Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what to tell my DS about her dad

35 replies

L0neParent · 15/06/2023 23:09

I was with my ex-dp for 8 years. He wanted DC, I wasn’t so sure but after lots of pressure throughout the years, in the 7th year of our relationship I decided the time was right and we tried for a baby and I became pregnant.

A week before my due date he up and left, disappeared and I found out he was living with a woman.

He has nothing to do with our DS (not my choice) and has rejected him at each turn, asking for a DNA test, refusing maintenance etc. I jumped through all the hoops, proved paternity etc. and still he doesn’t even acknowledge him.

I have been open with my DS, haven’t hid the fact he has a dad but I’ve always used the excuse he is busy working, but that he loves him so much and works hard to provide for him financially. I am nothing but complimentary about my ex to my DS (when he asks questions).

Today I got a call from DS’ school, DS had been quite upset at school. The class were making Father’s Day cards and he insisted he wanted to make one and give it to his dad (whom he’s never even met). Then he said that because his dad lives so far away could he save up his pocket money and give it to his dad to enable him to travel to see him. It broke my heart and I’m at a total loss as to what to do.

I contacted ex-dp, explaining the situation and asking if he would at least just maybe send a card now and again. Just show some interest.

So of course he’s not going to respond but any tips on how I handle this with my DS id be grateful as I’m worried he could end up fucked up because his dad has just abandoned him.

thanks if you made it to the end.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user3199 · 19/07/2023 18:42

Agree with being as truthful as possible. A relative was in a similar situation to you. She lied to her child and said their father was dead. He wasn't, he just wanted nothing to do with the child. She thought she was doing the kindest thing. When her child was older they discovered the truth and the relationship between mother and child never recovered. (Child is now in their 40s). Very sad situation.

Kath85 · 17/06/2023 21:00

It’s a different scenario but my DS is adopted and has no contact with birth parents. They didn’t attend any court hearings and haven’t agreed to yearly letter contact with him. I talk about birth parents in a factual way telling my DS where he came from but I don’t build them up and when he has asked where they are I have told him they make bad choices and aren’t able to have a good relationship with him which is similar to your son. At this age you don’t need a big sit down conversation just wait until it comes up again which it definitely will (usually on car journeys in my experience!). I would tell your son similar about his father eg he sends money to help make your DS life easier but he can’t be a good father right now. You don’t need to be overly negative about DS father just be factual and your son will form his own opinions as he becomes older.

Champions League Sport GIF by UEFA
cestlavielife · 17/06/2023 20:21

Dont sit him down
Consuot family therapust
They will do it through play or advise ypu eg reading a book about mum and dad if he asks the question
Drawing family tree etc
The fathers day was a good moment maybe still is do something nice tomorrow

AcrossthePond55 · 16/06/2023 16:12

Oh, meant to add. If you feel at a loss as how to do this, as PPs have suggested consult a child therapist and let them guide you.

AcrossthePond55 · 16/06/2023 16:10

@L0neParent

DS is nearly 6 so still very young but he’s obviously struggling to grapple with what’s happening so I’m going to sit him down and tell him that in all honesty I’m not sure he will ever get to see his biological dad because it’s best for us all this way.

At his age I wouldn't 'sit him down and tell him' anything. That's a lot to put on his little shoulders at one go.

I'd simply change the way I've been answering his questions as he asks them or when he makes statements regarding his dad I'd make gentle corrections. If the first time you do this it leads to more of a discussion, that's fine. Just let him lead the discussion. Children will only ask as much as they can absorb at the time.

Season0fTheWitch · 16/06/2023 14:34

You're explaining yourself like you haven't lied- but you have. I say this gently but you have created a false story for your son which he didn't need. I know you meant well but how will you now tell him the truth- that his dad doesn't love him, provide for him etc? Money doesn't matter, no kid cares about money if they're not loved. Contact professionals- therapists, play therapists, anyone who will tell him the truth in an appropriate way.

Astromelia · 16/06/2023 14:15

L0neParent · 16/06/2023 12:48

Thanks for all the thoughtful and kind responses.

