Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is insanely childish? Anyone else been shocked by an adult’s immaturity?!

232 replies

llammar · 15/06/2023 19:57

In our group of friends one of us can’t make the birthday dinner for someone in the group. They birthday girls has taken huge offence and said the alternative date suggested ‘isn’t her actual birthday so it won’t feel the same.’ Wtf? She’s going to
be 38 not 6? It’s literally moving the day from a Friday (her birthday) to a Saturday. I’ve

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 17/06/2023 06:28

Sometimes you can't attend everything. The one person who wants the date changed is being precious. Also - she could always arrive later in the evening - straight from her flight.

MintyBinty · 17/06/2023 06:09

That should say - it’s her birthday, so what she wants takes precedent over day for example a general group plan

MintyBinty · 17/06/2023 06:09

I don’t understand why you’re being so judgmental about your friend not wanting to move the date. She invited her friends out on her actual birthday. That’s the date, that’s the plan. It’s her birthday, not a group meal out.

it’s actually really fucking rude of your other friend to expect the birthday plans to be moved to accommodate her. I’m really surprised you can’t see that.

JustOneCornettoPlease · 17/06/2023 05:50

I agree OP. My priority would be that everyone could attend.

But then again I felt the same about my hen and wedding. It was about accommodating guests and having as many people I liked there. It was never ‘all about the bride and groom’.

For me, I would want as many good
friends as possible around me. Changing the date would be an easy compromise.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 17/06/2023 05:36

What I'm finding really strange about the whole scenario is it seems to be about what the friend wants and no one seems interested in the actual person whose birthday it is! 😵‍💫

WilkinsonM · 17/06/2023 04:56

Maybe she doesn't have anything else nice to do on her birthday and would end up alone? That to me would feel sad and rubbish. I would want the meal to be on my birthday if that were the case.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 17/06/2023 04:28

I couldn't care less about my birthday, they've just never been a big thing in my family. I do have some friends who make a huge deal about their birthday. If the friend wants to have her celebration on her birthday because that's what's important to her I don't see what's wrong with that. You are all shitty and judgemental friends for sayings he's the immature one.

Grrrrdarling · 17/06/2023 00:51

llammar · 15/06/2023 20:38

No I’m not getting back late! It’s already being planned months in advance (it’s in august).

It’s not being moved. The person flying back said they could do the Saturday, everyone else was fine with it, birthday girl was not!

I have posted because I was shocked that someone could be so much of a princess about their birthday! She is a lovely person but I honestly cannot believe someone could be this precious.

@llammar It’s her party & she’ll cry if she wants to comes to mind… lol
It wouldn’t be an issue for me but for this person it clearly is.
Maybe they are a creature of habit & for them they have to celebrate their birthday on their birthday.

Onelifeonly · 16/06/2023 22:51

I agree with you OP, birthday girl is being childish. Why leave out one friend just because she can't wait a day? Even actual kids celebrate their birthdays on days other than their birthdays - eg by having a party on Saturday rather than a weekday.

In my family we give presents on the actual.day, maybe have a special tea with cake at home but choose a suitable day / evening to go out. It does feel like a birthday celebration, strangely! Of course it's nice to be able to do it on the actual day, but really! If I were the left out friend I'd be pretty upset.

I guess a lot of posters are as childish as OP's friend though.

LaDamaDeElche · 16/06/2023 22:29

Lollipop81 · 16/06/2023 21:22

I guess it depends on her situation. Does this mean she will spend her Birthday on her own. Don’t understand why you wouldn’t just have the meal without the friend that can’t make it

No, she will spend her bday with all her other friends, apart from the friend who can’t make it because they’re busy.

Lollipop81 · 16/06/2023 21:22

I guess it depends on her situation. Does this mean she will spend her Birthday on her own. Don’t understand why you wouldn’t just have the meal without the friend that can’t make it

phoenixrosehere · 16/06/2023 21:15

LaDamaDeElche · 16/06/2023 19:40

I don’t think people have said it’s necessary, just that it’s up to the person whose birthday it actually is to decide when they want to celebrate it. I think you are really odd for thinking she should accommodate another person on HER birthday. If she’s ok with them not being there, then fine. It isn’t their birthday.

I agree with this. It reads like this was decided by the group without actually considering if the birthday friend wanted to do that and because she expressed she isn’t (which she is well within her right to since it is about her birthday), OP is annoyed with her because she won’t accommodate someone else for her birthday which she doesn’t have to.

I can see where OP is coming from BUT, it’s not something I would be upset about nor do I think it is OP’s problem since they’re the ones that can make it. If the person who can’t make it is put out about it, that’s between them and the birthday girl and tbh, I wouldn’t be upset or resort to OP’s level of annoyance or insults if someone wanted to celebrate their birthday on their actual day.

DadBodAlready · 16/06/2023 20:44

Maybe birthday girl can't do saturday because she has other plans

PeachyPeachTrees · 16/06/2023 20:01

I would prefer to go on the Saturday and everyone is there than the Friday and 1 isn't there. My birthday is a popular time for people to go on holiday, so I rarely celebrate on the day itself, sometimes not even the same week, shock horror!!

thesugarbumfairy · 16/06/2023 19:53

I cant remember the last time one of my friends actually had a birthday night out on their actual birthday. We always try to find a date to suit as many people in our friendship group as possible. Sometimes people still cant make it and they withdraw gracefully. I think its ridiculous for an adult to sulk about such a thing.

