Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want to socialise with people significantly wealthier than us

295 replies

AliceMay55 · 16/06/2023 08:15

DH reconnected with his old mates a few years ago and we started socialising with this group. it has now started to impact me. They are all quite wealthy (he went to a very posh school on scholarship). We are ok financially. We have good jobs, a large detached house in the suburbs, nice cars, a couple of nice holidays a year etc, These friends are in a different league all together (say a few million a year income types).
We have a busy life with 3 kids. we have limited help. So I’m constantly busy, knackered, my kids don’t do many activities (just 2 each) and I look tired. On the other hand, the women in this group are doing very well professionally, have nannies/mothers help/cleaners, beautiful hands, lovely hair, designer clothes/bags, always look perfect. All their kids go to private schools, have a lot more “stuff” than our kids. We all just stand out like that.
AIBU to not want to socialise with the group anymore, just because of the very obvious financial disparity? DH can socialise if he wants;

OP posts:
Marchintospring · 16/06/2023 14:15

Whadda · 16/06/2023 13:20

This will sound like it’s made-up to prove a point, but it’s actually true.

My sister-in-law is a single mum who works part-time as a cleaner on minimum wage. Her best friend is a multimillionaire who owns a helicopter.

It’s a significant wealth gap but they make their friendship work.

Yes but that’s her best friend. I guess their friendship goes back to a different time.

It’s not someone she’s only meets up with because they’re married to her husbands old school friends.

neverbeenskiing · 16/06/2023 14:11

Turn this on its head and pretend you're the one with the multi-million pound bank balance and they are living in social housing. I'm just imagining what it would sound like if you'd posted that you weren't comfortable with people because they were significantly poorer than you.

It's not difficult to imagine that a multimillionaire might feel a tad out of place, uncomfortable or excluded from the conversation at a social gathering with a large group of people who were all living in social housing and on low incomes.
Lots of posters are making out that because she feels uncomfortable in this group OP must be so bitter and insecure she can't tolerate being around anyone who has more money than her, but that doesn't seem to be what she's saying. The issue here is that in this particular social group they are all, without exception, obscenely wealthy so the OP is very much the 'odd one out'. Spending time with someone much wealthier than you 'one on one', or in mixed company, is entirely different to being the only non-rich person surrounded by very rich people.

I'm surprised at home harsh some of the responses on this thread have been. I don't think it's unreasonable to want to spend what precious free time you have in an environment where you feel at ease, with people you feel you have things in common with. That doesn't make OP a monster.

Caroparo52 · 16/06/2023 14:01

Your gut is telling you something. If you're not comfortable then its not the law to socialise with certain people.
Let hubby rock on, but cool it for yourself.

dancingsands · 16/06/2023 13:55

AliceMay55 · 16/06/2023 09:27

Just to clarify, these people are nice. I’d happily socialise and enjoy their company if they went on a centreparcs vacation with us, or a beach trip or meeting up for lunch with families at pizza express.

Have you ever asked? Them would probably love it!

CecilyP · 16/06/2023 13:38

DrCoconut · 16/06/2023 12:59

Same here @VeterinaryCareAssistant I'm an example of the "poor" hypothetical friend being discussed - terraced house, small yard, annual holiday is a few nights in a glamping pod this year, an upgrade from our usual tent. I would find the OP very well off with their detached house and cruises. But one of my best (sadly now late) friends was very well to do. She was proper old money, with ancestors who lived in a now national trust property, and the least snobby person ever. Was quite happy to visit me despite arriving in a car that probably cost more than my house!

I think a one to one friendship with someone you really get on well with is very different to socialising with a group where the only link is that your husbands went to school together.

NatureNurture85 · 16/06/2023 13:21

I think don’t limit friendships if they’re nice, maybe work on your own self worth. Trust me the people who seem to have the most, who strive to show they have the most are just like anyone else and will lack in other areas.

I know a lot of very wealthy people and my God do they have their issues, but we’re all humans. There is no black and white to friendship.

Whadda · 16/06/2023 13:20

This will sound like it’s made-up to prove a point, but it’s actually true.

My sister-in-law is a single mum who works part-time as a cleaner on minimum wage. Her best friend is a multimillionaire who owns a helicopter.

It’s a significant wealth gap but they make their friendship work.

coxesorangepippin · 16/06/2023 13:00

It matters if it makes you feel inferior

We have a nice big house, good lifestyle etc but we have friends whose houses are four times the size!!

Doesn't really make me feel good, I don't think that's surprising

Mischance · 16/06/2023 13:00

Go to the things you enjoy and not to the ones you don't. Their income and lifestyle don't come into it.

DrCoconut · 16/06/2023 12:59

Same here @VeterinaryCareAssistant I'm an example of the "poor" hypothetical friend being discussed - terraced house, small yard, annual holiday is a few nights in a glamping pod this year, an upgrade from our usual tent. I would find the OP very well off with their detached house and cruises. But one of my best (sadly now late) friends was very well to do. She was proper old money, with ancestors who lived in a now national trust property, and the least snobby person ever. Was quite happy to visit me despite arriving in a car that probably cost more than my house!