To clear up the post, DSs dad does pay maintenance (albeit court ordered) hence why I’ve said he provides for him financially. I have read that children who have no relationship with a parent do better knowing that they at least took care of them financially so this is not a lie.

The only thing I have lied about, is that I’ve told him his dad loves him very much, I did this because I didn’t want him feeling unloved, perhaps this was short-sighted of me and I never ever bring his father into conversation, ever, although I do address questions when I am being asked by my son.

I have and will never say an ill-word against his dad because at one time I loved the man very much and it’s not fair on my DS to do this.

DS is nearly 6 so still very young but he’s obviously struggling to grapple with what’s happening so I’m going to sit him down and tell him that in all honesty I’m not sure he will ever get to see his biological dad because it’s best for us all this way.

I just don’t want to see my little boy upset and consequently have put this off for what is obviously too long.

I’m sorry to the posters who have been through similar situations.

I see how it’s happened, and it’s understandable. You want to protect your child.

But you really need to be honest with him and help him to face how distressing the truth is. It’s not better for him to never see his dad - it’s awful that his dad doesn’t want him, and it’s ok if he feels the awfulness. Your job is to tell him the truth, to an age appropriate extent, and support him emotionally to come to terms with it.

His father is a real disappointment. It’s ok, it’s not your fault and it’s not your son’s fault. It’s ok to be be sad or angry about it. You’ll both be alright. But you need to tell him that his dad is a real, flawed person and has made a bad decision.

Your son is upset right now because he’s been told a lovely story that has confused him. Time to be brave and tell the truth.

mindutopia · 16/06/2023 14:08

You do need to be honest with him, in an age appropriate way. Because the most important thing for your relationship as a parent is for him to know that he can trust you. You've lied to him, albeit with good intentions, and it's worked for him for now. It's allowed him to make sense of a tricky situation. But he's getting old enough now for you to start being a bit more honest. Because it's important for him to know you will tell him the truth and that he can talk to you about anything. Beyond that, you don't want him learning from a young age that this is the way to be a good day, just fucking off and sending money because the court told him he had to. A good dad is like a good mum, like you, there and present and nurturing him and taking him places and looking after him when he's poorly.

He's still young though, so while upsetting at first, this will just become his normal once he gets his head around it. Lots of love and attention and connection while he comes to understand it all. But maybe wait until after Father's Day. It's such a loaded time when you don't have a dad in your life. Let things die down a little while. He sounds like a lovely, kind boy though and I would let him know that what he said was a really thoughtful thing (even if his rubbish dad doesn't deserve it).

Starlightstarbright1 · 16/06/2023 13:54

L0neParent · 16/06/2023 12:48

Thanks for all the thoughtful and kind responses.

To clear up the post, DSs dad does pay maintenance (albeit court ordered) hence why I’ve said he provides for him financially. I have read that children who have no relationship with a parent do better knowing that they at least took care of them financially so this is not a lie.

The only thing I have lied about, is that I’ve told him his dad loves him very much, I did this because I didn’t want him feeling unloved, perhaps this was short-sighted of me and I never ever bring his father into conversation, ever, although I do address questions when I am being asked by my son.

I have and will never say an ill-word against his dad because at one time I loved the man very much and it’s not fair on my DS to do this.

DS is nearly 6 so still very young but he’s obviously struggling to grapple with what’s happening so I’m going to sit him down and tell him that in all honesty I’m not sure he will ever get to see his biological dad because it’s best for us all this way.

I just don’t want to see my little boy upset and consequently have put this off for what is obviously too long.

I’m sorry to the posters who have been through similar situations.

its best for us sounds really like you taking the blame .His dad stopped contact and not you. You are once again protecting his dad .

you have created a fantasy dad. You need to unpick this very carefully - because you are in danger of your child not believing a word you say.

You also need to know as he gets older he will have more questions . My Ds was 13 when he needed to know the whole truth of why it wasn’t safe to see his dad. But every time he questioned and needed to know more.

I think letting him know he has never met you so taking responsibility away from anything child did or didn’t do is important .

I have never ever said that his dad loved him as that’s not what I think someone who loves you should do.

I think you need time to think through what exactly needs to be said but you are going to hurt him no matter which way this happens .

