Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is insanely childish? Anyone else been shocked by an adult’s immaturity?!

232 replies

llammar · 15/06/2023 19:57

In our group of friends one of us can’t make the birthday dinner for someone in the group. They birthday girls has taken huge offence and said the alternative date suggested ‘isn’t her actual birthday so it won’t feel the same.’ Wtf? She’s going to
be 38 not 6? It’s literally moving the day from a Friday (her birthday) to a Saturday. I’ve

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThinWomansBrain · 18/06/2023 20:25

reminds me of a birthday party I organised (for myself) - a few years ago - afternoon tea on a canal boat for about thirty, lots of champagne.
One of the people I invited replied with it was a bit inconvenient because it was a bank holiday. I didn't change the date.
the potential guest who expects the date to be changed is the one being unreasonable.

plantsandwich · 18/06/2023 20:19

I think It's a bit odd to be that bothered about one's birthday celebration being on a certain day as a fully fledged adult to be honest but I appreciate not everyone feels that way. I'd much rather just have a day with all my loved ones, even if that did have to be a few days/weeks either side of my birthday. My last birthday was a significant one and I had two celebrations (I've lived in two regions about half of my life each and have friends in both!) about a month apart!

MRex · 18/06/2023 07:21

I think some of us have different ideas about a party. It's supposed to be a social gathering for a group. Some time at a party can be devoted to one or more individuals such as singing happy birthday, but most of the event is a social occasion. The group thought it would be nice to all be together, because they care about each other. The birthday woman-child wanted it to be all about her, because she only cares about herself. That is the where the disconnect has happened. When she's moaning later about people being turned against her, you can bet she'll have no awareness of how they all suddenly actually saw her lack of interest in anyone's happiness except her own. Clearly others on the thread have a similar approach, so she needs to just find new friends who are comfortable with the approach of putting themselves first even when it's unnecessary.

MichelleScarn · 17/06/2023 23:03

Wonder if op and rest of group are used to birthday girl having to go along with what they tell her so are shocked she's finally stood up for herself?

drpet49 · 17/06/2023 22:34

CrazyHedgehogLover · 17/06/2023 21:15

Sounds to me like you all just made a new plan and didn’t give your friend “the birthday girl” a second thought! If it’s been planned for months it’s actually really rude to just start discussing new and different plans and suggesting moving the day.

the world doesn’t revolve around your friend (the one flying in late) so yes the birthday girl has every right to not uproot her plans because someone has known well in advance and claimed they can’t make it last minute.

surely it’s your friends fault (the one flying in) for not making alternative arrangements for work/booking time off knowing this meal and plan had already been arranged?

you sound like you don’t even like your friend.. who gives a shit if you all think she’s being “precious” because she actually wants the plans that were agreed to go ahead🤷‍♀️ also everyone bitching and moaning how childish she is because she just simply wants the meal on her birthday need to grow up, people are entitled to choose when they want there birthday celebration ffs, if she wants it on her birthday so be it.

YABU

This. No thought for the birthday girl at all.

Frogmila · 17/06/2023 22:13

llammar · 15/06/2023 20:12

@Whenwillitallmakesense I’m not upset I just couldn’t believe the drama but it seems that it’s quite normal from this thread!

What drama? A suggestion was made and she rebuffed it.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 17/06/2023 21:15

Sounds to me like you all just made a new plan and didn’t give your friend “the birthday girl” a second thought! If it’s been planned for months it’s actually really rude to just start discussing new and different plans and suggesting moving the day.

the world doesn’t revolve around your friend (the one flying in late) so yes the birthday girl has every right to not uproot her plans because someone has known well in advance and claimed they can’t make it last minute.

surely it’s your friends fault (the one flying in) for not making alternative arrangements for work/booking time off knowing this meal and plan had already been arranged?

you sound like you don’t even like your friend.. who gives a shit if you all think she’s being “precious” because she actually wants the plans that were agreed to go ahead🤷‍♀️ also everyone bitching and moaning how childish she is because she just simply wants the meal on her birthday need to grow up, people are entitled to choose when they want there birthday celebration ffs, if she wants it on her birthday so be it.

