Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to resent helping family member daily?

111 replies

Foodfan · 16/06/2023 05:48

I know you’re probably already judging me after reading the title and maybe IABU.

If you had a family member who needed practical help everyday… eye drops, socks and shoes on etc, would you mind doing it?

They have a number of health issues including bad arthritis and awful bunions, frozen shoulder etc so simply cannot do them alone. They don’t want a carer as it’s too embarrassing and would make them feel old (they’re 70 but with health issues).

I have to therefore help them daily before and after work and the only time I can go round on my way to work and still be on time myself is 6-7am (depending on my work commitments that day). They always know in advance what time I am coming.

I also have to go round after work to do their eyes again, help them lift washing out the machine etc. It also extends to driving them sometimes but I find that stressful as all they do is critique my driving!!

I am ashamed to admit I feel resentful for having these commitments every single day without a break. They simply couldn’t manage without the help and have no one else they can ask so I can’t ever say no. When I went away, my brother had to move in temporarily (doesn’t drive so couldn’t do daily trips like me).

Their argument is they did loads for me growing up and gave me lifts etc and never asked for anything in return so basically I ‘owe’ then this. Me pointing out they chose to become a parent and have me did not go down well.

I then feel bad for thinking I’d like to be free of the commitment. 🙈

Would you feel resentful too? can’t talk about this in real life as people would think I was awful! 😣

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Davros · 29/10/2023 19:21

@Zebedee55 we still don't have a formal care assessment or Carer's assessment. But we have had OT input, home adaptations, blue badge and PIP applications accepted, key safe put in etc. there's much that can be done

PostItInABook · 29/10/2023 17:48

Having children so that they’ll care for you in older age is awful.

And yet it’s one of the lines constantly trotted out on here against people choosing not to have children. 😂

”Oh but who will look after you when you’re old? MY children will surround me with love and bathe me in a bath of milk everyday”

Createausername1970 · 29/10/2023 17:40

Thread from June? There are a lot of old threads appearing 🙂

Zebedee55 · 29/10/2023 17:39

Davros · 18/06/2023 10:35

Don't characterise yourself as selfish, you are not, she is. I suspect you believe she can't afford carers because she has told you so. Either way, some things you can do:

  • contact Adult Social Services for a care assessment for her. When/if they draw up a care plan, be absolutely clear that you are not an integral component in that. You intend to resume your normal relationship with visits, outings, shopping etc but no more
  • ditto above for a carer's assessment for you
  • apply for Attendance Allowance
  • get a key safe installed
  • look online for disability aids and equipment. There is SO much out there E.g. I use a "handle" to help DH get out of a chair sometimes, much better then holding hands
  • get OT in to assess her home, DH has a riser/recliner chair free from OT, we've had rails installed around the house which are actually attractive. This is all separate from us being deemed able to afford carers ourselves
  • discuss all of this with your family, DH, brother etc. TELL them your position, don't consult or inform them

Care assessments in this area are currently taking 18 months for the assessment. It's not that easy nowadays.

ohdamnitjanet · 29/10/2023 17:14

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 10:13

We have had a chat this morning and I am now in the bad books and have made her cry. (Not on purpose!)

She said she’s always brought me up to be kind and me saying this and feeling this way isn’t. All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love. She’s worried about when she ages and is more disabled as she she’s as she says from my attitude to the little things she asks of me now she knows I’ll be horrible. 😞

Oh she really knows how to guilt trip you. Little things? Twice daily 7 days a week for maybe 20 years when you have a job and a family?
How extraordinarily selfish of her to not even look into having a carer. I’d be far more embarrassed asking my dc to do personal care for me than a professional. It would have to be absolutely the last resort to ask my child and I’d really hate it. At the very least you and your brother should share the load, but ideally 3 ways with a carer. You are NOT being selfish and while she was being so rude, ungrateful and selfish I wouldn’t be going round either.

aloris · 19/06/2023 15:45

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 18:09

Thank you everyone for your insights and perspective. I am looking into attendance allowance for her. I know she was able to do this for my dad before he died several years ago but his needs were far greater and she had to apply twice to get the money as was turned down the first time.

