Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this parent is setting her daughter up to fail

217 replies

Anonoteacher · 15/06/2023 22:33

I teach in a large all girls secondary school. This is about a year 7 pupil who has no additional needs or medical issues of any kind.
Her mother is a nurse and regularly writes in her planner that she will be staying in her uniform and not getting changed for pe due to “personal female issues”
I think this is such an odd thing for a female nurse to write to a female teacher at a large school for girls.
For one, why are we phrasing it like this continually?
and for two, why are we teaching girls to opt out of sport every time they get a period. Is this normal?
I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.
Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

OP posts:
Hiderun · 16/06/2023 08:21

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 16/06/2023 07:42

To play devils advocate for those saying girls should be excused when on Period what should they do for the two hours a week? Nothing? Sit out? Watch? Whilst you have 50% ish of the cohort sitting out at least once a month. What about the others who aren't on their period and see the other sitting out but equally hate PE? What about 'my DD was shamed and told to sit on side everyone knew she had her period' type comment. What about female PE teachers. Can they just not come to work for 5 days a month?

I would flag this with safeguarding in response to OP

Hi ‘devils advocate’ I can’t speak for everyone but wouldn’t it open other peoples eyes to the fact that for a good percentage periods are not plain sailing? Also teach them not to make assumptions because without going into personal details I did have a couple of terms where I could not do pe for another reason which only my friends knew about. Nothing juicy to gossip about and back then no one did funnily enough. As for pe teachers or any other employee they are grown adults and have to cope not a teen trying to find out how to cope plus on top of it having others not understanding because they don’t experience it in the same way or have the attitude “back in my day….”. As an adult some out there wouldn’t believe how other colleagues have rallied round to help another manage bad periods or not known about how someone they see always professional has fainted from periods starting. I could go on…..

BrunchMonster · 16/06/2023 08:16

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 16/06/2023 07:42

To play devils advocate for those saying girls should be excused when on Period what should they do for the two hours a week? Nothing? Sit out? Watch? Whilst you have 50% ish of the cohort sitting out at least once a month. What about the others who aren't on their period and see the other sitting out but equally hate PE? What about 'my DD was shamed and told to sit on side everyone knew she had her period' type comment. What about female PE teachers. Can they just not come to work for 5 days a month?

I would flag this with safeguarding in response to OP

no-one is saying that all girls need to be excused every time, though. The fact that you are still saying it sets a precedent and shouldn't be allowed suggests that you think some of them don't really have it bad enough. Of course teachers don't miss 5 days a month, but if they have bad periods and are vomiting or flooding or migrainey, then they probably do miss a day or two at times. Same with girls. What the girls do in that time probably depends how bad they're feeling. I could have sat and watched, or just curled up, possibly could read depending how bad it was. If vomiting and in lots of pain, no. If just drained and dizzy, then yes I could have watched or helped. For me, it would only have been the first day that was a problem. Others it might be more.

Teaslurpershutup · 16/06/2023 08:06

Yes I would especially if she really didn't like sports. Its always pushed on pupils as more important than it is at school. Some just aren't good at sports. Yes exercise is good for everyone but you should be able to choose which ones and when you take part in.
There could be many reasons why she doesn't want to go including heavy periods which she'd feel more self conscious of if wearing PE kit. I don't understand how you couldn't work this out for yourself and have to ask tbh. If you really think its to cover up something else then of course you need to discuss it with the parent.

Kazzyhoward · 16/06/2023 08:05

SilverGlitterBaubles · 16/06/2023 06:46

What would be helpful is for schools to teach more about the importance of exercise for general physical and mental health. Try to inspire a love of exercise as part of life rather than instilling an ingrained fear. Schools should open up different forms of exercise to those that do not want to play team sports such as football, hockey or netball etc. Offer yoga, gym sessions, fitness classes using dance, swimming walking, running, cycling etc. Make it a time each week where everyone has their time to enjoy their chosen activity.

Nail on the head. Unfortunately, most PE teachers are the "sporty kids" of a couple of decades ago who loved team sports and bullied the kids who didn't. Now they're teachers and just doing the same!

I suffered a horrid time at secondary school in PE/games classes. However "resilient" I was, I couldn't "compete" with the sporty kids and got bullied as a result. It was all just a complete waste of time.

It wasn't until fifth year (now year 11) that a different games teacher, one who had some compassion/common sense, realised the harm it was causing and let me do swimming for every half term instead of the "carousel" of just one half term per year. Swimming was something I could do, so finally the games lessons were actually useful and didn't cause any harm. A win-win, shame it took 5 years before a games teacher realised and understood that it's insanity to keep doing the same thing and expecting different results!

