Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to resent helping family member daily?

111 replies

Foodfan · 16/06/2023 05:48

I know you’re probably already judging me after reading the title and maybe IABU.

If you had a family member who needed practical help everyday… eye drops, socks and shoes on etc, would you mind doing it?

They have a number of health issues including bad arthritis and awful bunions, frozen shoulder etc so simply cannot do them alone. They don’t want a carer as it’s too embarrassing and would make them feel old (they’re 70 but with health issues).

I have to therefore help them daily before and after work and the only time I can go round on my way to work and still be on time myself is 6-7am (depending on my work commitments that day). They always know in advance what time I am coming.

I also have to go round after work to do their eyes again, help them lift washing out the machine etc. It also extends to driving them sometimes but I find that stressful as all they do is critique my driving!!

I am ashamed to admit I feel resentful for having these commitments every single day without a break. They simply couldn’t manage without the help and have no one else they can ask so I can’t ever say no. When I went away, my brother had to move in temporarily (doesn’t drive so couldn’t do daily trips like me).

Their argument is they did loads for me growing up and gave me lifts etc and never asked for anything in return so basically I ‘owe’ then this. Me pointing out they chose to become a parent and have me did not go down well.

I then feel bad for thinking I’d like to be free of the commitment. 🙈

Would you feel resentful too? can’t talk about this in real life as people would think I was awful! 😣

AIBU?

OP posts:
CuckooStation · 17/06/2023 17:13

Have you applied for attendance allowance for them ?

Have you applied for carers allowance ?

Then you can out source some of the tasks

What happens if you go on holiday?

Whiskyinajar · 17/06/2023 17:03

In case nobody has said this, apply for Attendance Allowance. She needs help and this will help towards it.

funinthesun19 · 17/06/2023 14:52

They’re going to have to get a carer.

The lifts were optional and not a daily occurrence I bet. They chose to do it when they didn’t have to. That’s on them. You don’t owe them a huge commitment just because they made a choice to help you (not every day) when you was younger.

And if this this a parent, well part of parenting is bringing your child up isn’t it? Your child doesn’t “owe” you for that.

I’d hate to think that when I’m older and have health problems I’ve made my family member’s life miserable just because I don’t want a carer as it’s “embarrassing”.

OP I’m sure you’d drop in and see them when you can. But the daily care needs need to be met by a carer.

Whydotodaywhatyoucandotomorrow · 17/06/2023 14:41

It know from experience it is such a difficult situation- feel bad when you go and bad if you don't. I had this for years and honestly please look after yourself as the stress made me feel ill. Ask for help, social care assessment/financial assessment/paid carers twice a day, anything that helps. Don't feel bad, you can still do what works for you and they will get their needs met. And don't feel guilty, no one holds their lovely new baby in their arms and thinks that what they want for their child is what you are currently doing.

user1469908585 · 17/06/2023 14:39

I looked after both my parents in their final months, they both died young and quickly from cancer, but there is a big difference looking after someone with a defined life expectancy and someone who may well go on for decades yet.

I have a distant relative who is late 60’s, looking after her mum in her late 90’s, her life has been on hold for the last 20 years or so, getting more onerous with every year that passes. No way I’d want my kids in that position.
Be careful what you volunteer for OP, set your boundaries!

We used to get old, then ill and die, now we get old, ill and drag on!

cptartapp · 17/06/2023 14:31

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 10:13

We have had a chat this morning and I am now in the bad books and have made her cry. (Not on purpose!)

She said she’s always brought me up to be kind and me saying this and feeling this way isn’t. All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love. She’s worried about when she ages and is more disabled as she she’s as she says from my attitude to the little things she asks of me now she knows I’ll be horrible. 😞

But she's not being kind?
And a carer would only be in and out 'in a few minutes' then what's the problem?
See how manipulative they are.
Did this person get to enjoy the prime of their life without this kind of burden?

GettingStuffed · 17/06/2023 14:22

OK attendance allowance is £68.10, my MiL's carer was,£16.00 be so you should be able to get 4 hrs help a week.. That would put a slight debt in the time you spend with her. Hopefully her frozen shoulder will repair it of and she'll have a bit more independence

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 14:08

She said she’s always brought me up to be kind and me saying this and feeling this way isn’t. All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love. She’s worried about when she ages and is more disabled as she she’s as she says from my attitude to the little things she asks of me now she knows I’ll be horrible
@Foodfan this is her metaphorically sticking a knife into you and twisting it, she knows exactly the pain she is causing she doesn't care as long as she gets what she wants and you have to subordinate yourself to her.
If it was me I don't think I'd confront her I would turn the tables and just say sorry I'm too ill can't come today..... on repeat.

Cornettoninja · 17/06/2023 14:02

I’m sure your comments have been invaluable to the OP @whatwasIgoingtosay. miraculously though, other posters have managed to offer support and advice regardless so I think this may be a poorly chosen thread to illustrate your irrelevant grievance.

YouJustDoYou · 17/06/2023 14:02

I would feel very selfish if it were me expecting someone to do this for me. Sick of hearing family members struggling because older people/in-need people refuse help because of ego.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 17/06/2023 14:01

They might not 'want' a carer, but have you pointed out that you don't 'want' to be an unpaid carer?

whatwasIgoingtosay · 17/06/2023 14:00

I am so fed up with posts on MN not identifying the gender of the person referred to - and why 'family member', which could be a second cousin or a nephew, instead of 'my mother', which we have to infer from the clues we are given???

