Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know how to feel about this information?

64 replies

tertrisnblox · 15/06/2023 21:09

I am a criminal justice social worker and have had a student with me for the past six weeks (I am her link worker). She's been great, passed with flying colours, went above and beyond, was really empathetic and this really stood out. She was able to communicate and build strong relationships with the clients in such a short period of time. I have no doubt she will make a fantastic social worker.

Wednesday was her last day, and we had our final supervision. Said our goodbyes etc. At the end student said to me, something along these lines (can't remember exactly), 'I never shared this with you in the beginning as I was worried about being judged, but eleven years ago I actually went through the criminal justice system and have four convictions, I've also had my own addiction issues, it's been such an honour being on this side of things and able to help others'.

I just said some pleasantries, nodded and smiled and told her well done again.

I know that she will have been PVG checked through both the uni and my employers before starting her so I have no doubt they have deemed her suitable. However, I feel slightly duped and unsure how to feel. To come out with this on the last day? Kind of feels like she's been keeping some big secret.

Am I being precious? I just feel uncomfortable about it and don't feel it's something I can speak to my colleagues regarding.

Should I approach my team leader?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissingMoominMamma · 15/06/2023 22:26

tertrisnblox · 15/06/2023 21:22

She didn't need to share it with me at all surely?

She trusted you and wanted to tell you how good it felt to be helping others to possibly achieve what she has, despite past trauma (which is the root of most addiction).

You should feel very privileged.

AtomicBlondeRose · 15/06/2023 22:26

Duped because you felt like she was one of “you” and now you feel like she’s one of “them”…? I’d maybe use this as a chance to reflect about how you feel about the people who work with in your role.

DanielRicciardosSmile · 15/06/2023 22:23

Anotherparkingthread · 15/06/2023 21:21

Surely 11 years ago she wasn't even adult herself? She has turned things around and now wants to help people, or do you propose no second chances and she shouldn't be allowed to pursue any type of career? Get a fucking grip, everybody has a past.

Not everyone goes to university at 18. There are thousands of mature students. This woman could easily be 35-45 or older.

RhosynBach · 15/06/2023 22:22

Sounds like her life experiences have given her an insight into the difficulties others face and are likely a huge contributing factor to her social and empathy skills which you have just been praising.
Why you’d be annoyed with her past is beyond me. She’s moved on and is obviously working incredibly hard to not only help herself but to help others too. That should be commended not criticised.

SunnySaturdayinJune · 15/06/2023 22:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it was posted by a previously bas

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/06/2023 22:19

I think it's just shock that's making you feel a bit odd about it - you know, realistically, that all those checks have already been done.

Don't report, just try not to think about it again. These weird feelings will fade.

FOJN · 15/06/2023 22:15

She was right not to tell you earlier. Despite performing really well on her placement you are now judging her on her past, you are doing exactly what she feared she would.

Rather than admire her for overcoming her past difficulties and using her experience to help others you feel duped.

She trusted you enough to tell you now thinking that it would matter less because she had proved herself and thought you would no longer think badly of her. I think she's the one who has been duped.

Why would you betray her confidence by discussing it with your team leader. Nothing bad happened to you, get a grip.

Fattygettingthinner · 15/06/2023 22:09

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:37

I’m wondering if this is a reverse because no one in criminal justice social work would be smelling the salts over something like a previous criminal history.

I can’t get my head round it either. She should be more experienced and better trained than this and I’d worry if the op is actually any good at her job, which she maybe feels is us and them.

momonpurpose · 15/06/2023 22:08

Wow instead of being proud of her you judge her...

Fattygettingthinner · 15/06/2023 22:07

I’m a bit stunned by the contradiction between your job and your horrible judgey reaction. She’s suitable. She’s good ar her job, she clearly liked you enough to share and didn’t realise what you were really like.

yeah go running to your boss. I’m fairly sure their reaction will be like mine.

embarased for you.

