Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to resent helping family member daily?

111 replies

Foodfan · 16/06/2023 05:48

I know you’re probably already judging me after reading the title and maybe IABU.

If you had a family member who needed practical help everyday… eye drops, socks and shoes on etc, would you mind doing it?

They have a number of health issues including bad arthritis and awful bunions, frozen shoulder etc so simply cannot do them alone. They don’t want a carer as it’s too embarrassing and would make them feel old (they’re 70 but with health issues).

I have to therefore help them daily before and after work and the only time I can go round on my way to work and still be on time myself is 6-7am (depending on my work commitments that day). They always know in advance what time I am coming.

I also have to go round after work to do their eyes again, help them lift washing out the machine etc. It also extends to driving them sometimes but I find that stressful as all they do is critique my driving!!

I am ashamed to admit I feel resentful for having these commitments every single day without a break. They simply couldn’t manage without the help and have no one else they can ask so I can’t ever say no. When I went away, my brother had to move in temporarily (doesn’t drive so couldn’t do daily trips like me).

Their argument is they did loads for me growing up and gave me lifts etc and never asked for anything in return so basically I ‘owe’ then this. Me pointing out they chose to become a parent and have me did not go down well.

I then feel bad for thinking I’d like to be free of the commitment. 🙈

Would you feel resentful too? can’t talk about this in real life as people would think I was awful! 😣

AIBU?

OP posts:
hettie · 17/06/2023 12:04

If she needs care and can't afford it then get a care needs assessment done via social services. It will be provided by them if needed (and she doesn't have the money). Did she have children so that they would look after her in old age then? How fucking awful and completely negating of you as an actual living breathing person with autonomy and a life. You work, a paid carer would do this as their job not in addition. It's madness and she's being ridiculous to only accept care from you.

Cornettoninja · 17/06/2023 12:04

Prelapsarianhag · 17/06/2023 11:54

She is your mum, needs care and can't afford a carer. What is she supposed to do?

Explore her options. Not as many as in years gone by granted but there is support out there and it’s generally accessed through her GP and social services initially. She’s 70 and unable to care for herself, this is unlikely to go any way other than decline further.

OP please don’t beat yourself up over this. Speak to her GP, social services and Age UK to find out what support might be available in her area. Being relied on for such small but essential tasks is a huge commitment, if your relative isn’t grasping that then it makes it even harder for you. Set the ball rolling and step away.

Be honest with any support that you access, services are stretched and won’t flinch at asking more of you just simply because you exist. Don’t worry about their perception of you, you have to put yourself first.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 17/06/2023 12:04

Presumably her parents cared for her as a child so that was her pay back for caring for you as a child. Its good to help parents as they age but this is too much. She needs a carer, but you will have to say no to make her accept this. Offer to help with contacting social services, applying for benefits and get some equipment to help her. Age concern would be a good place to start, putting on socks is easy with one of the tools you can buy, I forget the name but do some research.

jeaux90 · 17/06/2023 11:59

Prelapsarianhag · 17/06/2023 11:54

She is your mum, needs care and can't afford a carer. What is she supposed to do?

Get one via social services. It's what the rest of us do. The only blocker is if you have over 23k of savings in my county in which case you can afford one.

Prelapsarianhag · 17/06/2023 11:54

She is your mum, needs care and can't afford a carer. What is she supposed to do?

CC4712 · 17/06/2023 11:53

What happens when you go on holiday or are sick??? Do you have siblings who could help?

You really need to get social services involved-if nothing else, but to get an assessment done and her on their books. I would then happen to come down with a dreadful bout of something contagious (covid, D&V etc) and ask the carers to go in. You need to look after your own physical and mental health OP, otherwise you will burn out.

I absolutely sympathise OP. My nan was just like this, manipulative, never grateful and always demanding more. She would phone my mum to close the window or grate a carrot- even though her other daughter lived in the exact same street and my mum lives 20mins away!!!

Does she have another relative/friend she trusts? Sibling, neighbour, cousin? I'd have a word with them, and ask them to set the seed about how wonderful having carers in would be and her continual demands might push you away altogether.

jeaux90 · 17/06/2023 11:48

@CatfoodOzymandias makes a great point. You could get a carer and frame the time you do spend with her as quality oriented.

jeaux90 · 17/06/2023 11:47

OP why wouldn't she qualify for a carer? We have one three times a day for my mum. She owns her own house but does have less than the savings ceiling.

Chamomileteaplease · 17/06/2023 11:40

I have no patience for those in need who refuse carers and yet expect their usually adult children, to do all this work for them.

I don't know if you have said if you work full time, have a partner, children etc but even if you had none of those things then twice a day is an enormous commitment.

Phrase it how you like but arm yourself against emotional blackmail and tell this person they are going to have to get assessed for carers. No argument. Be strong.

orangeflags · 17/06/2023 11:36

I'm pretty tough as old boots with issues like this these days after years and years of looking after my very elderly mum and disabled brother. Iran myself ragged, couldn't take a day off even when I had pneumonia because they needed me. And yet there were carers who could do this and not burn themselves out. I was a fool to myself and resentful for years.