There definitely needs to be more choice and a lot less importance/emphasis attached to team sports.

Kazzyhoward · 16/06/2023 07:56

Personally, I think that school PE/Games/Sports should be voluntary and that pupils should be able to "opt out" without the lies/subterfuge of sick notes etc.

I hated it at school and is caused a lot of damage to me. It drove serious bullying against me (from the sporty kids), it left me with feeling useless and hopeless at sports, helped to increase my obesity, etc. It was only in my late 20's that I discovered I actually did enjoy physical activity, and started playing squash, golf, tennis, swimming, cycling, skiing and walking!

School (and school PE/games teachers) had sucked all interest, ability and fun out of sports for me.

Or, if a voluntary opt out of sports in schools isn't possible, then the teachers need one hell of a kick up the arse to change the way they "teach" it, as they're the ones who are causing most of the problems. I think the tone of the original poster here speaks volumes - typical attitude that the pupil in question must put up with whatever crap they're suffering in PE lessons in the name of "resilience".

wildfirewonder · 16/06/2023 07:55

School PE is absolute shite. It needs a complete overhaul to be 'exercise and wellbeing' or something. Until it is worth doing, people - both pupils and parents - will not value it. It is just not a good use of kids' time.

I think the mother is right to prioritise her daughter's needs. That is how real life works - you do the things you really need to and sack off the pointless stuff.

greyhairnomore · 16/06/2023 07:52

@LifeIsPainHighness absolutely agree. HATED PE , every single thing about it. I was (am) very uncoordinated and not very good at sport. Had good friends at school but always last to be picked.
Used to skive off whenever possible.
I still wouldn't join in team sports.

OneSugar1 · 16/06/2023 07:51

You need to develop more resilience OP - stop overthinking this and let it go.

Thehippowife · 16/06/2023 07:45

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 22:36

God I wish my mum had done this.

People who don’t understand what’s it’s like to hate PE with a passion and find it painful and extremely exhausting, both physically and mentally, will never get it - and it’s especially bad when you’re on your period or have one boob growing bigger than the other and have to share a changing room with girls.

I wish schools would stop acting like PE is the be all and bloody end all. Most kids don’t bother with sports after age 16, and it’s one of those things that as a child, if you’re not good at it you’re unlikely to get better. Exercise is important but not to the point that it should be carried out at the expense of pain and discomfort.

I suspect I’ll be in the minority there though.

I couldn’t agree more . I loved PE but my daughter hated it. She was made to run for ages around a field , no matter what the weather - some kids were actually sick from running. It’s ridiculous, PE is not the most important topic a school has to offer.

Legolegends · 16/06/2023 07:43

You don’t know this kid’s circumstances - how do you know there are no issues? can you speak to the Mum or child to see if any help or reassurance can be given eg if very heavy periods, can she leave the lesson? Also she may have sensory issues that stop her sometimes from joining in - individual teachers do not always know about autism / SEN issues as this is often shared on a need to know basis.

MortifiedSeptember · 16/06/2023 07:42

Make an appointment with the mother, if you can't understand why she is requesting unreasonable demands (according to you). After some discussion you might understand the situation better.

I used to read notes my mom sent school. Maybe the mother used words that she thought was best to cause her daughter less embarrassment.

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 16/06/2023 07:42

To play devils advocate for those saying girls should be excused when on Period what should they do for the two hours a week? Nothing? Sit out? Watch? Whilst you have 50% ish of the cohort sitting out at least once a month. What about the others who aren't on their period and see the other sitting out but equally hate PE? What about 'my DD was shamed and told to sit on side everyone knew she had her period' type comment. What about female PE teachers. Can they just not come to work for 5 days a month?

I would flag this with safeguarding in response to OP

SchoolQuestionnaire · 16/06/2023 07:42

DeoForty · 15/06/2023 22:36

How do you know it's her period she's referring to?

This. And if it is periods, perhaps she’s writing it in that way to save her daughter’s feelings. Teenagers are easily embarrassed by these things.

Tbh I’m really struggling to believe that someone who works in an all-girls school cannot comprehend that some women and girls suffer far more from periods and other ‘personal female issues’ than others that they may be sensitive about this.

Kookookachooo · 16/06/2023 07:41

I find this post very strange in that you as a professional decided to come on a forum and post identifying information regarding a pupil in your care.