T1Dmama · 16/06/2023 19:49

Wills · 16/06/2023 19:44

Haven't read all the way through but can't believe how many people are supporting the idea that the celebration HAS to be on their birthday. YES OP the woman is being incredibly childish. So when she turn's 40 and it lands on a Monday she's going to insist that everyone attends a big birthday bash on that MONDAY - I mean seriously??? Pathetic! I didn't even do this with my kids - their parties were always at weekends that got the greatest number of yeses!

This!

I delayed my 18th birthday party by 6 weeks so someone could attend.
But I guess it depends how much the birthday girl likes the person!

nosyupnorth · 16/06/2023 19:47

So who wants to bet this is a semi-reverse and OP is the childish and entitled friend who wants somebody to reschedule their birthday to her convenience rather than just accepting there is a party they can't go to.

Wills · 16/06/2023 19:44

Haven't read all the way through but can't believe how many people are supporting the idea that the celebration HAS to be on their birthday. YES OP the woman is being incredibly childish. So when she turn's 40 and it lands on a Monday she's going to insist that everyone attends a big birthday bash on that MONDAY - I mean seriously??? Pathetic! I didn't even do this with my kids - their parties were always at weekends that got the greatest number of yeses!

LaDamaDeElche · 16/06/2023 19:44

llammar · 15/06/2023 20:38

No I’m not getting back late! It’s already being planned months in advance (it’s in august).

It’s not being moved. The person flying back said they could do the Saturday, everyone else was fine with it, birthday girl was not!

I have posted because I was shocked that someone could be so much of a princess about their birthday! She is a lovely person but I honestly cannot believe someone could be this precious.

It’s not everyone else’s birthday though 😂 Am I missing something? The important person in a birthday party is surely…the person whose birthday it is. Are you guys like the cast of Friends or something? You have a really odd mindset about this.

T1Dmama · 16/06/2023 19:42

Also @llammar when she said she couldn’t make that date, was it her suggestion to move the date or other friends from the group suggesting moving the date? I think it’s reasonable for other friends to say ‘oh Sandra can’t make that date, how about the following night?
is she single?? (The birthday girl)…

when I was married I used to spend birthday with family and DH, now single I suppose going out with family in the day and friends in the evening might seem more important, not wanting to sit alone on your birthday etc… but also spreading over 2 days has its benefits

LaDamaDeElche · 16/06/2023 19:40

llammar · 15/06/2023 20:10

Sorry, to clarify, it’s not being moved! She was just in a huge mood about it and said it was unreasonable to suggest the day went to the Saturday even though everyone else (six in total) were fine with it.

I’m genuinely amazed people think it’s necessary for the day to be the actual birthday. I cannot imagine getting worked up about that.

I don’t think people have said it’s necessary, just that it’s up to the person whose birthday it actually is to decide when they want to celebrate it. I think you are really odd for thinking she should accommodate another person on HER birthday. If she’s ok with them not being there, then fine. It isn’t their birthday.

T1Dmama · 16/06/2023 19:36

@llammar well for me personally I suppose it depends whether celebrating with all your friends is more important or whether having it on your actual birthday is… for me I’d arrange the date for when everyone could attend.. but I know people who wouldn’t change the date for anyone..
People are precious, I’ve known people throw a hissy about kids birthday present being wrapped in the ‘wrong’ paper… A family member hated the fact her birthday was shared with her Nan… felt it awful she had to ‘share’ her birthday! My birthday often falls on Mother’s Day or Easter and it really doesn’t bother me… but we are all different! The friend that can’t make it should just say ‘OK, we’ll I’m out of the country so won’t be there! I wouldn’t apologise if I was her as the birthday girl clearly isn’t bothered about her being there.

EmeraldFox · 16/06/2023 19:22

ToWhitToWhoo · 15/06/2023 23:15

I can't stand the attitude that your birthday MUST be celebrated ON THE DAY. On the other hand, if the other person is demanding that everyone change the day just to accommodate her, that's also childish. The birthday person should not take offence if someone can't make the day, but she's not obliged to change the time- with any date, there's likely to be someone who can't make it.

I'm sure the OP said that everyone could make it the next day

EmeraldFox · 16/06/2023 19:19

Hidinginaonesie · 15/06/2023 23:10

Op, I totally agree with you. At 38, surely the important thing about celebrating a birthday is getting to celebrate with as many of your friends as possible..Seriously, who gives an actual toss about the date?!!!!

This is my attitude too. It's not about the woman who can't make it making anyone change the date, if I was the birthday person I'd want that friend to be at my birthday celebration!

Ifeelsuchafool · 16/06/2023 18:36

Sorry, I haven't read the full thread, just popped on to say that I'm currently on a train to my dd's house to celebrate the birthday of my granddaughter. Her birthday is today but we are going out to celebrate tomorrow as Fridays are school days. My granddaughter is eight today. She will be in bed when I arrive. We skyped briefly this morning. Your friend needs to grow up.