I also would say - it is far easier for there to be no contact at all. An odd Christmas/ birthday card from a stranger called dad would be worse than dealing with reality

BusyBeeThirtyThree · 16/06/2023 13:04

For context, I have a similar situation- my DS (15) SD (sperm donor) was unreliable and lives quite far away- he seen him when he was 6 weeks for a few hours and that's it. I always explained to my DS that he was so lucky to have everyone around him (my family/friends) which not everyone has and every family is differe t. I explained that sometimes adults make bad choices and my ex wasn't ready to be a dad and that i felt sad for my ex missing out because my DS is brilliant in so many ways (and listed his qualities). I always referred to my ex as 'the man who made him' and used his name, explaining the qualities that a Dad has. Now my husband is his Dad (my son calls him his name, but tells everyone else he's his dad). My ex has got back In touch and whilst my DS is happy for my ex to know about him- at the moment he doesn't have or want any contact with him. My husband adopted my DS and social services feel DS is well rounded and has a good perspective and outlook on the situation. They did suggest showing pics of my ex, so my son can see resemblances and help his identity. I also tell him nice stories about my ex so he has some history there but overall I've always made it clear the truth- that my ex is the silly one, who's missed out, and adults are people who make bad choices too. On fathers day, my son always made a card for my Mum, as she always stepped in and helped, and it was an extra day for us to do something together. I hope you and your son are OK and some of the advice on the thread, helps you both 🤞

L0neParent · 16/06/2023 12:48

Thanks for all the thoughtful and kind responses.

To clear up the post, DSs dad does pay maintenance (albeit court ordered) hence why I’ve said he provides for him financially. I have read that children who have no relationship with a parent do better knowing that they at least took care of them financially so this is not a lie.

The only thing I have lied about, is that I’ve told him his dad loves him very much, I did this because I didn’t want him feeling unloved, perhaps this was short-sighted of me and I never ever bring his father into conversation, ever, although I do address questions when I am being asked by my son.

I have and will never say an ill-word against his dad because at one time I loved the man very much and it’s not fair on my DS to do this.

DS is nearly 6 so still very young but he’s obviously struggling to grapple with what’s happening so I’m going to sit him down and tell him that in all honesty I’m not sure he will ever get to see his biological dad because it’s best for us all this way.

I just don’t want to see my little boy upset and consequently have put this off for what is obviously too long.

I’m sorry to the posters who have been through similar situations.

OP posts:
TheFormidableMrsC · 16/06/2023 08:52

Oh goodness me, I'm sorry you're going through this. This happened to me too, all the pressure, we were married, he left after an affair when DS was 2 as "family life wasn't for him". OW didn't want my son around at all and without going into the full horror of it, my ex finally dumped our son completely when he was 8. It was so unbearably cruel and it's taken a lot of therapy for my son to unpick.

I told my son that some people are just not cut out to be good Dads. They think they can be or want to be but don't have the ability to actually do it. I have reiterated over and over that it's not his fault, it's nothing he's done. I have said that one day his dad will probably regret losing him but that was his problem to live with. It's really difficult. I still find little piles of torn up pictures or letters he's tried to write. However, I try not to dwell and distract him straight away. I have given him a good, secure and loving childhood. He writes Father's Day cards to me and when he was at primary, they were brilliant with this so it might be worth speaking to them.

I'm so sorry he's struggling, maybe consider some counselling, again school can often refer for this. You've done a great job on your own Flowers

thebabessavedme · 16/06/2023 08:51

Don't lie, just don't tell the whole truth. I never badmouthed my dds father, (I didn't have too, his actions showed what he was and dd learnt what he was as she got older, no discussion needed really)I just used to say that he wasn't very good at being at being a dad, now she is an adult with her own child she agrees I said the right things.

Has you ds got a grandad/uncle/close family male friend that could take him under his wing a bit? I do think we all need good influences from older people as we grow up. Also, be very very careful if and when you meet someone, I was so lucky in meeting dds 'stepfather', he has and continues to be the best father and grandfather after 30 years, I could not have introduced multiple men to her as a new 'daddy'.

WunWun · 16/06/2023 08:43

I think you've handled this quite badly unfortunately, although obviously you meant well.