CandlelightGlow · 16/06/2023 12:59

I think the difference may be in values rather than wealth. If they focus on extrinsic values such as owning things, luxury and status, you're not going to be able to compete, and are going to feel left out. If, despite their wealth, they are able to focus on intrinsic values such as friendship, experiences, community, conversation and human connection, then you're more likely to find common ground and to get on

Yes that's exactly it. I am not a materialistic person, so I don't get on with people who so greatly value possessions, I find it crass and I also don't relate (I don't think you have to actively disagree with everything you personally don't enjoy, I just also find it crass in this case).

I'm sure there are wealthy people who are also not materialistic and judge people by their wealth, and I'm sure there are less well off people like me who are infatuated with materialism also. In fact I know both types of people exist.

CandlelightGlow · 16/06/2023 12:53

I do get it OP I think. I'm not a jealous person at all but it depends on the wealthier person's personality.

In real life I never think about the word "class" though hear it all the time on MN. Legitimately never heard it in conversation. I worked at a place in my first role where lots of people from wealthier backgrounds worked. I am not middle or upper class. I've made a small group of life long friends who I see regularly and they are much better off financially than me, and their families are too so they get a lot of support. I've never felt jealous of them, truly. It's not how I operate.

But one of them got married recently and MY GOD there was a friend of my friend their and his wife who did NOT stop banging on about how they were middle class, went to private school, all sorts of other minute things like that all night. It was so tiresome and embarrassing. They weren't just talking about their life and happened to be wealthy so the stuff they mentioned made it obvious they were well off, you know?

So if the friends are anything like that, even if otherwise nice, I can see why even if you have no issues with confidence or jealousy, why you would not want to socialise with them. Because at the end of the day, in that scenario, it's not the wealth of the person that's the problem but their demonstrated attitude toward money, life and others.

MarkWithaC · 16/06/2023 12:53

LolaSmiles · 16/06/2023 10:58

I get the difficulty especially when it's a group and you're the 'odd one out' because of the way the conversations will go. They are friends, but you feel a bit of an outsider. It can happen when people have kids, or get married and you are single, or buy houses and you still rent. All kinds of things like that. It doesn't mean you don't like them or they are not friends, but the disparity can be 'felt' quite keenly
I'm inclined to agree but also think some people are quite insecure too.

Obviously outside of MN-land people with millions are unlikely to have lots in common with someone they've just met living below the poverty line, but friends with a shared history and shared interests should be able to remain friends and socialise with their spouses. I'd be really disappointed if DH decided he wasn't going to socialise with my friends based on how their husbands groom themselves, what clothes they wear and what their salaries were.

TBF the OP isn't talking about such a big disparity as people with millions and people living below the poverty line.

MarkWithaC · 16/06/2023 12:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

gldd · 16/06/2023 12:50

I think the difference may be in values rather than wealth. If they focus on extrinsic values such as owning things, luxury and status, you're not going to be able to compete, and are going to feel left out. If, despite their wealth, they are able to focus on intrinsic values such as friendship, experiences, community, conversation and human connection, then you're more likely to find common ground and to get on.

You could try to find common ground with them according to intrinsic values, but it may not be possible. Depends on what they value in life really, doesn't it?

Zarataralara · 16/06/2023 12:47

AliceMay55 · 16/06/2023 08:24

They are definitely nice people. But I just don’t fit in.

If you don’t feel you fit in then you don’t have to socialise with them. DH can keep up with his mates, you could go to the odd meet up but the rest of the time be too busy with friends/work/family/hobbies. Life’s too short to feel you have to do things you don’t need to and don’t want to.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 16/06/2023 12:45

None of these events sound fun to me! I find socializing in groups not nearly so much fun as getting together with a good mate over lunch or a couple of female friends to sit and have a drink. I just wouldn't enjoy those type of activities, as you have to make polite conversation which is tiresome, I'd go along occasionally so the kids could run around but it wouldn't be my favoured style of interacting. Also in a few years, the divorces will start and then there's the issues of who you stay friends with, do the newly single women get an invite (I've been that lone woman at a party several times and you just don't know who to talk to as it's lots of couples). I'd make good friends yourself and just dip in and out of this other group if you feel like it- send your husband along with the kids to most events and get him to organize a BBQ once a year and smile and that's it.

OpenDoors72 · 16/06/2023 12:45

Sounds like inverse snobbery.

MrsAlgernon · 16/06/2023 12:44

Some stereotyping about rich people interests are hilarious. Many don't flash that much, can appreciate 'run down' cafes and you may find their interests to be just as varied and there are ways to join in with activities that may tickle your interests that aren't just fancy partying and Soho houses. One of my friends is a long term nanny to a wealthy (but kind) family and I am almost jealous of all access she has to events and activities she's able to join in with.