Being totally honest, I don’t want to be her at home carer at all. More than happy to keep taking her to do her weekly shop etc but all the other stuff I selfishly simply don’t want to do it. I’m sure there are lots of people who wouldn’t mind but I am not one of them!

It's not selfish. It's a lot. Driving there and back twice a day to do small tasks that could be more easily done by a hired carer who lived nearby. It may seem like a few minutes to her, but to you it's easily an hour or more out of your day, not to mention the restrictiveness of it, having to work your entire schedule around it, being unable to do something spontaneous with friends, having to work out how to manage it if you want to go on holiday at all, etc.

Davros · 18/06/2023 10:35

Don't characterise yourself as selfish, you are not, she is. I suspect you believe she can't afford carers because she has told you so. Either way, some things you can do:

  • contact Adult Social Services for a care assessment for her. When/if they draw up a care plan, be absolutely clear that you are not an integral component in that. You intend to resume your normal relationship with visits, outings, shopping etc but no more
  • ditto above for a carer's assessment for you
  • apply for Attendance Allowance
  • get a key safe installed
  • look online for disability aids and equipment. There is SO much out there E.g. I use a "handle" to help DH get out of a chair sometimes, much better then holding hands
  • get OT in to assess her home, DH has a riser/recliner chair free from OT, we've had rails installed around the house which are actually attractive. This is all separate from us being deemed able to afford carers ourselves
  • discuss all of this with your family, DH, brother etc. TELL them your position, don't consult or inform them
billy1966 · 18/06/2023 07:55

Itsallaloadofbollocks · 17/06/2023 21:08

Contact your local adult social care service and ask for a needs assessment. https://www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/arranging-care/care-needs-assessment/
Ask her GP for an Occupational Therapy referral for aids and adaptations to help day to day living.

Excellent advice.

The pressure on you for twice a day is totally unreasonable.

What about holidays, nights out, personal relationships?

This is you available to here night and day.

Not your responsibility.

You need to be firm on this and pull back before it gets worse.

This is completely unreasonable to ask.

She did it for your dad but they were living together, a completely different dynamic.

You have no wish to be your mothers carer, that is 100% your choice.

Best to be clear on that point now.

Itsallaloadofbollocks · 17/06/2023 21:08

Contact your local adult social care service and ask for a needs assessment. https://www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/arranging-care/care-needs-assessment/
Ask her GP for an Occupational Therapy referral for aids and adaptations to help day to day living.

https://www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/arranging-care/care-needs-assessment

UpaladderwatchingTV · 17/06/2023 21:06

As she's not talking to you at present OP, I would stop going round there. Then when she calls and asks why you haven't been round, you can tell her, that she sulked and stopped talking to you, to punish you for wanting to spend time with her as your Mother, rather than as her Carer. Tell her you're no longer prepared to keep running around after her, and that there are a lot of people in this world, younger than her, who have no choice but to employ a Carer. At 70 years old, she needs to accept that she's no spring chicken any more, and if she needs help, she's going to have to pay someone else to do it, as if you wanted to be a Carer, you'd be doing it for a living. Telling her that you love her as your Mum, but don't want to be her Carer, as you feel it makes you see her as a whinging old woman, rather than the Mum that you love, will hopefully make her see what she is doing to you. If she gets nasty again, then just continue not going round there, she'll soon realise that she HAS to get a Carer. I hope you can sort this out, without making a long term rift between you OP.

Marmablade · 17/06/2023 20:44

No I don't think YABU. She doesn't want a stranger carer but therefore she's forcing her preferences onto you. She could get a social services carer, especially if she can't afford a private carer. And attendance allowance is for this. There are other allowances too but I don't know them because they didn't apply to me. You definitely don't have to do this if you don't want to. Caring needs to be a two way street and resentment is not a good basis for caring. She can emotionally blackmail you all she likes but that will only increase the resentment.

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/06/2023 20:39

Snugglemonkey · Today 20:31
I wouldnot be resentful because I would not do it, unless it was for one of my children.”

As it should be. (Though obviously there are cases where parents need outside, professional help too).

No one should grind themselves down for anyone else, however much they love them, when there are viable options.

