket
Put away clean washing
Check homework diary for new homework
Do new homework

Do it at a really granular level. They then have a thing they can check every day. I would either then put it in a really prominent place, and to start with ask them to check the list once a day (for example after school, once they have had a snack) at a time when there's time to work through the list.

I have vivid memories of being left in the house as a teenager and my mum coming back and asking "why haven't you hung the washing out/hoovered/done this other thing" - they were all things she saw needed doing but at that age I just really didn't notice it. Whereas as an adult I have a mental list of all the things I need to check if they need doing and can just run through it. So I wonder if a physical list might be the stepping stone while they haven't got to the point that they have the mental list?

Combine that with no lifts etc etc and you'll get somewhere. I do suggest you make the consequences clear beforehand though - if your daughter thought she was okay to do homework Sunday (because she would have been before) and is now missing a day out, then that will be mighty frustrating for her. But if she's had advance warning that she needed to do it before the weekend because she's going to be too busy to do it then then that's her lookout.

Yes she had advance warning - I made it very clear when she asked that the sleepover was contingent on homework being done. And reminded. Even that feels like spoon feeding!

OP posts:
HerMammy · 17/06/2023 08:34

Just stop, why are you micro managing their homework? let them learn the consequences of not having mummy do everything.

CovertImage · 17/06/2023 07:43

Fromaworkaholic · 16/06/2023 09:18

Absolutely not being unreasonable, to many DC have mothers as slaves these days, my own included, I imagine your husband hasn’t chosen to work long hours for the sheer pleasure of it, far too many opinions on here that would tell you your DH needs to do more, He probably already is by working so much.

You forgot to say "Bloke here".

I can't imagine there's any other reason than that as to why you form your evidence-free opinion of the OP's husband in the way that you have, irrespective of whether she's later said he does his share

vestanesta · 17/06/2023 07:38

We don't pay for chores exactly but they got a pretty generous monthly allowance once they hit 12 on the basis that they contributed to the household properly. They didn't so we halved it and they can earn it back if they are consistent and don't have to be nagged.

Tidying their own rooms/managing their own laundry in terms of dirty goes in the basket, clean is collected form the pile and put away, making their own breakfast and lunch on school days and pet care (her own small furry) is just basic and has natural consequences as others say - dd1 adores her pet and it's actually been a real pleasure to see her take care of it so well.

Chores which benefit the household have been trickier but what worked better has been to let them pick their own. Dd1 will cook dinner and help meal plan/food shop with her dad. Dd2 will close the kitchen door, put on some music and do all the washing up and cleaning the kitchen.

It's still a battle though - dh loses his shit over how messy they leave the living room pretty much every day.

crazyaboutcats · 17/06/2023 07:22

Best thing I saw was a daily WiFi code that is given on completion of chores

But you also need to allow a certain amount of mess to accumulate (for them to clear up) before doing it yourself

And use the single word reminder of 'homework', 'plate', 'bag' rather then the full nag