Spidey66 · 17/06/2023 13:58

Would she qualify for PIP? That might help fund carers, at least part time.

TrexTeeth · 17/06/2023 13:55

They'll have to get over it and get carers even if it's just once a day. What if you were ill or on holiday ?

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 13:53

I would develop my own health problems which would prevent me from helping them with theirs, you're being played here op.

MsRosley · 17/06/2023 13:51

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 10:13

We have had a chat this morning and I am now in the bad books and have made her cry. (Not on purpose!)

She said she’s always brought me up to be kind and me saying this and feeling this way isn’t. All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love. She’s worried about when she ages and is more disabled as she she’s as she says from my attitude to the little things she asks of me now she knows I’ll be horrible. 😞

This is blatant emotional blackmail. This woman isn't kind or considerate. She's entitled and manipulative.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 17/06/2023 13:42

"Im sure you're judging me"
"They don’t want a carer as it’s too embarrassing and would make them feel old (they’re 70 but with health issues). I have to therefore help them daily"

NO NO NO. This is completely unreasonable emotional blackmail. She knows damn well it's not just a couple of minutes a day, it's all the travel and faff and commitment and mental load.

Attendance allowance, Social Services care assessment, Carers Assessment if you can get one.

Obviously you wouldn't be in this position if your relationship was a bit different - it sounds as if you've been trained by her to see the obligation. Could you afford a bit of counselling to help you?

LookItsMeAgain · 17/06/2023 13:36

I do not think you're being in the slightest but unreasonable. I do think this woman is though. I'm not sure if she's your mother or an aunt (I flew through reading the posts).

What I think is that while she might be 70 and have these health issues, in her mind, she is still the young, vivacious woman who did X, Y and Z and she is desperately, desperatly trying to hang on to that mental image of herself for as long as she possibly can. Getting old is a terrible thing, even more so if you're no longer as able-bodied as you were in your 40's, 50's or 60's or any age really.

That said, she needs help. You are stretched to snapping point. Something has got to give here and I honestly think that it would be much much better in the long term if you began the process of getting her assessed for social care now rather than waiting until her situation disimproves and she will start at the bottom of a very long list at that point. At least if you start now, she'll be on the radar of someone in some department and can begin to have things done in her home to help her negotiate her stairs, use the shower/bath safely etc. etc. etc.

I do think that you are also right in the middle of the FOG (Fear, Obligation & Guilt). Fear about what would happen to her if you didn't do what you're currently doing, feeling Obliged to make all of these visits to help her out and Guilt if you miss a visit or whatever.

You both actually need help, and the help from whomever would step in to do what you're currently doing for her, will also help you and make your visits to her far more pleasant and useful to her.

Best of luck to you both.

Cornettoninja · 17/06/2023 13:31

I just wanted to add that shouldering this also robs you both of your core relationship.

She probably isn’t going to actively agree with you, but at least put the thought in her head that whilst you’re having to manage her needs she’s losing out on whatever energy and resources you would have left for an actual relationship with her.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 17/06/2023 13:27

I had to for my mum for a long time, she did have carers, but I took her evening meal, did shopping, washing, cleaning,took her out in chair while she was able. Yes I did resent it, yes I was worn out, however the difference was mum never guilted me. She was grateful and on the occasions I couldn’t she never complained.
you need to calmly explain, like someone said, take the emotion out of it. Don’t feel guilty, resentment damages affection.

aloris · 17/06/2023 13:24

I don't think "It's embarrassing and would make me feel old" is a good reason to burden your child instead of getting a carer. It's a few minutes per day to her, but it's a lot for you - has to be scheduled before and after work, restricts other things you might want to do (go for a drink with friends after work), probably takes up driving time etc.

Raising you is not a good equivalent because you are not her mother.

I think this is pretty common, including the fear, obligation, guilt. You just have to limit what you do, to what you can do sustainably without feeling resentful. It's only going to get worse over time so you have to pace yourself or else her needs will eventually swallow your entire life.

SnapPop · 17/06/2023 13:24

OP, I couldn't do this. Your mum is being unreasonable to expect it and to guilt trip you.

I say that as someone who is close to her mum and will help out when she needs me, but every single day is far too much. This could continue for years!

I would be looking into alternative solutions. Even if you were still doing it part of the time, and a career for part of the time, that would still reduce the burden on you.

Boomboom22 · 17/06/2023 13:18

She doesn't sound like a good parent. These kinds of expectations are not what family is. It is very unfair and manipulative for her to compare this to your childhood. Would you treat your kids like this? My parents are older than yours and would go out of their way to make sure I never ever felt like you do. In fact too far as they might not tell me until they really really need help.

Createausername1970 · 17/06/2023 13:15

You can't care for others if you don't care for yourself. What you are currently doing is brilliant and well done for stepping up when needed. If it had been a short term necessity following an operation etc., it would have been fine, but it is totally unsustainable in the long term.

As others have said, it's not going to get any better. You need to have a frank and honest conversation with your brother and tell him you cannot do this and you need him to support you to sort out a carer etc. If you are both saying the same thing and putting on a united front it will be easier.

Forestfriendlygarden · 17/06/2023 13:11

Also have you tried getting a carers assessment for yourself? You are entitled to one.
UK | Carers UK

Carers UK homepage

We’re here for unpaid carers with expert information, advice & support and also campaign to make life better for carers.

https://www.carersuk.org/