CalistoNoSolo · 17/06/2023 11:00

No I absolutely wouldn't do this. I'm not in the slightest cut out to be anyone's carer. Your relative needs to suck it up and accept that he/she needs professional help. No child owes their parent anything.

Discretionassured · 17/06/2023 10:45

orangeflags makes a good point OP, what if you were ill and couldn't be there to help her? This is the angle I would have gone with when talking to your mum, 'Mum, I'm worried about what would happen if I was ill and couldn't get to you, can we discuss getting your needs assessed so that at least we have options if that happens?'

There's so much that could go wrong with your current arrangement and it sounds like she would be completely stranded if you did suddenly become ill, or (god forbid) had some sort of accident, needed surgery etc so it would be really sensible to have a contingency plan. If you can go at it from this perspective maybe she would agree and then you can gradually start to step back and let carers take over?

INeedAnotherName · 17/06/2023 10:36

I have health needs too so I do understand why your family member needs your help so much but I've tried to be more independent. So let's break down the needs.

You can get aids to help with putting socks on/buttons/bras. Have any been considered?
What are the lifts for and can taxis be used instead?
Can washing be taken home once a week - or spend a couple of hours on a weekend doing some while doing another job? Brother can help with this.
Cooking - my DD says getting those Hello Fresh boxes work out same price as buying ingredients yourself, with less waste. Can something similar be done? Gusto, Wiltshire Foods also spring to mind.

Eye drops...um no. No help there as I couldn't cope with that myself either.

TomatoSandwiches · 17/06/2023 10:29

She sounds horribly manipulative op, ask yourself why she has no one else to turn to.
There's being kind and being put upon, make sure you have some boundaries in place before she starts speaking to you again.

nothingcomestonothing · 17/06/2023 10:26

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 10:13

We have had a chat this morning and I am now in the bad books and have made her cry. (Not on purpose!)

She said she’s always brought me up to be kind and me saying this and feeling this way isn’t. All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love. She’s worried about when she ages and is more disabled as she she’s as she says from my attitude to the little things she asks of me now she knows I’ll be horrible. 😞

Well let's take that apart OP

You didn't 'make her cry', she cried, you're not in charge of her emotions.

Is she being 'kind' to expect this is to and guilt trip you? No.

She has dismissed your feelings, also not kind.

She asking for much more than 'a few minutes'.

She is not asking for 'little things' she wants things more than once a day, every day.

If you're 'horrible' a paid carer or your brother will be preferable, won't it?

Look up FOG -fear obligation guilt. It might be useful for you to see this situation differently.

orangeflags · 17/06/2023 10:26

Well that's just how it is. What would happen if you were ill, or moved away or went on a long holiday? Not fair to rely on you. Stand firm

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 10:23

No she can’t afford a carer, so unless we could get one via social services then she wouldn’t quality.

She’s not speaking to me at the moment.

OP posts:
CatfoodOzymandias · 17/06/2023 10:21

But she can afford a carer? If so, she is being unreasonable. I like the idea of the carer doing the boring bits and you just taking her out for lunch or to the movies. Can you frame it like that?

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 10:13

We have had a chat this morning and I am now in the bad books and have made her cry. (Not on purpose!)

She said she’s always brought me up to be kind and me saying this and feeling this way isn’t. All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love. She’s worried about when she ages and is more disabled as she she’s as she says from my attitude to the little things she asks of me now she knows I’ll be horrible. 😞

OP posts:
Lacucuracha · 16/06/2023 14:16

They need to get a carer. Give them notice that they need to get one from 1 July as you will only be able to help once a week.

Why don’t they expect twice daily help from their son?

Caroparo52 · 16/06/2023 14:13

Difficult situation for you. You sound like a saint. I agree that getting a carer in is the best option. That's what the setvice is designed for. Also meals on wheels
It would be nice if the time spent together was quality time - little trips out to cafe or park/ shops/ cinema- not feeling like the (unpaid )help. It will only get more intense and you need to future proof the situation now for your own sanity and your parent.

Blackbyrd · 16/06/2023 06:55

I guess OP was using the phrase "family member" to keep the emotion out of her question. Does it matter anyway?
OP, I would contact Adult Social Services and request a needs assessment. It may be that your relative is exaggerating their needs to guilt trip you. If they're not, then they can work to clearly identify their needs and make arrangements to have them met. Get their GP involved in this too
Apply for Attendance Allowance for them, if awarded (and it's not difficult frankly) the benefit will go towards buying in help for them
This needs to be stopped now or your health will suffer, you deserve a life of your own. Be strong and ignore the inevitable emotional blackmail from your family member and Social Services

londonrach · 16/06/2023 06:42

They need a carer it's too much for you

CatfoodOzymandias · 16/06/2023 06:40

I think a couple of times a week would be nice and insist on a carer or your brother to do the rest. What do I know though; I am making arrangements to move my mum in with me in a few years! ( she's great though).

Mosaic123 · 16/06/2023 06:39

It is too much.

They need to have a carer so that you can go a couple of times a week and the carer the rest of the time.