Honestly, I think it absolutely does not affect you in any way, shape or form if this person misses Hockey every couple of weeks?! It’s P.E! Why are you not thrilled that this mother is advocating for her daughter and not putting her in a shitty situation. I know my mum didn’t for me and I dreaded P.E/periods, it have me massive anxiety and makes me sad to think about 20 years later.

speakout · 16/06/2023 07:40

SilverGlitterBaubles · Today 06:46

What would be helpful is for schools to teach more about the importance of exercise for general physical and mental health. Try to inspire a love of exercise as part of life rather than instilling an ingrained fear. Schools should open up different forms of exercise to those that do not want to play team sports such as football, hockey or netball etc. Offer yoga, gym sessions, fitness classes using dance, swimming walking, running, cycling etc. Make it a time each week where everyone has their time to enjoy their chosen activity.

I totally agree.
I think PE puts many people off exercise for life. I dreaded PE days, and idetested competitive sport - forced to play netball, hockey, athletics. I dreaded and felt physically on PE days, ir didn't help that PE teachers all seemed to be vindictive nasty teachers.

Some may enjoy competitive sport, but many, I would suggest the majority of girls especially don't.
I too would like to see more of an emphasis on personal fitness, zumba, yoga, body pump etc.
When I left school I vowed I would never set foot in a gym again, but thankfully I discovered school PE departments are not good examples of places to motivate and develop our personal fitness.
It would be 10 years after school that I wanted to try any type of fitness activity.
Despite the bad PE experience at school I did eventually find activities I enjoyed- body pump, and now yoga- I attend 6 classes a week at my local gym.

But my exercise regime now is despite my school experience, not because of it.

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 07:38

And also agree with PPs about periods. Luckily my DD’s are manageable currently, but if you knew how badly some girls and women suffer with them, you wouldn’t call it an excuse. I know there is an issue with high rates of teenage girls dropping out of / avoiding PE. Instead of blaming them we should understand the reasons and give them period-friendly options.

willWillSmithsmith · 16/06/2023 07:37

Hated PE with a passion. Not sure what business it is of yours, maybe this girl really suffers and doesn’t want to go in to detail?

ilovesushi · 16/06/2023 07:37

Could the girl be writing the notes? I would always email the teacher not write in the planner.

Maireas · 16/06/2023 07:37

I think you're right, @SockGoddess because failing at PE is obvious, and it's humiliating. My classes can make mistakes in my lessons and it's only obvious to them and me. Plus it usually doesn't prevent a good outcome. PE is much more of a public performance. If you fail to catch a ball or kick a ball, it's obvious to all.

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 07:34

My DD really struggles with school PE. The reasons are because she feels humiliated and embarrassed having to “perform” physically in front of others, she hates physical contact with people she doesn’t like/is scared of (with good reason), and making them do competitive sport makes her feel shown up. When it’s dance or fitness like yoga, she’s fine. She also is happy to go swimming, climb a hill etc even on her period. You can’t assume it’s about laziness or “using a period as an excuse”. Both in my own experience and my DCs’, it’s often because many PE teachers are unsympathetic and have little time for anyone who’s not good at competitive sport, and because schools don’t give those kids other options. I’d make PE multi-option so you could choose to join a dance lesson or hill walk group and kids could get exercise without having to compete under pressure.

NatureNurture85 · 16/06/2023 07:34

I think we forget as women to treat each other kindly. This mother is doing what’s best for her daughter at that time. There is a great podcast by Mindy Pelz about your cycle and when’s best to do certain types of exercise. There is a lot to be said for nurturing your body through your period. Protecting your limited energy reserves. The start of your cycle is great for cardio/active exercises.

ladydimitrescu · 16/06/2023 07:33

I started my Periods aged 9, and by the time I started secondary school I experienced flooding, fainting and dizziness and severe cramps. It was difficult enough to attend school some months, let alone do PE.
YAB massively unreasonable, have no idea of this girls circumstances, and are shockingly unprofessional slagging a student and her parent off online.

BrunchMonster · 16/06/2023 07:32

another one here with horrendous periods at that age, really awful, painful, could turn into vomiting and migraines, total aching in legs, couldn't have done PE at all.

And I'd have been embarrassed if my mum used the word 'period' with my teachers in a note, so could easily have asked her to write something else that seemed more subtle to me, even if it wasn't to the teacher!

CaptainMyCaptain · 16/06/2023 07:32

People are assuming the OP is the PE teacher. She says she 'works in a school ' she could be office staff receiving the note or a nosey TA who is not involved at all.

changeme4this · 16/06/2023 07:28

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 07:22

FGS your mum isn’t in a wheelchair because she skipped PE!

She is in a wheelchair because she has continually failed to adhere to advice to take exercise.

don’t try to give advice where you have no expertise or knowledge!