I think it would be best to speak to a children's therapist as to how to unravel this rather than talking advice here x

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 16/06/2023 08:40

I totally see what you are saying there against "sadness" but the previous lies need to be reframed for the child somehow

cestlavielife · 16/06/2023 07:36

Be the heroes of your story.

cestlavielife · 16/06/2023 07:36

Daddy has made me very sad

Dont do this either
Dont make it a sad life. It isnt.
Neutral
Make it ok
Im so pleased daddy made you with me
It s, a shame he isnt around and i dont know why he decided to leave. but i am here and you have xxx snd xxx in your life. We are a great team. We are a great family.

AcrossthePond55 · 16/06/2023 00:58

I agree with PPs that you shouldn't have given your son a 'fantasy dad'. But that's water under the bridge now. So now you have to find a way to 'let him down slowly'.

Considering that the class was making FD cards I assume he's relatively young. So I don't think I'd set him down for a 'big talk'. Rather, I'd stop telling him lies and if/when he asks about his father I'd start backing away from the 'busy working to support you' to a gentle 'I don't really know why he doesn't make time to see you' or words to that effect. There's nothing wrong with "I don't know" when a child is too young to absorb the real truth. Then as time goes on you can add more bits of the truth to the narrative until you've gotten to the real truth "Your dad doesn't have it in him to be a good father. It's not you, it's him".

MysteryBelle · 16/06/2023 00:25

🥺 this is heartbreaking, op. Your precious son deserves a father who loves him.

Has your ex given any kind of reason (there is no good reason) that he uses to justify his absence from his own son? I hope there is a way to resolve this. A boy needs his dad.

ejbaxa · 16/06/2023 00:09

You need to go with the truth IMO. As nicely as you can. But don't let him have this fantasy in his head that his dad is a great man who loves him.

Merryoldgoat · 16/06/2023 00:06

My dad is like your son’s dad. I’ve never met him.

My mum wasn’t unpleasant about him but she was truthful and told me in an age appropriate way that he didn’t want to be part of our lives.

It is better to be honest than set up a fantasy.

‘The truth is pickle that some men aren’t very good dads and your dad is like that. BUT that means I get to be your mum AND dad and I get to love you twice as much!’

You can also show him he can make Father’s Day cards for someone else - granddad/uncle etc who loves him.

Kaffiene · 16/06/2023 00:02

My DS hasn’t seen his Dad in over a year even though he lives round the corner. I am as honest as I can be. I just say some people are just rubbish at being Dads. I don’t understand it either and go on to say all things I love about DS. I reiterate I am here and I am not going anywhere, how we are a good team together. I don’t bring up his Dad but will answer any questions truthfully. We talked about Fathers Day. I asked if he wanted to make me an extra card as I was doing the job of mum & dad. He thought that was funny and has been proudly telling everyone.
i spoke to the Ed Pysch about the situation and they recommended a good book The Whole Brain Child which really highlighted the importance of talking through with your kids.
It was reading the book that encouraged me to bring up Father’s Day and make a plan for how we would deal with it rather than hiding from it. so far it seems to have helped.

Mariposista · 16/06/2023 00:00

Bless you, OP what a horrible situation to be in. My mum was abandoned by my father while pregnant and she never spoke a bad word about him (and he would deserve this). However she didn’t lie and say he cared/provided money neither. I know this is coming from a place of love but don’t fabricate ideallic images of this man to protect your son, it will only hurt more when he discovers the truth. Say to him that family is important and he is a lucky boy as he has lots of people who love him, his mum, grandparents, aunts uncles etc and friends too, and all they are family.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 15/06/2023 23:50

I also agree that you never should have gone with kind lies, but it's too late now. You can get this back

DS I didn't want to make you sad but Daddy has made me very sad that he is not here for you. Mummy doesn't understand why either darling

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 15/06/2023 23:47

My friends DS will never meet his Dad whilst a child. She has given him age appropriate explanations as he has got older, yes at this stage you need to be a bit less vague. There's being gentle and then there's actually giving false hope.

Mummy can't get messages to Daddy might be a good start

Swipe left for the next trending thread