LadyLolaRuben · 15/06/2023 21:59

Tbh I'd expect someone in a role like yours to be more worldly wise. If you've been in a mentoring type role with this person, things like this come to your attention. If you feel uncomfortable maybe you need to seek some further mentor training and then decide if your comfortable doing it in future. Or perhaps you need a mentor to support you during the next placement you have

boringlady · 15/06/2023 21:56

U don't sound very nice

LadyLolaRuben · 15/06/2023 21:54

She's lived the experience, she'll be fab at the job for that reason.

Many Drs and nurses have criminal records. You declare them during your application and they assess if that will impact on how well you do the job and check it won't put the public at risk.

For example, say they rescued an animal being mistreated by its owner and was convicted of theft or stood up for human rights and got caught up in a protest. So what. Yes you are being precious.

The law can be an ass and sometimes it means you stood up for something in your life and had courage and character.

In this case this lady has beaten her demons by the sounds of it.

Btw...I've never been arrested or convicted of anything but know that life is not clear cut

bottleofbeer · 15/06/2023 21:53

She's been checked and considered fine to do the job. Lived experience is really valuable. She told you because she's built a rapport with you and trusts you.

Spirallingdownwards · 15/06/2023 21:51

tertrisnblox · 15/06/2023 21:22

She didn't need to share it with me at all surely?

No she didn't need to but she felt she was able to.

However, she was clearly wrong because of the way you are now feeling towards her. She sounds like she has a made a good career choice but the way you are now behaving and judging her perhaps the trip to your manager should be to ask for further training for yourself?

Lamelie · 15/06/2023 21:45

Threads like this make me despair that clinical supervision isn’t more widespread. Not having a pop at you op but this is 100% the sort of issue that reflecting with a supervisor would be invaluable.

Starsnspikes · 15/06/2023 21:43

Different perspective here, but I can understand you feeling this way OP. For me, it's the fact that I'd expect her to reflect on her own experiences and whether/how they impact on her current practice. It sounds like they've had a positive impact on her, but either way it's something I'd want her to be acknowledging and thinking through (within the safe, confidential space of supervision). The fact that she didn't do this would leave a question mark in my mind.

She has chosen to go into this profession. While it is absolutely right that she should be able to put her past behind her, the choice to enter this career negates that to an extent as she needs to be able to discuss it with future employers, presuming it still shows up on record. And reflection is so crucial to safe practice in social work.

Blendiful · 15/06/2023 21:40

I think you should feel honoured she felt she could share it.

People change, after all isn't that what the jobs about and based on? The fact people can make and sustain change and the hope for that.

She will have been checked by others to come to you. By all means discuss in your supervision if you want some reflection. But perhaps it's just some uncomfortable feelings from you as you deemed her fully capable and so weren't 'expecting' that, we all have biases and it's good to address them, and sometimes have them shoved in our face to address them, it's not wrong but I think addressing how you feel now you know that, and perhaps whether you may have felt differently if you had known from the off, could be good learning.

Curseofthenation · 15/06/2023 21:39

I would find it uplifting that someone who had gone down the wrong path (like many of the people you deal with) had turned her life around and made good choices. It would motivate me in my job to encourage and work with the vunerable people I deal with too, as I'd want them to have bright futures.

SafeguardingSocialWorker · 15/06/2023 21:38

I kind of get it OP, I'm a SW prac ed (in England not Scotland where I think you are and it so it might be different) but the relationship you can have with a student can be quite intense sometimes and I would feel a bit weird if they only disclosed something like this at the end of a placement, it's something I would hope they would have discussed as part of the pre-placement meeting, they potentially are going to have to disclose it to every employer when they qualify so good practice for them to do it.

saying that, I wouldn't have been upset about it, just a bit surprised, and probably a bit concerned (for my own abilities as a prac Ed) that they hadn't trusted me with the information earlier.

at least you will remember her. My less interesting students over the years have all blurred into one now.

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:37

I’m wondering if this is a reverse because no one in criminal justice social work would be smelling the salts over something like a previous criminal history.

HollaHolla · 15/06/2023 21:37

Ponoka7 · 15/06/2023 21:20

I think that you are duty bound to share the disclosure. It's more than likely that the convictions can be disregarded because they were over ten years ago. As you know, you can never assume that someone else has been told. I find on here the codes of conduct/responsibility etc within SW isn't understood. You are questioning, so do it. When I was doing my BA in SW we had people half way through placements suddenly being told that they couldn't continue.

Not this. At all.
OP, I’m assuming you’re in Scotland, as you refer to PVG. This is a live system, which throws up alerts as they happen. Also, it will be under the category that most convictions are never seen as ‘spent’.

I manage the screenings of PVGs for nursing and medical students in my job. This will have been risk assessed, as it would show up on their PVG.

This is also a prime example of why we continue to impress upon students that their PVG is between them and the university. Course tutors won’t need to know about this, and neither would practice educators or supervisors. The legal responsibility remains with the university. I can think of at least two students who have gone through their course, and have served custodial sentences; but have shown appropriate change in their lives.
You need to butt out, and leave this to those involved. I’m really sorry to hear that you have shown this prejudice to this student.

pinkunicorns54 · 15/06/2023 21:35

tertrisnblox · 15/06/2023 21:09

I am a criminal justice social worker and have had a student with me for the past six weeks (I am her link worker). She's been great, passed with flying colours, went above and beyond, was really empathetic and this really stood out. She was able to communicate and build strong relationships with the clients in such a short period of time. I have no doubt she will make a fantastic social worker.

Wednesday was her last day, and we had our final supervision. Said our goodbyes etc. At the end student said to me, something along these lines (can't remember exactly), 'I never shared this with you in the beginning as I was worried about being judged, but eleven years ago I actually went through the criminal justice system and have four convictions, I've also had my own addiction issues, it's been such an honour being on this side of things and able to help others'.

I just said some pleasantries, nodded and smiled and told her well done again.

I know that she will have been PVG checked through both the uni and my employers before starting her so I have no doubt they have deemed her suitable. However, I feel slightly duped and unsure how to feel. To come out with this on the last day? Kind of feels like she's been keeping some big secret.

Am I being precious? I just feel uncomfortable about it and don't feel it's something I can speak to my colleagues regarding.

Should I approach my team leader?

Fellow SW here, previously in YJ!

I think the only issue for me is that the people who would have 'cleared' the student is the university as she was on placement.
If the student was being employed by the LA you work in, they would have had to complete their own DBS etc and would have been able to have a conversation with them, in order to unpick it a little further.

Having said that though, with all of the students I've looked after - it has been mandatory to see their DBS... did you not see theirs?

However, I think the incidents would have been a long time ago and they are clearly in a different place and probably have learnt from it. Their history wouldn't have stopped me offering them the opportunity - but would have probably enhanced supervision if you had known to be able to drawn upon their lived experience!

Alittlesummeroasis · 15/06/2023 21:33

Are you actually a social worker? From your posts you don’t appear to have the right understanding or outlook.

Surely the idea that someone builds trust before sharing information shouldn’t surprise you?

The idea that she might withhold information for fear of judgement shouldn’t surprise you either.

The fact that you wish to condemn her based on historic, resolved, issues, despite her demonstrating her qualities in the role suggest that you don’t think anyone can ever move forward after making a bad decision. Do you believe that all of the people you work with should be forever labelled as useless and untrustworthy because of their actions?

Surely your job has led you to meet people who have been drawn to crime through adverse childhood experiences, addiction, trauma etc. Do you not see the reasons that people offend, and try to understand this in your support for them?

Of course some people do reoffend, but if you have no hope or belief of anyone ever being reformed then why do you do the job that you do?

drumroll · 15/06/2023 21:31

Maybe by the end of placement she has felt comfortable enough to share that with u. I am assuming she has went through the PVG system etc ...

My opinion is that ppl with real life experience make the best workers. She may have come across social work in her earlier life and they have made a positive difference which is why she has chosen that career path .

I thinks it's great she's managed to turn her life around and do something positive.