Social status anxiety and fear of being looked down is real, granted and obviously there may be differences in struggles. But lets see if you give them a chance and see if you enjoy spending time with them.

If you see their amazing kitchen, it's fine to appreciate and get them to rattle off how much effort they have made to make their kitchen authentic, getting very specific tiles from Mauritius because it's their home country, etc.

CecilyP · 16/06/2023 12:41

And your parties in your garden sound great, BTW!

pizzaHeart · 16/06/2023 12:41

Zippedydoo123 · 16/06/2023 09:52

I must be honest here and add my two penneth. I prefer to mix with people on a similar level to myself. I cannot match their income level and they have no understanding in my experience.

Occasionally would be ok for me but not all the time.

I absolutely agree with this.^
OP spends money, time, energy to join this group. You can’t just turn up in a posh restaurant in jeans and a T-shirt so she is making an effort to dress up, to look nice . She does parties at home but they don’t come so easily for her, she probably cut on sleep before and after to tidy up etc. whereas for the rest of the group all these come easier. And then OP joins the event and has nothing to contribute to the discussions about expensive cars, cruises or other similar topics and she probably won’t be able to share her problems with them as they have very different life and very different problems. So in a way she is wasting a precious resource- her time when she could go for a walk with her DC or read a book or call her mum. We can’t fit everything in our life so we have to prioritize. Yes they are nice people so very occasionally it’s fine but regularly it’s too much of a burden.
I suspect OP’s husband doesn’t see it this way (yet) because he doesn’t carry the mental load of organising things - he probably is not the one who is organising their home parties- Op is, he can escape with less investment into appearance and he naturally has some common ground with this people from the past so the differences are not so noticeable (so far).

CecilyP · 16/06/2023 12:40

They walk around in scruffy jeans, have a 25 year old car, the windows and the kitchen and the bathroom in the house have not been replaced for 25-30 years, and they drink in the local pub, and have a £5.99 carvery with a pint of Guinness. Why do SOME people assume that the upper classesare all 'well groomed' with designer gear, three holidays abroad every year, a £50,000 car, an Apple watch, and a 5 bed detached new-build in the suburbs? 😆(And that they all go to swanky overpriced restaurants for meals?)

Well, these obviously aren't OP's friends, are they? OP hasn't said that they are upper class but that they are wealthy and that they display all the trappings of that wealth. And where on earth do you get a £5.99 carvery in 2023? The thing that you have in common with a lot of the people you are talking about is that you live in the same village. The thing that OP has in common is that her DH went to school with their DH's.

I don't think OP sounds jealous at all. She must be aware that she has quite a comfortable life compared to the majority of people. But this is a group that have a lot in common, so she is something of an outlier. While they might be pleasant enough and good company, I would imagine that the conversation goes in a way that they take their good fortune for granted and OP could often feel left out. Maybe she doesn't feel comfortable just coming out and saying they can't afford a cruise (and possibly a lot of other things).

OP, how does your DH feel? Do your children get on with their children? If they value the friendships and the shared activities, I would do my best to make it work.

Chocchops72 · 16/06/2023 12:33

I get you OP. I live / work in an area where most people are significantly wealthier than DH and I are, and I have several friendship groups that are the same. I've just spent a weekend away with one such group and it was really hard going. It's not jealousy per se - it's feeling like I don't have much in common with them, that their priorities, plans, values, aims etc in life are significantly different and that I don't fit in. I can smile and nod along but that's about it

But when it's one-to-one I barely notice this to be an issue. We talk about all the things we have in common, we connect on a more personal level, they reveal their weak spots and so do I. Individually I really enjoy the company of pretty much all these women, I value their experience and their friendship.

It's just when they are in a group I find it hard going - the conversation stays on the topics of: holidays and travelling, funding children to study overseas as international students, buying flats / property for their children, extending their own places / building swimming pools / installing aircon, their husbands heading off to the US / Brazil / Canada / India for their latest Big Important Job assignment, retirement bucket lists (all exotic), buying new EVs etc etc. I can't afford to do any of these (and a lot of them I outright disapprove of in this day and age).

So one-to one with someone I genuinely like - fine. In a group, not so easy.

whoamI00 · 16/06/2023 12:33

You clearly don't enjoy their company. For whatever reason, it's better not to waste your precious time on something you don't like. Life is short.

Sundaefraise · 16/06/2023 12:29

Freddiefox · 16/06/2023 09:35

You don’t sound jealous op. It sounds like you just don’t all fit together. It also grinds you down when it always has to be you not doing something or asking for an alternative because you can’t afford it. Gets a bit soul destroying and can make you feel embarrassed.

Agree - It sounds like they are just not a good fit for you. People bond over common life experiences and interests. They can be perfectly lovely, but if you don't have much common ground, for whatever reason, its always going to be hard work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread