Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want to socialise with people significantly wealthier than us

295 replies

AliceMay55 · 16/06/2023 08:15

DH reconnected with his old mates a few years ago and we started socialising with this group. it has now started to impact me. They are all quite wealthy (he went to a very posh school on scholarship). We are ok financially. We have good jobs, a large detached house in the suburbs, nice cars, a couple of nice holidays a year etc, These friends are in a different league all together (say a few million a year income types).
We have a busy life with 3 kids. we have limited help. So I’m constantly busy, knackered, my kids don’t do many activities (just 2 each) and I look tired. On the other hand, the women in this group are doing very well professionally, have nannies/mothers help/cleaners, beautiful hands, lovely hair, designer clothes/bags, always look perfect. All their kids go to private schools, have a lot more “stuff” than our kids. We all just stand out like that.
AIBU to not want to socialise with the group anymore, just because of the very obvious financial disparity? DH can socialise if he wants;

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 09:44

gannett · 16/06/2023 17:40

*I also have recently started occasionally moving in circles where people are seriously richer than me - billionaire space. (Nearly) everyone I have met is lovely and doesn't seem to judge me in anyway and is actually fairly down to earth. I don't think I could be close friends with them though as I'd worry that if I wanted a moan about how expensive something was, or saying I didn't have enough money to do something, they'd think I was after money from them. Conversely I don't think this would ever cross my mind if a friend on a much lower income had a moan about money to me!

They also (because they're not arses) probably feel like there are things they can't discuss - they're not going to mention having spent 100s of thousands on curtains in front of me, whereas with people in the same financial range they might discuss options in that price range.*

This isn't really my experience of being friends with people who earn different amounts to me. Firstly, I don't really talk about spending money or how much things cost, and neither do most of my friends most of the time.

Secondly, if it comes up I don't feel any type of way. If they refer to the cost of something and I don't identify... well, I already know we have different perspectives, so it doesn't make me feel bad or anything. (Recently a friend was moaning about house prices and how difficult it was to pull off some complex three-property chain with millions of pounds involved - so far out of my experience but an amusing insight into how people with her income live. She has an amusing turn of phrase and told it well, that's what matters to me.)

Thirdly you just never actually know people's situations. I've done a few luxurious things in my time and all the most luxurious were free, mostly through various lines of work. Most people I know well would have known or guessed this, but a casual acquaintance looking at my Insta might've assumed I had a much higher income than I do!

Agree with everything you’ve said.

Money and spending rarely comes up and I don’t automatically think “well at least you can do xyz” if I can’t afford to do something because someone else can nor do I understand the mentality for it. I have no urgings to keep up with anyone and neither do my friends. We have so many things to talk about that doesn’t involve bringing up money.

Most of the concerns seem to come from people’s own thoughts about their current situations and assuming what others will think because they would think the same if the shoe was on the other foot when that may not be the reality.

Zipps · 17/06/2023 09:09

Whatifthegrassisblue · 17/06/2023 04:34

They're not multi-millionaires, most people who own a house fall under that category. They have millions a year as their income. I feel that's a completely different thing. Yes you could still be friends with them if you liked them and had things in common but I can also see how you might also have zero in common.

Billionaires then? 😁
Honestly don't have any friends then just in case they have a bit more than you.
I'll stick with my wonderful friends with their financially differences.
I always wondered why there were so many threads on MN about people who can't make friends and don't have social lives, now I know.

Figmentofmyimagination · 17/06/2023 06:01

If they make you feel miserable and dissatisfied about your lot then find some other friends - life is too short. I have some fabulously successful friends who are a joy and much more sociable than me - when they invite me out they book stratospherically expensive places and always find an excuse
to pick up the bill - I do sometimes wish they would choose somewhere cheaper so I could dare to reciprocate!

If these people are new to you and not long-standing friends who know you well, I’d probably be wary too. Nothing worse than feeling grumpy as a result of seeing how the other half live and doing yourself and your husband down with comparisons etc. Jealousy is a horrid emotion best avoided. You are only human. Look after yourself. It’s also very boring. My DH is guilty of a bit of this and can get a bit tedious going on about how other people have inherited large sums etc - he finds it much easier to deal with if he feels they have inherited it than if they have made it themselves. I think it’s a bit of an 80s man thing - we are thatchers children.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 17/06/2023 04:55

nosyupnorth · 16/06/2023 18:31

YANBU OP and you have my sympathy that you're getting the pile on from people whose performative niceless has deluded them to the reality of the world.

Of course it is uncomfortable to have to socialise with people constantly flaunting their wealth and making a display of their social and financial superiority and planning events you are excluded from for financial reasons like the cruise but acting like it's some kindness that they didn't invite you because they know you can't afford it.

All the idiots saying 'but would you socialise with somebody living in a council house' are ignoring that OP has access to everything a person living in a council house does and they could easily find common ground by shopping in the same stores or go to the same places, whereas these wealthy acquaintences have a lifestyle that is inaccessible to anybody other the equally super rich so it is impossible to share common ground with them as long as their ground is expensive clubs and elaborate events that cost ££££.

Yes that's a good way to put it, it sounds like these people are so wealthy it's a completely different world. That whole "Keeping up with the Joneses" when you don't want to, and couldn't even if you did!

Whatifthegrassisblue · 17/06/2023 04:34

Zipps · 16/06/2023 23:43

Agreed only on mumsnet are millionaires friends and socialise regularly with people who work in a minimum wage job and live in social housing, you never see the Soho house crowd hanging around with Darren the carpet fitter, but on here it’s apparently perfectly normal

Of course it's perfectly normal. We have friends who live in social housing and some who are multi millionaires.
People don't live in little enclaves with "Do not enter unless you have £X amount in your bank account"
The thing I find really strange is people only mix with those that have exactly the same amount of money. How is that possible? Finances can change dramatically over the years and also in an instant. What if one of your friends won the lottery, inherited lots of money, got a big promotion, started a successful business and many more scenarios? Do you tell them you can't be friends anymore?

They're not multi-millionaires, most people who own a house fall under that category. They have millions a year as their income. I feel that's a completely different thing. Yes you could still be friends with them if you liked them and had things in common but I can also see how you might also have zero in common.

Peverellshire · 16/06/2023 23:53

Micky Flanagan talks about exactly this, humour & levity & inner confidence are key. We don’t do insta. Those that lord it over others or look down on them, I regard with kindness. Insecurity…

This one woman in her Maxi (remember those? 70s) & her shag pile, told her daughter not to play with the ‘common’ kids. That family could be vicious. Now I realise how ‘small’, dull & limited they were…

Zipps · 16/06/2023 23:43

Agreed only on mumsnet are millionaires friends and socialise regularly with people who work in a minimum wage job and live in social housing, you never see the Soho house crowd hanging around with Darren the carpet fitter, but on here it’s apparently perfectly normal

Of course it's perfectly normal. We have friends who live in social housing and some who are multi millionaires.
People don't live in little enclaves with "Do not enter unless you have £X amount in your bank account"
The thing I find really strange is people only mix with those that have exactly the same amount of money. How is that possible? Finances can change dramatically over the years and also in an instant. What if one of your friends won the lottery, inherited lots of money, got a big promotion, started a successful business and many more scenarios? Do you tell them you can't be friends anymore?

Peverellshire · 16/06/2023 23:31

Acquaintances can play a one upmanship game at times, I swerve where I can.

Friends, are few but we’d walk over broken glass for each other.

Wit & humour and so approx intellectual parity important & always there. We discuss things not people & belly laugh, a lot. OP life is very short, don’t sweat the material stuff. Do what makes you happy. People are people.

Theoldgreygoose · 16/06/2023 22:32

Agreed only on mumsnet are millionaires friends and socialise regularly with people who work in a minimum wage job and live in social housing, you never see the Soho house crowd hanging around with Darren the carpet fitter, but on here it’s apparently perfectly normal.

Not everyone on MN lives in the UK, and some other countries don't have such a rigid class structure.

Fisharejumping · 16/06/2023 21:57

LadyVictoriaSponge · 16/06/2023 11:50

Agreed only on mumsnet are millionaires friends and socialise regularly with people who work in a minimum wage job and live in social housing, you never see the Soho house crowd hanging around with Darren the carpet fitter, but on here it’s apparently perfectly normal.

It can depend what industry you work in. If you work in the arts you often find yourself socialising with all sorts of people.

Fisharejumping · 16/06/2023 21:42

MysteryBelle · 16/06/2023 09:52

Why even think about it? You choose to obsess over nonsense.

Haha. I wish I had a friend like you.

redfacebigdisgrace · 16/06/2023 20:49

This is a bit sad. People are people. I have friends who are a lot wealthier than us and friends who have very little. I love spending time with them all.

Having said that, the whole being excluded from expensive holidays is a bit tricky. Can’t you suggest somewhere cheaper for a change?

Theoldgreygoose · 16/06/2023 20:39

AliceMay55 · 16/06/2023 09:44

I would happily socialise with a friend living in a council house. If I want to propose holidaying with them, I’d propose camping. Not cruising. Get my point?
To our friends’ defence, it’s perfectly reasonable that they were looking at suites for the cruise ship. Everyone else can comfortably afford that, except us.

Then don't go on the cruise. Surely you can turn down some invitations. I have friends who do lots of things I can't afford, and I don't try to keep up with them.

nosyupnorth · 16/06/2023 18:31

YANBU OP and you have my sympathy that you're getting the pile on from people whose performative niceless has deluded them to the reality of the world.

Of course it is uncomfortable to have to socialise with people constantly flaunting their wealth and making a display of their social and financial superiority and planning events you are excluded from for financial reasons like the cruise but acting like it's some kindness that they didn't invite you because they know you can't afford it.

All the idiots saying 'but would you socialise with somebody living in a council house' are ignoring that OP has access to everything a person living in a council house does and they could easily find common ground by shopping in the same stores or go to the same places, whereas these wealthy acquaintences have a lifestyle that is inaccessible to anybody other the equally super rich so it is impossible to share common ground with them as long as their ground is expensive clubs and elaborate events that cost ££££.

Pipsquiggle · 16/06/2023 17:54

I think if they are nice, kind and enjoy their company you should keep seeing them.

I have mates who earn way more than me. I just cannot do everything they do. They invite me but I decline and that's fine.

When they come to my home, it is bring a bottle affair and burgers on the BBQ or spag bol - that's fine, everyone enjoys themselves and also, importantly, it's authentic to us.

You do not have to 'Keep up with the Jones'

There's a lady in the village who is loaded, lives half the year in Dubai, weekends in Monaco. She's lovely, I was at her gorgeous house the other day - she taught me to paint, she's wonderful. I love her company and she likes mine.

gannett · 16/06/2023 17:40

*I also have recently started occasionally moving in circles where people are seriously richer than me - billionaire space. (Nearly) everyone I have met is lovely and doesn't seem to judge me in anyway and is actually fairly down to earth. I don't think I could be close friends with them though as I'd worry that if I wanted a moan about how expensive something was, or saying I didn't have enough money to do something, they'd think I was after money from them. Conversely I don't think this would ever cross my mind if a friend on a much lower income had a moan about money to me!

They also (because they're not arses) probably feel like there are things they can't discuss - they're not going to mention having spent 100s of thousands on curtains in front of me, whereas with people in the same financial range they might discuss options in that price range.*

This isn't really my experience of being friends with people who earn different amounts to me. Firstly, I don't really talk about spending money or how much things cost, and neither do most of my friends most of the time.