YABU

MrsMikeDrop · 17/06/2023 20:41

Either scenario is fine, having the birthday on the day or moving it. The mean part is calling her immature etc, real friends (over 12), don't do this.

MrsMikeDrop · 17/06/2023 20:38

EmeraldFox · 17/06/2023 09:47

Nothing wrong with finding out if a day later would mean everyone could come then asking. If someone else couldn't come then it would be pointless. If the next day doesn't work for the birthday woman then she just says so, but it's not unreasonable to ask. I'd naturally assume she'd want as many of her friends there as possible.

Nope. Much easier to ask the birthday girl first, and if she's keen to then ask the others. It was only one person who couldn't make it. I think it's pretty obvious what has gone on here. These 'girls' are just bullies.

Wills · 17/06/2023 19:45

However the OP seems to have disappeared so I doubt it will clarified.

Wills · 17/06/2023 19:44

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 16:55

OP wrote

She was just in a huge mood about it and said it was unreasonable to suggest the day went to the Saturday even though everyone else (six in total) were fine with it.

I read it as someone suggested the Saturday and instead of asking the birthday person they decided that was ok and the birthday person disagreed.

YEP, on reflection I can see your point.

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 16:55

Wills · 17/06/2023 16:35

I was under the opposite impression. That she’s upset that said friend wont make it. As long birthday girl has had a pleasant conversation with friend who can’t make it then as it’s her birthday she can do what she likes.

However I have to admit that as I’ve been desperately decorating a daughter’s bedroom before she arrives home I haven’t kept up with (read) all of it - sorry!

OP wrote

She was just in a huge mood about it and said it was unreasonable to suggest the day went to the Saturday even though everyone else (six in total) were fine with it.

I read it as someone suggested the Saturday and instead of asking the birthday person they decided that was ok and the birthday person disagreed.

Wills · 17/06/2023 16:35

MoonInTheNight · 17/06/2023 16:08

Wills

Only she's not upset the friend can't make it. She understands that.
She just doesn't want to rearrange the dinner to suit said friend, which is fair enough.

I was under the opposite impression. That she’s upset that said friend wont make it. As long birthday girl has had a pleasant conversation with friend who can’t make it then as it’s her birthday she can do what she likes.

However I have to admit that as I’ve been desperately decorating a daughter’s bedroom before she arrives home I haven’t kept up with (read) all of it - sorry!

EbonyRaven · 17/06/2023 16:25

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 17/06/2023 09:58

Wow, the seconds of thought that must have gone into that ingenious nickname.

😂

MoonInTheNight · 17/06/2023 16:08

Wills

Only she's not upset the friend can't make it. She understands that.
She just doesn't want to rearrange the dinner to suit said friend, which is fair enough.

Wills · 17/06/2023 14:35

Sorry but I have to do this though I’m aware I’m outing my age

It’s my pwarty and I’ll crwy if I want to,
crwy if I want to
You would do too if you had a nasty disrespectful “friend” who puts a foreign based business meeting ahead of my pwarty

MoonInTheNight · 17/06/2023 14:18

AaBbCcDdEeFfGEEEEEE
I'm with you OP. All the adults I know have birthday gatherings at weekend's, because everyone generally works and has other commitments during the week. In fact, we even do it for my DC. They have their birthday with us at home - gifts, cards and a cake with candles - and then they get to do it all over again at the weekend with his friends. So, essentially, we're all getting 2 days of birthday celebrations if we happen to have a mid-week birthday.

Her birthday is at the weekend (or near enough) - she wants to celebrate on Friday evening. She may even be pleased it's finally possible to celebrate on the day after several years of mid-week birthdays.

Suggesting you get two days of celebrations only makes sense if you still get to do something on your actual birthday. Even if it's just a present and some recognition from a partner. If you don't have a partner/family, and can't see friends on the day, birthdays can be pretty grim (especially at 38, if you were hoping to have a partner/DC by now). I'm around that age and it's much more important to me to have a pleasant day (even if low-key) on my actual birthday than big celebrations another day, for the above reasons.