Snugglemonkey · 17/06/2023 20:31

I wouldnot be resentful because I would not do it, unless it was for one of my children.

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/06/2023 20:12

Nicecow · Today 12:14

YABU they are your parent. Why don't you pay someone to do it if you don't want to”

Why doesn’t her mother pay someone to do it? She claims she “doesn’t need care” but continues to make manipulative demands for care on her daughter, who has her own life.
I repeat, having children with the expectation that they will provide personal care in old age is reprehensible.

annabelnw9 · 17/06/2023 18:59

I think it’s perfectly reasonable to help a parent out on a daily basis, IF you live near them, have a good relationship with them, and can easily meet their needs. However. There is no doubt that , depending on your own situation/age, this can become very detrimental to your own life and you need to be honest and clear about what you can - and cannot - offer.

rookiemere · 17/06/2023 18:46

Don't feel awful OP. I couldn't and wouldn't do what you're doing, also she's only 70 this could go on for another 20+ years.

What happens if you're not well and can't come ? Could that be an option to prompt a crisis?

You can't keep on doing it, if she applied for care and didn't get it that would be different.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 17/06/2023 18:44

All she’s asking for is a few minutes of my time and thought I could do that out of love.

That is completely untrue.
She's asking for your daily attendance twice a day before and after work
Its blackmail.
Now you are getting the cold shoulder until you cave and keep obeying her.

This situation is unsustainable. They are lucky that you call in regularly but this could go on for years and when there is a crisis - there will be a crisis - the whole scenario will crash. What happens if you are ill? God forbid.

I've dealt with family members that age who insist that what they want is the only way and refuse all assistance from "outsiders". They won't change their minds.
The best thing in this situation is to get advice from somewhere like Age Concern, or even social services. Find out what help is available so that you can get some kind of respite.

Foodfan · 17/06/2023 18:09

Thank you everyone for your insights and perspective. I am looking into attendance allowance for her. I know she was able to do this for my dad before he died several years ago but his needs were far greater and she had to apply twice to get the money as was turned down the first time.

Being totally honest, I don’t want to be her at home carer at all. More than happy to keep taking her to do her weekly shop etc but all the other stuff I selfishly simply don’t want to do it. I’m sure there are lots of people who wouldn’t mind but I am not one of them!

OP posts:
MereDintofPandiculation · 17/06/2023 17:35

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 17:22

Why does no one plan for old age and infirmity????
because they are fully confident of their ability to manipulate others into doing their bidding

Because there’s so many ways of being old and infirm that it’s hard to plan

Because moving into elderly-suitable accommodation may mean giving up most of what makes life worth living for you.

Because no matter how much money you’ve saved,you know it’s got to last you the rest of your life and it’s scary to start spending it

Because it’s hard to realise that a few minutes help for you may be an hour’s travelling for the person helping

Because it’s hard to realise quite how unimportant you are to your children when they are still the most important people in your life (apart from your partner)

billy1966 · 17/06/2023 17:26

orangeflags · 17/06/2023 10:26

Well that's just how it is. What would happen if you were ill, or moved away or went on a long holiday? Not fair to rely on you. Stand firm

This.

Twice a day is a huge imposition.

You have a right to your life.

This person is hugely entitled.

Let them sulk.

Take back control of your life.

This entitlement will only increase.

You need to insist on alternatives, otherwise I think you should consider moving.

You are being lined up to be their carer by stealth.

That is not fair and not your responsibility.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 17:25

She’s not speaking to me at the moment
RESULT!
Now you're free of her, she thinks you'll plead with her and beg forgiveness, DO NOT CONTACT HER AT ALL.
Take back your power, just let it ride, if she contacts you wait a few days before you respond.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 17:22

Why does no one plan for old age and infirmity????
because they are fully confident of their ability to manipulate others into doing their bidding

Triptoqueen · 17/06/2023 17:19

Why does no one plan for old age and infirmity????
im nearly her age - what about using an eye bath to apply the eye solution (even with arthritis). Difficult to dress with frozen shoulder but some loose sleeveless tops etc might help.
Difficult to get carers twice a day. Does she shower herself? So she needs to work with either morning or evening g help and work around. Taxi numbers, Uber.