Secondly, if it comes up I don't feel any type of way. If they refer to the cost of something and I don't identify... well, I already know we have different perspectives, so it doesn't make me feel bad or anything. (Recently a friend was moaning about house prices and how difficult it was to pull off some complex three-property chain with millions of pounds involved - so far out of my experience but an amusing insight into how people with her income live. She has an amusing turn of phrase and told it well, that's what matters to me.)

Thirdly you just never actually know people's situations. I've done a few luxurious things in my time and all the most luxurious were free, mostly through various lines of work. Most people I know well would have known or guessed this, but a casual acquaintance looking at my Insta might've assumed I had a much higher income than I do!

potniatheron · 16/06/2023 17:38

I wouldn't hang out with people significantly wealthier than me because it'd be too expensive to hang out with them. When I was younger I had a colleague who was essentially a trust fund baby and doing the job to have something to do. I stopped going out with her very often because she always wanted to do things and go to places that were too expensive for me. A compromise was that we had park walks instead.

Beenalongwinter · 16/06/2023 17:30

CoalCraft · 16/06/2023 08:47

Beautiful hands? If all the reasons not to want to hang out with people, this must be the oddest.

Personally I think you're being a bit ridiculous, OP.

But it's not just the beautiful hands.
It is the swishy hair, the facials, manicures and pedicures. Perfect grooming , takes so much time even if you DIY.

GeekyThings · 16/06/2023 17:22

AliceMay55 · 16/06/2023 09:44

I would happily socialise with a friend living in a council house. If I want to propose holidaying with them, I’d propose camping. Not cruising. Get my point?
To our friends’ defence, it’s perfectly reasonable that they were looking at suites for the cruise ship. Everyone else can comfortably afford that, except us.

I get this - it's not that they're not nice people, they're just clueless about the disparity.

But I think that actually makes them as bad in terms of friendship as someone who just straight up isn't nice, because it's means they don't give a crap enough to take on board that you're not wealthy and that if they want to include you then they need to actually be inclusive. They genuinely haven't even been bothered to notice. I would never do this in any of my friendship groups, all parties, nights out, etc etc are tailored to the person on the lowest budget. I wouldn't want to leave any of my friends out, they're my friends, and I do notice how they're doing!

So on those grounds YANBU, you don't have to be friends with anyone you don't want to be, and they sound like too much hard work to deal with. I can imagine it's quite stressful, and friendship shouldn't be stressful.

cushioncovers · 16/06/2023 17:09

It's about having things in common afaic. A vast difference in income affects all conversations you have with that person. They may be a lovely person but if their lifestyle and expectations are completely different because of income I would struggle to have a deep relationship or friendship with them. Chitchat is fine. But so many topics would be off limits to discuss with a person say living on the poverty line compared to someone who was earning a huge salary. Someone who is going to bed hungry doesn't want to listen to someone talking about the new restaurants they've tried and the luxuries they've bought.

LolaSmiles · 16/06/2023 17:02

Agree with both your posts Sowhatifthatswhatisaid

I think on conversations sometimes it's about knowing your audience.

A high earning friend saying to a middle earning friend that they're a bit disappointed not to be doing their annual ski trip when they know the friend is likely to be able to empathise that it's become a family tradition and it's a bit disappointing to cut back on family traditions is probably going to be a fairly standard conversation. Neither of them are stupid enough to ignore the income disparity and the middle income friend is probably going to understand the intent behind their friend's sharing.

A high earning friend hearing a middle-low income friend talk about very real money stresses due to the cost of living crisis and then responds "oh darling I understand, everything is going up in price. We've had to cancel the ski break this Easter! Everyone is cutting back on things at the moment aren't they. I totally under what you mean" is either being ignorant, insensitive or both.

Sowhatifthatswhatisaid · 16/06/2023 16:22

And for people who say there would be no need to avoid topics with close friends substantially poorer than you, look at what happens here when someone comes up and says that with cost of living increases they might have to give up the annual ski trip. Inevitably (when people don't feel the need to have the polite filter on) there's a backlash of 'worlds smallest violin, there are people with actual real problems'.