Vmlillie · 17/06/2023 13:29

I just want to point out that OP never said the friend who couldn’t make the Friday party wanted to move the date. If the group is anything like mine, they were just trying to accommodate everyone attending. I am a little surprised the birthday girl is being so childish, but that’s her prerogative, I guess. I do know none of my friends would care what day we celebrate, as long as we were all there together. Choose your friends wisely.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 17/06/2023 11:57

Personally, I’d rather everyone could come than it be on the specific day, so it wouldn’t worry me to delay it until the Saturday. However, I do wonder how this was pitched to the birthday girl. This part of the OP sticks out for me:

She was just in a huge mood about it and said it was unreasonable to suggest the day went to the Saturday even though everyone else (six in total) were fine with it.

Why had all six been asked if they were okay with it before the suggestion to the birthday girl? Or was it a group chat where everyone jumped in and said “Ooh yes, I can do Saturday; let’s make it Saturday!” Maybe she felt a bit ambushed or as if it was a fait accompli. I wonder if her “huge mood” was because she felt like she’d been presented with his decision and was then told “Well, everyone else can make it…”

EmeraldFox · 17/06/2023 11:46

memyselfi · 17/06/2023 10:42

I think if the Birthday Girl wanted the guest there she would have made it work .
I suspect she was quite happy for this guest to miss it.

Yes, unless there was a reason she couldn't do Saturday then she clearly wasn't bothered about seeing this friend. Her call of course, but if she was in a mood just because the next day was suggested then that is childish.

zingally · 17/06/2023 11:46

The person expecting the date to be moved is being fairly childish. But the birthday girls response is also pretty immature.

I kind of get wanting to have a "big birthday" celebration on the day, but for a mid-decade birthday it's certainly not expected.

ToWhitToWhoo · 17/06/2023 11:38

If the birthday person got in a mood over the mere suggestion that the day be changed, then that's very unpleasant and unreasonable of her. If she calmly said no, and the others wouldn't accept it and nagged her about it, then it's more understandable if she got annoyed,

What would REALLY upset me would be if she got angry and offended with anyone who couldn't come on the day.

KingOfThieves · 17/06/2023 11:26

Why should she not celebrate on her actual birthday? Would you rather she sat at home? So one friend can’t make it, it isn’t a big deal.

if bd girl didn’t want to move the date then I am assuming she didn’t suggest moving the date. So why would others suggest moving the meal when it wasn’t their place to?

you will all catch up another time

bernadette1984 · 17/06/2023 11:20

8pm? At the airport!? Lol

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 17/06/2023 10:59

MrsToothyBitch · 17/06/2023 10:33

Hmm... I can see why asking for a birthday party to be moved for you may be seen as cheeky. But I also think kicking off because it's your birthdaaaaaayyyyyy is bratty behaviour from an adult. Either say no sorry, Saturday doesn't work for me or move it to Sat so you can all celebrate. Personally I'd do the Saturday so we could all go and I'd enjoy slightly spinning my birthday out for couple of hoursGrin.

I used to work with a birthday pwincess. She ALWAYS took the whole week off for birthday - and replied to any comments as such with the words above, with exactly that emphasis and hard stare downs. This was retail, she was an assistant manager and she insisted on both weekends at either end as well. I couldn't go to my cousins wedding because of her - she wouldn't give up one weekend day and someone else had to rearrange a massive holiday and spend more money because she wouldn't swap the last day of her week off one year. I do understand it was her right to book a weeks leave and it was first come first served and I could completely understand if she had holidays booked herself over it - but she didn't really and her stock answer of "it's my birthday" for the whole 9 days seemed really childish on an adult - and one who tried to duck work at every opportunity anyway tbh. We paid the entitled bitch back in kind at every turn though.

I’m confused. If you knew she ALWAYS did this, why didn’t you book your holiday for the wedding as soon as you knew the date? Why did your colleague have to “rearrange” her holiday? Why not just arrange it for a different week in the first place?

Swipe left for the next trending thread