Sowhatifthatswhatisaid · 16/06/2023 16:14

I'll say straight up that I don't think I would be able to be close friends with a group that were all significantly poorer than me UNLESS we had a connection that brought us together - eg a hobby that is the centre of our meetups or school friends. It's not because I care about how much money people make, or am particularly materialistic but that I'd feel I had to avoid talking about certain topics because of the risk of seeming to be gloating/insensitive and realistically I couldn't be close friends with people I felt I had to hide where I was going on holiday with or similar.

It's similar with one-one close friends - in reality my close friends are in the same ballpark in terms of income as me, except where they're close friends from school/university i.e. old friends. I'm in a similar financial position to OP and realistically it would be unlikely that I'd become close friends with someone struggling on benefits because our lives are so different. That doesn't mean I'd stop being friends with someone if their financial position changed, or that I'd be actively avoiding a friendship, just that in experience they don't happen.

The same applies for people substantially richer than me. For OP's DH, he has a connection there from school that transcends the different in income and it sounds like the income gap has always been there anyway. For OP this is new and she doesn't have the shared experience.

I have friends who are substantially richer than me and that's ok up to a point but I admit at times it makes me feel like I haven't achieved as much as I should have done. It's not jealousy, it's insecurity.

I also have recently started occasionally moving in circles where people are seriously richer than me - billionaire space. (Nearly) everyone I have met is lovely and doesn't seem to judge me in anyway and is actually fairly down to earth. I don't think I could be close friends with them though as I'd worry that if I wanted a moan about how expensive something was, or saying I didn't have enough money to do something, they'd think I was after money from them. Conversely I don't think this would ever cross my mind if a friend on a much lower income had a moan about money to me!

They also (because they're not arses) probably feel like there are things they can't discuss - they're not going to mention having spent 100s of thousands on curtains in front of me, whereas with people in the same financial range they might discuss options in that price range.

For the OP I'd advise to keep trying because these are close friends of her husband's and it sounds like they're nice people. I also agree with the PP that you think they are all in the same financial bracket, but I'd make a bet that at least one couple is only going for the suite on the cruise because they feel they need to keep up appearances. You might find it's quite a high number of them. What you need to get to is a position where you don't feel you need to make excuses and can say straight up that you can't afford it and not feel like the group will resent you for that. Easier said than done though.

Avondale89 · 16/06/2023 14:46

They’re school friends of your partner, not your friends. Life’s too short to spend time with people who make you feel uncomfortable. I’m unclear why people are being so harsh to you about this. You don’t have to socialise with these people if you don’t want to. However if you do feel like you’re missing out, it might be worth digging into your own feelings a bit more. But if your life is fine and dandy without them, then don’t bother.

gannett · 16/06/2023 14:25

I could understand not wanting to socialise with rich people who looked down on you, patronised you or had materialistic values. But if none of that was true and I enjoyed someone's company... well, I wouldn't be thinking about whether I measured up to them or comparing myself to them.

DP has lots of old friends who are much better-off than us (most of his uni friends went into finance, he didn't; my friends are mostly from arty circles where there's not much money generally). It never matters. We stay in their massive houses and have a great time. They come and chill in our little garden and have a great time. We're probably cooler than them, even in our late 30s, which matters exactly as much as them being richer than us (ie, we recognise it in each other and it simply doesn't matter to our friendship). We definitely host better parties because interesting people and good music makes for a better party than lavish paid-for entertainment.

Interestingly about 10 years ago another social circle we were in sort of meshed with the richer social circle above and there were definitely a few feelings about the class gap and a few who suddenly tried to "keep up with the Joneses". DP and I weren't really part of that though. It didn't seem to make anyone involved happy.

There have also been one or two people I've become acquainted with through the richer group who have made a few patronising comments, which is good because it's a handy warning not to bother getting friendlier with them.